Little Green Men: A Primer on Modern Russian Unconventional Warfare, Ukraine 2013-2014
Page Count: 78 pages
Date: June 2015
Originating Organization: U.S. Army Special Operations Command
File Type: pdf
File Size: 8,767,432 bytes
File Hash (SHA-256):2F98D69E0550FB86FB8820C6C936948C0B6B0E3B81C788C4B061A2B6244D93AA
This document is intended as a primer—a brief, informative treatment—concerning the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. It is an unclassified expansion of an earlier classified version that drew from numerous classified and unclassified sources, including key US Department of State diplomatic cables. For this version, the authors drew from open source articles, journals, and books. Because the primer examines a very recent conflict, it does not reflect a comprehensive historiography, nor does it achieve in-depth analysis. Instead, it is intended to acquaint the reader with the essential background to and course of the Russian intervention in Ukraine from the onset of the crisis in late 2013 through the end of 2014. The document’s key points are summarized below.
Part I. Context and Theory of Russian Unconventional Warfare
- Key Principles
- Strategy to deal with states and regions on the periphery of the Russian Federation
- Primacy of nonmilitary factors: politics, diplomacy, economics, finance, information, and intelligence
- Primacy of the information domain: use of cyberwarfare, propaganda, and deception, especially toward the Russian-speaking populace
- Persistent (rather than plausible) denial of Russian operations
- Use of unidentified local and Russian agents
- Use of intimidation, bribery, assassination, and agitation
- Start of military activity without war declaration; actions appear to be spontaneous actions of local troops/militias
- Use of armed civilian proxies, self-defense militias, and imported paramilitary units (e.g., Cossacks, Vostok Battalion) instead of, or in advance of, regular troops
- Asymmetric, nonlinear actions
- For the purpose of clarity and uniformity within this study, the authors use the term unconventional warfare to embrace the wide variety of military, informational, political, diplomatic, economic, financial, cultural, and religious activities Russia employed in Ukraine.
- Evolution of Russian unconventional warfare. Russian intervention in Ukraine has featured refined and modernized techniques evolved through observation and analysis of Western methods (the color revolutions, Arab Spring) and Russian experiences since the collapse of the Soviet Union. Specifically, they drew lessons from interventions in:
- Lithuania, 1991
- Transnistria, 1990–1992
- Chechnya (and Dagestan), 1994–1996 (1999–2009)
- Georgia, 2008
- Russian information warfare has emerged as a key component of Russian strategy. Igor Panarin and Alexandr Dugin are the primary theorists.
- Russian Chief of Staff Valery Gerasimov’s model for interstate conflict reflects the growing importance of nonkinetic factors in Russian strategy.
Part II. Russian Unconventional Warfare in Ukraine, 2013–2014
- Historical Context
- Ukraine’s historical, cultural, religious, and economic ties to Russia make it a vital interest to Moscow.
- Western encroachment into the Russian sphere of influence, primarily through North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) expansion and European Union (EU) economic ties, stimulated a reactionary movement among Russian conservatives to stop the loss of peripheral states to the West.
- The Crimean peninsula, with a majority of ethnic Russians, includes Russia’s Black Sea naval base of Sevastopol and is a vital interest to Moscow.
- The Maidan movement is viewed as a product of Western—especially American—conspiracy.
- Vladimir Putin has boosted his popularity by portraying himself as the defender of Russian nationalism and Russian Orthodoxy in Ukraine.
