BERND PULCH.ORG – THE ONLY MEDIA WITH THE LICENSE TO SPY -YOU WILL SEE GOD IN ACTION – Censored and surpressed by Google – TOXDAT, STASI Liste, STASI Schläfer Liste, KGB Liste, BDVP Liste, DDR POLIZEI Liste, GOMOPA4ALL -THE INDEPENDENT VOICE OF FREEDOM – NO MORE FAIRY TALES – NO GATES OR SOROS FUNDING – NO PROJECT SYNDICATE – SCHLUSS MIT MÄRCHENSTUNDE – Kein Relotius – Keine Hitler-Tagebücher – Keine Peanuts – Great Reset, GOMOPA4KIDS-Pädophilen-Netzwerk, GOMOPA Opfer Liste, GOMOPA Täter, NO FAIRY TALES – TOXDAT, STASI List, STASI SLEEPER List, KGB List, BDVP List, STASI Names A-Z, DDR-EAST GERMAN POLICE List, Offshore List, WEF Lists, Leaks Lists, GOMOPA4KIDS-Pedophiles-Network, GOMOPA Victims List, GOMOPA Offender Names, Stalin, Berija, Mao, Xi, Kim, Pol Pot, Putin, Erich Mielke, Ehrenfried Stelzer, Monika Mucha, Michèle Mucha, Jochen Resch, Alexander Schalck-Golodkowski, Kim Philby, Wolfgang Schnur, IM Erika, Gregor Gysi, Gerhard Schroeder, Matthias Warnig, Friedhelm Laschütza, Angela Merkel, William Borm, Adolf Kanter, Udo Albrecht, Gerhard Baumann, Gert Caden, Andreas Lorch, Anette Lorch, Britta Lorch, Catrin Lorch, Hermann Simm, Mischa Wolf, Peter Ehlers, Axel Hilpert, Thomas Promny, Jan Mucha, Klaus Croissant, Isabell Colonius, Sven Schmidt / Eagle IT, Gerd Löffler, Detlev K. Manthey, Dieter Feuerstein, Klaus-Dieter Maurischat, Beate & Thomas Porten, Sonja Lüneburg, Rainer Rupp, Christel & Günter Guillaume – The One And Only Website With The License To Spy ! Donations: www.berndpulch.org/donations Warning: Only this facebook account of me is legit:https://m.facebook.com/bernd.pulch/ The others are faked by the STASI Desperados as well as berndpulch.com
Become a Patron! True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.
Until now, this has been a computational challenge of “extraordinary difficulty,” the researchers wrote, with obstacles posed by different facial poses, expressions, and variable lighting.
“Typically if you want to reconstruct a face you have to try and use something called 3D morphable models, or shape from shading,” Aaron Jackson, a Ph.D. student who works on deep learning applied to human faces and who is one of the authors of the paper, told Seeker.
This method of 3D facial reconstruction analyzes shadows on the face to come up with a likely structure. It requires multiple images and poses.
The Directorate of Military Intelligence is called Agaf HaModi’in in Hebrew. It is often abbreviated as A’man.
Service Years
Name
2010 – Present
Maj. Gen. Aviv Kokhavi
2006 – 2010
Maj. Gen. Amos Yadlin
2001 – 2006
Maj. Gen. Aharon Zeevi-Farkash
1998 – 2001
Maj. Gen. Amos Malka
1995 – 1998
Maj. Gen. Moshe Ya’alon
1991 – 1995
Maj. Gen. Uri Saguy
1986 – 1991
Maj. Gen. Amnon Lipkin-Shahak
1983 – 1985
Maj. Gen. Ehud Barak
1979 – 1983
Maj. Gen. Yehoshua Saguy
1974 – 1978
Maj. Gen. Shlomo Gazit
1972 – 1974
Maj. Gen. Eliahu Zeira
1964 – 1972
Maj. Gen. Aharon Yariv
1962 – 1963
Maj. Gen. Meir Amit
1959 – 1962
Maj. Gen. Chaim Herzog
1955 – 1959
Maj. Gen. Yehoshafat Harkabi
1950 – 1955
Col. Binyamin Gibli
1949 – 1950
Col. Chaim Herzog
1948 – 1949
Isser Be’eri
Israel News, Israel Map, Israel Flag, Israel Keyes, Israel Houghton, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole, Israel Palestine, Israel Population, Israel Houghton Kids, Israel Capital, Israel And Palestine, Israel Airlines, Israel Abbreviation, Israel Airport, Israel Apartheid, Israeli Army, Israel Anti Boycott Act, Israel Allies, Israel And Syria, Israel And New Breed, Israel Bonds, Israel Broussard, Israel Birthright, Israel Bombs Syria, Israel Borders, Israel Bombing, Israel Boone, Israel Beaches, Israel Baseball Hat, Israeli Border Wall, Israel Capital, Israel Continent, Israel Country Code, Israel Consulate Chicago, Israeli Couscous, Israel Climate, Israel Cities, Israel Conflict, Israel Capital City, Israel Coins, Israel Del Toro, Israel Definition, Israel Defense Forces, Israel Duffus, Israel Demographics, Israel Desert, Israel Diamonds, Israel Discount Bank, Israel Desalination, Israel Declares Independence, Israel Englander, Israel Egypt War, Israel Exports, Israel Established, Israel Experts, Israel Egypt, Israeli Embassy, Israel Etf, Israel Enemies, Israel Education, Israel Flag, Israel Facts, Israel Founded, Israel Flag Emoji, Israeli Food, Israel Fun Facts, Israel Flights, Israel Finkelstein, Israel Free Spirit, Israel Flag Meaning, Israel Government, Israel Gdp, Israel Geography, Israel Gdp Per Capita, Israel God, Israel Gutierrez, Israel Gross, Israel Gonzalez, Israel Gun Laws, Israel Gaza, Israel Houghton, Israel Houghton Kids, Israel History, Israel Hands, Israel Hayom, Israel Houghton Songs, Israel Holidays, Israel Hodish, Israel Houghton You Are Good, Israel Houghton Wedding, Israel Iz Kamakawiwo\u02bbole, Israel Independence Day, Israel Independence, Israel Iron Dome, Israel In Hebrew, Israel Isis, Israel In The Bible, Israel Iran, Israel India, Israel Idonije, Israel Jerusalem, Israel Jewish, Israel Jordan, Israel Jewish Population, Israel Jimenez, Israel Jesus, Israel Jobs, Israel Jacob, Israel Jewelry, Israel Juarbe, Israel Keyes, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Wife, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Songs, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Israel Kristal, Israel Kali A K, Israel Kibbutz, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Over The Rainbow, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Net Worth, Israel Language, Israel Location, Israel Local Time, Israel Leader, Israel Liberzon, Israel Landscape, Israel Life Expectancy, Israel Literacy Rate, Israel Lebanon, Israel Lebanon War, Israel Map, Israel Meaning, Israel Museum, Israel Money, Israel Movie, Israel Music, Israel Middle East, Israel My Glory, Israel Meme, Israeli Military, Israel News, Israel Name Meaning, Israel National News, Israel National Anthem, Israel News Live, Israel Nash, Israel News Today, Israel Natural Resources, Israel Nukes, Israel Name, Israel On Map, Israel Of God, Israel Outdoors, Israel On World Map, Israel Official Language, Israel On The House, Israel Oil, Israel Or Palestine, Israel Outline, Israel Outlet, Israel Palestine, Israel Population, Israel Palestine Map, Israel Putnam, Israel Post, Israeli Prime Ministers, Israel Palestine Conflict Timeline, Israel Pictures, Israel Population 2017, Israel Pakistan, Israel Quotes, Israel Quizlet, Israel Qatar, Israel Quest, Israel Qatar Relations, Israel Quiz, Israel Questions, Israel Queen, Israel Quality Of Life, Israel Quest Reviews, Israel Religion, Israel Russia, Israel Regardie, Israel Real Estate, Israel Rodriguez, Israel Rose, Israel Radio, Israel Region, Israel Resources, Israel Railways, Israel Syria, Israel Settlements, Israel Size, Israel Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Israel Six Day War, Israel Square Miles, Israel Supports Isis, Israel Saudi Arabia, Israel Symbols, Israel Shamir, Israel Time, Israel Time Now, Israel Tours, Israel Travel, Israel Today, Israel Tourism, Israel Trump, Israel Trip, Israel Third Temple, Israel Timeline, Israel United In Christ, Israel Us Relations, Israel Update, Israel United In Christ Videos, Israel Un, Israel Unlimited, Israel Unemployment Rate, Israel Us Embassy, Israel Universal Health Care, Israel University, Israel Vs Palestine, Israel Vibration, Israel Video Network, Israel Vacation, Israel Visa, Israel Vs Iran, Israel Vaccinations, Israel Visa Requirements, Israel Vs Syria, Israel Vs Judah, Israel Wall, Israel World Baseball Classic, Israel Weather, Israel War, Israeli Women, Israel World Baseball Classic Roster, Israel Wikipedia, Israel World Map, Israel West Bank, Israel Western Wall, Israel X Factor, Israel Xp, Israeli X95, Israel X Factor 2016, Israel X, Israel X Factor 2017, Israeli X, Israel X Factor Judges, Israel Xbmc, Israel X Band Radar, Israel Youtube, Israel Year Of Independence, Israel Year, Israel Y Palestina, Israel Yad Vashem, Israel Yemen, Israel Young, Israel Y Moises, Israel Youtube Channel, Israel Yearly Weather, Israel Zangwill, Israel Zip Code, Israel Zamora, Israel Zin River, Israel Zionist, Israel Zolli, Israel Z, Israel Zangwill Melting Pot, Israeli Zoo, Israel Zip Code Lookup, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Analyst Jobs, Intelligence Agencies, Intelligence Analyst Salary, Intelligence Analysis, Intelligence Agencies Us, Intelligence Agent, Intelligence Analyst Jobs Michigan, Intelligence Analyst Army, Intelligence Analyst Fbi, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 4, Intelligence By Race, Intelligence Briefing, Intelligence Bell Curve, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 3, Intelligence Build Dark Souls 3, Intelligencebank, Intelligence Bureau, Intelligence Build Fallout 4, Intelligence By State, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Cycle, Intelligence Committee Members, Intelligence Careers, Intelligence Committee Hearing, Intelligence Committee House, Intelligence Cast, Intelligence Contractors, Intelligence Committee Russia, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Definition Psychology, Intelligence Degree, Intelligence Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Design, Intelligence Director, Intelligence Dark Souls, Intelligence Disciplines, Intelligence Dnd, Intelligence Depression, Intelligence Explosion, Intelligence Everywhere, Intelligence Etymology, Intelligence Examples, Intelligence Estimate, Intelligence Emotional, Intelligence Essay, Intelligence Events Google Analytics, Intelligence Evolution, Intelligence Education, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence For Your Life Cast, Intelligence Fallout 4, Intelligence For Your Life Wiki, Intelligence From Mother, Intelligence From Secrets To Policy, Intelligence For Your Life Tv Show, Intelligence Failures, Intelligence Fusion Center, Intelligence For Your Health, Intelligence Gathering, Intelligence Gene, Intelligence Genetic, Intelligence Group, Intelligence Games, Intelligence G, Intelligence Gap, Intelligence Gathering Process, Intelligence Gathering Techniques, Intelligence Gardner, Intelligence Hearing, Intelligence Heritability, Intelligence Hereditary, Intelligence House Committee, Intelligence Home, Intelligence Hearings Today, Intelligence Hierarchy, Intelligence History, Intelligence Hearing Russia, Intelligence Happiness, Intelligence Is Sexy, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change Shirt, Intelligence In Spanish, Intelligence Is, Intelligence In Psychology, Intelligence Internships, Intelligence Icon, Intelligence In Latin, Intelligence Inherited, Intelligence Jobs, Intelligence Journal, Intelligence Jokes, Intelligence Jobs In The Navy, Intelligence Jobs Salary, Intelligence Jobs Army, Intelligence Jobs In The Air Force, Intelligence Jobs In Texas, Intelligence Jobs Colorado, Intelligence Job Description, Intelligence Knowns And Unknowns, Intelligence Knowledge Network, Intelligence Knowledge, Intelligence Kotor, Intelligence Kink, Intelligence Kevin Hart, Intelligence Knowledge Wisdom, Intelligence Kanji, Intelligence Kid Buu Dokkan, Intelligence Kotor 2, Intelligence Led Policing, Intelligence Level, Intelligence Leaks, Intelligence Led Policing Definition, Intelligence Logo, Intelligence Law, Intelligence Level Meme, Intelligence Life Cycle, Intelligence Level Of Dogs, Intelligence Led Policing Ratcliffe, Intelligence Meme, Intelligence Meaning, Intelligence Movie, Intelligence Mos, Intelligence Meme Template, Intelligence Military, Intelligence Measurement, Intelligence Magazine, Intelligence Major, Intelligence Mother, Intelligence News, Intelligence Nature Vs Nurture, Intelligence New Vegas, Intelligence Network, Intelligence Navy, Intelligence Nunes, Intelligence Node, Intelligence New Findings And Theoretical Developments, Intelligence Nature, Intelligence Nurture, Intelligence Officer, Intelligence Of Dogs, Intelligence Oversight, Intelligence Officer Air Force, Intelligence Officer Navy, Intelligence Officer Army, Intelligence Of Octopus, Intelligence Of Border Collies, Intelligence Of Crows, Intelligence Of Pigs, Intelligence Psychology, Intelligence Preparation Of The Battlefield, Intelligence Plus Character, Intelligence Pathfinder, Intelligence Poe, Intelligence Pill, Intelligence Process, Intelligence Perks Fallout 4, Intelligence Passed From Mothers, Intelligence Psychology Quizlet, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Quiz, Intelligence Quotient Definition, Intelligence Quotient Test, Intelligence Quotient Psychology Definition, Intelligence Questions, Intelligence Quizlet, Intelligent Qube, Intelligence Quotient Quizlet, Intelligence Report, Intelligence Reform And Terrorism Prevention Act, Intelligence Research Specialist, Intelligence Reddit, Intelligence Ring Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Report Richard Young, Intelligence Research, Intelligence Reform, Intelligence Rhyme, Intelligence Research Specialist Salary, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence Specialist, Intelligence Support Activity, Intelligence Specialist Navy, Intelligence Squared Debate, Intelligence Studies, Intelligence Scale, Intelligence Symbol, Intelligence Search, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Test Psychology, Intelligence Test