Featured

The Shadow Spy: A Deep Dive into Booz Allen Hamilton

The Shadow Spy: Inside Booz Allen Hamilton
What happens when the government outsources its deepest secrets? Booz Allen Hamilton isn’t just a contractor—it’s a private corporation embedded at the heart of U.S. intelligence, with an estimated 70% of the intelligence budget flowing to firms like it.
From Edward Snowden to the largest theft of classified data in history, Booz Allen has been at the center of some of America’s most devastating security breaches. This deep dive explores how a management consultancy became a “shadow intelligence community,” and why its repeated failures point to a dangerous flaw in how modern espionage is run.

In the world of intelligence, where the line between government and industry is as thin as a fiber-optic cable, few names carry as much weight—or controversy—as Booz Allen Hamilton. Often described as the “shadow intelligence community,” the firm has become a central pillar of U.S. national security while repeatedly surfacing at the heart of some of the most consequential espionage and data-leak scandals of the modern era.

This is the story of how a management consultancy evolved into a core actor of the National Security Industrial Complex—and why that evolution now poses systemic risks.

The Hawaii Connection

In the spring of 2013, a 29-year-old computer technician named Edward Snowden reported for work at a National Security Agency facility in Hawaii. He was not a government employee. He was a contractor employed by Booz Allen Hamilton.

Within months, Snowden fled to Hong Kong carrying a trove of classified documents that exposed global mass-surveillance programs and ignited a worldwide debate over privacy, sovereignty, and the outsourcing of state power. The disclosures reshaped intelligence law, diplomacy, and public trust—and permanently tied Booz Allen’s name to one of the largest intelligence breaches in history.

Not an Exception, but a Pattern

The Snowden affair was not an anomaly. It was a visible rupture in a system that had quietly become dependent on private contractors.

Today, an estimated 70 percent of the U.S. intelligence budget flows to private firms. Booz Allen Hamilton sits at the apex of that ecosystem, staffed heavily by former CIA, NSA, and Pentagon officials and embedded deep inside classified programs.

As its influence has grown, so too has its exposure to failure. Again and again, the firm has surfaced as a common denominator in major security lapses—raising questions not about individual misconduct, but about structural vulnerability.

The Rise of a “Shadow Intelligence Community”

Booz Allen’s relationship with the U.S. military dates back to 1940, but its transformation into an intelligence powerhouse accelerated dramatically after September 11, 2001. Counterterrorism, cyberwarfare, data analytics, and surveillance became growth sectors—and Booz Allen became indispensable.

Key characteristics define its role today:

Security Penetration: More than three-quarters of its workforce holds U.S. security clearances.
Revenue Dependence: A substantial share of its multi-billion-dollar revenue derives from intelligence and defense agencies.
The Revolving Door: Senior leadership has routinely included former top officials, including a former Director of National Intelligence.

The result is not merely a contractor relationship, but a form of institutional fusion—private employees operating inside the nervous system of the state.

A Record of Breaches

Despite its central role in safeguarding classified systems, Booz Allen’s history is punctuated by some of the most damaging security failures on record:

The Snowden Disclosures (2013): Exposure of PRISM and global electronic surveillance programs, triggering diplomatic fallout and public backlash worldwide.
The Harold Martin Case (2016): A Booz Allen employee arrested for allegedly hoarding roughly 50 terabytes of classified material over two decades—the largest known theft of classified data in U.S. history.
The IRS Tax Leak Fallout (2024–2026): Contractor Charles Littlejohn sentenced for leaking confidential tax records of high-profile individuals. In response, the U.S. Treasury canceled 31 Booz Allen contracts in early 2026.

Each case differed in motive and method. The constant was access.

The Profitability of Privacy

Critics argue that Booz Allen embodies a fundamental conflict: a profit-driven corporation entrusted with the deepest secrets of a sovereign state. What begins as “surge capacity”—temporary external support—can quietly solidify into a permanent shadow bureaucracy, insulated from democratic oversight yet essential to daily operations.

When accountability fails, consequences tend to diffuse: responsibility shifts between agency, contractor, and individual, leaving systemic flaws intact.

As one intelligence observer put it: Booz Allen is not merely a vendor—it is embedded at the core of U.S. intelligence.

After the IRS Fallout

The Treasury Department’s 2026 contract cancellations serve as a rare instance of institutional consequence. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent summarized the decision bluntly: Booz Allen failed to implement adequate safeguards.

For a firm whose business model is built on security, trust, and risk mitigation, repeated breaches are not public-relations problems. They are existential questions about whether intelligence outsourcing at this scale is sustainable—or safe.

The Booz Allen story is ultimately not about one company. It is about a system in which national intelligence has been privatized, normalized, and monetized—often faster than the safeguards meant to contain it.

Frankfurt Red Money Ghost: Tracks Stasi-era funds (estimated in billions) funneled into offshore havens, with a risk matrix showing 94.6% institutional counterparty risk and 82.7% money laundering probability.
Global Hole & Dark Data Analysis: Exposes an €8.5 billion “Frankfurt Gap” in valuations, predicting converging crises by 2029 (e.g., 92% probability of a $15–25 trillion commercial real estate collapse).
Ruhr-Valuation Gap (2026): Forensic audit identifying €1.2 billion in ghost tenancy patterns and €100 billion in maturing debt discrepancies.
Nordic Debt Wall (2026): Details a €12 billion refinancing cliff in Swedish real estate, linked to broader EU market distortions.
Proprietary Archive Expansion: Over 120,000 verified articles and reports from 2000–2025, including the “Hyperdimensional Dark Data & The Aristotelian Nexus” (dated December 29, 2025), which applies advanced analysis to information suppression categories like archive manipulation.
List of Stasi agents 90,000 plus Securitate Agent List.

Accessing Even More Data

Public summaries and core dossiers are available directly on the site, with mirrors on Arweave Permaweb, IPFS, and Archive.is for preservation. For full raw datasets or restricted items (e.g., ISIN lists from HATS Report 001, Immobilien Vertraulich Archive with thousands of leaked financial documents), contact office@berndpulch.org using PGP or Signal encryption. Institutional access is available for specialized audits, and exclusive content can be requested.

FUND THE DIGITAL RESISTANCE

Target: $75,000 to Uncover the $75 Billion Fraud

The criminals use Monero to hide their tracks. We use it to expose them. This is digital warfare, and truth is the ultimate cryptocurrency.

BREAKDOWN: THE $75,000 TRUTH EXCAVATION

Phase 1: Digital Forensics ($25,000)

· Blockchain archaeology following Monero trails
· Dark web intelligence on EBL network operations
· Server infiltration and data recovery

Phase 2: Operational Security ($20,000)

· Military-grade encryption and secure infrastructure
· Physical security for investigators in high-risk zones
· Legal defense against multi-jurisdictional attacks

Phase 3: Evidence Preservation ($15,000)

· Emergency archive rescue operations
· Immutable blockchain-based evidence storage
· Witness protection program

Phase 4: Global Exposure ($15,000)

· Multi-language investigative reporting
· Secure data distribution networks
· Legal evidence packaging for international authorities

CONTRIBUTION IMPACT

$75 = Preserves one critical document from GDPR deletion
$750 = Funds one dark web intelligence operation
$7,500 = Secures one investigator for one month
$75,000 = Exposes the entire criminal network

SECURE CONTRIBUTION CHANNEL

Monero (XMR) – The Only Truly Private Option

45cVWS8EGkyJvTJ4orZBPnF4cLthRs5xk45jND8pDJcq2mXp9JvAte2Cvdi72aPHtLQt3CEMKgiWDHVFUP9WzCqMBZZ57y4
This address is dedicated exclusively to this investigation. All contributions are cryptographically private and untraceable.

Monero QR Code (Scan to donate anonymously):

(Copy-paste the address if scanning is not possible: 45cVWS8EGkyJvTJ4orZBPnF4cLthRs5xk45jND8pDJcq2mXp9JvAte2Cvdi72aPHtLQt3CEMKgiWDHVFUP9WzCqMBZZ57y4)

Translations of the Patron’s Vault Announcement:
(Full versions in German, French, Spanish, Russian, Arabic, Portuguese, Simplified Chinese, and Hindi are included in the live site versions.)

