By Françoise Daucé
In Russia as elsewhere, military journalists and war correspondents find themselves at the heart of the tensions between the discipline and confidentiality required in military matters and the independence and openness required by the media. Their task is to inform society and shape public opinion, but they are also bound by the rules of the armed forces1 in situations where their own safety is at stake and a war of information is often being waged alongside the war on the ground2. This tension is not particular to Russia3 but it is overt there perhaps more than in any other country. In the USSR, during wartime (whether the “Great Patriotic War” from 1941 or the Cold War until 1985), the constraints upon military journalists and war correspondents were severe, under the Main Political Directorate of the Soviet Army and Navy with its twofold responsibility for State censorship and Party ideological correctness. At a time when the media were called “means of mass information and propaganda”, what possible leeway did correspondents have between their “duty of self-restraint” and their “duty to speak up”? Under Gorbachev’s glasnost, starting in 1985, the coverage of military matters became a forum for expressing political criticism, whether by publicising the failures of the war in Afghanistan, bullying of new recruits, corruption among officers or the scandals of the nuclear deterrent. In the early 1990s, journalists put military discipline to one side in their work and devoted themselves to reporting on all the armed forces’ failings. Since the start of the new century, the authoritarian turn taken by the Russian government appears to have restored the priority of order, the “power vertical “and the “dictatorship of the law” both in the armed forces and the media, providing political control over media reporting on soldiers and war4.
5 C. Lemieux (dir), La subjectivité journalistique. Onze leçons sur le rôle de l’individualité dans l (…)
2What is the reality? What tensions are there in the particular task of military journalists? What compromises do they make? To answer these questions, this special report goes into the professional practices of journalists to reveal the trade-offs, stratagems and conflicts that make up their day-to-day work. The various articles describe people in action, professionals operating, journalists at work. This sociological approach, with people’s own opinions, transmitted directly or indirectly, shows both the extent of the constraints on their work and the degree of independence and subjectivity5 that exists in journalistic production. It outlines their participation in producing official discourse and their struggle to spell out alternative truths. Since the collapse of the USSR, the world of military journalists has been increasingly diverse and plural. Careers and backgrounds have broadened to include civilians, women, foreigners and non-specialists. They are committed in varying degrees to their jobs, which have been thrown open in ways that are politically, legally and technically complex. Even though there are indeed constraints, these are less the hierarchical, militarised type of the duty of self-restraint but more (neo-) liberalised in nature. This can be seen in the 2014 events in Ukraine, which have been particularly uncontrolled and dangerous for journalists on the ground. Our study of military journalism in the USSR and Russia provides an insight into the transformations within the Soviet and then Russian armed forces, the changes occurring in that country’s society and politics, the sociology of the media and journalism in Russia, and the contemporary world in general.
6 International Round Table. Military and War journalism from the USSR to Russia: Field Practices and (…)
3This special report comprises contributions that vary in form and content. There are duly verified scholarly articles and personal experiences of military journalists describing their ways of working. The report of a roundtable discussion in April 2014 in Moscow6 combines the views of journalists, historians and practitioners concerning the special features of military journalism. Book reviews remind the reader of how much research has been done in this area. Together the various sections offer new avenues for analysing military journalism in Russia.
Independence and subjectivity of war correspondents and military journalists
7 See Olga Pavlenko’s contribution to the April 2014 Round Table.
4Since the wars of the 19th century, particularly in the Crimea7, the history of military journalism has been marked by a gradual professionalization. An obviously male job until the end of the Cold War, military journalism and war reporting was done by officers and civilians, civil servants and writers, concerned to bear witness to the conflicts of their time. At the height of the Soviet 20th century, the drama of the Great Patriotic War featured the heroic figure of the war correspondent, whether international (such as Alexander Werth) or Soviet (Vasily Grossman). In the violence of the great clash between the Soviet and Nazi war machines, the reporting available shows how much independence and subjective freedom of expression journalists on the front could have. Nicolas Werth’s presentation of his father’s writings and career exemplifies the personal choices and commitments Alexander made on the Eastern Front. His articles were not so much the result of strategic constraints imposed by war as the account of a man fighting with the Soviet forces. In 1941-1945, war offered possibilities for journalistic expression that were perhaps greater than in later years, when the hierarchical and institutional apparatus was set up to control military journalism. After the victory, it was time to bureaucratise the army’s press section. The publications devoted to military matters during the Brezhnev years (Krasnaia Zvezda, the Soviet defence ministry’s daily newspaper, for example) showed this in their operations and content. Military journalists were trained by the army itself, as Ivan Chupin describes in his article on military journalists during the final years of the USSR, borne out by the journalist Nikolai Starodymov. The embargo on military information was clearly operating during the war in Afghanistan involving Soviet troops.