Questions, Intelligence Unit, Intelligence University, Intelligence Us, Intelligence Unmasking, Intelligence Usa, Intelligence Usmc, Intelligence Unit 8200, Intelligence Unbound, Intelligence Unit Nypd, Intelligence Unleashed An Argument For Ai In Education, Intelligence Vs Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Knowledge, Intelligence Vs Achievement, Intelligence Vs Intellect, Intelligence Vs Creativity, Intelligence Vs Iq, Intelligence Vs Religion, Intelligence Versus Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Information, Intelligence Vs Happiness, Intelligence Weapons Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Wiki, Intelligence Without Ambition, Intelligence Without Representation, Intelligence Websites, Intelligence Without Wisdom, Intelligence Work, Intelligence War, Intelligence Warfighting Function, Intelligence Warfare, Intelligence X Chromosome, Intelligence Xp Bonus Fallout 4, Intelligence Xp Boost Fallout 4, Intelligence X, Intelligence Xword, Intelligence X Chromosome Lancet, Intelligence Xmovies8, Intelligence X Ray, Xenomorph Intelligence, Xq Intelligence, Intelligence Youtube, Intelligence Y Chromosome, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Zodiac Signs, Intelligence Zinc Copper Hair, Zambian Intelligence, Intelligence Zero, Intelligence Zoom, Intelligence Zombie, Intelligence Czar, Zambian Intelligence News Facebook, Zeal Intelligence, Zambian Intelligence Service, Security Of State, Security Robot, Security Cameras, Security Robot Drowns Itself, Security Credit Union, Security Systems, Security Doors, Security Jobs, Security Guard, Security Movie, Security Auto Loans, Security Analyst, Security Administration, Security Analysis, Security Analyst Salary, Security Apps, Security And Exchange Commission, Security Awareness Training, Security Alarm, Security Account Manager, Security Bank, Security Benefit, Security Breach, Security Blanket, Security Booth Code Prey, Security Bond, Security Badge, Security Box, Security Bit Set, Security Bank Hours, Security Cameras, Security Credit Union, Security Clearance, Security Camera System, Security Companies, Security Council, Security Code, Security Corporation, Security Clearance Levels, Security Credit, Security Doors, Security Deposit, Security Definition, Security Deposit Definition, Security Deposit Help, Security Doors Detroit, Security Doors And Windows, Security Door Locks, Security Dilemma, Security Deposit Act Michigan, Security Essentials, Security Equipment Supply, Security Exchange Commission, Security Engineer, Security Engineer Salary, Security Equipment, Security Envelopes, Security Exterior Door, Security Earpiece, Security Exchange, Security Federal Credit Union, Security Federal, Security Finance, Security Federal Credit Union Flint, Security Forces, Security First, Security Fence, Security First Insurance, Security Film, Security Freeze, Security Guard, Security Guard Jobs, Security Guard Training, Security Guard Companies, Security Guard Salary, Security Gate, Security Guard Companies In Detroit, Security Guard Job Description, Security Guard Resume, Security Google, Security Health Plan, Security Hacker, Security Hat, Security Home Systems, Security Hardware, Security Home Cameras, Security Hinges, Security Headset, Security Hex Key, Security Hoodie, Security Interest, Security Icon, Security Industry Specialists, Security In Spanish, Security Inspection, Security Insurance, Security Instrument, Security Innovation, Security Images, Security Issues, Security Jobs, Security Jobs Near Me, Security Job Description, Security Jobs In Michigan, Security Jobs Hiring, Security Jobs Columbus Ohio, Security Jackets, Security Jobs In Detroit Michigan, Security Jobs Overseas, Security Jobs Hiring Near Me, Security Key, Security Keypad, Securitykiss, Security Keeper, Security King, Security Kalamazoo College, Security Key Usb, Security Key Fob, Security Key Wifi, Security Key Swtor, Security Lights, Security Lock, Security License, Security Level Iv, Security Logo, Security Level 2 Prison, Security Life Insurance, Security Light In Car, Security Light Bulbs, Security Life Of Denver, Security Movie, Security Metrics, Security Market Line, Security Meaning, Security Manager Jobs, Security Mortgage, Security Meme, Security Monitoring, Security Mirrors, Security Manager, Security National Bank, Security Now, Security News, Security National, Security National Mortgage, Security Number, Security National Bank Locations, Security National Insurance Company, Security National Bank Near Me, Security National Life, Security Of State, Security Office, Security Onion, Security Officer Jobs, Security Of State Michigan, Security Officer Job Description, Security Operations Center, Security Officer Salary, Security One, Security Of State Hamtramck, Security Plus, Security Pest Control, Security Plus Certification, Security Policy, Security Pest Control Canton Mi, Security Patches, Security Perimeter, Security Posture, Security Plus Training, Security Paper, Security Questions, Security Quotes, Security Questions List, Security Questions Apple, Security Questionnaire, Security Questions Facebook, Security Quiz, Security Qualifications, Security Questions Yahoo, Security Question Gmail, Security Robot, Security Robot Drowns Itself, Security Radios, Security Resume, Security Risk Assessment, Security Rule, Security Retirement, Security Rolling Shutters, Security Risk Analysis, Security Risk, Security Systems, Security Service Fcu, Security Storm Doors, Security State, Security Screen Doors, Security Synonyms, Security Safe, Security Software, Security Screws, Security State Bank, Security Trust Lofts, Security Threats, Security Training, Security Tag Remover, Security Theater, Security Trailer, Security Testing, Security Task Manager, Security Tags, Security Torx, Security Uniforms, Security Uniform Store Near Me, Security Updates, Security Union Bank, Security Union, Security Unlimited, Security Update Amazon, Security Update Error Virus, Security University, Security Uniform Pants, Security Vitals, Security Vest, Security Vulnerability, Security Vs Privacy, Security Video Camera, Security Vs Liberty, Security Vault, Security Video, Security Vault Works, Security Vulnerability Assessment, Security Windows, Security Window Film, Security Wallet, Security Window Shutters, Security Window Bars, Security Weekly, Security Wait Time At Dtw, Security Week, Security Wand, Security Window Screens, Security Xfinity, Securityxploded, Security X Ray Images, Security Xchange, Security X Ray Machine, Security X Ray Scanner, Security Xfinity Wifi, Security X Ray, Security Xss, Security Xkcd, Security Yard Signs, Security Youtube, Security Yellow Hoodie, Security Yard Sign Stakes, Security Yard Light, Security Young Thug, Security Yard Sign Light, Security Yahoo, Security Yield, Security Yuma Az, Security Zone, Security Zip Ties, Security Zip Code, Security Zero To Hero, Security Zero Escape, Security Zipper, Security Zero Day, Security Zones Network, Security Zones Internet Explorer, Security Zone Inc
Become a Patron! True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.
The Mossad (Hebrew: הַמוֹסָד, IPA: [ha moˈsad]; Arabic: الموساد, al-Mōsād; literally meaning “the Institute”), short for HaMossad leModiʿin uleTafkidim Meyuḥadim (Hebrew: המוסד למודיעין ולתפקידים מיוחדים, meaning “Institute for Intelligence and Special Operations”; Arabic: الموساد للاستخبارات والمهام الخاصة al-Mōsād lil-Istikhbārāt wal-Mahāmm al-Khāṣṣah), is the national intelligence agency of Israel. It is one of the main entities in the Israeli Intelligence Community, along with Aman (military intelligence) and Shin Bet (internal security).
The Mossad is responsible for intelligence collection, covert operations, and counterterrorism, as well as bringing Jews to Israel from countries where official Aliyah agencies are forbidden, and protecting Jewish communities. Its director reports directly to the Prime Minister.
The Directorate of Military Intelligence (Hebrew: אגף המודיעין, Agaf HaModi’in — lit. “the Intelligence Section”, often abbreviated to Aman) is the central, overarching military intelligence body of the Israel Defense Forces. Aman was created in 1950, when the Intelligence Department was spun off from the IDF’s General Staff (then, Agam: אג”ם); the Intelligence Department itself was composed largely of former members of the Haganah Intelligence Service (HIS). Aman is an independent service, and not part of the ground forces, navy or the Israeli Air Force.
It is one of the main entities in the Israeli Intelligence Community, along with Mossad (national intelligence) and Shin Bet (general security). It is currently headed by Major General Aviv Kochavi. It has a staff of 7,000 personnel (1996 estimate). Its special forces and field-reconnaissance unit is Sayeret Matkal.
Sherut haBitachon haKlali (Hebrew: שירות הביטחון הכללי, General Security Service), better known by the acronym Shabak (Hebrew: שב״כ, IPA: [ʃaˈbak], Arabic: شاباك), in English as the Israel Security Agency (ISA) or the Shin Bet (a two-letter Hebrew abbreviation of the name), is Israel’s internal security service. Its motto is “Magen VeLo Yera’e” (Hebrew: מגן ולא יראה, lit. “Defender that shall not be seen” or “The unseen shield”). It is one of three principal organizations of the Israeli Intelligence Community, alongside Aman (military intelligence) and the Mossad (foreign intelligence service). Shin Bet’s special operations unit is Yamas.
Israel News, Israel Map, Israel Flag, Israel Keyes, Israel Houghton, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole, Israel Palestine, Israel Population, Israel Houghton Kids, Israel Capital, Israel And Palestine, Israel Airlines, Israel Abbreviation, Israel Airport, Israel Apartheid, Israeli Army, Israel Anti Boycott Act, Israel Allies, Israel And Syria, Israel And New Breed, Israel Bonds, Israel Broussard, Israel Birthright, Israel Bombs Syria, Israel Borders, Israel Bombing, Israel Boone, Israel Beaches, Israel Baseball Hat, Israeli Border Wall, Israel Capital, Israel Continent, Israel Country Code, Israel Consulate Chicago, Israeli Couscous, Israel Climate, Israel Cities, Israel Conflict, Israel Capital City, Israel Coins, Israel Del Toro, Israel Definition, Israel Defense Forces, Israel Duffus, Israel Demographics, Israel Desert, Israel Diamonds, Israel Discount Bank, Israel Desalination, Israel Declares Independence, Israel Englander, Israel Egypt War, Israel Exports, Israel Established, Israel Experts, Israel Egypt, Israeli Embassy, Israel Etf, Israel Enemies, Israel Education, Israel Flag, Israel Facts, Israel Founded, Israel Flag Emoji, Israeli Food, Israel Fun Facts, Israel Flights, Israel Finkelstein, Israel Free Spirit, Israel Flag Meaning, Israel Government, Israel Gdp, Israel Geography, Israel Gdp Per Capita, Israel God, Israel Gutierrez, Israel Gross, Israel Gonzalez, Israel Gun Laws, Israel Gaza, Israel Houghton, Israel Houghton Kids, Israel History, Israel Hands, Israel Hayom, Israel Houghton Songs, Israel Holidays, Israel Hodish, Israel Houghton You Are Good, Israel Houghton Wedding, Israel Iz Kamakawiwo\u02bbole, Israel Independence Day, Israel Independence, Israel Iron Dome, Israel In Hebrew, Israel Isis, Israel In The Bible, Israel Iran, Israel India, Israel Idonije, Israel Jerusalem, Israel Jewish, Israel Jordan, Israel Jewish Population, Israel Jimenez, Israel Jesus, Israel Jobs, Israel Jacob, Israel Jewelry, Israel Juarbe, Israel Keyes, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Wife, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Songs, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Israel Kristal, Israel Kali A K, Israel Kibbutz, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Over The Rainbow, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole Net Worth, Israel Language, Israel Location, Israel Local Time, Israel Leader, Israel Liberzon, Israel Landscape, Israel Life Expectancy, Israel Literacy Rate, Israel Lebanon, Israel Lebanon War, Israel Map, Israel Meaning, Israel Museum, Israel Money, Israel Movie, Israel Music, Israel Middle East, Israel My Glory, Israel Meme, Israeli Military, Israel News, Israel Name Meaning, Israel National News, Israel National Anthem, Israel News Live, Israel Nash, Israel News Today, Israel Natural Resources, Israel Nukes, Israel Name, Israel On Map, Israel Of God, Israel Outdoors, Israel On World Map, Israel Official Language, Israel On The House, Israel Oil, Israel Or Palestine, Israel Outline, Israel Outlet, Israel Palestine, Israel Population, Israel Palestine Map, Israel Putnam, Israel Post, Israeli Prime Ministers, Israel Palestine Conflict Timeline, Israel Pictures, Israel Population 2017, Israel Pakistan, Israel Quotes, Israel Quizlet, Israel Qatar, Israel Quest, Israel Qatar Relations, Israel Quiz, Israel Questions, Israel Queen, Israel Quality Of Life, Israel Quest Reviews, Israel Religion, Israel Russia, Israel Regardie, Israel Real Estate, Israel Rodriguez, Israel Rose, Israel Radio, Israel Region, Israel Resources, Israel Railways, Israel Syria, Israel Settlements, Israel Size, Israel Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Israel Six Day War, Israel Square Miles, Israel Supports Isis, Israel Saudi Arabia, Israel Symbols, Israel