Stalin’s America | Socialism in America

Stalin’s America | Socialism in America


How the Socialist Party platform of 1928 worked its way into American political policy.

“The American people will never knowingly adopt Socialism. But under the name of ‘liberalism’ they will adopt every fragment of the Socialist program, until one day America will be a Socialist nation, without knowing how it happened.”

– Norman Thomas (1884-1968), six-time U.S. Presidential candidate for the Socialist Party of America

Socialist Party Platform 1928
(click to read entire platform)

( NOTE:   It is the intention of to remain politically independent, and not become mired in partisan politics.  Our mission is to study the world economy, and in that mission, at times, the relationship between politics and economics becomes highly relevant.  This is an important time for this commentary.  Whether the reader is liberal or conservative, Democrat or Republican, we believe this is of interest to all investors. These observations were first made by economists (Nobel Laureate) Milton and Rose Friedman, in Free to Choose in 1979, but have been updated here.  Thankfully, we have been spared the brutality of a Joseph Stalin, though many of the economic principles of his early years have crept into American life.)

Let’s set the stage…  The year is 1928.  World War I ended ten years ago, but its effects and settlements have left much of the world in dire straits economically.  The National Socialist German Workers’ Party (Nazi) is gaining power in an economically-destitute Weimar Germany.  Benito Mussolini and the National Fascist Party are firmly entrenched in Italy.  The Bolshevik Revolution, where first the peasants, then Vladimir Lenin and the Bolshevik Party wrested power from the czars in Russia, is now a decade in the past.  Joseph Stalin has built a “cult of personality” in Russia, using mass media to create an idealized and heroic public image through unquestioned idolatry, flattery, and praise.

The propaganda machines of both Stalin’s Socialism and Mussolini’s Fascism are in full swing, painting rosy pictures of life under government control.  Franklin Delano Roosevelt is campaigning to become governor of New York.  The cocktail parties of Upper Manhattan are abuzz with chatter about the foreign rulers.  In fact, a year earlier, future members of FDR’s “Brain Trust” (mostly professors at Columbia University) went on a junket to Russia to meet with Stalin, and came back in admiration and awe.  One Brain Trust member, Stuart Chase, went on to write a very prophetic book, The New Deal, which laid the groundwork for the social programs of the FDR administration.  The last sentence of The New Deal reads, “Why should Russians have all the fun remaking a world?”

The U.S. economy is strong.  Life is good, but the “roaring 20’s” are about to come to an end.

In the 1928 election for President of the United States, Norman Thomas and James Maurer ran on the Socialist Party ticket.  They captured only one percent of the vote, but laid out a vision for what Socialism meant in the early part of the 20th century.  The planks of the Socialist Party platform were clearly defined.  It is fascinating that in just a few decades, most of the planks of the 1928 Socialist Party platform would be enacted into law, without the party ever winning an election.  Thomas finally quit American politics, stating that he was no longer needed, as the Democrat and Republican parties had adopted every plank in the platform.  He said, “The difference between Democrats and Republicans is: Democrats have accepted some ideas of Socialism cheerfully, while Republicans have accepted them reluctantly”.

Here are the economic planks of the Socialist Party platform of 1928, with editorial comment added (Click to read entire platform):

1. “Nationalization of our natural resources, beginning with the coal mines and water sites, particularly at Boulder Dam and Muscle Shoals.” (Boulder Dam, renamed Hoover Dam, and Muscle Shoals are now both federal government projects.)

2. “A publicly owned giant power system under which the federal government shall cooperate with the states and municipalities in the distribution of electrical energy to the people at cost…” (Tennessee Valley Authority, et al.  This is a generally accepted process across the country.  Even the private utilities are highly regulated.)

3. “National ownership and democratic management of railroads and other means of transportation and communication.” (Railroad passenger service was completely nationalized through Amtrak. Some freight service was nationalized through Conrail. Private railroads are strictly regulated by the federal government. The FCC controls communications by telephone, telegraph, radio, television, and the internet.)

4. “An adequate national program for flood control, flood relief, reforestation, irrigation, and reclamation.” (Government expenditures for these purposes are currently tens of billions of dollars per year, including FEMA, Army Corps of Engineers, etc.)