English:
© 2000–2026 Bernd Pulch. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the author.

(Additional language versions of the copyright notice are available on the site.)

❌©BERNDPULCH – ABOVE TOP SECRET ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS – THE ONLY MEDIA WITH LICENSE TO SPY ✌️
Follow @abovetopsecretxxl for more. 🙏 GOD BLESS YOU 🙏

Credentials & Info:

Bio & Career: https://berndpulch.org/about-me
FAQ: https://berndpulch.org/faq

Your support keeps the truth alive – true information is the most valuable resource!

🏛️ Compliance & Legal Repository Footer

Formal Notice of Evidence Preservation

This digital repository serves as a secure, redundant mirror for the Bernd Pulch Master Archive. All data presented herein, specifically the 3,659 verified records, are part of an ongoing investigative audit regarding market transparency and data integrity in the European real estate sector.

Audit Standards & Reporting Methodology:

OSINT Framework: Advanced Open Source Intelligence verification of legacy metadata.
Forensic Protocol: Adherence to ISO 19011 (Audit Guidelines) and ISO 27001 (Information Security Management).
Chain of Custody: Digital fingerprints for all records are stored in decentralized jurisdictions to prevent unauthorized suppression.

Legal Disclaimer:

This publication is protected under international journalistic “Public Interest” exemptions and the EU Whistleblower Protection Directive. Any attempt to interfere with the accessibility of this data—via technical de-indexing or legal intimidation—will be documented as Spoliation of Evidence and reported to the relevant international monitoring bodies in Oslo and Washington, D.C.

Digital Signature & Tags

Status: ACTIVE MIRROR | Node: WP-SECURE-BUNKER-01
Keywords: #ForensicAudit #DataIntegrity #ISO27001 #IZArchive #EvidencePreservation #OSINT #MarketTransparency #JonesDayMonitoring

✌WORLD EXCLUSIVE: OPERATION TECHNARCHY 5.1 UNVEILED✌DEUTSCHE VERSION✌️VERSION FRANÇAISE✌️

🕵️♂️💻🌐 **“BREACHING THE DIGITAL ABYSS”**
*The hidden nexus of Langley’s algorithms & Berlin’s hybrid war doctrine—rendered in corrupted neon.*
*Silicon circuits feed the machine. Shadow capital writes the code.*
**#CIA #InQTel #SiliconValleyPsyOps #ZMZ40 #CyberNoirIntel**
**#Geheimdienst #BlackBudget #TotalSurveillance #CosmicBlackLeaks**
**#CIAFrench #OpérationZMZ #BerndPulchExposed**
*// This is not a simulation. This is the classified blueprint.* 🔒🌌

🔴 ABOVE TOP SECRET – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPERATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

The Deep Nexus Between Intelligence Agencies, Silicon Valley & Global Cognitive Control

🗓️ Declassified: May 22, 2025
Source: Multi-Agency Brief // Redacted Files from ODNI, EUROPOL, NSA, U.S. Congress Hearings
LEVEL: RED OMEGA // COSMIC BLACK // NATO–EYES ONLY

BONUS DOSSIER FOR PATRONS ONLY

ABOVE TOP SECRET – COSMIC BLACK

OPERATION Q-NODE // THE GHOST BANK OF LANGLEY

https://www.patreon.com/posts/word-exclusive-5-129605047?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=postshare_creator&utm_content=join_link

FREE

☣️ SUBJECT: Integrated Cognitive Warfare & Digital Domination

Entities Involved: CIA, Elon Musk (X, Starlink, xAI), Facebook (Meta), Google (Alphabet), Palantir, Amazon, OpenAI

1. CIA–Silicon Valley Nexus

Codename: OP. MINERVA CHAMBER

FACT: The CIA founded In-Q-Tel in 1999 to fund startups beneficial to intelligence operations.
Notable investments: Palantir, Keyhole Inc. (later Google Earth), Recorded Future.
The CIA cloud infrastructure is hosted by Amazon (AWS).
Verified via: In-Q-Tel portfolio, Congressional hearings.

2. ELON MUSK: Architect of Dual-Use Systems

Codename: OP. STARSPY

Starlink is deployed in Ukraine for NATO-aligned operations.
xAI & Neuralink monitored by DARPA; potential neuro-digital warfare uses.
Musk’s takeover of X/Twitter drew scrutiny from U.S. & EU regulators.
Sources: Pentagon, FCC, Neuralink whitepapers.

3. FACEBOOK/META: Mass Surveillance & Behavior Manipulation

Codename: OP. EMOTION REACTOR

2014: Conducted a psychological experiment on millions without consent.
Links to DARPA’s LifeLog, cancelled the day Facebook launched.
Internal leaks show active tolerance of disinfo and emotional manipulation.
Verified: Facebook Papers, Congressional Testimony, Nature journal.

4. GOOGLE/ALPHABET: The Algorithmic Panopticon

Codename: OP. PREDPOL PRIME

Keyhole Inc. (Google Earth’s precursor) was CIA-funded.
DeepMind involved in predictive modeling for military/medical simulations.
Project Maven: Google faced employee protests over Pentagon AI contracts.
Sources: The Intercept, Wired.

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON: Data Dominance for Defense

Codename: OP. BLACK SPHERE

Palantir used in ICE deportations, battlefield intelligence, predictive policing.
Amazon provides facial recognition tools & CIA cloud hosting.
Sources: ACLU, SEC filings, DHS contracts.

6. OPENAI: The Algorithmic Cold War

Codename: OP. LUCID FRAME

OpenAI now at center of geopolitical AI race.
DARPA & DoD interested in Large Language Model applications for wargaming.
EU AI Act and Pentagon’s DIU closely monitoring developments.
Confirmed by: EU legislation, U.S. AI initiatives.

⚠️ CLASSIFIED FINDINGS

Total Integration: Silicon Valley is an unofficial extension of intelligence.
Cognitive Warfare: Thought manipulation via Big Data & AI.
Civil–Military Fusion: Tech giants are now defense contractors in all but name.

✊ FINAL WARNING

You are not the user – you are the payload.
The digital war is quiet – but fully operational.
This file is COSMIC BLACK. Unauthorized redistribution prohibited.

✌️DEUTSCHE VERSION✌️

🔴 OBERSGEHEIM – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPERATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

Geheimdienstliche Schattennetzwerke, Silicon Valley & globale Steuerung durch kognitive Kriegsführung

🗓️ Freigegeben am: 22. Mai 2025
Quelle: Multi-Agency-Bericht // Redigierte Akten von ODNI, EUROPOL, NSA, Kongressanhörungen
STUFE: ROT OMEGA // COSMIC BLACK // NATO ONLY

☣️ THEMA: Kognitive Kriegsführung & Digitale Vorherrschaft

Beteiligte Akteure: CIA, Elon Musk (X / Starlink / xAI), Facebook (Meta), Google (Alphabet), Palantir, Amazon, OpenAI

1. CIA–Silicon Valley

Codewort: OP. MINERVA CHAMBER

In-Q-Tel gegründet zur Finanzierung geheimdienstrelevanter Startups.
Investitionen: Palantir, Keyhole Inc. (→ Google Earth), Recorded Future.
CIA-Cloud auf AWS gehostet.
Quellen: In-Q-Tel Portfolio, Kongressprotokolle.

2. ELON MUSK: Dual-Use-Technologiearchitekt

Codewort: OP. STARSPY

Starlink operativ in NATO-Missionen (Ukraine).
xAI / Neuralink von DARPA überwacht.
X/Twitter wegen sicherheitsrelevanter Änderungen im Fokus von Behörden.
Bestätigt durch: Pentagon, Neuralink-Dokumente, FCC.

3. FACEBOOK/META: Verhaltensmanipulation & Überwachung

Codewort: OP. EMOTION REACTOR

2014: Psychologisches Experiment mit Nutzern ohne Zustimmung.
Parallelen zu LifeLog (DARPA).
Intern tolerierte Desinformation.
Belegt durch: Facebook Papers, Nature, Kongressanhörungen.