Shamir, Israel Time, Israel Time Now, Israel Tours, Israel Travel, Israel Today, Israel Tourism, Israel Trump, Israel Trip, Israel Third Temple, Israel Timeline, Israel United In Christ, Israel Us Relations, Israel Update, Israel United In Christ Videos, Israel Un, Israel Unlimited, Israel Unemployment Rate, Israel Us Embassy, Israel Universal Health Care, Israel University, Israel Vs Palestine, Israel Vibration, Israel Video Network, Israel Vacation, Israel Visa, Israel Vs Iran, Israel Vaccinations, Israel Visa Requirements, Israel Vs Syria, Israel Vs Judah, Israel Wall, Israel World Baseball Classic, Israel Weather, Israel War, Israeli Women, Israel World Baseball Classic Roster, Israel Wikipedia, Israel World Map, Israel West Bank, Israel Western Wall, Israel X Factor, Israel Xp, Israeli X95, Israel X Factor 2016, Israel X, Israel X Factor 2017, Israeli X, Israel X Factor Judges, Israel Xbmc, Israel X Band Radar, Israel Youtube, Israel Year Of Independence, Israel Year, Israel Y Palestina, Israel Yad Vashem, Israel Yemen, Israel Young, Israel Y Moises, Israel Youtube Channel, Israel Yearly Weather, Israel Zangwill, Israel Zip Code, Israel Zamora, Israel Zin River, Israel Zionist, Israel Zolli, Israel Z, Israel Zangwill Melting Pot, Israeli Zoo, Israel Zip Code Lookup, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Analyst Jobs, Intelligence Agencies, Intelligence Analyst Salary, Intelligence Analysis, Intelligence Agencies Us, Intelligence Agent, Intelligence Analyst Jobs Michigan, Intelligence Analyst Army, Intelligence Analyst Fbi, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 4, Intelligence By Race, Intelligence Briefing, Intelligence Bell Curve, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 3, Intelligence Build Dark Souls 3, Intelligencebank, Intelligence Bureau, Intelligence Build Fallout 4, Intelligence By State, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Cycle, Intelligence Committee Members, Intelligence Careers, Intelligence Committee Hearing, Intelligence Committee House, Intelligence Cast, Intelligence Contractors, Intelligence Committee Russia, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Definition Psychology, Intelligence Degree, Intelligence Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Design, Intelligence Director, Intelligence Dark Souls, Intelligence Disciplines, Intelligence Dnd, Intelligence Depression, Intelligence Explosion, Intelligence Everywhere, Intelligence Etymology, Intelligence Examples, Intelligence Estimate, Intelligence Emotional, Intelligence Essay, Intelligence Events Google Analytics, Intelligence Evolution, Intelligence Education, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence For Your Life Cast, Intelligence Fallout 4, Intelligence For Your Life Wiki, Intelligence From Mother, Intelligence From Secrets To Policy, Intelligence For Your Life Tv Show, Intelligence Failures, Intelligence Fusion Center, Intelligence For Your Health, Intelligence Gathering, Intelligence Gene, Intelligence Genetic, Intelligence Group, Intelligence Games, Intelligence G, Intelligence Gap, Intelligence Gathering Process, Intelligence Gathering Techniques, Intelligence Gardner, Intelligence Hearing, Intelligence Heritability, Intelligence Hereditary, Intelligence House Committee, Intelligence Home, Intelligence Hearings Today, Intelligence Hierarchy, Intelligence History, Intelligence Hearing Russia, Intelligence Happiness, Intelligence Is Sexy, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change Shirt, Intelligence In Spanish, Intelligence Is, Intelligence In Psychology, Intelligence Internships, Intelligence Icon, Intelligence In Latin, Intelligence Inherited, Intelligence Jobs, Intelligence Journal, Intelligence Jokes, Intelligence Jobs In The Navy, Intelligence Jobs Salary, Intelligence Jobs Army, Intelligence Jobs In The Air Force, Intelligence Jobs In Texas, Intelligence Jobs Colorado, Intelligence Job Description, Intelligence Knowns And Unknowns, Intelligence Knowledge Network, Intelligence Knowledge, Intelligence Kotor, Intelligence Kink, Intelligence Kevin Hart, Intelligence Knowledge Wisdom, Intelligence Kanji, Intelligence Kid Buu Dokkan, Intelligence Kotor 2, Intelligence Led Policing, Intelligence Level, Intelligence Leaks, Intelligence Led Policing Definition, Intelligence Logo, Intelligence Law, Intelligence Level Meme, Intelligence Life Cycle, Intelligence Level Of Dogs, Intelligence Led Policing Ratcliffe, Intelligence Meme, Intelligence Meaning, Intelligence Movie, Intelligence Mos, Intelligence Meme Template, Intelligence Military, Intelligence Measurement, Intelligence Magazine, Intelligence Major, Intelligence Mother, Intelligence News, Intelligence Nature Vs Nurture, Intelligence New Vegas, Intelligence Network, Intelligence Navy, Intelligence Nunes, Intelligence Node, Intelligence New Findings And Theoretical Developments, Intelligence Nature, Intelligence Nurture, Intelligence Officer, Intelligence Of Dogs, Intelligence Oversight, Intelligence Officer Air Force, Intelligence Officer Navy, Intelligence Officer Army, Intelligence Of Octopus, Intelligence Of Border Collies, Intelligence Of Crows, Intelligence Of Pigs, Intelligence Psychology, Intelligence Preparation Of The Battlefield, Intelligence Plus Character, Intelligence Pathfinder, Intelligence Poe, Intelligence Pill, Intelligence Process, Intelligence Perks Fallout 4, Intelligence Passed From Mothers, Intelligence Psychology Quizlet, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Quiz, Intelligence Quotient Definition, Intelligence Quotient Test, Intelligence Quotient Psychology Definition, Intelligence Questions, Intelligence Quizlet, Intelligent Qube, Intelligence Quotient Quizlet, Intelligence Report, Intelligence Reform And Terrorism Prevention Act, Intelligence Research Specialist, Intelligence Reddit, Intelligence Ring Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Report Richard Young, Intelligence Research, Intelligence Reform, Intelligence Rhyme, Intelligence Research Specialist Salary, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence Specialist, Intelligence Support Activity, Intelligence Specialist Navy, Intelligence Squared Debate, Intelligence Studies, Intelligence Scale, Intelligence Symbol, Intelligence Search, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Test Psychology, Intelligence Test Questions, Intelligence Unit, Intelligence University, Intelligence Us, Intelligence Unmasking, Intelligence Usa, Intelligence Usmc, Intelligence Unit 8200, Intelligence Unbound, Intelligence Unit Nypd, Intelligence Unleashed An Argument For Ai In Education, Intelligence Vs Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Knowledge, Intelligence Vs Achievement, Intelligence Vs Intellect, Intelligence Vs Creativity, Intelligence Vs Iq, Intelligence Vs Religion, Intelligence Versus Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Information, Intelligence Vs Happiness, Intelligence Weapons Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Wiki, Intelligence Without Ambition, Intelligence Without Representation, Intelligence Websites, Intelligence Without Wisdom, Intelligence Work, Intelligence War, Intelligence Warfighting Function, Intelligence Warfare, Intelligence X Chromosome, Intelligence Xp Bonus Fallout 4, Intelligence Xp Boost Fallout 4, Intelligence X, Intelligence Xword, Intelligence X Chromosome Lancet, Intelligence Xmovies8, Intelligence X Ray, Xenomorph Intelligence, Xq Intelligence, Intelligence Youtube, Intelligence Y Chromosome, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Zodiac Signs, Intelligence Zinc Copper Hair, Zambian Intelligence, Intelligence Zero, Intelligence Zoom, Intelligence Zombie, Intelligence Czar, Zambian Intelligence News Facebook, Zeal Intelligence, Zambian Intelligence Service, Mossad 101, Mossad Agent, Mossad 9\/11, Mossad Training, Mossad Motto, Mossad Homeland, Mossad 101 Review, Mossad 101 Season 2, Mossad Movies, Mossad Book, Mossad Agent, Mossad Assassinations, Mossad Aliyah Bet, Mossad Agent Salary, Mossad Agent In Danger, Mossad And 9\/11, Mossad Application, Massad Ayoob, Mossad And Trump, Mossad Assassination Dubai, Mossad Book, Mossad Blacklist, Mossad Badge, Mossad By Deception, Mossad Beretta, Mossad Building, Mossad Budget, Mossad Book Pdf, Mossad Blackmail, Mossad Bodyguards, Mossad Cia, Mossad Careers, Mossad Created Isis, Mossad Covert Affairs, Mossad Cell Phone Bomb, Mossad Contact, Mossad Cz 75, Mossad Chemical Attack, Mossad Cz, Mossad Character Homeland, Mossad Definition, Mossad Documentary, Mossad Did 911, Mossad Dubai, Mossad Dogs, Mossad Draw, Mossad Director Orli Elbaz, Mossad Deception, Mossad Documentary On Netflix, Mossad Dagan, Mossad Eichmann, Mossad Emblem, Mossad Exodus, Mossad Employment, Mossad Equipment, Mossad Ethiopia, Mossad Eagle, Mossad Elite Unit, Mossad Eichmann Movie, Mossad English Website, Mossad False Flag, Mossad Flag, Masada Fortress, Mossad Facepalm, Mossad Failures, Mossad Facts, Mossad Film, Mossad Founder, Mossad Foreign Recruitment, Mossad Funds Isis, Mossad Guns, Mossad Gal Gadot, Mossad Gov Il, Mossad Greatest Hits, Mossad Gun Choice, Mossad Girl, Mossad Group, Mossad Germany, Mossad Greatest Missions Pdf, Mossad Greatest Missions, Mossad Homeland, Mossad History, Mossad Harav Kook, Mossad Headquarters, Mossad Handgun, Mossad Hit Squad, Mossad Honey Trap, Mossad Head, Mossad Hits, Mossad Hamas, Mossad Israel, Mossad Isis, Mossad In Syria, Mossad In Usa, Mossad In Homeland, Mossad In India, Mossad In Iran, Mossad Internship, Mossad In Dubai, Mossad Images, Mossad Jobs, Mossad Jfk, Mossad Jfk Killing, Mossad Jokes, Mossad Join, Mossad Jfk Assassination, Mossad Jewish, Mossad Jacket, Mossad Job Application Form, Mossad Job Openings, Mossad Kidon, Mossad Kidon Training, Mossad Kushner, Mossad Knife, Mossad Killings, Mossad Killed Jfk, Mossad Katsa, Mossad Kennedy, Mossad Kidnapping, Mossad Kush, Mossad Logo, Mossad Lealiyah Bet, Mossad London Attack, Mossad Lillehammer, Mossad Lebanon, Mossad London, Mossad Libro, Mossad Libya, Mossad Logo Translation, Mossad Links To Isis, Mossad Motto, Mossad Movies, Mossad Meaning, Mossad Munich, Mossad Meme, Mossad Murders, Mossad Mission Statement, Mossad Marked Pistol, Mossad Michael Bar-zohar, Mossad Manchester, Mossad Ncis, Mossad Netflix, Mossad News, Mossad Norway, Mossad North Korea, Mossad Nazi, Mossad Name Origin, Mossad Novels, Mossad Nazi Executions, Mossad Nazi Assassinations, Mossad Officer, Mossad Operation, Mossad On Netflix, Mossad Operation In Dubai, Mossad On Twitter, Mossad Official Website, Mossad Olympic Revenge Movie, Mossad Official Motto, Mossad Og, Mossad Operations Youtube, Mossad Pistol, Mossad Pistol For Sale, Mossad Pdf, Mossad Pen, Mossad Podcast, Mossad Pistol Training, Mossad Paris, Mossad Phone Bomb, Mossad Pics, Mossad Pronunciation, Mossad Quotes, Mossad Quora, Mossad Qualifications, Mossad Qatar, Mossad Quiz, Mossad Que Es, Mossad’s Quest, Mossad Quick Draw, Kidon Mossad, Mossad Quotations, Mossad Recruitment, Mossad Russia, Mossad Recruitment Website, Mossad Reddit, Mossad Recruitment Process, Mossad Ranks, Mossad Riddle, Mossad Harav Kook, Mossad Reputation, Mossad Retraining, Mossad Syria, Mossad Spy, Mossad Stole My Shoe, Mossad Stories, Mossad Shirt, Mossad Slogan, Mossad Show Netflix, Mossad Self Defense, Mossad Season 2, Mossad Series, Mossad Training, Mossad Tanfoglio, Mossad Twitter, Mossad Trump, Mossad Tv Show, Mossad Tactical, Mossad T Shirts, Mossad Tactical Duffle Bag, Mossad Training School, Mossad The Greatest Missions, Mossad Uae, Mossad Usa, Mossad Units, Mossad Uniform, Mossad Uk, Mossad Uganda Operation, Mossad Unit 8200, Mossad Ukraine, Mossad Vs Cia, Mossad Vs Kgb, Mossad Video, Mossad Vs Assad, Mossad And Shin Bet, Mossad Vanunu, Mossad Vs Seals, Mossad Vs Navy Seal, Mossad Vs Isi, Mossad Vs Raw, Mossad Website, Mossad Wiki, Mossad Weapons, Mossad Worldwide, Mossad War By Deception, Mossad Workout, Mossad Wikileaks, Mossad Wrath Of God, Mossad Weapons Of Choice, Mossad Ww2, Mossad X, X Mossad Agent, Mossad Prisoner X, Mossad Committee X, Comitato X Mossad, Mossad Xaqida, Comite X Mossad, Mossad Youtube, Mossad Yossi Cohen, Mossad Yearly Cyber Challenge, Mossad Yousef, Mossad Yahudi, Mossad Yemen, Mossad Yahoo Answers, Mossad Yom Kippur War, Massad Ymca, Mossad Youtube Dubai, Mossad Zionist, Mossad Ziva David, Mossad Zippo, Mossad Zohar, Mossad Zoo, Mossad Zamir, Mossad Znacenje, Mossad Zimbabwe, Mossad Zinc, Mossad Zohar Pdf, Aman Park, Aman Resorts, Aman Tokyo, Aman Meaning, Aman Park Trail Map, Aman Venice, Aman Chugh, Aman Hundal, Aman Hambleton, Aman Utah, Amon Amarth, Aman Awan, Aman Ali, Amon Amarth Tour, Aman Aman, Aman Arora, Aman At Summer Palace, Aman Arizona, Aman Agarwal, Aman Advani, Aman Bali, Aman Bhutan, Aman Batra, Aman Beijing, Aman Bhutani, Aman Brar, Aman Bora Bora, Aman Bansal, Aman Bundy, Aman Bains, Aman Chugh, Aman Chugh Md, Aman Canal Grande, Aman City, A Man Called Ove, Aman Cara, Aman Clinic, Amal Clooney, Aman Cambodia, Aman China, Aman Definition, Aman Dominican Republic, Aman Dhaliwal, Aman Disease, Aman Dhuper, Aman Dhanda, Aman Dhillon, Aman Duh, Amandeep, Aman Developers, Aman Enterprises, Aman En La Biblia, Aman Expedia, Amanemu, Aman Europe, Aman Environmental, Aman En Ingles, Amun