5. “Immediate governmental relief of the unemployed by the extension of all public works and a program of long range planning of public works . . .” (In the 1930s, WPA and PWA were a direct counterpart; now, a wide variety of other programs are.) “All persons thus employed to be engaged at hours and wages fixed by bona-fide labor unions.” (The Davis-Bacon and Walsh-Healey Acts require contractors with government contracts to pay “prevailing wages,” generally interpreted as highest union wages.)

6. “Loans to states and municipalities without interest for the purpose of carrying on public works and the taking of such other measures as will lessen widespread misery.” (Federal grants in aid to states and local municipalities amount to billions of dollars a year.  Federal highway funds and many other public works projects.)

7. “A system of unemployment insurance.” (Part of Social Security system, as well as the Federal Unemployment Tax.)

8. “The nation-wide extension of public employment agencies in cooperation with city federations of labor.” (U.S. Employment Service and affiliated state employment services administer a network of thousands of local employment offices.)

9. “A system of health and accident insurance and of old age pensions as well as unemployment insurance.” (Part of Social Security, Unemployment. Universal health insurance coming soon.)

10. “Shortening the workday” and “Securing every worker a rest period of no less than two days in each week.” (Legislated by Department of Labor’s Wages and Hours Laws that require overtime for working more than eight hours per day or forty hours per week.)

11. “Enacting of an adequate federal anti-child labor amendment.” (Child labor provisions under Fair Labor Standards Act.)

12. “Abolition of the brutal exploitation of convicts under the contract system and substitution of a cooperative organization of industries in penitentiaries and workshops for the benefit of convicts and their dependents.” (In the 1930’s, contract labor was outlawed.  After that, rather than making products for private profit, inmates made license plates and other products for government or nonprofit agencies.  The Justice System Improvement Act of 1979 loosened regulations to allow prisons to put people to work, provided they paid prevailing wages, consulted unions, and didn’t displace workers outside prisons.)

13. “Legislation aiming at the prevention of occupational diseases.” (OSHA)

14. “Increase of taxation on high income levels, of corporation taxes and inheritance taxes, the proceeds to be used for old age pensions and other forms of social insurance.” (In 1928, highest personal income tax rate, 25 percent; in 2009, 35 percent, current proposals take that above 40%; in 1928, corporate tax rate, 12 percent; in 2009, 35-39% percent with proposed increases; in 1928, top federal estate tax rate, 20 percent; in 2009, 48% with proposed increases.)

15. “Appropriation by taxation of the annual rental value of all land held for speculation.” (Not achieved in this form, but property taxes have risen drastically.)

What were shunned as Socialist principles in 1928 are now generally accepted in American life.

If you find this interesting, please use the links below to forward to your friends.

The time when Stalin sent KGB agents to Hollywood to kill John Wayne because of his anti-communist beliefs

The time when Stalin sent KGB agents to Hollywood to kill John Wayne because of his anti-communist beliefs

The abused son of a poor, alcoholic Georgian cobbler, Josef Vissarionovich Djughashvili (the future Stalin) was one of the history’s most prolific killers. Stalin eliminated anyone and everyone who was a threat to his power – including (and especially) former allies. He had absolutely no regard for the sanctity of human life.

Stalin was, without a doubt, one of the most ruthless world leaders of the 20th Century, responsible for millions upon millions of deaths. But estimates of the number of deaths he caused vary wildly – from 3 million to 60 million.

Joseph Stalin - Russian revolutionary and Soviet political, state, military and party leader.
Joseph Stalin – Russian revolutionary and Soviet political, state, military and party leader.

Everyone who was against his politics, and against communism could be killed. It didn’t matter if they were a Soviet citizen or from another country. Michael Munn, a film historian and author of “John Wayne — The Man Behind The Myth,” claims that Stalin wanted to the famous Hollywood icon.

Stalin was so angered by John Wayne’s anti-communism that he plotted to have him murdered. He ordered the KGB to assassinate John Wayne because he considered him a threat to the Soviet Union.

When the Russian filmmaker Sergei Gerasimov attended a peace conference in New York in 1949 he heard about John Wayne and his anti-communist beliefs. When he returned to the Soviet Union he immediately told Stalin about John Wayne.