8 Concerning this weekly, see V. Solov’ev, “Stanovlenie nezavisimoi voennoi pechati v Rossii: opyt “N (…)
5As glasnost opened up reporting after 1985, military journalists became more diverse. The opening up and liberalisation of the Russian media world extended to military journalism. Censorship (Glavlit) disappeared. The former Soviet army newspapers did continue, working under the control of the defence ministry. They largely remained attached to the Soviet Army’s “Cold War” editorial line, as can be seen in Sophie Momzikoff’s article on Zarubezhnoe Voennoe Obozrenie. But journalists from these editorial offices seized the opportunity to criticise the armed forces as an institution and move into independent media at a time when their expert knowledge was valued. Civilian media developed their military coverage, written by correspondents and specialists. New publications devoted to military matters appeared (Nezavisimoe Voennoe Obozrenie in the mid-1990s, for example8). The amount of space given over to the armed forces became larger and more diverse. Personal accounts of the war in Afghanistan and the many conflicts that erupted in the post-Soviet zone (Chechnya, Moldova and Nagorno-Karabakh) were given pluralistic treatment in the press in the 1990s.
9 Iu. Zheglova, Fenomen “prikomandirovannoi” zhurnalistiki. In: Mikhail Pogorelyi, Ivan Safranchuk (e (…)
6Within this diversified environment, journalists made choices. Their careers reveal the tensions and controversies they encountered and the compromises they devised. Some Soviet military journalists escaped from the control of their former employers to join the civilian media (such as Aleksandr Golts). Others stayed put but altered their vision of the armed forces and modified their editorial line. These careers and practices became more diverse, and Ivan Chupin describes two conceptions of the work: one toeing the army line and the other critical and investigatory. In response, the military authorities attempted to keep control of these changes by sending their own journalists to write for civilian publications9. However, their control was losing its force. New professionals were appearing in the war journalist community. Foreign correspondents went out to operational areas in the former Soviet Union and established relations with Russian journalists (see the account by war photographer Yuri Tutov). These new arrangements raised the issue of the relations and exchanges between journalists of various origins and the specific constraints imposed on them. This period also saw women arriving in military journalism. Examples are Anna Politkovskaya covering the Chechnya War and Olga Allenova, a journalist on Kommersant, in the same theatre. This diversification brought plurality into the treatment of military information. In this issue of PIPSS, Allenova’s account shows how she shifted away from being a supporter of “restoring order” in Chechnya in the early 2000s as she saw the violence this entailed (see Amandine Regamey’s review of her book). Allenova describes her growing awareness of the criminal abuses of the anti-terrorist operation in Chechnya. The interview with Tutov reveals how he distanced himself from the interior ministry’s media and began to work more with international press agencies. These journalists displayed their independence of judgement in a changing military world. More recently, since the early 2000s, this independence has increased as a result of new information and communication technologies that extend the range of journalistic practice. Reduced technical constraints, miniaturisation of recording devices, and speed of transmission lead to faster circulation of information, including from war zones. The possibilities available to military journalists seem therefore to be widening.
Tensions and constraints at work
7But this diversification has aroused strong tensions. This could be seen at the round table discussion of military journalism held in April 2014 at the Russian State University for the Humanities (RGGU), Moscow, in partnership with the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). Andrei Raskin, journalism professor at the RGGU, listed the new difficulties facing military journalism at the present time. He said that untrained journalists are often sent to report on hostilities, showing great independence but at the risk of their personal safety. He expressed concern at the presence in operational theatres of independent journalists of uncertain status, given great freedom but little protection by their editorial managers. He also questioned women’s legitimacy to cover conflict: “War journalism as a whole is ‘not a place for women’ any way”, he said. Journalists’ independence, more diverse backgrounds and allegiance to the civilian community raise the question of their security in military theatres and arouse distrust from the professionals of military journalism.
10 A.-J. Bizimana, Au cœur du dispositif embedding: la surveillance des journalistes intégrés lors de (…)
11 H. Tumber, J. Palmer, Media at war. The Iraq crisis, London, Sage, 2004.
8In the Russian armed forces, this distrust has given rise to new communication strategies better suited to post-Soviet political and media reality. Raskin described a certain distrust in the armed forces towards independent journalists. But the military authorities are also aware of the need to work with journalists. More flexible types of constraint, often inspired by Western practice, are being tried out by the military institutions. Having “embedded” journalists during armed conflict makes it possible to control the transmission of information. Embedment enables journalists to be at the heart of events and broadcast authentic factual accounts of warfare but does raise the question of their surveillance10 and official exploitation of them at times of crisis11. The communication practice was developed by the Russian army during the Second Chechnya War from 1999 on. Journalists may even appreciate being enrolled in this way. Aleksandr Sladkov, a well-known Russian television presenter, said, “Embedded journalism is a good progressive way to regulate the links between civilians and the military. A large-scale example of embedded journalism would be in the Soviet Army, during World War II, when 280 operators were recording films”. This reference to the Great Patriotic War is used to justify current cooperation arrangements between the armed forces and journalists.