4. GOOGLE/ALPHABET: Überwachung & Predictive Tech

Codewort: OP. PREDPOL PRIME

Google Earth entstand aus CIA-geförderter Firma.
DeepMind für militärische Simulationen.
Project Maven: Massenkündigungen bei Google.
Quellen: The Intercept, Wired, Whistleblower.

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON: Zivil-militärische Datenkontrolle

Codewort: OP. BLACK SPHERE

Palantir für ICE, Polizei, Militär.
Amazon stellt KI & CIA-Cloud bereit.
Quellen: ACLU, DHS-Verträge, SEC.

6. OPENAI: Der Algorithmische Kalte Krieg

Codewort: OP. LUCID FRAME

OpenAI = Zentrum geopolitischer KI-Wettkampf.
DARPA-Interesse an LLMs für Kriegsführung.
EU AI Act beobachtet Entwicklungen.
Quellen: EU-Gesetzgebung, US-Militärprojekte.

⚠️ KLASSIFIZIERTE ERKENNTNISSE

Globale Kontrolle: Tech = Schattenarm der Geheimdienste.
Denkkontrolle durch Algorithmen.
Zivil-militärische Fusion auf Maximalniveau.

✊ SCHLUSSWORT

Du bist nicht Nutzer – du bist Payload.
Der digitale Krieg ist leise – aber real.
Dieses Dossier ist COSMIC BLACK. Keine Weitergabe.

✌️VERSION FRANÇAISE✌️

🔴 ULTRA SECRET – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPÉRATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

Liaisons occultes entre services de renseignement, la Silicon Valley et la guerre cognitive globale

🗓️ Déclassifié le : 22 mai 2025
Source : Rapports multi-agences, ODNI, NSA, auditions parlementaires
NIVEAU : ROUGE OMEGA // COSMIC BLACK // OTAN SEULEMENT

☣️ SUJET : Guerre Cognitive Intégrée & Domination Numérique

Cibles : CIA, Elon Musk (X, Starlink, xAI), Facebook (Meta), Google (Alphabet), Palantir, Amazon, OpenAI

1. CIA & Silicon Valley

Nom de code : OP. MINERVA CHAMBER

La CIA crée In-Q-Tel pour financer des startups.
Investissements : Palantir, Keyhole Inc., Recorded Future.
Cloud de la CIA hébergé par AWS.
Sources : Portefeuille In-Q-Tel, dossiers publics.

2. ELON MUSK : Le Stratège Dual Usage

Nom de code : OP. STARSPY

Starlink utilisé par l’armée ukrainienne.
xAI / Neuralink sous surveillance DARPA.
Rachat de Twitter (X) provoque alertes sécurité.
Sources : Pentagon, Neuralink, FCC.

3. FACEBOOK : Manipulation Psychologique

Nom de code : OP. EMOTION REACTOR

2014 : Expérience émotionnelle secrète.
Lien fort avec LifeLog de la DARPA.
Meta tolère manipulation algorithmique.
Sources : Facebook Papers, Nature.

4. GOOGLE : Domination Algorithmique

Nom de code : OP. PREDPOL PRIME

Google Earth = CIA.
DeepMind simule des scénarios militaires.
Project Maven : conflits éthiques internes.
Sources : Intercept, Wired.

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON : Infrastructure de Surveillance

Nom de code : OP. BLACK SPHERE

Palantir outil de guerre hybride & ICE.
Amazon = cloud de la CIA + IA policière.
Sources : ACLU, documents officiels.

6. OPENAI : La Guerre Algorithmiques

Nom de code : OP. LUCID FRAME

OpenAI = arme géopolitique.
LLM + Wargaming = danger militaire.
UE et USA surveillent.
Sources : Législation, rapports Défense.

⚠️ CONCLUSIONS CLASSIFIÉES

Fusion tech–renseignement : complète.
Guerre cognitive via IA.
Silicon Valley = bras armé de l’ombre.

✊ AVERTISSEMENT FINAL

Vous n’êtes pas l’utilisateur – vous êtes le produit.
La guerre digitale est silencieuse – mais active.
Ce dossier est COSMIC BLACK. Diffusion interdite.

Here is the full Call to Action (CTA) section, styled to match your earlier “Above Top Secret” post, tailored specifically for this Patreon bonus dossier on In-Q-Tel, CIA Langley, and Christopher Darby:

✅ ACTION DIRECTIVE – FOR COSMIC BLACK PATRONS ONLY

You’ve now seen inside the hidden nexus of Langley and Silicon Valley.
You’ve read the files the public never sees.
Now it’s your move.

Support the Mission

Your patronage keeps these disclosures flowing. Without you, they stay buried in classified vaults.
Every tier strengthens our access to black-level archives and suppressed intel.

Spread the Signal

Share this post (public-friendly version) on Twitter, Mastodon, Telegram, and darknet drops.
Use the hashtag: #COSMICBLACKINTEL

Report Anomalies

Got tips? Screenshots? Whistleblowings?
Send encrypted intel via:
berndpulch.org

TAG THE HIDDEN INFOSPHERE

#CIA #InQTel #Langley #ChristopherDarby #BlackBudget #PatriotActSiliconValley #GhostVC #TotalSurveillance #DARPA #MetaDataOps #CosmicBlackIntel #BerndPulchLeaks #AboveTopSecret

Certainly. Here are the Call-To-Action (CTA) sections in German and French, without the ProtonMail address, formatted for standalone use:

✅ HANDLUNGSBEFEHL – NUR FÜR COSMIC BLACK SUPPORTER (Deutsch)

Du hast Einblick in das Silicon-Valley–Langley-Konglomerat erhalten.
Jetzt liegt es an dir.

Unterstütze die Mission

Nur durch dich bleiben diese Leaks sichtbar.
Jedes Support-Level stärkt den Zugriff auf die Schwarzakten.

Signal verbreiten

Veröffentliche die öffentliche Version auf Twitter, Mastodon, Telegram & Co.
Nutze den Hashtag: #COSMICBLACKINTEL

Melde Anomalien

Du hast Hinweise, Material, Screenshots?
Nutze das Dead Drop-Portal auf berndpulch.org

✅ DIRECTIVE POUR LES PARRAINS COSMIC BLACK (Français)

Vous avez franchi le voile.
Le pouvoir est désormais entre vos mains.

Soutenez la mission

Chaque soutien permet l’accès à des données noires.
Sans vous, le silence l’emporte.

Diffusez l’information

Partagez la version publique sur Twitter, Mastodon, Telegram & Co.
Utilisez le hashtag : #COSMICBLACKINTEL

Signalez toute anomalie

Vous avez des documents, des captures, des données sensibles ?
Utilisez le portail Dead Drop sur berndpulch.org

🔒 OFFICIAL SOURCES
Primary Domain: berndpulch.org
Mirror: googlefirst.org
Archives: Rumble Video • WordPress

🌟 EXCLUSIVE ACCESS
Support via donations to unlock classified briefings. Full disclosure available to patrons.
Donation Portal

📜 CREDENTIALS

💳 CRYPTO SUPPORT
BTC/ETH/BNB:
0xdaa3b887...d616bb
Multi-Chain (BSC/ETH/Polygon):
0x271588b5...7AC7f
XMR: 41yKiG6...Coh
Full addresses via Donations Page

May truth prevail under divine protection.