Egypt, Aman Etymology, Aman Environmental Construction, Aman Foundation, Aman Fashions, A Man For All Seasons, Aman Folk Ensemble, Aman France, Aman Farooq Shadow King, Aman Facebook, Aman Family, Amanfayun, Aman Food Mart, Aman Greece, Aman Giri, Aman Gupta, Aman Gbs, Aman Goel, Amon Goeth, Aman Gill, Aman Group, Ahman Green, Aman Grand Canal, Aman Hotels, Aman Hundal, Aman Hambleton, Aman Hotel Venice, Aman Hotel Tokyo, Aman Hotel Utah, Aman Hayer, Aman Hotel Japan, Aman Hambleton Twitter, Aman Hotel Bali, Aman Israel, Aman India, Aman In English, Aman Indonesia, Aman I Khas, Aman In Hebrew, Aman In The Bible, Aman Iman, Aman In Spanish, Aman Italy, Amman Jordan, Aman Jackson Hole, Aman Japan, Amman Jordan Weather, Amman Jordan Time, Aman Johal, Amman Jordan News, Amman Jordan Hotels, Aman Jain, Amman Jordan Map, Aman Kainth, Aman Kapoor, Aman Kaur, Aman Ki Asha, Aman Khan, Amon Korra, Aman Kumar, Aman Kapoor Immigration Voice, Aman Kyoto, Aman Khanna, Aman Lotr, Aman Lyrics, Aman Le Melezin, Aman Laos, Aman Luthra, Aman Locations, Aman Logo, Aman Lijiang, Amon Legend Of Korra, Aman Last Name, Aman Meaning, Aman Morocco, Aman Movie, Aman Map, Aman Meaning In Hebrew, Aman Manji Tennis, Aman Meaning In English, Aman Meaning In Hindi, Aman Maldives, Aman Makkar, Aman Name Meaning, Aman Name, Aman Name Origin, Aman Neuropathy, Aman New Delhi, Aman New York, Aman Naimat, Aman Nath, Aman Nyc, Aman Navy, Aman Or Amen, Aman Overseas, Aman Owner, Aman Organics, Aman Oman, Amen Origin, Aman Obsiye, Aman Onallah, Aman Oberoi, Aman Orono, Aman Park, Aman Park Trail Map, Aman Perry, Aman Park Allendale, Aman Patel, Aman Phuket, Amanpulo, Aman Properties, Amazon Prime, Aman Pronunciation, A Man Quote, Aman Qureshi, Aman Qatar, Aman Quora, Alone Quotes In Punjabi, Aman Quadri, Aman Qureshi Instagram, Aman Kabir, Aman Qatar Foundation, Aman Qureshi Ringtone, Aman Resorts, Aman Resort Utah, Aman Ra, Aman Rah, Aman Resorts Bali, Aman Resort Greece, Aman Resort Venice, Aman Resort Locations, Aman Reclaimer, Aman Resort Japan, Aman Sveti Stefan, Aman Shukairy, Aman Singh, Aman Summer Palace, Aman Siddiqui, Aman Sri Lanka, Aman Sharma, Aman Sandhu, Aman Shanghai, Aman Spa, Aman Tokyo, Aman’thul, Aman Tera, Amen Travis Scott, Aman Trikha, Aman Tell, Aman Thailand, Aman Turks And Caicos, Aman Tyler, Aman’thul Wisdom, Aman Utah, Aman Upadhyay Md, Aman Upadhyay, Aman Usa, Amanullah, Aman Ubud, Aman Urban Dictionary, Aman Uppal, Aman Usa Inc, Aman Utah Hotel, Aman Venice, Aman Verma, Amanoi Vietnam, Aman Verjee, Aman Verma Wife, Aman Venice Restaurant, Aman Vs Amen, Aman Virk, Aman Venice Review, Aman Villas, Aman Wyoming, Aman Wiki, Aman Wedding, Aman Wellness, Aman Wadhwa, Aman Wote, Amana Washer, Aman Walia, Aman Woldemariam, Aman Without A Country, Aman X Ray & Ultrasound Clinic Delhi, Aman X Ray Model Town, Amanx, Aman Xii, Aman_xo, Aman Exchange, Aman Yadav, Amanyara, Aman Yaar, Aman Yellowstone, Aman Yemen, Aman Yatan Verma, Aman Yadav Msu, Aman Youtube, Aman Yang Yun, Aman Yacht, Amanzoe, Aman Zahiruddin, Aman Zaman, Aman Zarmina Md, Aman Zarmina, Aman Zug, Aman Zaidi, Aman Zna\u010denje, Amanz, Aman Zafar, Shin Bet Israel, Shin Bet Bodyguards, Shin Bet Training, Shin Bet Website, Shin Bet Jobs, Shin Bet Riddle, Shin Bet Movie, Shin Bet And Mossad, Shin Bet Are You Good Enough, Shin Bet Tav, Shin Bet Are You Good Enough, Shin Bet And Mossad, Shin Bet Abbas, Shin Bet Adalah, Shin Bet Ami Ayalon, Shin Bet Assassinations, Shin Bet Avraham Shalom, Shin Bet Ami, Shin Bet And Mossad Documentary, Shin Bet Al Jazeera, Shin Bet Bodyguards, Shin Bet Books, Shin Bet Bus 300, Shin Bet Bbc, Shin Bet Blog, Shin Bet Budget, Shin Bet Breaking The Silence, Shin Cau Bet But Chi, Shin Cau Be But Chi, Shin Bet Betekenis, Shin Bet Cyber Riddle, Shin Bet Chief, Shin Bet Created Hamas, Shin Bet Chief Yoram Cohen, Shin Bet Careers, Shin Bet Splinter Cell, Former Shin Bet Chief, King’s College Shin Bet, Shin Bet Director Yoram Cohen, Shin Cau Bet But Chi, Shin Bet Documentary, Shin Bet Director, Shin Bet Deputy, Shin Bet Director Yoram Cohen, Shin Bet Doku, Shin Bet Dokumentarfilm, Shin Bet Documentaire, Shin Bet Documentario, Shin Bet Dokumentar, Shin Bet Mossad Difference, Shin Bet Film, Shin Bet Facebook, Shin Bet France, Shin Bet Vs Fbi, Shin Bet Special Forces, Former Shin Bet Chief, Former Shin Bet, Shin Bet Folter, Shin Bet Gatekeepers, Shin Bet Green Prince, Shin Bet Gonen, Shin Bet Gaza, Gonna Shin Bet, Gatekeepers Shin Bet Stream, Shin Bet Headquarters, Shin Bet Heads, Shin Bet Hq, Shin Bet Hospital, Shin Bet Created Hamas, Haaretz Shin Bet, Shin Bet Homepage, Shin Bet Israel, Shin Bet Interrogation Techniques, Shin Bet Iran Deal, Shin Bet Isis, Shin Bet Intelligence Agency, Shin Bet Internal Security Service, Shin Bet In Action, Shin Bet Interrogation, Shin Bet Idf, Shin Bet Israli, Shin Bet Jobs, Shin Bet Jewish Division, Shin Bet Jacket, Shin Bet Al Jazeera, Shin Bet Krav Maga, Shin Bet Kastner, King’s College Shin Bet, Shin Bet Kft, The Gatekeepers Shin Bet, Shin Bet Logo, Loai Shin Bet, Leibowitz Shin Bet, Le Shin Bet, Shin Beth Livre, Lo Shin Bet, Shin Bet Movie, Shin Bet Meaning, Shin Bet Mossad Difference, Shin Bet Malaysia, Shin Bet Missions, Shin Bet Manuel Valls, Shin Bet Torture Methods, Shin Bet Krav Maga, Shin Bet And Mossad Documentary, Shin Bet Islamic Movement, Shin Bet News, Shin Bet Netanyahu, Shin Bet Nedir, Shin Bet Operations, Shin Bet Official Website, Shin Bet Officer, Shin Bet On Iran Deal, Shin Bet Organization, Shin Bet Official Site, Shin Bet Ospedale, Shin Bet Pronunciation, Shin Bet Puzzle, Shin Bet Pdf, Shin Bet Pictures, Shin Bet Protection, Shin Bet Pin, Shin Bet Pelicula, Shin Bet Green Prince, Shin Bet Security Procedures, Szin Bet Pl, Shin Bet Quotes, Shin Bet Que Es, Shin Bet Riddle, Shin Bet Riddle Link, Shin Bet Recruitment Video, Shin Bet Recruitment Puzzle, Shin Bet Recruitment, Shin Bet Rabin, Shin Bet Report, Shin Bet Ranks, Shin Bet Reportage, Shin Bet Security Service, Shin Bet Scandal, Shin Bet Structure, Shin Bet Splinter Cell, Shin Bet Shirt, Shin Bet Salary, Shin Bet Stories, Shin Bet Size, Shin Bet Security Procedures, Shin Bet T Shirt, Shin Bet Training, Shin Bet Tav, Shin Bet Torture, Shin Bet Tech Puzzle, Shin Bet Twitter, Shin Bet T Shirt, Shin Bet Torture Methods, Shin Bet The Gatekeepers, Shin Bet Translation, Shin Bet The Green Prince, Shin Bet Uniform, Unterschied Shin Bet Und Mossad, Shin Bet And Mossad, Shin Bet Vs Fbi, Shin Bet Video, Shin Bet Valls, Israeli Shin Bet Videos, Shin Bet Manuel Valls, Shin Bet Website, Shin Bet Wiki, Shin Bet Weapons, The Gatekeepers Shin Bet Watch Online, Shin Bet Israel Wiki, Shin Bet Youtube, Shin Bet Yamas, Shin Bet Yoram Cohen, Shin Bet Yuval Diskin, Shin Bet Director Yoram Cohen
Become a Patron! True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.
The news that the U.S. government has been recording data from phone calls and Internet activity, broken by former CIA employee Edward Snowden, is just the latest in a long line of legendary leaks. Here are some of the most notorious leaks in U.S. history.
The Pentagon Papers
What may be the most famous leak in U.S. history occurred in June 1971, when The New York Times published sections of a top-secret Department of Defense report on the country’s involvement in Vietnam from 1945-1967. Dubbed the “Pentagon Papers,” the report detailed how the Johnson administration and others repeatedly misled Congress and the public about the causes and progress of the Vietnam War, according to the History Channel. [7 Great Dramas in Congressional HistoryThe report was leaked by antiwar activist Daniel Ellsberg,
a former Defense Department analyst working for the RAND Corp., who stole it from the Pentagon and sent copies to the Times. The Pentagon Papers’ publication fueled the antiwar movement and sparked a debate over the freedom of the press to divulge “classified” information and the public’s right to know about government affairs. President Richard Nixon tried but failed to get the Supreme Court to prevent further publication of the papers.
The Watergate Scandal
One of the best-known leaks, of course, is the Watergate scandal of Richard Nixon’s presidency. On June 17, 1972, five men were arrested for breaking into the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee at the Watergate hotel complex in Washington, D.C., and installing illegal wiretaps. The men were linked to a fundraising group for Nixon’s 1972 re-election campaign, but the Nixon administration denied any involvement.
Later in 1972, Washington Post reporters Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward exposed the administration’s role in the scandal and cover-up. Their key source was an informant nicknamed “Deep Throat,” who was later revealed to be former FBI agent W. Mark Felt. A series of Senate hearings nailed the lid on Nixon’s coffin, and he resigned from the presidency in 1974 — the first president to do so. [The 10 Weirdest Presidential Inaugurations in US History]
The Iraq War Logs (WikiLeaks)
The so-called “Iraq War Logs” were just one of many leaks made by the non-profit organization WikiLeaks, founded by Australian journalist and activist Julian Paul Assange. The organization publishes secret or classified information or news from anonymous sources. In October 2010, WikiLeaks published Army field reports from 2004 to 2009 that listed the number of civilian deaths as 66,081 out of 109,000 total recorded deaths. The leaked logs confirmed some partially reported events. For instance, some American troops had been classifying civilian deaths as enemy deaths. The Iraq War Logs represent the largest leak in U.S. history.
The Plame Affair
In 2003, a case of leaked identity ended the career of a CIA agent. On July 6, 2003, The New York Times published an Op-Ed by former U.S. diplomat Joseph Wilson, which questioned the reasons given by President George W. Bush’s administration for invading Iraq earlier in 2003. Wilson, who had been a CIA envoy to Niger in 2002, said Bush’s claim that Iraq had attempted to buy enriched uranium yellowcake — a step toward enriched uranium but not weapons-grade yet — from Niger was unsubstantiated. In response, Washington Post columnist Robert Novak wrote a column on July 14, 2003 criticizing Wilson and referring to Wilson’s wife, Valerie Plame, as an “agency operative” — blowing her cover. Wilson accused the White House of leaking Plame’s identity as retribution for his Op-Ed, prompting an investigation. Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald interviewed Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and other administration officials and journalists. New York Times reporter Judith Miller, who conducted interviews in the leak but had never written an article about it, refused to testify and was held in contemp. She served time at a federal detention center, but was released after three months when Lewis “Scooter” Libby, Cheney’s chief of staff, signed a waiver granting Miller permission to speak.
In 2007, Libby was convicted of obstruction of justice, perjury and making false statements to government investigators. Libby was sentenced to prison, but Bush later reduced his sentence.
Climategate
Named in the Watergate tradition, “Climategate” refers to a controversy in the fall of 2009 in which hackers leaked thousands of emails and documents from the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) at the University of East Anglia, United Kingdom. The documents appeared to show scientists suppressing the publication of research undermining the existence of global warming. Even though an investigation later revealed no foul play was afoot, the leak added fuel to the global warming debate. Climate change critics claimed the leaked emails showed that global warming was a conspiracy among scientists, while the CRU said the emails were taken out of context.
The documents were leaked just weeks before the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen, Denmark. In response, the scientific community released statements affirming the consensus that the planet’s average surface temperature is rising as a result of human activities.
Operation Mincemeat
Not all leaks are about exposing the truth — some are about deception. Such was the case with Operation Mincemeat, a leak planned and executed by the Allies during World War II. The plan, part of the larger Operation Barclay, was intended to make the Germans think the Allies were planning to invade Greece and Sardinia instead of Sicily. The Allies put fake “top secret” invasion plans on a dead body that was left to wash up on a beach in Spain. The plan worked: The Germans found the body and copied the fake plans. The trickery made the Germans suspicious, so they ignored other real intelligence leaks, thinking they were ruses.
Edward Snowden and the PRISM leak
On June 6, 2013, The Guardian broke the news that the U.S. National Security Agency (NSA) has been collecting the phone records of millions of customers of Verizon, the U.S. telecom provider, as authorized by a top-secret court order issued in April. Technical contractor and former CIA employee Edward Snowden leaked classified details of a top-secret NSA electronic surveillance program, codenamed PRISM, to The Washington Post and The Guardian.