9The work of military journalists is regulated by new legislative codes. In the early 2010s, a large number of laws were passed to control the activities of newspapers, their editorial staff and the independent journalists who produce blogs (now deemed to be mass media if they have more than 3,000 hits a day). The role of Roskomnadzor (Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media) in controlling media content has also been extended. Although direct institutional constraint in the form of censorship has disappeared, political control over military journalists has taken on a variety of new forms. “The laws regulating journalism in Russia are not that bad since they are inspired by French laws; however, in the past few years they have been amended significantly. The laws now act in a more restrictive way, with the excuse of the last counterterrorist laws’ boundaries”, says Galina Arapova from the Mass Media Defence Centre. These legal forms of control of journalists’ activities do not guarantee the professionals’ security. Violence against critical independent journalists (the murders, for example, of Dmitri Kholodov and Anna Politkovskaya) illustrates the dangers of the profession. In the past three years, 250 journalists have been killed in Russia (according to Arapova).
10Since the spring of 2014, the fighting in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of eastern Ukraine has ironically revealed both the freedoms military journalists enjoy and the constraints they work under. This conflict, widely covered by print and digital media, is also one of the most dangerous for journalists and most closely monitored in media terms. In this undeclared war, involving anti-terrorist operations, guerrilla warfare and undercover counter-espionage, the control over military journalism and war reporting is variable and may even be absent. Because there has been no official declaration of war, the system of embedding journalists with the armed forces is not operational. News reporting therefore depends on the initiative of special correspondents, accounts by members of the public, part-time and citizen journalism, web posts and blogs open to more than one interpretation. The ill-defined nature of the current conflict and doubts about the identity of its protagonists place journalists from outside in a dangerous position. According to statistics kept by Reporters sans frontières12, the arbitrary arrest and disappearance of journalists soared in eastern Ukraine in spring and summer 2014. The victims of the conflict come from every category of journalist of whatever nationality (Russian, Ukrainian or Western) or media (television, radio, print). The insurgents of the People’s Republic of Donetsk actually issued a decree in July 2014 prohibiting “journalists, cameramen and photo-reporters” from “being present in combat zones and near military installations” during armed operations. These measures restricting access to the theatre of operations allow the most divergent interpretations of the military situation. In the absence of any clear institutional, legal or political framework, the new freedoms afforded by post-Soviet liberalisation and new media have not automatically led to a pluralistic coverage of military events but do endanger both journalists and the pluralism of information. Military journalism is thus a reflection of the social and political transformations that have occurred in contemporary Russia and its areas of intervention. It may consist of bearing witness, expressing opinion and commitment—a sign of journalists’ independence. But this degree of subjectivity comes at a higher cost than elsewhere in the absence of any effective public procedures for protecting its authors.
Top of page
1 And also by a specifically military conception of writing and discourse: C. Oger, “De l’esprit de corps au corps du texte: cohésion militaire et dissolution journalistique”, Langage et société, # 4, 2000.
2 H. Tumber, J. Palmer, Media at war. The Iraq crisis, London, Sage, 2004.
3 A.-J. Bizimana, “Les relations militaires-journalistes: évolution du contexte américain”, Les cahiers du journalisme, # 16, Autumn 2006.
4 E. Sieca-Kozlowski, “From controlling military information to controlling society: the political interests involved in the transformation of the military media under Putin”, Small Wars and Insurgencies, vol. 20, # 2, 2009, pp. 300-318.
5 C. Lemieux (dir), La subjectivité journalistique. Onze leçons sur le rôle de l’individualité dans la production de l’information, Paris, Editions de l’EHESS, 2010.
6 International Round Table. Military and War journalism from the USSR to Russia: Field Practices and Legal Regulations. Moscow, 15 April 2014. Organised by the Regional Delegation of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in the Russian Federation, Russian State University for the Humanities, Union of Journalists of Russia, Franco-Russian Centre for Social Sciences in Moscow and the journal PIPSS.
7 See Olga Pavlenko’s contribution to the April 2014 Round Table.
8 Concerning this weekly, see V. Solov’ev, “Stanovlenie nezavisimoi voennoi pechati v Rossii: opyt “Nezavisimogo voennogo obozrenia””, in M. Pogorelyi, I. Safranchuk (eds), Sovremennaia rossiiskaia voennaia zhurnalistika. Opyt, problemy, perspektivy, Moscow, Gendal’f, 2002, pp. 11-21.
9 Iu. Zheglova, Fenomen “prikomandirovannoi” zhurnalistiki. In: Mikhail Pogorelyi, Ivan Safranchuk (eds). Sovremennaia rossiiskaia voennaia zhurnalistika. Opyt, problemy, perspektivy. Moscow, Gendal’f, 2002, pp. 22-39.
10 A.-J. Bizimana, Au cœur du dispositif embedding: la surveillance des journalistes intégrés lors de la guerre en Irak, PhD Thesis, 2010, http://www.archipel.uqam.ca/3654/ (accessed on 21 October 2014).