✌CISA/NSA: Securing Data in the Cloud – Original Document✌

Read all at

https://t.me/ABOVETOPSECRETXXL/40136

SUPPORT US AND Become a Patron! –

GET EXCLUSIVE GIFTS – TOP SECRET DOCUMENTS AND EXCLUSIVE EBOOKS

BY USING THE LINK BELOW

https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=54250700

(Paypal, Apple Pay, Venmo, Visa, Master Card, Discover, JCB, Diners Club, 3DS)

❌©BERNDPULCH.ORG – ABOVE TOP SECRET ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS – THE ONLY MEDIA WITH LICENSE TO SPY – websites: https://www.berndpulch.org
https://googlefirst.org

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR COMMON CAUSE AND HELP ME TO STAY ALIVE.

https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=54250700

https://www.patreon.com/berndpulch?utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator

https://www.buymeacoffee.com/berndpulch

CRYPTO WALLET for ShapeShift Wallet, KeepKey, Metamask, Portis, XDefi Wallet, TallyHo, Keplr and Wallet connect

0x271588b52701Ae34dA9D4B31716Df2669237AC7f

CRYPTO WALLET for Binance Smart Chain-, Ethereum-, Polygon-Networks

bmp

0xd3cce3e8e214f1979423032e5a8c57ed137c518b

for all crypto coins like

BITCOIN

ETHEREUM

TETHER

MATIC

USD COIN

BNB

WALL STREET MEMES

SHIBA INU

Follow the ONLY MEDIA with the LICENSE TO SPY ✌️@abovetopsecretxxl

To be absolutely anonymous please use Monero

Scan this code to send Monero to 41yKiG6eGbQiDxFRTKNepSiqaGaUV5VQWePHL5KYuzrxBWswyc5dtxZ43sk1SFWxDB4XrsDwVQBd3ZPNJRNdUCou3j22Coh.

True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you kindly to give back.

🙏God Bless You!🙏

Support also our friends please

https://www.givesendgo.com/pedowatcher

✌️Top Secret: NSA Mobile Device Best Practices – Original Document

SUPPORT US AND Become a Patron! –

GET EXCLUSIVE GIFTS – TOP SECRET DOCUMENTS AND EXCLUSIVE EBOOKS

BY USING THE LINK BELOW

https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=54250700

(Paypal, Apple Pay, Venmo, Visa, Master Card, Discover, JCB, Diners Club, 3DS)

❌©BERNDPULCH.ORG – ABOVE TOP SECRET ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS – THE ONLY MEDIA WITH LICENSE TO SPY – websites: https://www.berndpulch.org
https://googlefirst.org

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR COMMON CAUSE AND HELP ME TO STAY ALIVE.

https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=54250700

https://www.patreon.com/berndpulch?utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator

https://www.buymeacoffee.com/berndpulch

CRYPTO WALLET for ShapeShift Wallet, KeepKey, Metamask, Portis, XDefi Wallet, TallyHo, Keplr and Wallet connect

0x271588b52701Ae34dA9D4B31716Df2669237AC7f

CRYPTO WALLET for Binance Smart Chain-, Ethereum-, Polygon-Networks

bmp

0xd3cce3e8e214f1979423032e5a8c57ed137c518b

for all crypto coins like

BITCOIN

ETHEREUM

TETHER

MATIC

USD COIN

BNB

WALL STREET MEMES

SHIBA INU

Follow the ONLY MEDIA with the LICENSE TO SPY ✌️@abovetopsecretxxl

To be absolutely anonymous please use Monero

Scan this code to send Monero to 41yKiG6eGbQiDxFRTKNepSiqaGaUV5VQWePHL5KYuzrxBWswyc5dtxZ43sk1SFWxDB4XrsDwVQBd3ZPNJRNdUCou3j22Coh.

True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you kindly to give back.

🙏God Bless You!🙏

Support also our friends please

https://www.givesendgo.com/pedowatcher

NSA Top Secret Document about Mumbai Attacks✌️@abovetopsecretxxl

NSA Mumbai

DONATION OPTIONS

Revealed – Agadez, Niger, Drone Base Construction, 2017-2020

Become a Patron!
True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back

10/24/2019 [Image]

[Image]

10/22/2019 [Image]

[Image]

9/30/2019

[Image]

9/19/2019

[Image]

8/17/2019

[Image]

8/03/2019

[Image]

6/27/2019

[Image]

4/02/2019

[Image]

2/03/2019

[Image]

12/08/2018 [Image]

[Image]

5/01/2018

[Image]

11/30/2017 [Image]

[Image]

4/16/2017

[Image]

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Unvealed – Records Related to Former NSA Director Keith Alexander’s Attendance of Bilderberg Meetings in 2008, 2009, 2011

Become a Patron!
True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.

The following set of documents was obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request made to the National Security Agency for “records relating to NSA Director Gen. Keith B. Alexander’s attendance of the Bilderberg Meetings held in 2008 in Chantilly Virginia; in 2009 in Vouliagmeni, Greece; and in 2011 in St. Moritz, Switzerland.” The request took the NSA 5 years and 13 days to fulfill.

Continue reading →

Anderson Cooper about the notorious Russian Agents and their US Election Involvement

Become a Patron!
True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Kellyanne Conway and CNN’s Anderson Cooper clashed in an interview over CNN’s reporting of the classified documents presented to President Obama and President-elect Trump including allegations that Russian operatives claim to have compromising personal and financial information about Trump.

Russian Agents Of Shield,Russian Agents Killed,Russian Agents In The Us,Russian Agents Dying,Russian Agents Voted For Trump,Russian Agents Behind Yahoo,Russian Agents Of Influence,Russian Agents Indicted,Russian Agents Trump,Russian Agents Yahoo Hack,Russian Agents Arrested,Russian Agents Are Behind Yahoo Breach,Russian Agents In America,Russian Travel Agents Association,Russian Sleeper Agents In America,Russian Kgb Agents In America,Russian Travel Agents In Australia,Russian Visa Agents In Australia,Russian Agents Behind Yahoo,Russian Agents Behind,Russian Basketball Agents,Russian Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Agents Executed By Isis,Russian Agents Killed By Is,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Agents In Britain,Russian Visa Agents In Bangalore,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Chemical Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents Cold War,Russian Estate Agents Cyprus,Russian Sleeper Agents Caught,Russian Property Agents Cyprus,Russian Real Estate Agents Chicago,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Visa Agents In Chennai,Child Russian Agents,Russian Agents Dying,Russian Agents Dead,Russian Double Agents,Russian Double Agents In The Cold War,Russian Double Agents Executed,Russian Visa Agents Delhi,Russian Travel Agents Directory,Russian Real Estate Agents Dubai,Russian Visa Agents In Dubai,Russian Travel Agents In Dubai,Russian Agents Executed,Russian Agents Executed By Isis,Russian Estate Agents,Russian Estate Agents London,Russian Estate Agents In Cyprus,Russian Estate Agents In Spain,Russian Education Agents,Russian Estate Agents In Paphos,Russian Estate Agents In Limassol,Russian Estate Agents Tenerife,Russian Foreign Agents Law,Russian Football Agents,Russian Fsb Agents,Russian Free Agents,Russian Free Agents Hockey,Russian Fifa Agents,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Fsb Agents Executed,Russian Free Agents Nhl,Russian Federal Agents,Russian Gru Agents,Russian Real Estate Agents Greece,Russian Hockey Agents,Russian Hunting Agents,Russian Free Agents Hockey,Russian Holiday Agents,Russian Agents In The Us,Russian Agents Indicted,Russian Agents In America,Russian Agents In The White House,Russian Agents In Uk,Russian Agents Isis,Russian Agents In Ukraine,Russian Agents In Europe,Russian Agents In Syria,Russian Agents In Romania,Russian Agents Killed,Russian Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Kgb Agents In America,Russian Kgb Agents,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Famous Russian Kgb Agents,Russian Visa Agents In Kolkata,Russian Sleeper Agents Movie,Russian Estate Agents Marbella,Russian Travel Agents Melbourne,Russian Real Estate Agents Miami,Russian Visa Agents In Mumbai,Russian Nerve Agents,Russian Free Agents Nhl,Russian Real Estate Agents New York,Russian Agents Of Shield,Russian Agents Of Influence,Russian Travel Agents Outbound,Russian Property Agents,Russian Property Agents London,Russian Property Agents Cyprus,Russian Port Agents,Russian Patent Agents,Russian Agents In Poland,Russian Visa Agents In Pakistan,Russian Estate Agents In Paphos,Russian Estate Agents Selling Property In Spain,Russian Agents In Romania,Russian Sleeper Agents Real,Russian Inteligence Agents Face Risk Of Disclosure,Russian Agents Shot,Russian Agents Series,Russian Sleeper Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents 2010,Russian Sleeper Agents 2014,Russian Secret Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents Tv Series,Russian Secret Agents Arrested In Us,Russian Sleeper Agents 1980s,Russian Special Agents,Russian Agents Trump,Russian Travel Agents,Russian Travel Agents List,Russian Travel Agents Association,Russian Travel Agents Uk,Russian Travel Agents In Dubai,Russian Tour Agents,Russian Travel Agents In Australia,Russian Travel Agents Melbourne,Russian Travel Agents In San Francisco,Russian Undercover Agents,Russian Agents In Us,Russian Agents In Uk,Russian Agents In Ukraine,Russian Travel Agents Uk,Russian Estate Agents In Uk,Russian Agents Voted For Trump,Russian Visa Agents In Delhi,Russian Visa Agents In Mumbai,Russian Visa Agents In Pakistan,Russian Visa Agents In Chennai,Russian Visa Agents In Dubai,Russian Visa Agents,Russian Visa Agents In Islamabad,Russian Visa Agents In India,Russian Visa Agents In Lahore,Russian Agents Were Behind Yahoo Hack,Russian Sleeper Agents Wiki,Russian Sleeper Agents Cold War,Russian Agents Yahoo Hack,Russian Agents Yahoo,Russian Agents Yahoo Breach,

Cryptome unveils Snowden Documents

Become a Patron!
True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.