Via this program, the NSA can obtain information such as email, voice and video chat, other videos, photos, and social networking details, according to The Guardian. The NSA and FBI are obtaining data from the central servers of nine major Internet companies, including Google, Facebook and Apple, The Washington Post reported. The leak has launched criticism of President Barack Obama’s administration over breach-of-privacy concerns. The president has defended the surveillance program, claiming it has helped prevent terrorist attacks. The controversy continues, as more details of the surveillance programs are unveiled.
Leak Detection, Leak Down Test, Leak Down Tester, Leak Detector, Leak Definition, Leak In Spanish, Leak Detection Pump, Leak Seal, Leak Stopper, Leakforums, Leak And Sons Funeral Home, Leak Alarm, Leak Ap Gov, Leak Amniotic Fluid, Leak Alert, Leak Around Chimney, Leake And Watts, Leek And Potato Soup, Leaked Albums, Leak At Water Meter, Leak B Gone, Leak Bros, Leak Barrier, Leak Base, Leak Bali, Leak Barrier Ms300, Leak Busters, Leak Behind Shower, Leak Behind Wall, Leak Before Break, Leak Channels, Leakcanary, Leak Crossword Clue, Leak Check, Leak Channels Definition, Leak Controller, Leak Code, Leak Catcher, Leak City, Leak Ceiling, Leak Detection, Leak Down Test, Leak Down Tester, Leak Detector, Leak Definition, Leak Detection Pump, Leak Detection Equipment, Leak Doctor, Leak Definition Government, Leak Defense System, Leak Ender 2000, Leak En Espanol, Leak Eliminators, Leaked Early, Leak Electric, Leak Experts, Leak En Francais, Leak Early Album, Leak Exhaust, Leak Emoji, Leakforums, Leak Freeze, Leek Food, Leak Finders, Leak Fix, Leakfrog, Leak Fixer, Leak Fix Spray, Leaked Forms, Leak Famous.com, Leak Gopher, Leak Guard, Leak Gif, Leak Geeks, Leak Guard Protection, Leaky Gut, Leak Garbage Disposal, Leak Guardian, Leak Girl, Leak Gopher Vs Fortrezz, Leak Heart Valve, Leak House Of Cards, Leak Hunters, Leak Hack, Leak Hose, Leek Hustle, Leak House Of Cards Season 5, Leak Head Gasket, Leek Hunting, Leek Herb, Leak In Spanish, Leak In Ceiling, Leak In Roof, Leak In Radiator, Leak In Basement, Leak In Pool, Leak In Tire, Leak In Basement Wall, Leak In The Boat, Leak In Heart, Leek Jack, Leak Jones, Leak Jet, Leak Jokes, Leak Jacob, Leek Jack Campus Girl, Leek Jack Lyrics, Leak Journalism, Leak James Comey, Leek Jack Age, Leak Kingdom, Leak King, Leak Kitchen Faucet, Leek Knife, Leak Kitchen Sink, Leak Kanseng, Leak Kitchen Sink Drain, Leak Khan Bombak Sne, Leak K Channels, Leaky Kohler Faucet, Leak Lock, Leak Live, Leak Like A Siv, Leak Locators, Leak Less, Leak Like A Sieve, Leak Location Services, Leak Light, Leak Lock Sds, Leak League Of Legends, Leak Meaning, Leak Masters, Leak Memory Chapel, Leak Meme, Lake Mead, Leak Music, Leak Master Roofing, Leak Movie, Leak Memorial, Leak Meaning In Hindi, Leak No More, Leak News, Leak No More For Dogs, Leak Nutrition, Leak Near Me, Leak No More Reviews, Leak No More York Pa, Leak Near Water Meter, Leaked Nsa, Leak No Stallin, Leak Off Test, Leak Out, Leak Oil, Leak Of Information, Leek Onion, Leak On Ceiling, Leak Of Orange Is The New Black, Leak On Roof, Leak Out Meaning, Leak Or Leakage, Leak Project, Leak Proof Underwear, Leak Proof, Leak Proof Travel Bottles, Leak Proof Containers, Leek Plant, Leak Proof Tape, Leak Proof Water Bottle, Leak Proof Bag, Leak Project Youtube, Leak Quotes, Leek Quiche, Leak Quizlet, Leek Quiche Recipes, Leek Quinoa, Leek Quiche Bacon, Leek Quiche Healthy, Leek Quiche Crustless, Leek Quiche Epicurious, Leek Quiche Allrecipes, Leak Repair, Leak Repair Tape, Leak Rate Calculator, Leak Rate, Leak Reddit, Leek Recipes, Leak Rate Units, Leak Rate Conversion, Leak Repair Spray, Leak Repair Putty, Leek Soup, Leak Seal, Leak Stopper, Leak Synonym, Leak Stop, Leak Sealer, Leek Spin, Leak Seal Tape, Leak Squad, Leak Source, Leak Test, Leak Tape, Leak Tester, Leak Threads, Leak Tamer, Leak Tech, Leak Tec, Leak Tools, Leak Test Solution, Leak Tracing Powder, Leak Under Sink, Leak Under Car, Leak Urine, Leak Under Toilet, Leak Under Slab, Leak Under Bathroom Floor, Leak Under Dishwasher, Leak Under Washer, Leak Under Toilet Tank, Leak Under House, Leak Video, Leek Vegetable, Leak Valve, Leak Veggie, Leek Veggie, Leek Vs Onion, Leek Vs Scallion, Leek Vegetable Soup, Leak Vrf To Global, Leak Or Leakage, Leak Wizard, Leak Water, Leak Website, Leak Wall House Rockingham Nc, Leak Week, Leaked White House, Leaked Winner, Leak Washington Post, Leak Water Heater, Leak Wrap, Leak Xenforo, Leak Xur, Leak Xbox One, Leak Xur 3 April, Leak You, Leak Your Ex, Leak Youtube, Leak Your Number, Leak Year, Leak You Up And Down, Leak Young Og Project, Leak Leaky, Leak Make Your Future Bleak, Liveleak Youtube, Leak Zip, Leak Z10, Leak Z4, Leak Zelda, Leak Zimbabwe, Leak Zhang Ziyi, Leak Zelda Wii U, Leak Zombies, Zircon Leak Alert, Zero Leak Gold, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Analyst, Intelligence Analyst Jobs, Intelligence Agencies, Intelligence Analyst Salary, Intelligence Analysis, Intelligence Agencies Us, Intelligence Agent, Intelligence Analyst Jobs Michigan, Intelligence Analyst Army, Intelligence Analyst Fbi, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 4, Intelligence By Race, Intelligence Briefing, Intelligence Bell Curve, Intelligence Bobblehead Fallout 3, Intelligence Build Dark Souls 3, Intelligencebank, Intelligence Bureau, Intelligence Build Fallout 4, Intelligence By State, Intelligence Committee, Intelligence Community, Intelligence Cycle, Intelligence Committee Members, Intelligence Careers, Intelligence Committee Hearing, Intelligence Committee House, Intelligence Cast, Intelligence Contractors, Intelligence Committee Russia, Intelligence Definition, Intelligence Definition Psychology, Intelligence Degree, Intelligence Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Design, Intelligence Director, Intelligence Dark Souls, Intelligence Disciplines, Intelligence Dnd, Intelligence Depression, Intelligence Explosion, Intelligence Everywhere, Intelligence Etymology, Intelligence Examples, Intelligence Estimate, Intelligence Emotional, Intelligence Essay, Intelligence Events Google Analytics, Intelligence Evolution, Intelligence Education, Intelligence For Your Life, Intelligence For Your Life Cast, Intelligence Fallout 4, Intelligence For Your Life Wiki, Intelligence From Mother, Intelligence From Secrets To Policy, Intelligence For Your Life Tv Show, Intelligence Failures, Intelligence Fusion Center, Intelligence For Your Health, Intelligence Gathering, Intelligence Gene, Intelligence Genetic, Intelligence Group, Intelligence Games, Intelligence G, Intelligence Gap, Intelligence Gathering Process, Intelligence Gathering Techniques, Intelligence Gardner, Intelligence Hearing, Intelligence Heritability, Intelligence Hereditary, Intelligence House Committee, Intelligence Home, Intelligence Hearings Today, Intelligence Hierarchy, Intelligence History, Intelligence Hearing Russia, Intelligence Happiness, Intelligence Is Sexy, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change, Intelligence Is The Ability To Adapt To Change Shirt, Intelligence In Spanish, Intelligence Is, Intelligence In Psychology, Intelligence Internships, Intelligence Icon, Intelligence In Latin, Intelligence Inherited, Intelligence Jobs, Intelligence Journal, Intelligence Jokes, Intelligence Jobs In The Navy, Intelligence Jobs Salary, Intelligence Jobs Army, Intelligence Jobs In The Air Force, Intelligence Jobs In Texas, Intelligence Jobs Colorado, Intelligence Job Description, Intelligence Knowns And Unknowns, Intelligence Knowledge Network, Intelligence Knowledge, Intelligence Kotor, Intelligence Kink, Intelligence Kevin Hart, Intelligence Knowledge Wisdom, Intelligence Kanji, Intelligence Kid Buu Dokkan, Intelligence Kotor 2, Intelligence Led Policing, Intelligence Level, Intelligence Leaks, Intelligence Led Policing Definition, Intelligence Logo, Intelligence Law, Intelligence Level Meme, Intelligence Life Cycle, Intelligence Level Of Dogs, Intelligence Led Policing Ratcliffe, Intelligence Meme, Intelligence Meaning, Intelligence Movie, Intelligence Mos, Intelligence Meme Template, Intelligence Military, Intelligence Measurement, Intelligence Magazine, Intelligence Major, Intelligence Mother, Intelligence News, Intelligence Nature Vs Nurture, Intelligence New Vegas, Intelligence Network, Intelligence Navy, Intelligence Nunes, Intelligence Node, Intelligence New Findings And Theoretical Developments, Intelligence Nature, Intelligence Nurture, Intelligence Officer, Intelligence Of Dogs, Intelligence Oversight, Intelligence Officer Air Force, Intelligence Officer Navy, Intelligence Officer Army, Intelligence Of Octopus, Intelligence Of Border Collies, Intelligence Of Crows, Intelligence Of Pigs, Intelligence Psychology, Intelligence Preparation Of The Battlefield, Intelligence Plus Character, Intelligence Pathfinder, Intelligence Poe, Intelligence Pill, Intelligence Process, Intelligence Perks Fallout 4, Intelligence Passed From Mothers, Intelligence Psychology Quizlet, Intelligence Quotient, Intelligence Quotes, Intelligence Quiz, Intelligence Quotient Definition, Intelligence Quotient Test, Intelligence Quotient Psychology Definition, Intelligence Questions, Intelligence Quizlet, Intelligent Qube, Intelligence Quotient Quizlet, Intelligence Report, Intelligence Reform And Terrorism Prevention Act, Intelligence Research Specialist, Intelligence Reddit, Intelligence Ring Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Report Richard Young, Intelligence Research, Intelligence Reform, Intelligence Rhyme, Intelligence Research Specialist Salary, Intelligence Squared, Intelligence Synonym, Intelligence Specialist, Intelligence Support Activity, Intelligence Specialist Navy, Intelligence Squared Debate, Intelligence Studies, Intelligence Scale, Intelligence Symbol, Intelligence Search, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Test Psychology, Intelligence Test Questions, Intelligence Unit, Intelligence University, Intelligence Us, Intelligence Unmasking, Intelligence Usa, Intelligence Usmc, Intelligence Unit 8200, Intelligence Unbound, Intelligence Unit Nypd, Intelligence Unleashed An Argument For Ai In Education, Intelligence Vs Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Knowledge, Intelligence Vs Achievement, Intelligence Vs Intellect, Intelligence Vs Creativity, Intelligence Vs Iq, Intelligence Vs Religion, Intelligence Versus Wisdom, Intelligence Vs Information, Intelligence Vs Happiness, Intelligence Weapons Dark Souls 3, Intelligence Wiki, Intelligence Without Ambition, Intelligence Without Representation, Intelligence Websites, Intelligence Without Wisdom, Intelligence Work, Intelligence War, Intelligence Warfighting Function, Intelligence Warfare, Intelligence X Chromosome, Intelligence Xp Bonus Fallout 4, Intelligence Xp Boost Fallout 4, Intelligence X, Intelligence Xword, Intelligence X Chromosome Lancet, Intelligence Xmovies8, Intelligence X Ray, Xenomorph Intelligence, Xq Intelligence, Intelligence Youtube, Intelligence Y Chromosome, Intelligence Test, Intelligence Talent, Intelligence Types, Intelligence Test Definition, Intelligence Tests Are Biased In The Sense That, Intelligence Thesaurus, Intelligence Test Definition Psychology, Intelligence Test Free, Intelligence Zodiac Signs, Intelligence Zinc Copper Hair, Zambian Intelligence, Intelligence Zero, Intelligence Zoom, Intelligence Zombie, Intelligence Czar, Zambian Intelligence News Facebook, Zeal Intelligence, Zambian Intelligence Service, History Channel, History Of Dunkirk, History Of Japan, History Of The World, History Of Detroit, History Museum, History Of Violence, History Channel Schedule, History Of Basketball, History Of Easter, History Alive Textbook, History Alive, History Alive The Ancient World, History Alive Textbook 8th Grade, History And Physical, History Articles, History Alone, History Activate, History App, History Answers, History Books, History Buff, History Book Club, History Browser, History Boys, History By One Direction, History Background, History Books For Kids, History Bee, History By Olivia Holt, History Channel, History Channel Schedule, History Channel Alone, History Channel Shows, History Channel Vikings, History Channel App, History Chicks, History Channel Documentary, History Clear, History Channel Forged In Fire, History Definition, History Department Umich, History Documentaries, History Degree Jobs, History Delete, History Detectives, History Degree, History Day, History Documentaries On Netflix, History Department, History Events, History Etymology, History Eraser, History Extra, History Eraser Button, History Encyclopedia, History Essay, History Education, History Eraser Lyrics, History Essay Topics, History For Kids, History Facts, History For Dummies, History Final Exam, History Flight, History For Sale, History Fanatic, History Fact Of The Day, History Fair, History For Google, History Google, History Games, History Grade Calculator, History Garage, History Gif, History Games For Kids, History Goes Bump, History Gifts, History Graduate Programs, History Go, History Has Its Eyes On You, History Haven, History Honor Society, History Heroes, History Homework, History Help, History Health Insurance, History Holocaust, History Hub, History Here, History In Spanish, History In Orbit, History Is Written By The Victors, History In The Making, History Icon, History Ia Topics, History Images, History In Memes, History Ia Rubric, History Is A Weapon, History Jokes, History Jobs, History Jobs Michigan, History Journals, History Jeopardy, History Jaeho, History Japan, History Jobs Near Me, History Js, History Jobs Wiki, History Kpop, History Kids, History Kyungil, History Korea, History Kpop Profile, History Korean War, History Kpop Disband, History Karaoke, History Kkk, History Kahoot, History Lyrics, History Learning Site, History Lesson, History Logo, History Level 3 Wordbrain, History Lists, History Level 5 Wordbrain, History Listverse, History Live, History Location, History Memes, History Maker Lyrics, History Maker, History Museum, History Movies, History Museum Detroit, History Minor Umich, History Major Jobs, History Major Umich, History Major, History Net, History News, History News Network, History Notes, History Now, History Network, History North Korea, History Novels, History Names, History Nerd, History Of Dunkirk, History Of Japan, History Of The World, History Of Detroit, History Of Violence, History Of Basketball, History Of Easter, History Of Michigan, History Of The World Part 1, History Of Soccer, History Podcast, History Puns, History Professor Salary, History Pictures, History Pick Up Lines, History People, History Project Ideas, History Painting, History Place, History Professor, History Quiz, History Quotes, History Questions, History Quiz Questions, History Quizlet, History Queen, History Queen Lyrics, History Quiz Buzzfeed, History Questions To Ask, History Question Of The Day, History Repeats Itself, History Repeats Itself Quote, History Research Paper Topics, History Reddit, History Repeating, History Rhymes, History Riddles, History Revealed, History Research Paper Outline, History Review, History Synonym, History Supreme, History Search, History Song, History Shows, History Safari, History Settings, History Schedule, History Six, History Scholarships, History Trivia, History Timeline, History Today, History Trivia Questions, History Theater, History Textbook, History Teacher, History Topics, History Teacher Salary, History Test, History Umich, History Uncovered, History Unboxed, History Umich Major, History Ukulele Chords, History Unfolded, History Us, History Umich Faculty, History Usa, History Uti Icd 10, History Vault, History Vs Hollywood, History Videos, History Vikings, History Vocabulary, History Vietnam War, History Video Games, History Videos Youtube, History Vietnam, History Vs Hollywood Hacksaw Ridge, History Websites, History Will Absolve Me, History Worksheets, History Words, History Wallpaper, History Will Be Made, History With Mr E, History Wordbrain, History World, History Ww2, History X, History Channel, History X Cast, History X Reader, History Xbox, History X Song, History X Ray, History X Words, History X Factor, History Channel Schedule, History Youtube, History Youtube Channels, History Yijeong, History Year By Year, History Yuri On Ice, History Yale, History Yoga, History You Should Know, History Yahoo Mail, History Youtube App, History Zinn, History Z, History Zimbabwe, History Zion National Park, History Zika Virus, History Zine, History Zsh, History Zambia, History Zionism, History Zero
Become a Patron! True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.