11 H. Tumber, J. Palmer, Media at war. The Iraq crisis, London, Sage, 2004.
Top of page
Françoise Daucé, « Military Journalists and War Correspondents From The USSR To Russia: Subjectivity Under Fire », The Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies [Online], Issue 16 | 2014, Online since 30 January 2014, connection on 22 March 2015. URL : http://pipss.revues.org/4121
About the author
CERCEC / EHESS
War Correspondents Memorial, War Correspondents Movie, War Correspondents Memorial Arch, War Correspondents Vietnam War, War Correspondents Killed In Vietnam, War Correspondents Brooklyn Brewery, War Correspondents Arch, War Correspondents Killed In Action, War Correspondents Netflix, War Correspondents Memorial Maryland, War Correspondents Arch, War Correspondents At The Brooklyn Brewery, War Correspondents At Gallipoli, War Correspondents And Ptsd, War Correspondents Association, War Correspondents In Afghanistan, Canadian War Correspondents Association, War Correspondents Memorial Awm, War Correspondents Killed In Action, Australian War Correspondents, War Correspondents Brooklyn Brewery, War Correspondents Bbc, War Correspondents Book, Female War Correspondents Bbc, War Correspondents Boer War, Vietnam War Correspondents Books, Bbc War Correspondents List, British War Correspondents, Best War Correspondents, British War Correspondents Ww2, War Correspondents Crossword, War Correspondents Club, War Zone Correspondents Crossword, War Correspondents Memorial Canberra, Do War Correspondents Carry Weapons, War Correspondents Helen Chadwick, Gulf War Cnn Correspondents, Cnn War Correspondents, Civil War Correspondents Memorial Arch, Civil War Correspondents, War Correspondents During World War 2, War Correspondents Documentary, War Correspondents During Wwii, A War Correspondent’s Dilemma, War Correspondents Memorial Dedication, War Correspondents Who Have Died, Do War Correspondents Carry Weapons, War Correspondents During The Civil War, Define War Correspondents, English War Correspondents, Embedded War Correspondents, Early War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents, Famous War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents Wwii, Female War Correspondents Bbc, Falklands War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents Vietnam, Female War Correspondents In Iraq, Freelance War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents Ww2, Female War Correspondents Uk, War Correspondents Gallipoli, Vietnam War Correspondents Gather Saigon Reunion, Gulf War Correspondents, Greatest War Correspondents, How Much Do War Correspondents Get Paid, German War Correspondents, Can War Correspondents Carry Guns, War Correspondents Helen Chadwick, War Correspondents History, War Correspondents Who Have Died, War Correspondents In Ww2, War Correspondents In Vietnam, War Correspondents In Syria, War Correspondents In Afghanistan, War Correspondents In Ww1, War Correspondents Itv, War Correspondents Interview, War Correspondents Killed In Action, War Correspondents Killed In Ww2, War Correspondents Killed In Vietnam, War Correspondents Killed In Vietnam, War Correspondents Killed In Action, War Correspondents Killed In Ww2, British War Correspondents Killed, List Of War Correspondents Killed, Korean War Correspondents, War Correspondents List, Bbc War Correspondents List, War Correspondents Club London, Today Show War Correspondents List, War Correspondents Memorial, War Correspondents Movie, War Correspondents Memorial Canberra, War Correspondents Memorial Awm, War Correspondents Memorial Dedication, War Correspondents Meaning, Civil War Correspondents Memorial, Civil War Correspondents Monument, Female War Correspondents, Modern War Correspondents, War Correspondents Netflix, War Correspondents Memorial New York, Vietnam War Correspondents, Vietnam War News Correspondents, Iraq War News Correspondents, Civil War Newspaper Correspondents, Gulf War News Correspondents, Nbc War Correspondents, National War Correspondents Memorial, Notable War Correspondents, War Correspondents Ptsd, Pbs War Correspondents, War Correspondents Problems, War Correspondents Review, Russian War Correspondents, War Correspondents Salary, War Correspondents Scala, War Correspondents In Syria, Why Are War Correspondents So Important, Soviet War Correspondents, Vietnam War Correspondents Gather Saigon Reunion, Sky War Correspondents, War Correspondents Today, War Correspondents Today Crossword, War Correspondents At The Brooklyn Brewery, World War Two Correspondents, Tv War Correspondents, Top War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents Uk, Uk War Correspondents, What Camera Do War Correspondents Use, War Correspondents Vietnam War, Vietnam