Donate for the Cryptome archive of files from June 1996 to the present

10 February 2016. Add 99 pages to Boing Boing (released 2 February 2016). Tally now *6,318 pages of The Guardian first reported 58,000 files; caveat: Janine Gibson, The Guardian NY, said on 30 January 2014 “much more than 58,000 files in first part, two more parts” (no numbers) (tally about ~10.6%). DoD claims 1,700,000 files (~.04% of that released). ACLU lists 525 pages released by the press. However, if as The Washington Post reported, a minimum of 250,000 pages are in the Snowden files, then less than 1% have been released. Note Greenwald claim on 13 September 2014 of having “hundreds of thousands” of documents. At Snowden current rate it will take 20-620 years to free all documents.

6 February 2016. (±) False Tallies-the Prisoner’s Dilemma? https://vimeo.com/145453201

2 February 2016. Add 14 pages to The Intercept.

23 December 2015. Add 7 pages to The Intercept

20 November 2015. Add 5 pages to Telesurtv and The Intercept.

28 September 2015. Add 21 pages to The Intercept.

24 September 2015. Add 283 pages to The Intercept.

15 August 2015. Add 74 pages to New York Times-Propublica.

11 August 2015. Add 29 pages to The Intercept.

3 August 2015. Add 10 pages to The Intercept.

16 July 2015. Add 8 pages to The Intercept.

1 July 2015. Add 1,240 pages to The Intercept.

26 June 2015. Add 13 pages to The Intercept.

22 June 2015. Add 250 pages to The Intercept.

13 June 2015. Italian journalist provides correspondence with USG on Snowden documents:

2015-1504.pdf offsite Stefania Maurizi-NSA Snowden Correspondence      June 13, 2015
2015-1503.pdf offsite Stefania Maurizi-DoJ Snowden Correspondence      June 13, 2015
2015-1502.pdf offsite Stefania Maurizi-State Snowden Correspondence    June 13, 2015

12 June 2015. Paul and FVEYDOCS tweet:

https://fveydocs.org/IC off the Record:

https://nsa.gov1.info/dni/

12 June 2015. Aeris tweets:

https://nsa.imirhil.fr/OCRized/indexed/full-text-searchable PDF.

12 June 2015. Christopher Parsons writes:

Saw your tweet re: sources for Snowden docs. I’ve compiled all the relevant Canadian documents, along with summary information of the documents’contents along with indexing information, here:https://www.christopher-parsons.com/writings/cse-summaries/

In the coming months I’m hoping to have equivalent summaries for Australia and New Zealand (and will then be moving on to do similar summary work for US- and UK-based documents).

12 June 2015. Snowden documents compilations (plus this one):

https://search.edwardsnowden.com/
https://edwardsnowden.com/revelations/
http://cjfe.org/snowden
https://github.com/nsa-observer/documents/tree/master/files/pdf
https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-search
http://freesnowden.is/category/revealed-documents/index.html
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/11/nsa-spying-primary-sources
https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-released-public-june-2013
http://leaksource.wordpress.com/

If all documents are free somewhere please send pointer to: cryptome[at]earthlink.net

12 June 2015. Add 4 pages to The Intercept.

4 June 2015. Add 91 pages to The New York Times.

28 May 2015. Add 23 pages to The Intercept.

22 May 2015. Add 26 pages to CBC (with The Intercept).

21 May 2015. Edward Snowden was quoted in Forbes on May 10, 2015:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/runasandvik/2015/05/10/what-edward-snowden-said-at-the-nordic-media-festival/2/

“What I did was that I worked in partnership with the journalists who received the material. As a condition of receiving the material they agreed, prior to publication, to run these stories by the government. Not for the government to censor them, but for the government to be able to look at these and go “look, this isn’t going to get anybody killed, this isn’t going to put a human agent behind enemy lines at risk” or something like that. “This isn’t going to make Al Qaeda be able to bomb buildings.” And I think the value of this model has been proven to be quite effective.”

This indicates all stories about document releases have been “run-by governments prior to publication.” Cryptome has filed an FOIA request to NSA for records of these “run-bys.”

https://cryptome.org/2015/05/snowden-media-usg-contacts-4.pdf

21 May 2015. Add 10 pages to The Intercept.

19 May 2015. Add 19 pages to The Intercept.

18 May 2015. Add 6 pages to The Intercept.

8 May 2015. Add 40 pages to The Intercept.

5 May 2015. Add 46 pages to The Intercept.

2 April 2015. Add 7 pages to The Intercept.

30 March 2015. Snowden documents archive by The Courage Foundation:

https://edwardsnowden.com/revelations/

24 March 2015. Add 152 pages to CBC News.

14 March 2015. Add 2 pages to New Zealand Herald.

10 March 2015. Add 12 pages to The Intercept. Add 8 pages to New Zealand Herald.

8 March 2015. Add 35 pages to New Zealand Star Times.

6 March 2015. Add 4 pages to New Zealand Herald.

5 March 2015. Snowden Archive, searchable: http://cjfe.org/snowden

5 March 2015. Add 6 pages to New Zealand Herald.

19 February 2015. Add 32 pages to The Intercept.

10 February 2015. Add 2 pages to The Intercept.

5 February 2015. Add 3 pages to The Intercept.

4 February 2015. Add 5 pages to The Intercept.

30 January 2015. Compilation of Snowden documents:

https://github.com/nsa-observer/documents/tree/master/files/pdf

[Repost] 4 April 2014. ACLU offers NSA documents search: https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-search

Also:

http://freesnowden.is/category/revealed-documents/index.html

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/11/nsa-spying-primary-sources

https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-released-public-june-2013

http://leaksource.wordpress.com/

If more lists please send: cryptome[at]earthlink.net

28 January 2015. Add 21 pages to CBC News.

26 January 2015. Add Citizenfour Snowden Documentary High-Definition, with innumerable images, by Cryptome.

25 January 2015. Add Citizenfour Snowden Documentary by Cryptome, with innumerable images, some 87 extracted by Paul Dietrich in following entry.