29 November 1999. Thanks to The New Yorker and SH.
Source: Hardcopy The New Yorker, December 6, 1999, pp. 58-76.
ANNALS OF NATIONAL SECURITY
___________________
THE INTELLIGENCE GAP
How the digital age left our spies out in the cold.
BY SEYMOUR M. HERSH
THE National Security Agency, whose Cold War research into code breaking and electronic eavesdropping spurred the American computer revolution, has become a victim of the high-tech world it helped to create. Through mismanagement, arrogance, and fear of the unknown, the senior military and civilian bureaucrats who work at the agency’s headquarters, in suburban Fort Meade, Maryland, have failed to prepare fully for today’s high-volume flow of E-mail and fibre-optic transmissions — even as nations throughout Europe, Asia, and the Third World have begun exchanging diplomatic and national-security messages encrypted in unbreakable digital code.
The N.S.A.’s failures don’t make the headlines. In May, 1998, India’s first round of nuclear tests, which took place in Pokharan, southwest of New Delhi, caught Washington by surprise, and provoked criticism of the Central Intelligence Agency from the press and from Congress. But it was the N.S.A., in the days and weeks before the detonations, that did not detect signs of increased activity or increased communications at Pokharan. “It’s a tough problem,” one nuclear-intelligence expert told me, because India’s nuclear-weapons establishment now sends encrypted digital messages by satellite, using small dishes that bounce signals beyond the stratosphere through a system known as VSAT (“very small aperture terminal”) — a two-way version of the system widely used for DirecTV.
Similarly, the North Koreans, with the help of funds from the United Nations, according to one United States intelligence official, have bought encrypted cell phones from Europe, high-speed switching gear from Britain, and up-to-date dialling service from America — a system that the N.S.A. cannot readily read. The official said of the North Koreans,”All their military stuff went off ether into fibre” — from high-frequency radio transmission to fibre-optic cable lines, which transmit a vast volume of digital data as a stream of light. A former high-level Defense Department official told me, “It’s a worldwide problem. You could wire up all of Africa for less than two billion dollars.” This former official, like most of the two dozen signals-intelligence (SIGINT) experts interviewed for this account, agreed to speak only after being assured of anonymity. A 1951 federal law prohibits any discussion or publication of communications intelligence.
The decline of the N.S.A. is widely known in Washington’s national-security community. “The dirty little secret is that fibre optics and encryption are kicking Fort Meade in the nuts,” a recently retired senior officer in the C.I.A.’s Directorate of Operations told me. “It’s over. Everywhere I went in the Third World, I wanted to have someone named Ahmed, a backhoe driver, on the payroll. And I wanted to know where the fibre-optic cable was hidden. In a crisis, I wanted Ahmed to go and break up the cable, and force them up in the air” — that is, force communications to be broadcast by radio signals. The number of daily satellite-telephone calls in the Arab world, many of which are encrypted, is in the millions, creating severe difficulties for eavesdroppers. The mobile-telephone system used by Saddam Hussein at the height of Iraq’s dispute last year with a United Nations arms-control inspection team operated on more than nine hundred channels. Each channel was separately encrypted, with multiple keys, and Saddam’s conversations bounced from channel to channel with each call. A U.N. intelligence team eventually gained access to the telephone system’s technical manuals and other data, and was able to record the encrypted conversations, but without these materials it could not have made sense of the intercepts. The code-makers are leaving the code-breakers far behind.
IN its heyday, during the Cold War, the N.S.A. had nearly ninety-five thousand employees, more than half of them military, monitoring communications from hundreds of sites around the world. It played a dominant role in American intelligence gathering behind the Iron Curtain and elsewhere, producing by the end of the nineteen-sixties more than a thousand intelligence reports a day. The N.S.A.’s intercepts were the government’s most reliable and important sources of intelligence on the Soviet Union — far outstripping the intelligence collected by the C.I.A. and its agents abroad. In Western Europe, N.S.A. linguists and Army G.I.s sat in unmarked vans monitoring the daily conversations of Soviet tank units on the other side of the Berlin Wall. In the Pacific, Air Force radiomen and N.S.A. technicians, in specially configured Boeing 707s, flew huge figure eights over the ocean, copying Morse-code transmissions from North Korea and the Soviet Far East. In the Mediterranean, Navy signalmen worked hectic shifts with their N.S.A. colleagues, eavesdropping on government communications in the Middle East. Many of the most sophisticated Soviet codes were broken, including the diplomatic traffic to Moscow from its Embassy in Washington. By the time President Nixon was in office, the agency was listening to telephone conversations of Soviet leaders as they were driven in limousines to and from the Kremlin. In the upper reaches of the United States government, access to the agency’s daily top-secret “take” was a sign of importance and success. Henry A. Kissinger, Nixon’s national-security adviser, went as far as to order the agency to scan the diplomatic traffic from Washington, isolate references to him, and deliver the cables to his office, without any further distribution inside the government. Many of his successors have received the same service.
These successes were the payoff for years of painstaking technical research. In the nineteen-fifties and sixties, the N.S.A.’s engineers, working closely with the American computer industry, coordinated and financed much of the early work in telecommunications, underwriting research on semiconductors, high-speed circuitry, and transistorized computers. With its research into microelectronics, the agency also helped to develop the early guidance systems for intercontinental ballistic nuclear missiles. And the agency’s team of mathematicians — aided by outside advisers, many of whom were tenured at places such as Harvard, Dartmouth, and Princeton — steadily tore through the Soviet cipher systems.
By the mid-seventies, as the world began routinely communicating by microwave, the agency maintained its edge with innovative use of satellite intelligence, and its mathematicians and computer experts were sometimes able to thwart the Russians’ attempts to scramble their signals. Even undersea and underground coaxial cables — the most secure means then of relaying telephone conversations and electronic communications — could be intercepted. Books and newspaper articles have described the penetration of Soviet cables at sea by N.S.A. units aboard Navy submarines as some of the most daring intelligence operations of the Cold War.
The collapse of Communism, in 1989, and the collapse of the Soviet Union, in 1991, led to a revised mission for the N.S.A., with more focus on international terrorism and drug dealing — both highly elusive targets. The agency’s budget was cut back. In the early nineties, as more nations turned to fibre optics, the N.S.A. shut down twenty of its forty-two radio listening posts around the world. (In some cases, equipment was left behind to be monitored remotely.) The agency’s overseas military personnel have been reduced by half.
The N.S.A.’s status within the government has also been diminished. Last year, Richard Lardner, a reporter for the Washington newsletter Inside the Pentagon, revealed that the agency had been “reined in” and would no longer be authorized to report directly to the Secretary of Defense. The N.S.A. was ordered instead to report through an Assistant Secretary. In recent years, according to a congressional study, the N.S.A.’s contribution to the President’s daily intelligence brief — a secret summary prepared at the C.I.A. every morning for the White House — has fallen by nearly twenty per cent. The N.S.A. was being jarred by the difficulties of tracking terrorism, and by the rapid spread of unbreakable codes. The agency also discovered that it had few advocates in the White House and among those officials at the Office of Management and Budget who control the flow of money to the top-secret world. The agency was not allowed to keep the funds it had saved by reducing manpower and drastically cutting overseas stations.
The N.S.A. is also getting very little help from its colleagues in the American intelligence community. One legislative aide told me that George Tenet, the director of Central Intelligence, who has nominal responsibility for all intelligence gathering, had expressed alarm upon taking office about the N.S.A.’s weakness, and told congressmen of his desire to rescue the agency from what appeared to be a “precipitous calamity.” But, the aide added,” he didn’t do it.”
The N.S.A.’s strongest supporters — the members and staffs of the Senate and House intelligence committees — are also its most vocal critics. The agency is now facing the most caustic congressional scrutiny in its history, amid much pessimism that it can right itself without major changes in its management. Staff members of the intelligence-oversight committees traditionally prefer not to be quoted by name, but John Millis, a former C.I.A. officer who is staff director of the House intelligence committee, openly discussed the N.S.A.’s problems in the fall of 1998 at a luncheon meeting with a group of retired C.I.A. officers. “Signals intelligence is in a crisis,” Millis told his former colleagues, who reprinted the speech in a newsletter. “We have been living in the glory days of SIGINT over the last fifty years, since World War II.” He went on, “Technology has been the friend of the N.S.A., but in the last four or five years technology has moved from being the friend to being the enemy.” Millis also made it clear that any significant increase in the agency’s budget was made more difficult by the fact that”there is no management of the intelligence community. There is no one in a position to make the tradeoffs within the intelligence community that will make a coherent, efficient organization that will function as a whole. So we end up doing it on Capitol Hill. And I’ve got to tell you, if you are depending on Capitol Hill to do something as important as this, you’re in trouble.”
SENATOR ROBERT KERREY, of Nebraska, the ranking Democrat on the Senate’s intelligence committee, told me that there was little he could add to Millis’s assessment, because most information dealing with the agency and its work is highly classified. Kerrey also pointed out that secrecy “does not equal security,” and can be self-defeating. For example, the agency is in desperate need of more money to get started on information-retrieval programs for the Internet which should have been under way years ago. “But I can’t tell you how much they need,” Kerrey said, “and I can’t tell you how much they have. The public doesn’t know about the N.S.A., or what it is. There are no editorials in the New York Times, no advocates. Does the public know that the nation might be more secure if more was invested? Out of sight, out of mind.”
Last July, during a little-noticed Senate colloquy on an intelligence-spending bill, Kerrey hinted at the N.S.A.’s problems. “The signals are becoming more complex and difficult to process,” he said. “And they are becoming more and more encrypted.” Because of the sophistication of current encryption systems for E-mail and other communications,” he said, “we will find our people on the intelligence side coming back and saying, ‘Look, I know something bad happened . . . I couldn’t make sense of the signal. We intercept, and all we get is a buzz and background noise. We cannot interpret. We can’t convert it.’ “
Kerrey says that his concern was heightened by a report on the N.S.A. that was filed last year by an unusual study group that he and Senator Richard C. Shelby, Republican of Alabama and the committee’s chairman, had put together. Secret congressional studies are routine, but the Senate team, known as the Technical Advisory Group, included a number of prominent outsiders — men who were in charge of re search and technology for major American high-tech corporations, such as George Spix, of Microsoft, Bran Ferren, of the Walt Disney Company, and a nuclear-weapons physicist, Dr. Lowell Wood, of the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. The outsiders were given full clearance and access to many of the most sensitive areas at the Fort Meade headquarters. Their conclusions were devastating. “We told them that unless you totally change your intelligence-collection systems you will go deaf,” one involved official told me. “You’ve got ten years.”
The advisory group put much of the blame for the agency’s problems on the stagnation and rigidity of the senior civilian management. “The N.S.A.’s party line to Congress is ‘We’re fine. We don’t need to change,’ ” the official told me. “It’s like a real Communist organization. Free thought is not encouraged” among the managers. Referring to the senior bureaucracy, the official said that the agency would “have to fire almost everyone.” This official and others singled out Barbara A. McNamara, the current N.S.A. deputy director, as someone especially resistant to change. “She’s leading a cohort of thirty-year veterans who go back to radio” — a reference to high-frequency radio transmissions — “and think nothing is needed,” the official said. In secret testimony this fall before Congress, he added, McNamara talked about “how good the N.S.A. is — how it caught this and that drug guy. They got a whole bunch of horseshit from Barbara.”