John Wayne in 1952
John Wayne in 1952

Stalin loved movies and he was more than a film-buff who’d teach Eisenstein how to make movies. He thought of himself to be a superior movie-producer/director/screenwriter as well as supreme censor; suggesting titles, ideas and stories, working on scripts and song lyrics, lecturing directors, coaching actors, ordering re-shoots and cuts and, finally, approving the movies for release.

Stalin loved Chaplin and films such as In Old Chicago (1937) and It Happened One Night (1934). Westerns with Spencer Tracy and Clark Gable were also some of his favorites.

Joseph Stalin
Joseph Stalin

Although he loved Westerns, he decided that John Wayne was a threat to the cause and should be assassinated.

Assassins were supposedly sent to Los Angeles in order to kill John Wayne. As Michael Munn says in his book, the FBI had discovered there were agents sent to Hollywood to assassinate the actor. They informed John about the plot and he told the FBI to let the men show up and he would deal with them himself.

John didn’t want his family to know about the fact that the KGB was trying to kill him and he moved with his family into a house with a big wall around it.

John Wayne in Rio Bravo, 1959
John Wayne in Rio Bravo, 1959

Mr. Munn says that a group of communists based in Burbank, near Hollywood, plotted to kill John Wayne. They failed to kill him just like the KGB agents that were sent before.

A further attempt to kill Wayne was made in Mexico on the set of the film Hondo led by a local communist cell, according to Mr. Munn.

The Soviet campaign was canceled after Stalin’s death in 1953 because his successor Nikita Khrushchev was a fan of the film star. The book says Krushchev told Wayne in a private meeting in 1958: “That was a decision of Stalin during his last five mad years. When Stalin died, I rescinded that order.”

Stalin depicted in the style of Socialist Realism. Painting by Isaak Brodsky
Stalin depicted in the style of Socialist Realism. Painting by Isaak Brodsky

Apparently, Stalin wasn’t the only communist leader that wanted the head of John Wayne. There was an attempt to kill John Wayne by an enemy sniper while he was visiting the troops in Vietnam in 1966. One of the snipers was captured, and said there was a price on John’s head, put there by Mao Zedong.

John Wayne died of cancer in 1979.