- Russian Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures in Ukraine, 2013–2014
- Political organization within the conflict region to create and sustain pro-Russian political parties, unions, and paramilitary groups
- Recruitment and support of regional SPETSNAZ
- Importation of “little green men”—unidentified Russian agents (usually SPETSNAZ) to organize and lead protests and paramilitary operations
- Importation of Cossack, Chechen, Serbian, and Russian paramilitary “volunteers”
- Persistent (rather than plausible) denial of Russian operations, even in the face of photographic evidence and firsthand testimonials
- Domination of television, radio, and social media through the use of highly trained operatives, including “hacktivists” and seemingly independent bloggers; use of Russia Today television as a highly effective propaganda tool; use of professional actors who portray themselves as pro-Russian Ukrainians
- Use of blackmail, bribery, intimidation, assassination, and kidnapping against regional political opponents and government officials, including police and military officials
- Use of “relief columns” to import weapons, soldiers, equipment, and supplies to pro-Russian forces
- Small-scale invasion and precision operations by conventional Battalion Tactical Groups (BTGs) based along the Russian border
- Issuing Russian passports to pro-Russian populations and touting Moscow’s need to defend the Russian diaspora against alleged abuses
- Driven by a desire to roll back Western encroachment into the Russian sphere of influence, the current generation of Russian leaders has crafted a multidisciplinary art and science of unconventional warfare. Capitalizing on deception, psychological manipulation, and domination of the information domain, their approach represents a notable threat to Western security.
- The new forms of Russian unconventional warfare challenge the structure of the NATO Charter, because they obviate the appearance of “armed invasion.”
Russian Warfare Tactics, Russian Warfare Technology, Russian Warfare, Russian Warfare In Syria, Russian Warfare Game, Russian Warfare Minecraft, Russian Warfare Mw3, Russian Warfare Strategy, Russian Warfare Mp3, Russian Warfare History, Russian Arctic Warfare, Russian Ambiguous Warfare, Russian Asymmetrical Warfare, Russian Amphibious Warfare Ships, Russian Armored Warfare, Russian Advanced Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Aircraft, Russian Information Warfare As Domestic Counterinsurgency, Russian Hybrid Warfare And Other Dark Arts, Modern Warfare Russian Airport, Russian Biological Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Brigade, Russian Electronic Warfare Black Sea, Armored Warfare Russian Bias, Russian Military Creating Cyber Warfare Branch, Russian Cyber Warfare, Russian Cyber Warfare Capabilities, Russian Chemical Warfare, Russian Cyber Warfare Doctrine, Russian Cyber Warfare Ukraine, Russian Cyber Warfare Unit, Russian Chemical Warfare Uniform, Russian Chemical Warfare Suit, Russian Electronic Warfare Capabilities, Russian Military Cyber Warfare, Russian Drone Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Device Called Khibiny, Russian Hybrid Warfare Doctrine, Russian Information Warfare Doctrine, Russian Cyber Warfare Doctrine, Russian Electronic Warfare Doctrine, Russian Electronic Warfare Device Khibiny, Russian Electronic Warfare Device, Russian Information Warfare As Domestic Counterinsurgency, Russian