22 January 2015. Add 87 pages to Paul Dietrich (via Citizenfour).

17 January 2015. Add 199 pages to Der Spiegel.

28 December 2014. Add 666 pages to Der Spiegel.

22 December 2014. Add 1 page to New York Times.

13 December 2014. Add 67 pages to The Intercept.

4 December 2014. Add 63 pages to The Intercept.

25 November 2014. Add 72 pages to Süddeutsche Zeitung.

6 November 2014. At current rate of release it will take 31 to 908 years for full disclosure.

10 October 2014. Add 69 pages to The Intercept.

17 September 2014. Add 2 pages to The Intercept.

14 September 2014. Add 68 pages to Der Spiegel.

13 September 2014. In video Glenn Greenwald claims to have “hundreds of thousands” of documents (at 9:06 min)

http://www.3news.co.nz/tvshows/thenation/interview-glenn-greenwald-2014091311?ref=video

Audio excerpt: http://youtu.be/xnfIp38AAhM

5 September 2014. Add 32 pages to The Intercept.

31 August 2014. Add 34 pages to Der Spiegel.

25 August 2014. Add 55 pages to The Intercept.

16 August 2014. Add 26 pages to Heise.

12 August 2014. Add 6 pages to The Intercept.

5 August 2014. Add 12 pages to The Intercept.

4 August 2014. Add 23 pages to The Intercept.

25 July 2014. Add 4 pages to The Intercept.

14 July 2014. Add 8 pages to The Intercept.

14 July 2014. “I’m as mad as hell and I’m not going to take this anymore!”

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_%28film%29

Cryptome has sent a demand for accounting and public release specifics to holders of the Snowden documents: New York Times, Washington Post, The Guardian, Barton Gellman, Laura Poitrias, Glenn Greenwald, ACLU, EFF and John and Jane Does, US Citizens:

https://cryptome.org/2014/07/snowden-documents-demand-14-0714.pdf

11 July 2014. See related essay, Open the Snowden Files, Krystian Woznicki, 11July 2014:

English: http://berlinergazette.de/wp-content/uploads/Open-the-Snowden-Files_KW_E.pdf
German: http://berlinergazette.de/open-the-snowden-files/

11 July 2014. @PaulMD notes this claim in the Washington Post, 11 July 2014:

We did not have an official NSA list of targets. We had to find them in the pile ourselves. Soltani, an independent researcher, did most of the heavy lifting on that. Because the information was not laid out in rows and columns, the way it might be in a spreadsheet, Soltani wrote computer code to extract what we were looking for from something like a quarter-million pages of unstructured text.

If a minimum of 250,000 pages are in the Snowden files, then less than 1% have been released.

9 July 2014. Add 8 pages to The Intercept.

9 July 2014. Add 1 page to Washington Post.

23 June 2014. Add 9 pages to Der Spiegel.

22 June 2014. Add 41 pages to Information-The Intercept.

Revised. This is included in entry above. 18 June 2014. Add 20 pages to The Intercept.

18 June 2014. Add 200 pages to Der Spiegel.

16 June 2014. Add 4 pages to Der Spiegel.

1 June 2014. Add 4 pages to New York Times.

23 May 2014. Cryptome placed online No Place to Hide, 310 pages, to compensate for failure to release Snowden documents:

https://cryptome.org/2014/05/npth-freed.htm

https://cryptome.org/2014/05/npth.7z (27MB)

19 May 2014. The Intercept released 12 pages.

13 May 2014. Glenn Greenwald released 107 pages, some new, some previously published, some full pages, some page fragments.

http://hbpub.vo.llnwd.net/o16/video/olmk/holt/greenwald/NoPlaceToHide-Documents-Uncompressed.pdf

5 May 2014. Related tally of redactions of Snowden releases:

https://cryptome.org/2014/05/snowden-redactions.htm

30 April 2014. Add 19 pages to The Intercept.

30 April 2014. Add 2 pages to Dagbladet belatedly.

5 April 2014. Add 21 pages to The Intercept.

4 April 2014. ACLU offers NSA documents search: https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-search

Also:

http://freesnowden.is/category/revealed-documents/index.html

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/11/nsa-spying-primary-sources

https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-released-public-june-2013

http://leaksource.wordpress.com/

If more lists please send: cryptome[at]earthlink.net

2 April 2014.

29 March 2014. Add 1 page to Der Spiegel.

22 March 2014. Add 3 pages to Der Spiegel.

22 March 2014. Add 2 pages to New York Times.

21 March 2014. Add 7 pages to Le Monde.

20 March 2014. Add 6 pages to The Intercept.

18 March 2014. Add 4 pages to Washington Post.

13 March 2014. Add 1 page to The Intercept.

12 March 2014. Add 35 pages to The Intercept.

12 March 2014. Add 62 pages to New York Times. Add 2 pages to NRC Handelsblad.

7 March 2014. Add 8 pages to The Intercept.

27 February 2014. Add 3 pages to Guardian.

25 February 2014. Add 11 pages to NBC News.

24 February 2014. Add 4 pages to The Intercept.

24 February 2014. Add *50 pages to The Intercept (7 pages are duplicates of GCHQ Psychology).

18 February 2014. Add *45 pages to The Intercept (37 pages are duplicates of release by NBC News).

Note: Between 10-17 February 2014, The Intercept disclosed fragments of Snowden pages and the New York Times referenced some but as far as known did not release them in full. If available please send link.

10 February 2014. Add 1 page to NRC Handelsblad (via Electrospaces.blogspot.com).

7 February 2014. Add 15 pages NBC News.

5 February 2014. Add 14 pages NBC News.

31 January 2014. Add 27 pages to CBC News.

27 January 2014. Add 47 pages to NBC News.

27 January 2014. Add 18 pages to Anonymous via New York Times.

16 January 2014. Add 8 pages to The Guardian.

* 14 January 2014. Add 21 pages to Information.dk (duplicate).

* 13 January 2014. Add 4 pages to Information.dk (duplicate).

Related Snowden Document and Page Count Assessment:

https://cryptome.org/2014/01/snowden-count.htm

* 5 January 2014. Add 16 pages to Der Spiegel (30 December 2013. No source given for NSA docs). Tally now *962 pages (~1.7%) of reported 58,000. NSA head claims 200,000 (~.50% of that released).

4 January 2014. The source was not identified for *133 pages published by Der Spiegel and Jacob Appelbaum in late December 2013. They are included here but have not been confirmed as provided by Edward Snowden. Thanks to post by Techdirt.

Glenn Greenwald tweeted:

Glenn Greenwald @ggreenwald, 8:05 AM – 29 Dec 13@Cryptomeorg @ioerror I had no involvement in that Spiegel article, ask them – and they don’t say those are Snowden docs.

Matt Blaze tweeted, 11:24 AM – 2 Jan 14

matt blaze @mattblazeIf there are other sources besides Snowden, I hope journalists getting docs are careful to authenticate them (& disclose uncertainty).

3 January 2014. Add 13 pages to Washington Post.

3 January 2014. See also EFF, ACLU and LeakSource accounts:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/11/nsa-spying-primary-sources

https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-released-public-june-2013

http://leaksource.wordpress.com/

2 January 2014. Add 1 page to Washington Post published 10 July 2013.

* 31 December 2013. Add 16 pages to Der Spiegel.

* 30 December 2013. Add 50 pages of NSA ANT Catalog by Jacob Appelbaum (no source given for NSA docs).

* 30 December 2013. Add 21 pages from 30C3 video by Jacob Appelbaum (no source given for NSA docs).

* 30 December 2013. Add 42 pages (8 duplicates) to Der Spiegel (no source given for NSA docs).

* 29 December 2013. Add 4 pages to Der Spiegel (no source given for NSA docs).

24 December 2013. Add 2 pages to Washington Post.

23 December 2013

http://www.adn.com/2013/12/22/3243451/pincus-snowden-still-has-a-road.html

We’ve yet to see the full impact of former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden’s unauthorized downloading of highly classified intelligence documents.

Among the roughly 1.7 million documents he walked away with — the vast majority of which have not been made public — are highly sensitive, specific intelligence reports, as well as current and historic requirements the White House has given the agency to guide its collection activities, according to a senior government official with knowledge of the situation.

The latter category involves about 2,000 unique taskings that can run to 20 pages each and give reasons for selective targeting to NSA collectors and analysts. These orders alone may run 31,500 pages.

13 December 2013. Add 26 pages to Trojkan (SVT). Tally now 797 pages (~1.4%) of reported 58,000. NSA head claims 200,000 (~.40% of that released). Australia press reports “up to 20,000 Aussie files.”

Rate of release over 6 months, 132.8 pages per month, equals 436 months to release 58,000, or 36.3 years. Thus the period of release has decreased in the past month from 42 years.

12 December 2013. Belatedly add 27 pages to Guardian and 18 pages to Washington Post.

21 November 2013. See also EFF and ACLU accounts:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/11/nsa-spying-primary-sources

https://www.aclu.org/nsa-documents-released-public-june-2013

Timeline of releases:

[See tabulation below for full timeline.]

5 October 2013

26 Years to Release Snowden Docs by The Guardian

Out of reported 15,000 pages, The Guardian has published 192 pages in fourteen releases over four months, an average of 48 pages per month, or 1.28% of the total. At this rate it will take 26 years for full release.