Exposed – The fourteen doubles of Joseph Stalin – Movie

Exposed – The fourteen doubles of Joseph Stalin – Movie

Joseph Stalin Young, Joseph Stalin Quotes, Joseph Stalin Facts, Joseph Stalin Definition, Joseph Stalin Death, Joseph Stalin Height, Joseph Stalin Quizlet, Joseph Stalin Biography, Joseph Stalin Cold War, Joseph Stalin Real Name, Joseph Stalin Apush, Joseph Stalin Accomplishments, Joseph Stalin Age, Joseph Stalin And Lenin, Joseph Stalin Animal Farm, Joseph Stalin And The Cold War, Joseph Stalin Ap Euro, Joseph Stalin And The Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin And Vladimir Lenin, Joseph Stalin As A Kid, Joseph Stalin Biography, Joseph Stalin Birthday, Joseph Stalin Beliefs, Joseph Stalin Birth And Death, Joseph Stalin Book, Joseph Stalin Born And Died, Joseph Stalin Bacon Number, Joseph Stalin Burial, Joseph Stalin Before Ww2, Joseph Stalin Baby, Joseph Stalin Cold War, Joseph Stalin Country, Joseph Stalin Cause Of Death, Joseph Stalin Communism, Joseph Stalin Cartoon, Joseph Stalin Communist, Joseph Stalin Cold War Speech, Joseph Stalin Costume, Joseph Stalin Clipart, Joseph Stalin Color, Joseph Stalin Definition, Joseph Stalin Death, Joseph Stalin Death Cause, Joseph Stalin Definition Ww2, Joseph Stalin Dies, Joseph Stalin Daughter, Joseph Stalin Drawing, Joseph Stalin Documentary, Joseph Stalin Date Of Birth, Joseph Stalin Death Date, Joseph Stalin Early Life, Joseph Stalin Economic Problems, Joseph Stalin Events, Joseph Stalin Eye Color, Joseph Stalin Essay, Joseph Stalin Era, Joseph Stalin Election, Joseph Stalin Effects, Joseph Stalin Economy, Joseph Stalin Erasing History, Joseph Stalin Facts, Joseph Stalin Family, Joseph Stalin Friends, Joseph Stalin Famous Quotes, Joseph Stalin Five Year Plan, Joseph Stalin Full Name, Joseph Stalin Fun Facts, Joseph Stalin Flag, Joseph Stalin Father, Joseph Stalin Funeral, Joseph Stalin Goals, Joseph Stalin Great Purge, Joseph Stalin Gulag, Joseph Stalin Gif, Joseph Stalin Granddaughter, Joseph Stalin Georgia, Joseph Stalin Grandson, Joseph Stalin Gorilla, Joseph Stalin Great Terror, Joseph Stalin General Secretary, Joseph Stalin Height, Joseph Stalin History, Joseph Stalin Haircut, Joseph Stalin How Did He Die, Joseph Stalin Hometown, Joseph Stalin History Definition, Joseph Stalin Hat, Joseph Stalin Hand, Joseph Stalin House, Joseph Stalin Hobbies, Joseph Stalin Importance, Joseph Stalin Interesting Facts, Joseph Stalin Images, Joseph Stalin Iq, Joseph Stalin Interests, Joseph Stalin Important Facts, Joseph Stalin Interview, Joseph Stalin Ideas, Joseph Stalin Iron Curtain, Joseph Stalin Influences, Joseph Stalin Job, Joseph Stalin Journal, Joseph Stalin Jacket, Joseph Stalin Joey Tribbiani, Joseph Stalin Joke Friends, Joseph Stalin John Wayne, Joseph Stalin Jesuit, Joseph Stalin Johnny Cash, Joseph Stalin Job In Ww2, Joseph Stalin Jesuit Priest, Joseph Stalin Korean War, Joseph Stalin Kid, Joseph Stalin Kgb, Joseph Stalin Kato, Joseph Stalin Kd Ratio, Joseph Stalin Kim Il Sung, Joseph Stalin Key Policies, Joseph Stalin Kimdir, Joseph Stalin Karl Marx, Joseph Stalin Kaiserreich, Joseph Stalin Leadership, Joseph Stalin Legacy, Joseph Stalin Life, Joseph Stalin Laughing, Joseph Stalin Life Timeline, Joseph Stalin Look Alike, Joseph Stalin Last Name, Joseph Stalin Leon Trotsky, Joseph Stalin Lenin, Joseph Stalin Last Photo, Joseph Stalin Memes, Joseph Stalin Movie, Joseph Stalin Man Of Steel, Joseph Stalin Main Accomplishments, Joseph Stalin Meaning, Joseph Stalin Mother, Joseph Stalin Minecraft Skin, Joseph Stalin Mario, Joseph Stalin Mii, Joseph Stalin Man Of Steel Worksheet, Joseph Stalin Nickname, Joseph Stalin Net Worth, Joseph Stalin Name Meaning, Joseph Stalin No Man No Problem, Joseph Stalin North Korea, Joseph Stalin Newspaper, Joseph Stalin Notes, Joseph Stalin Nicknames Vozhd, Joseph Stalin Nkvd, Joseph Stalin Napoleon, Joseph Stalin Original Name, Joseph