Electronic Warfare Uss Donald Cook, Russian Electronic Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Device Called Khibiny, Russian Electronic Warfare Systems, Russian Electronic Warfare Aircraft, Russian Electronic Warfare Capabilities, Russian Electronic Warfare Syria, Russian Electronic Warfare Ukraine, Russian Electronic Warfare Units, Russian Economic Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Weapons, Armored Warfare Russian Forum, Russian Word For Warfare, Russian Hybrid Warfare Finland, Russian Warfare Game, Russian Guerrilla Warfare, Russian Germ Warfare Program, Russian New Generation Warfare, Russian New Generation Warfare Study, Russian Next Generation Warfare, Russian New Generation Warfare Implications For Europe, Russian New Generation Warfare In Ukraine, Russian Sixth Generation Warfare, Russian Warfare History, Russian Hybrid Warfare, Russian Hybrid Warfare Doctrine, Russian Hybrid Warfare Pdf, Russian Hybrid Warfare In Ukraine, Russian Hybrid Warfare And Other Dark Arts, Russian Electronic Warfare Helicopter, Russian Word For Hybrid Warfare, Russian Hybrid Warfare Finland, Russian Warfare In Syria, Russian Warfare In Ukraine, Russian Information Warfare, Russian Information Warfare Doctrine, Russian Information Warfare As Domestic Counterinsurgency, Russian Irregular Warfare, Russian Information Warfare Ukraine, Russian Electronic Warfare In Syria, Russian Electronic Warfare In Ukraine, Russian Hybrid Warfare In Ukraine, Russian Electronic Warfare Jet, Russian Electronic Warfare Khibiny, Russian Electronic Warfare Device Khibiny, Russian Advanced Warfare Key, Cod Advanced Warfare Russian Key, Advanced Warfare Russian Language, Russian Non Linear Warfare, Armored Warfare Russian Language, Russian Warfare Minecraft, Russian Warfare Mw3, Russian Warfare Mp3, Russian Mountain Warfare, Russian Medieval Warfare, Russian Masked Warfare, Russian Modern Warfare 2, Russian Media Warfare, Russian Modern Warfare, Russian Mine Warfare, Russian New Warfare, Russian Nuclear Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Us Navy, Russian Hybrid Warfare And Other Dark Arts, Russian Psychic Warfare, Russian Psychological Warfare, Russian Political Warfare, Russian Electronic Warfare Plane, Russian Germ Warfare Program, Russian Hybrid Warfare Pdf, Russian Submarine Warfare Pin, Armored Warfare Russian Pts, Modern Warfare Russian Phrases, Russian Information Warfare Pdf, Russian Warfare Strategy, Russian Warfare Server, Russian Submarine Warfare, Russian Space Warfare, Russian Submarine Warfare Pin, Russian Electronic Warfare Systems, Russian Electronic Warfare Syria, Russian Warfare In Syria, Russian Electronic Warfare Ship, Russian Electronic Warfare System In Syria, Russian Warfare Tactics, Russian Warfare Technology, Russian Trench Warfare Ww1, Russian Tank Warfare, Russian Trench Warfare, Warfare Russian To English, Russian Urban Warfare Tank, Russian Electronic Warfare Technology, Russian Electronic Warfare Troops, Advanced Warfare Russian To English, Russian Unconventional Warfare, Russian Urban Warfare Tank, Russian Electronic Warfare Ukraine, Russian Electronic Warfare Units, Russian Cyber Warfare Ukraine, Russian Hybrid Warfare Ukraine, Russian Information Warfare Ukraine, Russian Cyber Warfare Unit, Russian Chemical Warfare Uniform, Russian Electronic Warfare Us Navy, Russian Electronic Warfare Vehicle, Advanced Warfare Russian Vpn, Russian Warfare Ww2, Russian Winter