In subsequent interviews, many former N.S.A. managers endorsed the advisory group’s findings. One former official described the civilian leadership as “a self-licking ice-cream cone,” with little tolerance for dissent or information it did not wish to hear. “If you didn’t support their position, you weren’t considered a team player,” this person told me. “You couldn’t go into a meeting, put your best ideas on the table, have it out, get the best idea, and then go have a beer.” McNamara’s authority stems from her longevity: the admirals and generals who serve the agency director remain on the job for an average of three years before retiring or going on to other military assignments. The agency’s top civilians have worked together, in many cases, for nearly thirty years, and inevitably share the same insular points of view. Another recently retired official told me that the N.S.A. has become a dynastic bureaucracy, in which the fathers have made room for their sons, with the wives and mothers of favored employees hired as mid-level staff in the human-resources office. “The place is full of warlords and fiefdoms,” the former official said. “Now we’re getting to the grandchildren.” Such insider hiring has led to the quip, which I heard from a number of officials, that the N.S.A. functions as a “Glen Burnie W.P.A. project.” Glen Burnie is a nearby suburb, and home to many N.S.A. employees. Questions also were raised during my interviews about the effectiveness of many of the senior military officers who are routinely assigned to the N.S.A. for two-, three-, or four-year tours of duty. Some perform brilliantly, but far too many find themselves put in charge of units for which they are unqualified, and end up relying extensively on their civilian staffs. “We call them the summer help,” a former manager told me, adding that the smart ones generally seek to get reassigned as soon as possible.
The Technical Advisory Group urged that the agency immediately begin a major reorganization, and start planning for the recruitment of several thousand skilled computer scientists. One of their missions would be to devise software and write information-retrieval programs that would enable the agency to make sense of the data routinely sucked up by satellite and other interception devices. The vast majority of telephone calls, E-mails, and faxes are not encrypted — almost all are sent as plain text — but the N.S.A. has been overwhelmed by the sheer volume of the intercepted data, much of which is irrelevant. “They’re still collecting a lot of digital,” one of the agency’s consultants told me,”and can’t do anything with it.” The consultant added that agency managers recently estimated that Fort Meade had three years’ worth of storage capacity for intercepted Internet traffic. “They filled it in eleven months,” he said.
“The bottom line is they’ve got to retool,” the advisory-group official said. “It will take a lot of money and effort — like starting the N.S.A. again.” Far from being able to retool, the agency has suffered a severe brain drain in recent years, losing mid-career managers to the high pay and upward mobility of private industry. One former senior official described the process as self-defeating: the agency’s recognized need for more outside contact with, and stimulation by, the computer world is offset by the fact that its budding young experts “meet new people and then get hired away by them.”
THE N.S.A.’s current alienation from the computer gurus in industry and academia might not have occurred if two Californians with a fascination for the mathematics of cryptoanalysis hadn’t decided to compare notes more than two decades ago. A 1951 law gave the government the right to classify as secret any invention considered potentially harmful to national security, but in November, 1976, Whitfield Diffie, a computer scientist, and Martin E. Hellman, a Stanford University electrical engineer, published a revolutionary technical paper on what has become known as public key cryptography Before their work, an encrypted message could be understood only if the sender and receiver had the same key, or decoder, to turn the scrambled letters into readable text. The beauty of the Diffie-Hellman breakthrough was its simplicity: the message would have two keys — one could be registered in a public directory (today it might be on the Internet) and the other would be known only to the intended recipient. One key would be used to encipher the message and the other to decipher it. A senior N.S.A. official has described the Diffie-Hellman concept as a series of computations that are easy to do but hard to reverse, like breaking a window.
To the agency’s dismay, the world now had access to a sophisticated level of cryptography that had not been previously fully understood even by N.S.A. analysts. In 1978, when George I. Davida, a computer scientist at the University of Wisconsin, tried to patent an encryption device he had invented, the N.S.A. invoked the 1951 secrecy law. Davida took his case to the media, and the agency, prodded by attorneys in the Carter Administration, eventually backed down, but the message was clear — the agency would do all it could to prevent public access to encryption techniques.
By the early nineties, the telephone system had been deregulated, the computer market was booming, and the Internet was beginning its ride, but the N.S.A.’s policy remained static: encryption was defined as a a weapons system whose export was controlled by the government. The debate over encryption was now a public controversy, with the government arrayed against privacy advocates, academics, and a computer industry that was bemoaning the annual loss of billions of dollars to foreign manufacturers whose computers included high-powered encryption.
In 1993, law-enforcement officials further infuriated the computer industry by beginning a criminal investigation of Philip R. Zimmermann, a software engineer then living in Boulder, Colorado. Zimmermann’s crime was being a free-spirited hacker; he cobbled together a cryptography program called P.G.P. — for Pretty Good Privacy — and gave it away. P.G.P. was the agency’s nightmare — it offered the average computer user a nontechnical and nonthreatening entry into easy, daily use of cryptography. P.G.P. soon found its way to the Internet, and it quickly spread around the world — making Zimmermann, in the government’s view, an exporter of munitions. A grand jury inquiry began. The computer industry rallied around Zimmermann, and after three years the case was dropped. Zimmermann eventually explained to a Senate committee, “I wrote P.G.P. from information in the open literature…. This technology belongs to everybody.” By the mid-nineteen-nineties, the Software Publishers Association was telling journalists that the number of cryptographic products being sold by foreign companies had reached three hundred and forty.
President Clinton and his senior advisers, under pressure from the law-enforcement and national-security communities, tried to compromise on the issue. The export of encryption for computers could go forward, the government said, if the industry agreed to install a government-approved encryption chip, known as the Clipper Chip, that could be directly accessed by law-enforcement officers. Under another proposal, American computer manufacturers would have been permitted to export new encryption products if a spare set of decoding keys were accessible to the government. The proposals, known as key recovery or key escrow, were assailed by privacy proponents, who demanded to know whether the Clinton Administration would have dared to advocate that citizens be required to give the keys to their house or safety-deposit box to a third person.
The cultural divide between Fort Meade and Silicon Valley was widening. The agency’s senior managers were unable to comprehend what every programmer and researcher in academia and industry intuitively understood: encryption could not be stopped. The managers had ample warning. In 1991, a secret study predicted that the use of encryption would grow exponentially — a prediction largely ignored by the agency’s senior management. A former N.S.A. director recalled that in the early nineties he had had a series of conversations with the civilian managers, urging them not to insist on their version of key recovery. “I couldn’t believe their proposals,” he said, adding that he had warned the managers that, given the public’s attitude toward privacy, key recovery “could not work if the government held the key. They were so arrogant. They knew all there was to know.”
“Export control is a legitimate concern to the agency,” one former senior official told me, but the issue made the top managers “paralyzed and afraid to move into the future.” He and many colleagues had argued for a two-prong approach — continuing to do all that was possible to maintain export controls while also planning for a fully encrypted world. The agency’s long fight against encryption delayed its widespread use by many years, but the agency’s senior managers spent those years “holding on to what we have today” instead of seeking ways to lessen encryption’s impact. The official lamented, “We were squandering time” while continuing to make more enemies inside the computer industry.
Today, the encryption fight is all but over. The Commerce Department is scheduled to issue new export regulations on December 15th that, many experts believe, will permit American computer companies to include advanced cryptography, with fewer restrictions, on equipment sold worldwide. “We’ve won,” Phil Zimmermann told me, jubilantly. “And they tried to put me in prison! Now we can export strong crypto and they can’t stop us. We can do whatever we wish.”
N.S.A.’s short-term solution to the encryption dilemma has been to urge the C.I.A. to go back to the world of dirty tricks and surreptitious entry. According to a 1996 congressional staff study, the next century will require a clandestine agency that “breaks into or otherwise gains access to the contents of secured facilities, safes and computers” and “steals, compromises and influences foreign cryptographic capabilities so as to make them exploitable” by the N.S.A.
Such information theoretically could help Washington policymakers disrupt future terrorist activity, intercept illicit shipments of nuclear arms, or uncover acts of espionage against American defense corporations. Unfortunately, several C.I.A. officers I spoke with found the proposal too ambitious. One retired case officer told me that while he was on a clandestine assignment years ago in the Third World, “I was designated to get a certain black box. I worked on it for three and a half years, and I got nowhere. If I had worked on it for ten years, and with a true stroke of luck, I might have gotten within ten feet of it.” Another retired operations officer, similarly skeptical of the C.I.A.’s chances of obtaining cryptological intelligence, told me that sometimes the clandestine operatives in the field have to report back, “This is too hard. “
Many Americans, of course, are deeply distrustful of the N.S.A. — a view reflected in recent Hollywood movies like “Enemy of the State” and “Mercury Rising.” The traditional American belief in privacy and constitutional protection is at odds with a superspy agency capable of monitoring unencrypted telephone conversations and E-mail exchanges anywhere in the world. Abuses have occurred. In the nineteen-seventies, the Senate intelligence committee revealed that the agency had systematically violated the law by surveilling American citizens, including more than twelve hundred anti-war and civil-rights activists. The revelations led to a public outcry and to the 1978 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which made monitoring of American targets illegal without a warrant from a special federal court. (The court rarely turns down such requests from the government.) The act, and a supporting executive order, set rules for the handling of intercepts or other intelligence involving Americans who were overheard or picked up in the course of legitimate foreign surveillance.
The N.S.A.’s bitter fight over encryption, with its tell-all computer chips and key-recovery proposals, has renewed long-standing fears that one of the agency’s satellite-data collection programs, code-named ECHELON, is routinely collecting and analyzing unencrypted telephone conversations and Internet chatter around the world. ECHELON was launched, in the mid-nineteen-seventies, to spy on Soviet satellite communications. “Imagine,” the BBC exclaimed last month — one of hundreds of such reports in the past ten years — “a global spying network that can eavesdrop on every single phone call, fax, or E-mail, anywhere on the planet. It sounds like science fiction, but it’s true.” The agency does routinely collect vast amounts of digital data, and it is capable of targeting an individual telephone line or computer terminal in many places around the world. But active and retired N.S.A. officials have repeatedly told me that the agency does not yet have the software to make sense out of more than a tiny fraction of the huge array of random communications that are collected. If the agency were able to filter through the traffic, the officials noted, international terrorists like Osama bin Laden would not be able to remain in hiding.
The fact is that ECHELON, far from being one of the N.S.A.’s secret weapons, as some believe, is viewed as a fiscal black hole by the Senate and House intelligence committees. John Millis, in his private talk to the retired C.I.A agents, complained that the United States was spending “incredible amounts of money” on satellite collection. “It threatens to overwhelm the intelligence budget.” Using satellites to sweep up communications indiscriminately, he said, “doesn’t make a lot of sense…. You shouldn’t be spending one more dollar than we do to try and intercept communications from space.” Millis’s point was that the data collected from satellites, like the data collected from the Internet, cannot be sorted or analyzed in any meaningful way.
THE agency’s critics, in and out of the government, told me that they see a glimmer of hope for the N.S.A. in the appointment, last May, of Lieutenant General Michael Hayden as its new director. Hayden, who joined the Air Force after earning a master’s degree in American history at Duquesne University, in Pittsburgh, has been praised for his intelligence and open-mindedness. “Hayden gets it,” one intelligence-committee aide told me. “But he’s parachuted in there, and faced with a deputy director whose job is to foil what the director wants to do. There’s no question that it’s the hardest job in the intelligence community. He’s got to manage a multibillion-dollar corporation that has a blue-collar mentality.”
General Hayden’s initial goal will be to convince Congress and the White House that he can do what his predecessors did not — develop a specific management plan and a budget for analyzing intelligence from the Internet and other digital sources. “We’ve criticized the N.S.A. for not having a well-coordinated strategy,” one legislative aide told me, “but we’re not in a position to tell them where to go.” The issues, of course, are highly technical, and it’s not clear that more money — even billions of dollars — will get the job done. The amount of data flowing through the Internet is growing exponentially, and skilled computer scientists are at a premium. The agency’s war against encryption has left a legacy of bitterness throughout the computer industry, and today’s technical advances are taking place not at Fort Meade but on university campuses and in corporation laboratories across America. Those computer whizzes who might have been attracted to high-level government work are instead being attracted by the far higher pay scales offered by private industry.
There also is little evidence that President Clinton and his national-security team view the agency’s signals-intelligence plight as significant. This year’s classified Defense Department budget request included a boost of nearly two hundred million dollars for the agency, with the funds ear-marked for long-range research into signals intelligence. The money never made it through the White House’s Office of Management and Budget, however. “George Tenet didn’t support it,” a former congressional aide explained. A similar secret request, for four hundred million dollars or more to modify the Jimmy Carter, a Seawolf-class nuclear submarine, for top-secret agency intelligence work, was approved — evidence that the White House believes that more covert operations will solve the nation’s coming intelligence problems.
Hayden also will have to contend with those, in and out of the government, who remain dubious about the N.S.A. One firm skeptic is the encryption expert Whitfield Diffie, who is now at Sun Microsystems. Diffie, a leading advocate of computer privacy, was quick to suggest that the current alarm in the N.S.A. may be a self-interested ruse. When I brought up the N.S.A.’s problems with new technology, he replied, “What bothers me is that you are saying what the agency wants us to believe — they used to be great, but these days they have trouble reading the newspaper, the Internet is too complicated for them, there is so much traffic and they can’t find what they want. It may be true, but it is what they have been ‘saying’ for years. It’s convenient for N.S.A. to have its targets believe it is in trouble. That doesn’t mean it isn’t in trouble, but it is a reason to view what spooky inside informants say with skepticism.”
Shortly after his appointment, Hayden assembled a group of highly regarded mid-level managers and gave them free rein to evaluate the agency. He also began a series of meetings, outside Fort Meade, to get independent advice. The evaluations were consistently “brutal,” according to one official, in terms of the ongoing management problems. On November 15th, Hayden announced to the N.S.A. workforce that he was beginning what he called One Hundred Days of Change. The next day, he made his move against the establishment. He dissolved the agency’s leadership structure, despite a bitter protest from Barbara McNamara, and announced the formation of a five-member executive group, under his leadership, which would be responsible for decision-making.
LAST month, General Hayden agreed to speak to me, at his unpretentious top-floor offices at Ops 2, the N.S.A. headquarters building. He is an affable spymaster, who laughs easily, offers no slogans, and promises no quick fixes for the agency’s problems. He seemed to understand that his new troops — computer gurus and mathematicians — are unlike any others he had commanded before.