Stalin Occupation, Joseph Stalin Old, Joseph Stalin Outfit, Joseph Stalin Obituary, Joseph Stalin On America, Joseph Stalin Order 227, Joseph Stalin Or Joseph Stalin, Joseph Stalin On Voting, Joseph Stalin Opposition, Joseph Stalin Political Party, Joseph Stalin Primary Sources, Joseph Stalin Policies, Joseph Stalin Pictures, Joseph Stalin Personality, Joseph Stalin Photoshop, Joseph Stalin Portrait, Joseph Stalin Poster, Joseph Stalin Powerpoint, Joseph Stalin Personality Type, Joseph Stalin Quotes, Joseph Stalin Quizlet, Joseph Stalin Questions And Answers, Joseph Stalin Quizlet Apush, Joseph Stalin Questions, Joseph Stalin Qualities, Joseph Stalin Quick Facts, Joseph Stalin Quiz, Joseph Stalin Quotes On America, Joseph Stalin Quizlet Chapter 16, Joseph Stalin Real Name, Joseph Stalin Rule, Joseph Stalin Russia, Joseph Stalin Red Terror, Joseph Stalin Reign Timeline, Joseph Stalin Relatives, Joseph Stalin Rank, Joseph Stalin Red Army, Joseph Stalin Reply To Churchill 1946, Joseph Stalin Resume, Joseph Stalin Son, Joseph Stalin Speech, Joseph Stalin Significance, Joseph Stalin Symbol, Joseph Stalin Summary, Joseph Stalin Statue, Joseph Stalin Siblings, Joseph Stalin Smiling, Joseph Stalin Short Biography, Joseph Stalin Strengths, Joseph Stalin Timeline, Joseph Stalin Title, Joseph Stalin Tank, Joseph Stalin Type Of Government, Joseph Stalin The Great Purge, Joseph Stalin Teenager, Joseph Stalin Traits, Joseph Stalin T Shirt, Joseph Stalin Tactics, Joseph Stalin Time Magazine, Joseph Stalin Us History Definition, Joseph Stalin Uniform, Joseph Stalin Ussr, Joseph Stalin Ukraine, Joseph Stalin Us History Quizlet, Joseph Stalin Urban Dictionary, Joseph Stalin Use Of Propaganda, Joseph Stalin Ukrainian Genocide, Joseph Stalin Ukraine Genocide, Joseph Stalin Ultranationalism, Joseph Stalin Video, Joseph Stalin Voice, Joseph Stalin Vs Napoleon, Joseph Stalin Views, Joseph Stalin Vs Trotsky, Joseph Stalin Vs, Joseph Stalin Values, Joseph Stalin Vs Rasputin Lyrics, Joseph Stalin Vietnam War, Joseph Stalin Vision, Joseph Stalin Ww2, Joseph Stalin Wife, Joseph Stalin Wiki, Joseph Stalin Ww2 Quizlet, Joseph Stalin Ww1 Definition, Joseph Stalin Winston Churchill Franklin Roosevelt, Joseph Stalin Webquest, Joseph Stalin Writings, Joseph Stalin Worksheet, Joseph Stalin Warsaw Pact, Joseph Stalin X Reader, Hitler And Joseph Stalin, Joseph Stalin Young, Joseph Stalin Young Life, Joseph Stalin Youtube, Joseph Stalin Year Of Power, Joseph Stalin Yalta, Joseph Stalin Years In Office, Joseph Stalin Young Zayn Malik, Joseph Stalin Yalta Conference, Joseph Stalin Yahoo Answers, Joseph Stalin Zodiac, Joseph Stalin Zayn Malik, Josef Stalin Zivotopis, Joseph Stalin Zayn, Joseph Stalin Zayn Malik Buzzfeed, Joseph Stalin Zoolander, Joseph Stalin Zitate, Joseph Stalin Zusammenfassung, Joseph Stalin Zoon, Young Joseph Stalin Zayn Malik, Double Stroller, Double Dragon, Double Door, Double Angle Formula, Double Entendre, Double Chalupa, Double Jeopardy, Doubletree, Double Rainbow, Double Decker Bus, Double Angle Formula, Double Angle Identities, Double A, Double Agent, Double A Battery, Double Action, Double Action Revolver, Double A Baseball, Double Arrow Symbol, Double Arrow, Double Bed, Double Bubble, Double Boiler, Double Bass, Double Bed Size, Double Barrel, Double Breasted Suit, Double Bob Stroller, Double Barrel 1911, Double Bed Dimensions, Double Chalupa, Double Chin, Double Cross Vodka, Double Crochet, Double Cream, Double Curtain Rod, Double Chocolate Chip Cookies, Double Clutch, Double Chalupa Box, Double Consciousness, Double Dragon, Double Door, Double Decker Bus, Double D, Double Down, Double Dutch Bus, Double Dutch, Double Din Radio, Double Dare, Double Down Casino, Double Entendre, Double Edged Sword, Double Entendre Example, Double Eyelid, Double Exposure, Double Eagle, Double Eyelid Surgery, Double Edge Razor, Double Eagle Golf, Double Elimination