War Correspondents, Female War Correspondents Vietnam, Famous War Correspondents Vietnam, Australian War Correspondents Vietnam, War Correspondents Killed In Vietnam, Vietnam War Correspondents Gather Saigon Reunion, Victorian War Correspondents, Vietnam War Correspondents Books, War Correspondents Who Have Died, War Correspondents Ww2, War Correspondents Ww1, Female War Correspondents Wwii, Australian War Correspondents Ww1, Australian War Correspondents Ww2, Canadian War Correspondents Wwii, British War Correspondents Ww1, Female War Correspondents Ww2, Female War Correspondents Ww1, War Correspondents Memorial New York, War Zone Correspondents Crossword, War Zone Correspondents, Military Reporter Jobs, Military Reporters And Editors, Military Reporter, Military Reporter Crossword, Military Reporters Contest, Military Justice Reporter, Military Court Reporter, Military Law Reporter, Military Commission Reporter, Knsd Military Reporter, Military Reporter Crossword, Military Court Reporter, Military Commission Reporter, Cnn Military Reporter, Reporter Military Czapka, Florida Military Reporter, Military Reporter Jobs, Military Justice Reporter, Knsd Military Reporter, Reporter Military Kurtka, Military Law Reporter, Politico Military Reporter, Russian Military News, Russian Military Size, Russian Military Surplus, Russian Military Ranks, Russian Military Strength, Russian Military Bases, Russian Military Parade, Russian Military Budget, Russian Military Aircraft, Russian Military Equipment, Russian Military Aircraft, Russian Military Allies, Russian Military Academy, Russian Military Activity, Russian Military Alliance, Russian Military Arctic, Russian Military Alphabet, Russian Military Aggression, Russian Military Awards, Russian Military Action, Russian Military Bases, Russian Military Budget, Russian Military Branches, Russian Military Base In Syria, Russian Military Base In Arctic, Russian Military Buildup, Russian Military Bases In Russia, Russian Military Boots, Russian Military Budget 2016, Russian Military Base In Antarctica, Russian Military Capability, Russian Military Camo, Russian Military Cargo Planes, Russian Military Conscription, Russian Military Clothing, Russian Military Choir, Russian Military Coat, Russian Military Compared To Usa, Russian Military Commands, Russian Military Conflicts, Russian Military Doctrine, Russian Military Drones, Russian Military Districts, Russian Military Doctrine 2016, Russian Military Draft, Russian Military Dog, Russian Military Dress Uniform, Russian Military Deaths In Ww2, Russian Military Drills, Russian Military Divisions, Russian Military Equipment, Russian Military Exercises, Russian Military Expenditure, Russian Military Emblems, Russian Military Expansion, Russian Military Exports, Russian Military Equipment For Sale, Russian Military Exercises 2016, Russian Military Equipment In Syria, Russian Military Enlistment, Russian Military Forces, Russian Military Flag, Russian Military Facts, Russian Military Food, Russian Military Fatigues, Russian Military Fails, Russian Military Firearms, Russian Military Females, Russian Military Forces In Syria, Russian Military Fighter Jets, Russian Military Gear, Russian Military Guns, Russian Military Gas Mask, Russian Military Girl, Russian Military Gloves, Russian Military Groups, Russian Military Girl Singing, Russian Military Gear For Sale, Russian Military Growth, Russian Military Guns For Sale, Russian Military Hat, Russian Military Helicopters, Russian Military Helmet, Russian Military History, Russian Military Haircut, Russian Military Hovercraft, Russian Military Handguns, Russian Military Hazing, Russian Military Headquarters, Russian Military Hardware, Russian Military In Syria, Russian Military Intervention In Ukraine, Russian Military Intelligence, Russian Military Insignia, Russian Military In North Korea, Russian Military In Cuba, Russian Military In Arctic, Russian Military Involvement In Syria, Russian Military In Libya, Russian Military Is Weak, Russian Military Jets, Russian Military Jacket, Russian Military Jeep, Russian Military Jokes, Russian Military Jumpsuit, Russian Military Jet Fighters, Russian Military Journal, Russian Military Join, Russian Military Jets For Sale, Russian Military Jargon, Russian Military Knives, Russian Military Kit, Russian Military Korea, Russian Military Kettlebell, Russian Military Kettlebell Weight, Russian Military Killed In Syria, Russian Military Knives For Sale, Russian Military Kettlebell Training, Russian Military Kettlebell Test, Russian Military Kettlebell Routine, Russian Military Leaders, Russian Military Logo, Russian Military Loadout, Russian Military Leaders Ww2, Russian Military Latest News, Russian