When I brought up the agency’s long-standing war against the export of encryption, Hayden quickly dismissed it as yesterday’s lost battle. He also took issue with those who criticized Barbara McNamara and other civilian managers for their failure to anticipate the communications upheaval. “Barbara McNamara has been a good deputy to me,” he said. “But I make the decisions.”
Hayden emphasized that the personnel problems are far less significant than the technological ones: “The issue is not people but external changes. For the N.S.A., technology is a two-edged sword. If technology in the outside world races away from us — at breakneck speed — our mission is more difficult. It can be our enemy.”
When I asked Hayden about the agency’s capability for unwarranted spying on private citizens — in the unlikely event, of course, that the agency could somehow get the funding, the computer scientists, and the knowledge to begin making sense out of the Internet — his response was heated. “I’m a kid from Pittsburgh with two sons and a daughter who are closet libertarians,” he said. “I am not interested in doing anything that threatens the American people, and threatens the future of this agency. I can’t emphasize enough to you how careful we are. We have to be so careful — to make sure that America is never distrustful of the power and security we can provide.”
General Hayden made no effort to minimize his agency’s plight. During the Cold War, he said, the N.S.A. was “technologically more adept than our adversary. Now it’s harder to predict where America!s interests will need to be in the future.” His goal in the near future, he added, speaking carefully, is to determine which of the agency’s past practices are applicable to today’s high-tech world — “and which of them may be counterproductive.”
“A lot of the choices are Sophie’s choices,” he said. “The trade-off is between modernizations (recruiting computer scientists and beginning long-range programs to tackle the Internet) “and readiness” — that is, meeting the hectic operational needs of the Defense Department and the White House for immediate intelligence. “We have a high ops tempo,” he added, “but choices have to be made.” In other words, he made clear, some ongoing N.S.A. intelligence-collection programs will have to be curtailed, or eliminated, so that funds are available for futuristic research.
“In its forty-year struggle against Soviet Communism,” Hayden noted, “the N.S.A. was thorough, stable, and focussed.” Then he asked “What’s changed?” and he answered, “All of that.”
Become a Patron! True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.
China’s Military: Culture Field Guide
81 pages
For Official Use Only
September 2009
China’s Military Culture Field Guide is designed to provide deploying military personnel an overview of China’s military cultural terrain. In this field guide, China’s military cultural history has been synopsized to capture the more significant aspects of China’s military cultural environment, with emphasis on factors having the greatest potential to impact operations.
The field guide presents background information to show China’s military mind-set through its history, values, and internal dynamics. It also contains practical sections on lifestyle, customs, and habits. For those seeking more extensive information, MCIA produces a series of cultural intelligence studies on China’s military that explores the dynamics of China’s military culture at a deeper level.
…
The People’s Liberation Army (PLA) is the world’s largest standing army; it protects the world’s fastestrising economic power. In recent years, U.S. personnel have gained a much greater understanding of the PLA’s equipment and capabilities. However, knowledge of the values, beliefs, and essential cultural features that influence the way PLA members behave, interact, and make decisions is much less widespread. This field guide is aimed at U.S. personnel who will interact with Chinese military personnel but have limited knowledge of China or the PLA. The guide is intended to help readers better understand why PLA members act as they do and how the PLA differs from the U.S. military. This guide is divided into three parts. “Who is the PLA?” provides background on the PLA’s structure and personnel and discusses how the PLA is transforming itself.“How the PLA Sees Itself” traces the beliefs the PLA promotes about its origins, historical legacies, and key values. “Understanding PLA Actions” describes key aspects of PLA behavior, including its changing operational practices and its decision-making principles and processes, and discusses how U.S. personnel can most effectively interact with PLA members.
…
The PLA is a Party-Army: its missions, institutions, and practices are all shaped by the fact that its ultimate loyalty is to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
Change is a key element of PLA culture. The PLA is undergoing tremendous changes in its personnel system and its operational doctrine and practices. It is experiencing the “growing pains” of its transformation from a peasant army to a modern military. The PLA promotes the view that its greatest strengths are the morale and discipline of its personnel, and that these qualities enable the PLA to compensate for weak material capabilities. However, PLA leaders worry that these “human qualities” are increasingly difficult to maintain in a rapidly changing society.
U.S. personnel are often frustrated by the different expectations that the PLA and the U.S. military bring to military-to-military interactions. However, U.S. personnel can improve the quality of these exchanges by gaining an understanding of the PLA’s professional and cultural norms and an appreciation of what its members seek to gain from interaction with the U.S. military.
…
…
Looking for a Few Good Men
According to a popular saying in imperial China, “Just as good iron is not forged into nails, good men do not become soldiers.” Today’s PLA faces immense difficulties in attracting the “good men” it needs in order to build the high-quality fighting force it wants. Based on the demands of 21st century warfare, the PLA now seeks:
● Conscripts from urban, educated backgrounds
● Officers who are better educated and more technically capable
● Personnel who are innovative and willing to take risks
However, due to recent changes in Chinese society, young people with strong skills have a wide range of opportunities in the private sector or overseas. Despite reforms to the personnel system, PLA leaders remain concerned that the PLA has too many:
● Conscripts who are rural, uneducated, and poor
● Officers who stay too long in their positions and are too slow to adapt to new techniques and technologies
● Personnel (particularly officers) who are conservative and risk averse
…
Recent Issues
● In 2002 China’s official news service reported that most PLA barracks finally had year-round electricity, heat, air conditioning, and indoor plumbing.
● In 2003 a PLAN depot reported that it was rethinking its earlier refusal to install air conditioning in the quarters for NCOs’ visiting family members. This refusal had resulted from concerns that if the quarters were too comfortable, family members would stay too long.
● In 2005 a PLAAF newspaper proudly reported that a tactical unit had installed 17 new showers, so that the troops could have one hot shower per week.
● In 2006 the leaders of a Second Artillery unit, concerned that unit personnel would be “tempted” by the bars and markets of a nearby town, built a wall around the unit compound to keep personnel inside. Personnel simply climbed over it to go into town, for such purposes as calling their families and taking uniforms to the dry cleaners.
…
Suspicion of Foreigners
Today’s PLA members—and Chinese citizens more generally—still display a sense of wounded pride over what they call the “Century of Humiliation,” the period between 1840 and 1949 when China lost sovereignty, power, and human lives to foreign invaders. Because of these bitter memories, Chinese resistance to foreign interference is very strong. PRC leaders and intellectuals interpret many U.S. actions as evidence that the United States is determined to keep China from gaining global influence.
The CCP actively encourages the PLA to distrust foreign intentions. For instance, President Hu Jintao, in a 2004 speech on the PLA’s main tasks, warned that “Western hostile forces have not given up the wild ambition of trying to subjugate us, intensifying the political strategy of westernizing and dividing up China.” U.S. guests of the PLA may be surprised to find their hosts questioning the intentions of the U.S. government and people toward China during seemingly unrelated conversations.
PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT OF SECURITY AND INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
446 pages
June 2011
This study evaluates the oversight of national security and intelligence agencies by parliaments and specialised non-parliamentary oversight bodies, with a view to identifying good practices that can inform the European Parliament’s approach to strengthening the oversight of Europol, Eurojust, Frontex and, to a lesser extent, Sitcen. The study puts forward a series of detailed recommendations (including in the field of access to classified information) that are formulated on the basis of in-depth assessments of: (1) the current functions and powers of these four bodies; (2) existing arrangements for the oversight of these bodies by the European Parliament, the Joint Supervisory Bodies and national parliaments; and (3) the legal and institutional frameworks for parliamentary and specialised oversight of security and intelligence agencies in EU Member States and other major democracies.
…
Access to and the protection of classified information by the European Parliament
As this study’s analysis of oversight of intelligence agencies at the national level demonstrates, information is the oxygen that sustains oversight; a mandate to oversee an agency’s work is of limited use unless it is accompanied by access to the relevant information. It will be extremely difficult to strengthen parliamentary oversight of the AFSJ bodies without clear and predictable rules and procedures for the EP to access relevant information from these bodies, the Commission and the Council. While access to relevant information is fundamental to oversight, the professional handling of this information by overseers is also crucial for effective oversight. Accordingly, improved access to classified information by the EP will need to be accompanied by the development of appropriate procedures for the protection of this information, as well as an ongoing commitment from MEPs to handle classified information in a professional manner.
Improving the European Parliament’s access to classified information in the AFSJ
The development of an appropriate legal and institutional framework for parliamentary access to classified information is of fundamental importance to strengthening the EP’s oversight of the AFSJ bodies. The discussion of the EP’s access to classified information must take place alongside deliberations on the evolution of the EP’s mandate to oversee the AFSJ bodies; indeed, we have argued throughout this study that an oversight body’s information needs are inextricably linked to its mandate. Yet, regardless of which aspects of the AFSJ bodies’ work the EP wishes to oversee and which institutional mechanism is chosen to carry out this oversight (see below for a discussion of these mechanisms), access to relevant classified information will be crucial. This is because various aspects of the work of AFSJ bodies are classified and/or involve the processing or creation of classified information.
Parliamentary access to classified information is currently being discussed in the context of deliberations regarding the revision of Regulation 1049—legislation which is ostensibly about public access to information from EU entities. The EP’s rapporteur on this matter, Michael Cashman, has opted to include provisions on parliamentary access to information in the broader draft legal framework for public access to EU documents. This approach has several advantages. First, it is aimed at ensuring that there is a general framework for the EP’s access to classified information from all EU entities and across all policy domains. This may be preferable to a fragmented legal framework for parliamentary access to information based on inter-institutional agreements across different fields. The effects of this current framework are that the EP has access to classified information from, e.g., the Council, in some fields but not others and that different modalities apply to access classified information in different policy domains. Second, the inclusion of provisions on the EP’s access to classified information as part of broader legislation on public access to information could help to ensure that these rules have the status of legislation rather than being enshrined in inter-institutional agreements, which are of a subordinate legal status. In spite of these advantages, we are of the view that parliamentary access to classified information should be decoupled from provisions on public access to information. This is supported by practice on the national level, where freedom of/access to information laws are separated entirely from regulations on parliamentary access to information. Parliamentary access to classified information implies access to the specific categories of information which are justifiably exempt from public access, e.g., information regarding the work of intelligence agencies. It is precisely because such information is beyond the reach of public access that it must be available to certain parliamentarians and institutions established by parliaments for overseeing, inter alia, intelligence agencies. In almost every state analysed in this study, parliaments have privileged access to classified information to, among other things, enable to them oversee intelligence activities. This is premised on the notion that parliamentarians are elected by a population to hold governments and their agencies to account. In order to do this, they require privileged access to information which is not necessarily available to members of the public. Therefore, rules governing parliamentary access to classified information are set out in law and are disconnected for general freedom of/access to information laws.
Recommendation 11: New regulations on the European Parliament’s access to classified information should be decoupled from legislation on public access to information.
…
…
4.1.1. The rationale for oversight of intelligence agencies
Many states created parliamentary and other specialised bodies to oversee intelligence agencies in light of revelations about their involvement in illegal and/or improper activities, e.g., Canada, the Czech Republic, Norway, Poland, South Africa, and the US. Notably, during or immediately after the Cold War, it became clear that in many Western states, governments had used intelligence agencies to surveil and disrupt persons involved in legitimate expressions of the rights to freedom of association, assembly and expression. Elsewhere, intelligence agencies were found to have exceeded their legal mandates and powers in tackling domestic terrorism. Perhaps the egregious violations of human rights by intelligence agencies took place in communist/authoritarian regimes, where intelligence agencies were an integral part of the repressive state apparatuses which permeated all areas of society. Against this backdrop, effective oversight (and legal regulation) of intelligence agencies came to be seen as essential for ensuring that they contribute to the security of the populations they serve without undermining democratic processes and human rights. That is, to ‘secure democracy against internal and external enemies without destroying democracy in the process’. Needless to say, the development of oversight of the EU’s AFSJ bodies is taking place in a vastly different climate from the types of conditions that led to the establishment of oversight bodies on the national level. Arguments for robust oversight of intelligence agencies can be distilled into five main areas.
First, and perhaps most importantly, the law gives most intelligence agencies powers that permit them to restrict human rights and which, if misused, could result in the violation of human rights. Indeed, as Canada’s Justice O’Connor stated in the Arar Inquiry: ‘national security activities involve the most intrusive powers of the state: electronic surveillance; search, seizure and forfeiture of property; information collection and exchange with domestic and foreign security intelligence and law enforcement agencies; and, potentially, the detention of and prosecution of individuals’. Intelligence agencies are necessarily given a considerable amount of discretion in their use of intelligence collection powers, which increases the scope for such powers to be misused. In view of this, oversight is necessary to help ensure that such powers are used in accordance with national and international law.
Second, on a national level, the political misuse of intelligence agencies has always been a risk, primarily because these agencies can be used to unlawfully gather information about political opponents. Oversight is seen to be an essential safeguard against incumbent governments using intelligence agencies to protect or promote party political interests. This is less of a concern at the EU level because there is not the same direct relationship of control between the executive and the agencies. Perhaps more importantly, the fact that 27 Member States, the Commission and Council are all involved in the political control of these agencies means that there are in-built checks and balances against there (mis)use by any one party or interest group.
Third, the secrecy surrounding national intelligence agencies shields them from the processes of public accountability which apply to public bodies in democracies. For example, these agencies are not usually particularly open with the media and are often exempt from freedom of information legislation. This makes it difficult for the media, civil society organisations and the public more generally to scrutinise the intelligence agencies’ work. This further increases the need for oversight by independent bodies that have access to information not available to the general public.
Fourth, in common with all public bodies, intelligence agencies are funded with public money and should therefore be held to account for their use of this money. There is particular need for oversight given that intelligence agencies are normally authorised to make secret payments to covert agents. The potential for the inappropriate use of money is heightened in this area. Robust oversight is necessary to ensure that intelligence agencies use public money lawfully and efficiently.
Finally, while oversight is often seen as necessary to guard against the misuse of, and abuse by, intelligence agencies, it also helps to ensure that these agencies fulfil their mandates effectively. Intelligence agencies are, inter alia, entrusted with collecting, analysing and disseminating information about very serious threats to national security and public safety, such as terrorism. The executive and other agencies, such as the police, rely on the information provided by intelligence agencies to take action to combat these threats. Failures by intelligence agencies to perform such functions effectively, e.g., by missing information indicating a terrorist attack, can have catastrophic consequences.
Independent oversight of the work of intelligence agencies helps to ensure that they are as effective as possible.
You must be logged in to post a comment.