Number	Date	Title	Pages

	The Guardian		276
	27 February 2014	GCHQ Optic Nerve	3
21	16 January 2014	SMS Text Messages Exploit	8
20	9 December 2013	Spying on Games	2
18	18 November 2013	DSD-3G	6
19	1 November 2013	PRISM, SSO SSO1 Slide SSO2 Slide	13*
18	4 October 2013	Types of IAT Tor	9
17	4 October 2013	Egotistical Giraffe	20*
16	4 October 2013	Tor Stinks	23
15	11 September 2013	NSA-Israel Spy	5
14	5 September 2013	BULLRUN	6*
13	5 September 2013	SIGINT Enabling	3*
12	5 September 2013	NSA classification guide	3
11	31 July 2013	XKeyscore	32
10	27 June 2013	DoJ Memo on NSA	16
9	27 June 2013	Stellar Wind	51
8	21 June 2013	FISA Certification	25
7	20 June 2013	Minimization Exhibit A	9
6	20 June 2013	Minimization Exhibit B	9
5	16 June 2013	GCHQ G-20 Spying	4
4	8 June 2013	Boundless Informant FAQ	3
3	8 June 2013	Boundless Informant Slides	4
2	7 June 2013	PPD-20	18
1	5 June 2013	Verizon	4

	Washington Post		297
	9 July 2014	NSA Emails	1
	18 March 2014	NSA SCALAWAG	2
	18 March 2014	NSA MYSTIC	2
	2 January 2014	Quantum Computer 2	10
	2 January 2014	Quantum Computer	3
	23 December 2013	NSA/CSS Mission	2
	11 December 2013	Excessive Collection	9
	11 December 2013	SCISSORS 2	7
	11 December 2013	SCISSORS 1	4
	11 December 2013	Yahoo-Google Exploit	6
	11 December 2013	Cable Spying Types	7
	11 December 2013	WINDSTOP	1
	11 December 2013	Co-Traveler	24
	11 December 2013	GSM Tracking	2
	11 December 2013	SIGINT Successes	4
	11 December 2013	GHOSTMACHINE	4
	5 December 2013	Target Location	1
	4 December 2013	FASCIA	2
	4 December 2013	CHALKFUN	1
	26 November 2013	Microsoft a Target?	4
	4 November 2013	WINDSTOP, SSO, Yahoo-Google	14
	30 October 2013	MUSCULAR-INCENSOR Google and Yahoo	4
	14 October 2013	SSO Overview	4
	14 October 2013	SSO Slides	7
	14 October 2013	SSO Content Slides	9
	4 October 2013	Tor	49
	4 October 2013	EgotisticalGiraffe	20*
	4 October 2013	GCHQ MULLENIZE	2
	4 October 2013	Roger Dingledine	2
	30 August 2013	Budget	17
	10 July 2013	PRISM Slide	1
	29 June 2013	PRISM	8
	20 June 2013	Warrantless Surveillance	25*
	7 June 2013	PPD-20	18*
	6 June 2013	PRISM	1

	Der Spiegel		* 1,278
	17 January 2015	NSA Prepares for Cyber Battle	199
	28 December 2014	NSA Attacks on VPN, SSL, TLS, SSH, Tor 197MB	666
	14 September 2014	GCHQ STELLAR	26
	14 September 2014	NSA Treasure Map	38
	14 September 2014	NSA Treasure Map New	4
	31 August 2014	NSA GCHQ Spy Turkey	34
	23 June 2014	NSA German SIGADs	9
	18 June 2014	NSA German Spying-2	200
	16 June 2014	NSA German Spying	4
	29 March 2014	NSA Spy Chiefs of State	1
	22 March 2014	NSA SHOTGIANT 2 NSA SHOTGIANT 1	21
	31 December 2013	QFIRE	* 16
	30 December 2013	TAO Introduction	* 16
	30 Deceber 2013	QUANTUM Tasking (8 duplicates of QUANTUMTHEORY)	28*
	30 December 2013	QUANTUMTHEORY	14
	29 December 2013	TAO ANT COTTONMOUTH (images) TAO ANT COTTONMOUTH (DE article)	4
	17 November 2013	ROYAL CONCIERGE (DE)ROYAL CONCIERGE (EN)	2
	29 October 2013	NSA-CIA SCS	3
	27 October 2013	NSA-CIA SCS	2
	20 October 2013	Mexico President	1
	20 September 2013	Belgacom	3
	16 September 2013	SWIFT	3
	9 September 2013	Smartphones	5
	1 September 2013	French Foreign Ministry	0
	31 August 2013	Al Jazeera	0

	O Globo Fantastico		~87
	7 October 2013	CSE Brazil Ministry	7
	8 September 2013	Petrobas	~60
	3 September 2013	Brazil and Mexico	20

	New York Times		216
	15 August 2015	NSA SSO Fairview Stormbrew Blarney (with Propublica)	74
	4 June 2015 4 June 2015	NSA Expands Phone Spying at Borders NSA Expands Phone Spying at Borders 2	90 1
	22 December 2014	NSA Tracks Zarrar Shah	1
	1 June 2014	NSA Identity Spying	4
	22 March 2014	NSA Huawei SHOTGIANT	2
	12 March 2014	NSA Stellarwind Classification NSA FISA FAA Classification AG Dissemination NSA Cryptanalyist FISA Database NSA Spying Timeline	37 18 2 4 1
	9 December 2013	Spying on Games	82*
	23 November 2013	SIGINT Strategy 2012-2016	5
	3 November 2013	SIGINT Mission 2013 SIGINT Mission 2017	22
	28 September 2013	Contact Chaining Social Networks	1
	28 September 2013	SYANPSE	1
	5 September 2013	BULLRUN	4*
	5 September 2013	SIGINT Enabling	3*


	ProPublica		163*
	15 August 2015	NSA SSO Fairview Stormbrew Blarney (with NY Times)	74*
	9 December 2013	Spying on Games	82*
	5 September 2013	BULLRUN	4*
	5 September 2103	SIGINT Enabling	3*

	Le Monde		20
	21 March 2014	CSE SNOWGLOBE	7
	25 October 2013	NSA Hosts FR Spies	4
	22 October 2013	Wanadoo-Alcatel	1
	22 October 2013	Close Access Sigads	2
	22 October 2013	Boundless Informant	2
	22 October 2013	PRISM	11

	Dagbladet		15
	April 2014 December 2013	Norway Assistance	2
	19 November 2013	BOUNDLESSINFORMANT	13

	NRC Handelsblad		7
	12 March 2014	NSA Aids Dutch Anti-Piracy	2
	8 February 2014	MIVD BoundlessInformant Cryptome mirror	1
	30 November 2013	Dutch SIGINT	3
	23 November 2013	SIGINT Cryptologic Platform	1

	Huffington Post		3
	27 November 2013	Muslim Porn Viewing	3

	CBC		214
	22 May 2015	US-UK-CA-AU-NZ Cellphone Spying	26*
	24 March 2015	CSEC Cyber Threats	152
	28 January 2015	CSE LEVITATION-FFU Project	21
	30 January 2014	CSEC IP Profiling	27
	10 December 2013	NSA-CSEC Partnership	1
	10 December 2013	G8-G20 Spying	4*
	2 December 2013	G8-G20 Spying	3
	29 November 2013	G8-G20 Spying	1

	The Globe and Mail		18
	30 November 2013	CSEC Brazil Spying	18*

	SVT (Swedish TV)		2
	5 December 2013	Sweden Spied Russia for NSA	2

	L’Espresso		3
	6 December 2013	NSA Spies Italy	3

	Trojkan (SVT)		29
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA Relationship	1*
	11 December 2013	NSA 5 Eyes Partners	1
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA Agenda	8
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA RU Baltic	1
	11 December 2013	NSA GCHQ Sweden FRA COMINT	1
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Plan	5
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Sources	1
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Tor et al	3
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Slide	1
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA Quantum 1	1
	11 December 2013	GCHQ Sweden FRA Quantum	1
	11 December 2013	NSA Sweden FRA Quantum Accomplishments	2
	9 December 2013	NSA and Sweden Pact	3*