Military Leadership, Russian Military Logistics, Russian Military Libya, Russian Military Leader Ww1, Russian Military Losses, Russian Military Memes, Russian Military March, Russian Military Medals, Russian Military Mre, Russian Military Music, Russian Military Movements, Russian Military Modernization, Russian Military Might, Russian Military Martial Arts, Russian Military Motorcycle, Russian Military News, Russian Military North Korea, Russian Military Numbers, Russian Military Names, Russian Military North Korean Border, Russian Military Near North Korea, Russian Military Night Vision, Russian Military Nicknames, Russian Military Navy, Russian Military News In Syria, Russian Military Outfit, Russian Military Officer, Russian Military Optics, Russian Military Outdated, Russian Military On North Korean Border, Russian Military Operations, Russian Military Organization, Russian Military Orders, Russian Military On Korean Border, Russian Military Oath, Russian Military Parade, Russian Military Power, Russian Military Planes, Russian Military Population, Russian Military Pistol, Russian Military Police, Russian Military Parade 2017, Russian Military Power 2017, Russian Military Patches, Russian Military Phrases, Russian Military Quotes, Russian Military Quora, Russian Military Quality, Russian Military Quadcopter, Russian Military Quiz, Funny Russian Military Quotes, Russian Military Aircraft Quiz, Russian Military Vehicles Quiz, Russian Military Ranks, Russian Military Rifles, Russian Military Robot, Russian Military Ranks Ww2, Russian Military Rations, Russian Military Reform, Russian Military Radio, Russian Military Rocket Factory, Russian Military Requirements, Russian Military Ranks Ww1, Russian Military Size, Russian Military Surplus, Russian Military Strength, Russian Military Spending, Russian Military Sidearm, Russian Military Surplus Ammo, Russian Military Shirt, Russian Military Salute, Russian Military Symbols, Russian Military Strategy, Russian Military Training, Russian Military Technology, Russian Military Trucks, Russian Military Tanks, Russian Military Tactics, Russian Military Tattoos, Russian Military Terms, Russian Military Transport Aircraft, Russian Military Trucks For Sale, Russian Military Titles, Russian Military Uniforms, Russian Military Uniforms 2016, Russian Military Units, Russian Military Undershirt, Russian Military Ukraine, Russian Military Uniforms 1800, Russian Military Ushanka, Russian Military Uniforms Ww1, Russian Military Under Stalin, Russian Military Unit Names, Russian Military Vehicles, Russian Military Vs Us Military, Russian Military Vs Usa Military, Russian Military Vehicles For Sale, Russian Military Vest, Russian Military Vs American Military, Russian Military Vehicles For Sale Usa, Russian Military Victories, Russian Military Vocabulary, Russian Military Van, Russian Military Weapons, Russian Military Watches, Russian Military Ww2, Russian Military Ww1, Russian Military Wiki, Russian Military Weapons 2017, Russian Military Website, Russian Military Words, Russian Military Winter Hat, Russian Military Wallpaper, Russian Military Youtube, Russian Military Youtube Channel, Russian Military Yahoo Answers, Russian Military Yemen, Russian Military Yeti, Russian Military Yutube, Russian Youth Military Training, Russian Youth Military, Russian Military Power Youtube, Russian Military Songs Youtube, Russian Military Zombie Attack, Russian Military Zone, Russian Military Zeppelin, Russian Zil Military, Russian Military Exercise Zapad, Russian Military Trucks Zil, Russia News, Russia Flag, Russia Map, Russia Population, Russia Investigation, Russia And North Korea, Russia Trump, Russia Today, Russia Gdp, Russia World Cup, Russia And North Korea, Russia Allies, Russia And Us, Russia And Trump, Russia And Ukraine, Russia And Syria, Russia And China, Russia Alaska, Russia Afghanistan, Russia And Nato, Russia Breaking News, Russia Bombing, Russia Birth Rate, Russia Borders, Russia Bear, Russia Beyond The Headlines, Russia Building, Russia Bitcoin, Russia Beaches, Russia Before Ww1, Russia Continent, Russia Collusion, Russia China, Russian Currency, Russia Country Code, Russia Communist, Russia Climate, Russia Crimea, Russian Circles, Russian Cursive, Russia Demographics, Russia Dossier, Russia Drinking Age, Russia Day, Russia During Ww2, Russia Definition, Russian Debt, Russia During Ww1, Russia Donald Trump, Russia Dollar, Russia Economy, Russia Election, Russia Election Hacking, Russia Etf, Russia Exports, Russia Exchange Rate, Russia Eu4, Russia Europe, Russia Embassy, Russia Ethereum, Russia Flag, Russia Facts, Russia Food, Russia Flies Over Us, Russia Fake News, Russia Friend Enemy Or Frenemy, Russia Fifa 17, Russia France