Bracket, Double French Braid, Double Fertilization, Double Fine, Double Fidget Spinner, Double Front Doors, Double Fantasy, Double Facepalm, Double Ferris Wheel, Double Feature, Double French Doors, Double Good, Double G, Double Garage Door, Double Gauze Fabric, Double Guitar, Double Good Burr Ridge, Double Good Chicago, Double Gang Box, Double Garage Door Size, Double Gate Latch, Double Helix, Double Hung Window, Double H Boots, Double Helix Definition, Double Header, Double Hammock, Double Helix Piercing, Double Hooded Sweatshirt, Double Hammock With Stand, Double Homicide, Double Indemnity, Double Integral Calculator, Double Impatiens, Double Impact, Double Ipa, Double Infinity, Double Integral, Double Identity, Double In Spanish, Double Impact 2, Double Jeopardy, Double Jj Resort, Double Jointed, Double Jogging Stroller, Double J, Double Jeopardy Movie, Double Jeopardy Law, Double Jeopardy Cast, Double Jaw Surgery, Double Jointed Arms, Double Knockout Roses, Double King, Double Kayak, Double K, Double Knockout, Double K Productions, Double Knot Tie, Double Kitchen Sink, Double Knitting, Double Knee Replacement, Double Life, Double Line Graph, Double Lyrics, Double Letter Words, Doublelift, Double Light Switch, Double Lung Transplant, Double Loft Bed, Double Leash, Double Lobe Piercing, Double Mastectomy, Double Map, Double Major, Double Minded Ink, Double Mattress, Double Monk Strap Shoes, Double Mommy, Double Meaning, Double Minded, Double Merle, Double Negative, Double Nose Piercing, Double Nose Ring, Double Neck Guitar, Double Nat, Double Nickel, Double Nickel 10s, Double Net Lease, Double Nickel Olathe, Double Negative Examples, Double Oven, Double Oven Gas Range, Double Object Pronouns Spanish, Double Or Nothing, Double Oven Range, Double Outlet Right Ventricle, Double Occupancy, Double Overhand Knot, Double Old Fashioned Glasses, Double O 7, Double Piercing, Double Pneumonia, Double Parking, Double Pane Windows, Double Process Color, Double Papasan Chair, Double Pole Switch, Double Pendulum, Double Play, Double Pulsar, Double Quarter Pounder, Double Quarter Pounder Calories, Double Quotes, Double Quotation Marks, Double Quick, Double Quarter Pounder Price, Double Question Mark C#, Double Queen Bed, Double Quinceanera, Double Queen Box Spring, Double Rainbow, Double Replacement Reaction, Double Recliner, Double Room Hotel, Double Rod Curtain, Double Room, Double Rainbow Song, Double Robotics, Double R Display, Double Rainbow Meaning, Double Stroller, Double Standard, Double Sided Tape, Double Slit Experiment, Double Sink Vanity, Double Stuffed Oreos, Double Stack, Double Stack 1911, Double Strap Sandals, Double Sleeping Bag, Doubletree, Double Tap, Double Team Movie, Double Trouble, Double Take, Doubletree Chicago, Double Toasted, Doubletree Skokie, Doubletree Alsip, Double Team, Double Umbrella Stroller, Double Unders, Double U, Double U Casino, Double Uni Knot, Double U Madison, Double Uterus, Double Up, Double Up Tankini, Double Under Wonder, Double Vision, Double Vanity, Double V Campaign, Double Vision Song, Double Vanity Cabinet, Double V, Doubleverify, Double Vision In One Eye, Double Vision Lyrics, Double Vs Float, Double Wide Trailer, Double Windsor, Double Whammy, Double Wide, Double Wall Oven, Double Windsor Knot, Double Wedding, Double Whopper, Double Wedding Ring Quilt, Double Wear Estee Lauder, Double X, Double Xl, Double Xp Weekend, Double X Speedway, Double Xl Pizza, Double Xp, Double Xxl, Double Xp Runescape, Double Xl Song, Double Xp Weekend Bo3, Double Yolk, Double Yolk Menu, Double Yolk Cafe, Double Yolk Aurora, Double Yellow Line, Double Y Sales, Double Yolk Mokena Menu, Double Your Dating, Double Yolk Hours, Double Your Money, Double Zero Flour, Double Zero Clothing, Double Zero, Double Zero Headphones, Double Zero Nyc, Double Zipper Wallet, Double Z Bra, Double Zero Gauges, Double Zeta Gundam, Double Zipper,