Warfare, Russian Weather Warfare, Russian Trench Warfare Ww1, Russian Electronic Warfare Weapons, Russian Woodpecker Weather Warfare, Russian Warfare Weapons, Armored Warfare Russian_xml.pak, Ukraine News, Ukraine Flag, Ukraine Map, Ukraine Women, Ukraine War, Ukraine Language, Ukraine Airlines, Ukraine Population, Ukraine Currency, Ukraine Russia, Ukraine Airlines, Ukraine And Russia, Ukraine Abbreviation, Ukraine Adoption, Ukraine Army, Ukraine Alphabet, Ukraine Airport, Ukraine Airlines Reviews, Ukraine Area, Ukraine Agriculture, Ukraine Basketball, Ukraine Boxer, Ukraine Beaches, Ukraine Bank, Ukraine Basketball Players, Ukraine Basketball Team, Ukraine Birth Rate, Ukraine Barbie, Ukraine Borders, Ukraine Bride, Ukraine Capital, Ukraine Currency, Ukraine Crisis, Ukraine Civil War, Ukraine Conflict, Ukraine Cities, Ukraine Country Code, Ukraine Culture, Ukraine Climate, Ukraine Crimea, Ukraine Documentary, Ukraine Demographics, Ukraine Date, Ukraine Definition, Ukraine Dnc, Ukraine Donetsk, Ukraine Donbass, Ukraine Dollar, Ukraine Debt, Ukraine During Ww2, Ukraine Economy, Ukraine Eu, Ukraine Embassy, Ukraine Eggs, Ukraine Explosion, Ukraine Express, Ukraine Eurovision, Ukraine Exports, Ukraine Elections, Ukraine Eurovision 2017, Ukraine Flag, Ukraine Food, Ukraine Famine, Ukraine Facts, Ukraine Flag Emoji, Ukraine Fighting, Ukraine Flights, Ukraine Free Territory, Ukraine Flag Meaning, Ukraine Founded, Ukraine Genocide, Ukraine Gdp, Ukraine Government, Ukraine Girl, Ukraine Gdp Per Capita, Ukraine Got Talent, Ukraine Geography, Ukraine Government Type, Ukraine Girl Names, Ukraine Gay, Ukraine History, Ukraine Hetalia, Ukraine Holidays, Ukraine Holocaust, Ukraine Hryvnia, Ukraine Hotel, Ukraine Hryvnia To Usd, Ukraine Holodomor, Ukraine Houses, Ukraine Human Name, Ukraine International Airlines, Ukraine Independence, Ukraine Is Not A Brothel, Ukraine In Spanish, Ukraine Is Weak, Ukraine Invasion, Ukraine Independence Day, Ukraine International Airlines Review, Ukraine Images, Ukraine In Nato, Ukraine Join Nato, Ukraine Jobs, Ukraine Joining Eu, Ukraine Jewish, Ukraine Jokes, Ukraine Jersey, Ukraine Jewelry, Ukraine Jacket, Ukraine Judicial System, Ukraine Judge, Ukraine Kiev, Ukraine Keyboard, Ukraine Kharkiv, Ukraine Kyiv, Ukraine Kiev Time, Ukraine Kiev Map, Ukraine Kherson, Ukraine Killers, Ukraine Known For, Ukraine Kazakhstan, Ukraine Language, Ukraine Location, Ukraine Leader, Ukraine Life Expectancy, Ukraine Landmarks, Ukraine Literacy Rate, Ukraine League Table, Ukraine Lviv, Ukraine Last Names, Ukraine Landscape, Ukraine Map, Ukraine Money, Ukraine Military, Ukraine Music, Ukraine Model, Ukraine Movie, Ukraine Maidan, Ukraine Mountains, Ukraine Major Cities, Ukraine Meme, Ukraine News, Ukraine Nato, Ukraine Nuclear, Ukraine National Anthem, Ukraine Names, Ukraine Natural Resources, Ukraine National Team, Ukraine Nuclear Weapons, Ukraine National Animal, Ukraine Nuclear Power, Ukraine On Map, Ukraine On Fire, Ukraine Or The Ukraine, Ukraine Official Language, Ukraine Odessa, Ukraine Orange Revolution, Ukraine Orphanage, Ukraine On World Map, Ukraine Orthodox Church, Ukraine Outline, Ukraine Population, Ukraine People, Ukraine President, Ukraine Population 2017, Ukraine Prime Minister, Ukraine Power Grid Attack, Ukraine Pictures, Ukraine Passport, Ukraine Protests, Ukraine Post, Ukraine Quotes, Ukraine Quality Of Life, Ukraine Quiz, Ukraine Queen, Ukraine Quizlet, Ukraine Quora, Ukraine Quick