Election, Russia Fun Facts, Russia Fsb, Russia Gdp, Russia Gdp Per Capita, Russiagate, Russian Government, Russia Geography, Russia Gay, Russia Gif, Russia Georgia, Russia Gay Camps, Russian Gdp 2016, Russia Hetalia, Russia House, Russia Hacked Election, Russia History, Russia Hunger Games, Russia House Movie, Russia Hack, Russia Hearings, Russian Hacking, Russia Health Care, Russia Investigation, Russia Insider, Russia Investigation News, Russia In Russian, Russia Isis, Russia In Ww1, Russia In Syria, Russia In Ww2, Russia In Spanish, Russia Interference, Russia Jones, Russia Jehovah’s Witnesses, Russia Japan War, Russia Jokes, Russia Jw, Russia Jehovah, Russia Japan, Russia Jehovah’s Witnesses Ban, Russian Jets, Russia Join Nato, Russia Korea, Russia Kremlin, Russia Kgb, Russia Korea Border, Russia Kushner, Russia Killing Gay, Russia Kazan, Russian Keyboard, Russia Kislyak, Russia Kaliningrad, Russia Leader, Russia Life Expectancy, Russia Land Area, Russia Landmarks, Russia Location, Russia Latest News, Russia Lgbt, Russian Language, Russia Literacy Rate, Russia Lenin, Russia Map, Russia Memes, Russia Military, Russia Military News, Russia Moscow, Russia Military Power, Russian Money, Russia Missile, Russia Military Budget, Russia Map Unturned, Russia News, Russia North Korea, Russia North Korea Relations, Russia New Tank, Russia Nato, Russia Nuclear Weapons, Russia Natural Resources, Russia National Team, Russian National Anthem, Russia Newspaper, Russia On North Korea, Russia On Map, Russia Olympics, Russia Oil, Russia Ohio, Russia Outline, Russia On World Map, Russia Official Language, Russia Ocean, Russia Official Website, Russia Population, Russia Probe, Russia Putin, Russia Population Density, Russian Presidents, Russia People, Russia Probe News, Russia Population Map, Russia Pictures, Russia Political System, Russia Qatar, Russia Qualifiers, Russia Quotes, Russia Quizlet, Russia Quality Of Life, Russia Quiz, Russian Queen, Russia Questions, Russia Quick Facts, Russia Quora, Russia Religion, Russia Russia Russia, Russia Russia Russia Meme, Russia Religion News, Russia Role In The Syrian Civil War, Russian Revolution, Russia Real Estate, Russia Rivers, Russia Red Square, Russia Reddit, Russia Sanctions, Russia Syria, Russia Soccer, Russia Square Miles, Russia Size, Russia Soccer Team, Russia Syria News, Russia Sanctions Bill, Russian Super Tank, Russia Symbol, Russia Trump, Russia Today, Russia Time, Russia Time Now, Russia Time Zones, Russia Trump News, Russia Type Of Government, Russia Timeline, Russia To Alaska, Russia Tourism, Russia Us, Russia Ukraine, Russia Usa, Russia Us War, Russia United States, Russia Unemployment Rate, Russia Us Election, Russia Us News, Russia Uranium Deal, Russia Ukraine News, Russia Vs Usa, Russia Visa, Russia Vs Mexico, Russia Vs China, Russia Vs New Zealand, Russia Vs, Russia Visa Application, Russia Vs Germany, Russia Vs Usa War, Russia Vs Ukraine, Russia World Cup, Russia War, Russia Weather, Russia War News, Russia Wiki, Russia Ww2, Russia Ww1, Russia World Cup Tickets, Russia Ww3, Russia Word Whizzle, Russia X Reader, Russia X Reader Lemon, Russia X America, Russia X China, Russia X Reader Fluff, Russia X America Lemon, Russia X Male Reader Lemon, Russia X Prussia, Russia X Reader Lemon Forced, Russia X Male Reader, Russia Youtube, Russia Yeltsin, Russia Yemen, Russia Yahoo, Russian Yeti, Russia Ypg, Russian Youtube, Russia Yellowstone, Russia Yekaterinburg, Russia Year Founded, Russia Zip Code, Russia Zapad, Russia Zorbing Accident, Russia Zapad 2017, Russian Z, Russian Zombies, Russia Zorb, Russia Zigzagzigal, Russia Zip Code Format, Russia Zabivaka Tweet, Ussr Flag, Ussr Anthem, Ussr Map, Ussr Meaning, Ussr Countries, Ussr Definition, Ussr Anthem Lyrics, Ussr Leaders, Ussr Collapse, Ussr Symbol, Ussr Anthem, Ussr Anthem Lyrics, Ussr Anthem Earrape, Ussr Acronym, Ussr Atomic Bomb, Ussr Abolished, Ussr Anthem Sheet Music, Ussr And Usa, Ussr Army, Ussr Allies, Ussr Breakup, Ussr Beatles, Ussr Buran, Ussr Beatles Meaning, Ussr Bear, Ussr Ball, Ussr Borders, Ussr Background, Ussr Before And After, Ussr Bomb, Ussr Countries, Ussr Cold War, Ussr Communism, Ussr Currency, Ussr Constitution, Ussr Colors, Ussr Capital, Ussr Collapse Date, Ussr Casualties Ww2, Ussr Communism Characteristics, Ussr Definition, Ussr Dissolved, Ussr Dictators, Ussr During Cold War, Ussr During Ww2, Ussr Death Toll, Ussr Deaths Ww2, Ussr Documentary, Ussr Dates, Ussr Department 12, Ussr Earrape, Ussr Economy, Ussr Emoji, Ussr End, Ussr Emblem, Ussr Established, Ussr Economic Reform, Ussr Expansion, Ussr Explodes Atomic Bomb, Ussr Evil Empire, Ussr Flag, Ussr Fall, Ussr Flag Emoji, Ussr First Atomic Bomb, Ussr Facts, Ussr Five Year Plan, Ussr Full