Facts, Ukraine Questions, Ukraine Qualify World Cup, Ukraine Quiz Questions, Ukraine Russia, Ukraine Religion, Ukraine Revolution, Ukraine Russia News, Ukraine Refugees, Ukraine Russia Map, Ukraine Russia Relations, Ukraine Rebels, Ukraine Resources, Ukraine Russia Border, Ukraine Symbol, Ukraine Soccer, Ukraine Size, Ukraine Sanctions, Ukraine Soccer Team, Ukraine Starvation, Ukraine Sports, Ukraine Ssr, Ukraine Special Forces, Ukraine Separatists, Ukraine Time, Ukraine Time Now, Ukraine To English, Ukraine Translation, Ukraine Today, Ukraine Travel, Ukraine Tourism, Ukraine Trump, Ukraine Timeline, Ukraine Traditions, Ukraine Unemployment Rate, Ukraine Ussr, Ukraine Us Relations, Ukraine University, Ukraine Un, Ukraine Uprising, Ukraine Us Embassy, Ukraine Update, Ukraine Ua, Ukraine Under Stalin, Ukraine Vs Russia, Ukraine Visa, Ukraine Visa Free, Ukraine Visa Usa, Ukraine Village, Ukraine Visa Free Eu, Ukraine Vodka, Ukraine Vs The Ukraine, Ukraine Vacation, Ukraine Violence, Ukraine Women, Ukraine War, Ukraine Weather, Ukraine War News, Ukraine War 2017, Ukraine Wiki, Ukraine Ww2, Ukraine World Map, Ukraine Wife, Ukraine Weapons, Ukraine X Factor, Ukraine X Reader Lemon, Ukraine X Factor Judges, Ukraine X Reader, Ukraine X Male Reader Lemon, Ukraine X Canada, Ukraine X Hungary, Ukraine X Factor Aida, Ukraine X Belarus Lemon, Ukraine X Factor 2017, Ukraine Yanukovych, Ukraine Youtube, Ukraine Yulia Tymoshenko, Ukraine Youth Center, Ukraine Yandex, Ukraine Yahoo, Ukraine Youth, Ukraine Yearly Weather, Ukraine Yellow Pages, Ukraine Yield Curve, Ukraine Zip Code, Ukraine Zoo, Ukraine Zhytomyr, Ukraine Zaporizhzhya, Ukraine Zoo Statue, Ukraine Zoo Slayer Statue, Ukraine Zaporozhye, Ukraine Zoo Slayer, Ukraine Zakarpattia, Ukraine Zip Code Kiev, Us Army Ranks, Us Army Corps Of Engineers, Us Army Rangers, Us Army Logo, Us Army Reserve, Us Army Uniforms, Us Army Special Forces, Us Army Jobs, Us Army Infantry, Us Army Size, Us Army Ako, Us Army Airborne, Us Army Air Corps, Us Army Address, Us Army Airborne School, Us Army Artillery, Us Army Academy, Us Army Aircraft, Us Army Airborne Units, Us Army Aviation, Us Army Bases, Us Army Birthday, Us Army Basic Training, Us Army Branches, Us Army Boot Camp, Us Army Badges, Us Army Band, Us Army Boots, Us Army Beret, Us Army Benefits, Us Army Corps Of Engineers, Us Army Cavalry, Us Army Cadet Command, Us Army Cif, Us Army Combat Engineer, Us Army Cid, Us Army Camo, Us Army Colors, Us Army Chain Of Command, Us Army Combat Medic, Us Army Dress Uniform, Us Army Divisions, Us Army Delta Force, Us Army Draft, Us Army Dress Blues, Us Army Dog Tags, Us Army Dts, Us Army Deployment, Us Army Division Patches, Us Army Drill Sergeant, Us Army Enlisted Ranks, Us Army Europe, Us Army Emblem, Us Army Ees, Us Army Email, Us Army Equipment, Us Army Enlistment, Us Army Engineer, Us Army Eod, Us Army Engineer School, Us Army Flag, Us Army Field Band, Us Army Field Artillery, Us Army Founded, Us Army Firefighter, Us Army Forms, Us Army Font, Us Army Field Manual, Us Army Facts, Us Army Formal Uniform, Us Army Green Berets, Us Army Generals, Us Army Golden Knights, Us Army Gear, Us Army General Orders, Us Army Gas Mask, Us Army Guns, Us Army Garrison Hawaii, Us Army Germany, Us Army Game, Us Army Hrc, Us Army Helicopters, Us Army Helmet, Us Army History, Us Army Hat, Us Army Headquarters, Us Army Honor Guard, Us Army Helicopter Pilot, Us Army Handgun, Us Army Humvee, Us Army Infantry, Us Army Insignia, Us Army In Syria, Us Army Intelligence, Us Army In Afghanistan, Us Army Intelligence Support Activity, Us Army Infantry School, Us Army Images, Us Army In Korea, Us Army Iperms, Us Army Jobs, Us Army Jacket, Us Army Jrotc, Us Army Japan, Us Army Jag, Us Army Jeep, Us Army Jag Corps, Us Army Jump School, Us Army Jungle School, Us Army Jets, Us Army Knife, Us Army Korea, Us Army Korean War, Us Army Knowledge Online, Us Army Kabar, Us Army Kevlar Helmet, Us Army Kilt, Us Army Keychain, Us Army Khaki Uniform, Us Army Kuwait, Us Army Logo, Us Army Logo Vector, Us Army Leadership, Us Army Leave Form, Us Army Logistics, Us Army Loadout, Us Army Lanyard, Us Army Letterhead, Us Army Lieutenant, Us Army Lapel Pins, Us Army Medals, Us Army Mil, Us Army Mos, Us Army Motto, Us Army Military Police, Us Army Medic, Us Army Medical Corps, Us Army Museum, Us Army Memes, Us Army Medical Command, Us Army News, Us Army National Guard, Us Army Name Tapes, Us Army Numbers, Us Army New Pistol, Us Army North, Us Army New Rifle, Us Army Nurse Corps, Us Army Nurse, Us Army Nco Ranks, Us Army Officer Ranks, Us Army Officer, Us Army Organization, Us Army Officer Pay, Us Army Ocs, Us Army Officer Uniform, Us Army Ocp, Us Army Officer Jobs, Us Army Old Guard, Us Army Ordnance Corps, Us Army Pay Scale, Us Army Patches, Us Army Phone Number, Us Army Pay, Us Army Pt Test, Us Army Population, Us Army Pay Chart 2017, Us Army Pathfinder, Us Army Pistol, Us Army Pathfinder School, Us Army Quotes, Us Army Quartermaster, Us Army Qualifications, Us Army Quartermaster Museum, Us Army Quartermaster School, Us Army Qualification Badges, Us Army Quartermaster Corps, Us Army Questions, Us Army Quiz, Us Army Quartermaster Officer, Us Army Ranks, Us Army Rangers, Us Army Reserve, Us Army Recruiter, Us Army Requirements, Us Army Records, Us Army Ranger School, Us Army Rank Insignia, Us Army Ribbons, Us Army Reserve Jobs, Us Army Special Forces, Us Army Size, Us Army Salary, Us Army Symbol, Us Army Seal, Us Army Song, Us Army Skillport, Us Army Sniper, Us Army Sniper School, Us Army Signal Corps, Us Army Tanks, Us Army Trips, Us Army Tattoos, Us Army Training, Us Army T Shirts, Us Army Theme Song, Us Army Times, Us Army Transportation Museum, Us Army Tattoo Policy 2017, Us Army Tacom, Us Army Uniforms, Us Army Unit Patches, Us Army Units, Us Army Unit Sizes, Us Army Uniform Guide, Us Army Uniform History, Us Army Uniform Regulations, Us Army Unit Structure, Us Army Unit Awards, Us Army Uniform 2017, Us Army Vehicles, Us Army Veteran, Us Army Vietnam, Us Army Values, Us Army Vs Marines, Us Army Veteran Hat, Us Army Video Game, Us Army Veterinary Corps, Us Army Videos, Us Army Vs Russian Army, Us Army War College, Us Army Weapons, Us Army Wallpaper, Us Army Webmail, Us Army Wtf Moments, Us Army Warrant Officer, Us Army Wiki, Us Army Ww2, Us Army Website, Us Army Watch, Us Army Xctc, Us Army Xm17, Us Army Xm25, Us Army Xo, Us Army Xm8, Us Army X Ray Tech Mos, Us Army X Ray Program, Us Army Xviii Airborne Corps, Us Army Xbox Controller, Us Army Xii Corps, Us Army Youtube, Us Army Yuma Proving Ground, Us Army Yearly Salary, Us Army Yeti, Us Army Yongsan, Us Army Yellow Book, Us Army Yearly Budget, Us Army Yes Program, Us Army Yell, Us Army Ypg, Us Army Zippo, Us Army Zika Vaccine, Us Army Zero Target, Us Army Zonk, Us Army Zika, Us Army Zulu Time, Us Army Zodiac Boat, Us Army Zombie Apocalypse, Us Army Zombie Manual, Us Army Zip Up Hoodie