Name, Ussr Fidget Spinner, Ussr Founded, Ussr Flag For Sale, Ussr Gets Atomic Bomb, Ussr Government, Ussr Gdp, Ussr Genocide, Ussr Gorbachev, Ussr Gif, Ussr Gulag, Ussr Great Purge, Ussr Government During Ww2, Ussr Gdp Over Time, Ussr History, Ussr Hat, Ussr Hockey Jersey, Ussr Hydrogen Bomb, Ussr Hockey, Ussr Hoi4, Ussr Hymn, Ussr History Timeline, Ussr Homosexuality, Ussr Healthcare, Ussr In Russian, Ussr In Spanish, Ussr In Afghanistan, Ussr In Ww2, Ussr Invaded Afghanistan, Ussr Independence Day, Ussr In The Cold War, Ussr Invades Poland, Ussr Involvement In Vietnam War, Ussr In Cyrillic, Ussr Jokes, Ussr Jacket, Ussr Jersey, Ussr Japan Ww2, Ussr Jeep, Ussr Jfk Assassination, Ussr Jobs, Ussr Joins The League Of Nations, Ussr Jeans, Ussr Jfk, Ussr Korean War, Ussr Kursk, Ussr Kgb, Ussr Knife, Ussr Kazakhstan, Ussr Killings, Ussr Kremlin, Ussr Kirov, Ussr Keyboard, Ussr Khrushchev, Ussr Leaders, Ussr Logo, Ussr Leader During Ww2, Ussr Lyrics, Ussr Leaders During The Cold War, Ussr Launches Sputnik, Ussr Launches Sputnik 1, Ussr Launches Mir Space Station, Ussr Location, Ussr Lenin, Ussr Map, Ussr Meaning, Ussr Memes, Ussr Military, Ussr Music, Ussr Motto, Ussr Meaning In English, Ussr Money, Ussr Moon Landing, Ussr Members, Ussr National Anthem, Ussr National Anthem Lyrics, Ussr National Anthem Earrape, Ussr National Anthem Sheet Music, Ussr Nations, Ussr National Anthem Download, Ussr Navy, Ussr Nuclear Bomb, Ussr News, Ussr Nuclear Weapons, Ussr On Map, Ussr On World Map, Ussr Olympics, Ussr Or Soviet Union, Ussr Or U.s.s.r, Ussr Officer Uniform, Ussr Outfit, Ussr Or Russia, Ussr Outline, Ussr On The Moon, Ussr Propaganda, Ussr Presidents, Ussr Population, Ussr Propaganda Posters, Ussr Population 1940, Ussr Premiers, Ussr Population 1990, Ussr Passport, Ussr Poland, Ussr Posters, Ussr Quizlet, Ussr Quotes, Ussr Quiz, Ussr Quality Of Life, Ussr Quora, Ussr Quality Mark, Ussr Quotes From Cold War, Ussr Questions And Answers, Ussr Queues, Ussr Quick Facts, Ussr Russia, Ussr Republics, Ussr Religion, Ussr Rulers, Ussr Rocket, Ussr Revolution, Ussr Theme, Ussr Role In Ww2, Ussr Referendum, Ussr Rhino, Ussr Symbol, Ussr Stands For, Ussr Song, Ussr Salute, Ussr Space Program, Ussr States, Ussr Secret Police, Ussr Shirt, Ussr Space Race, Ussr Satellite States, Ussr Theme, Ussr Timeline, Ussr Theme Lyrics, Ussr To Russia, Ussr Territory, Ussr Today, Ussr Tanks, Ussr Test First Atomic Bomb, Ussr Totalitarianism, Ussr T Shirt, Ussr Uniform, Ussr Under Lenin, Ussr Under Stalin, Ussr Ushanka, Ussr Ukraine, Ussr Usa, Ussr Unemployment Rate, Ussr Unicode, Ussr United Nations, Ussr Under Gorbachev, Ussr Vs Usa, Ussr Vs Russia, Ussr Vs Soviet Union, Ussr Vs Russia Map, Ussr Vs Nazi, Ussr Vietnam War, Ussr Vs Germany, Ussr Vs Usa Hockey, Ussr Vs China, Ussr Vs Germany Spongebob, Ussr Ww2, Ussr Wiki, Ussr Wallpaper, Ussr Ww2 Rations, Ussr War In Afghanistan, Ussr World Map, Ussr Watch, Ussr Wars, Ussr Ww1, Ussr Weapons, Ussr X Ray Records, Ussr Xb3, Ussr Ymca, Ussr Ymca Lyrics, Ussr Years, Ussr Yugoslavia, Ussr Youtube, Ussr Young Pioneers, Ussr Yuri Gagarin, Ussr Youth, Ussr Youth Groups, Ussr Zangief, Ussr Zone 3, Ussr Zionism, Ussr Zippo, Ussr Zombies, Ussr Zenit Camera, Uss Zhukov, Ussr Zone 6, Ussr Zebra, Ussr Zone 4,
“Tanks, artillery and infantry have crossed from Russia into an unbreached part of eastern Ukraine in recent days, attacking Ukrainian forces and causing panic and wholesale retreat not only in this small border town but also a wide section of territory, in what Ukrainian and Western military officials described on Wednesday as a stealth invasion.
The attacks outside this city and in an area to the north essentially have opened a new, third front in the war in eastern Ukraine between government forces and pro-Russian separatists, along with the fighting outside the cities of Donetsk and Luhansk.
Exhausted, filthy and dismayed, Ukrainian soldiers staggering out of Novoazovsk for safer territory said Tuesday they were cannon fodder for the forces coming from Russia. As they spoke, tank shells whistled in from the east and exploded nearby.”* The Young Turks hosts Ana Kasparian, Ben Mankiewicz (Turner Classic Movies), and Jasmyne Cannick (Political Commentator) break it down.
*Read more here from Andrew E. Kramer and Michael R. Gordon / NY Times:
An informative look at Crimea’s nostalgic Russian ties and how Crimaea became a part of the Ukraine in 1954. Opening with riveting footage of the crisis in Ukraine over this small but strategic peninsula, a look back at the glory days of the Crimea and an interesting analysis of Russian strategy.
Front line footage from Ukraine as brave civilians stand up to tanks and gunfire. Warning! Some footage can be disturbing!