	Jacob Appelbaum		* 71
	30 December 2013	NSA Catalog	* 50
	30 December 2013	NSA Catalog Video Clips	* 21

	Information.dk		63*
	19 June 2014	NSA Partners	41*
	14 January 2014	SSO (duplicate)	7*
	14 January 2014	PRISM (duplicate)	11*
	13 January 2014	5-Eyes Spy G8-G20 (duplicate)	4*

	Anonymous/ New York Times		18
	27 January 2014	NSA Smartphones Analysis	14
	27 January 2014	GCHQ Mobile Theme	4

	NBC News		87
	25 February 2014	GCHQ Cyber Effects	11
	7 February 2014	GCHQ Cyber Attack	15
	5 February 2014	GCHQ Anonymous	14
	27 January 2014	GCHQ Squeaky Dolphin	47

	The Intercept		2,704*
	2 February 2016	UAV Programs	14
	23 December 2015	NSA-GCHQ Juniper	7
	17 November 2015	NSA SCS Venezuela	5
	28 September 2015	NSA Rogue Olympics	21
	24 September 2015	NSA-GCHQ 29 Documents	283
	11 August	NSA SIGINT Philosopher	29
	3 August 2015	NSA ECHELON GCHQ COMSAT	73
	16 July 2015	NSA Manhunting	8
	1 July 2015	NSA XKeyscore and More	1,264
	26 June 2015	NSA on NYT Warrantless Wiretap Story	13
	22 June 2015	GCHQ 11 Filles	250
	12 June 2015	NSA SID Hacker Interview	4
	28 May 2015	NSA SID Today	23
	22 May 2015	US-UK-CA-AU-NZ Cellphone Spying	26*
	21 May 2015	NSA Medical Spying	10
	19 May 2015	NSA SID NATO	19
	18 May 2015	JTAC Attack Methodology	3
	18 May 2015	NCTC Major Terrorism Figures	1
	18 May 2015	Black Budget Bin Laden Raid	2
	8 May 2015	NSA SKYNET	40
	5 May 2015	NSA Black Budget SID RT10 WG Language	46
	2 April 2015	NSA GCHQ JTRIG Argentina-Iran	7
	10 March 2015	NSA Apple DPA Cryptanalysis	12
	19 February 2015	GCHQ PCS Harvesting At Scale	32
	10 February 2015	NSA Iran GCHQ	2
	5 February 2015	DNI NATO Cyber Panel	3
	4 February 2015	GCHQ Lovely Horse et al	5*
	13 December 2014	GCHQ Belgacom Hack	67
	4 December 2014	NSA AURORA GOLD et al	63
	10 October 2014	10 NSA Releases Computer Network Exploitation Declass National Initiative Task Security 2 National Initiative Task Security 1 Exceptionally Controlled Info Compartments Exceptionally Controlled Info Pawleys Exceptionally Controlled Information Sentry Eagle 2 Sentry Eagle 1 Tarex Classification Guide Whipgenie Classification Guide	69
	17 September 2014	NSA Visit by NZ Spy	2
	5 September 2014	Masterspy Quadrennial Report 2009	32
	25 August 2014	NSA ICREACH	55
	12 August 2014	GCHQ Covert Mobile Phones Policy	6
	5 August 2014	NCTC Terrorist Identifies	12
	4 August 2014	US-NSA Pays Israel $500,000	2
	4 August 2014	NSA-Israel Spying Pact 2013	3
	4 August 2014	Israel-US Spying Pact 1999	16
	25 July 2014	NSA Saudi Arabia	4
	14 July 2014	NSA JTRIG Tools-Techniques	8
	9 July 2014	NSA FISA Accounts	8
	19 June 2014	NSA Partners	41*
	19 May 2014	12 Various Pages	12
	30 April 2014	GHOSTMACHINE-ECHOBASE NSA Visit by GCHQ Lobban PRISM with Olympics	14:6+8 4:1+3 1:
	4 April 2014	GCHQ Full Spectrum Cyber NSA 5-Eyes SIGDEV Conference	19 2
	20 March 2014	NSA Hunt Sysadmins	6
	13 March 2014	NSA Third Party	1
	12 March 2014	NSA Hammerchant NSA UK on Mikey and Ibake NSA Turbine and Turmoil NSA Thousands of Implants NSA More Than One Way NSA GCHQ Quantumtheory NSA Selector Types NSA Quantum Insert NSA Analysis of Converged Data NSA Phishing and MTM Attacks NSA Menwith Hill xKeyscore NSA Industry Exploit NSA 5 Eyes Hacking	43 2 1 1 11 1 5 1 3 1 1 1
	7 March 2014	NSA Ask Zelda	8
	24 February 2014	GCHQ Disruption	4
	24 February 2014	GCHQ Online Deception (7 pages duplicates of GCHQ Psychology)	*50
	18 February 2014	GCHQ Psychology37 Duplicates of NBC News	*44
	18 February 2014	NSA-GCHQ Discovery	1

	Glenn Greenwald
	13 May 2014	A variety of documents	107

	Cryptome		310
	26 January 2015	Citizenfour Snowden Documentary High Definition (7-Zip MP4) (3.6GB)	~
	25 January 2015	Citizenfour Snowden Documentary (7-Zipped MP4) (1.2GB)	~
	23 May 2014	No Place to Hide (27MB)	310

	Heise		26
	16 August 2014	NSA GCHQ CSEC HACIENDA	26

	Süddeutsche Zeitung		7
	25 November 2014	Vodafone GCHQ Cables List and Slides	72

	Paul Dietrich @Paulmd199		87
	22 January 2015	87 Citizenfour Screengrabs	87

	New Zealand Herald		20
	14 March 2015	GCSB Targets Solomons	2
	10 March 2015	NSA-New Zealand Relationship	8
	6 March 2015	GCSB XKeyscore 2	4
	5 March 2015	GCSB XKeyscore	6

	New Zealand Star Times		35
	8 March 2015	GCSB XKeyscore 3	35

	Telesurtv
	17 November 2015	NSA SCS Venezuela	5*

	Boing Boing
	2 February 2016	GCHQ Malware	99

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Edward Snowden Wife, Edward Snowden Movie, Edward Snowden Twitter, Edward Snowden Dead, Edward Snowden Quotes, Edward Snowden Interview, Edward Snowden Wiki, Edward Snowden Russia, Edward Snowden Net Worth, Edward Snowden 2017, Edward Snowden Age, Edward Snowden Antarctica, Edward Snowden Articles, Edward Snowden Actor, Edward Snowden And Trump, Edward Snowden And Julian Assange, Edward Snowden And Wikileaks, Edward Snowden Apush, Edward Snowden Ama, Edward Snowden And Lindsay Mills, Edward Snowden Biography, Edward Snowden Book, Edward Snowden Bin Laden, Edward Snowden Booz Allen, Edward Snowden Birthday, Edward Snowden Bbc, Edward Snowden Blog, Edward Snowden Birth Chart, Edward Snowden Bernie Sanders, Edward Snowden Bitcoin, Edward Snowden Cia, Edward Snowden Cnn, Edward Snowden Cast, Edward Snowden Chelsea Manning, Edward Snowden Current News, Edward Snowden Citizen 4, Edward Snowden Conservative, Edward Snowden China, Edward Snowden Chemtrails, Edward Snowden Contact, Edward Snowden Dead, Edward Snowden Documentary, Edward Snowden Definition, Edward Snowden Documentary Netflix, Edward Snowden Doc, Edward Snowden Donald Trump, Edward Snowden Dell, Edward Snowden Documentary Hbo, Edward Snowden Date, Edward Snowden David Hoffman, Edward Snowden Essay, Edward Snowden Email, Edward Snowden Ethics, Edward Snowden Ethics Essay, Edward Snowden Early Life, Edward Snowden Effect, Edward Snowden Ecuador, Edward Snowden Education, Edward Snowden Everything About Donald Trump, Edward Snowden Event, Edward Snowden Facts, Edward Snowden Family, Edward Snowden Film, Edward Snowden First Interview, Edward Snowden Facebook, Edward Snowden Father, Edward Snowden Full Movie, Edward Snowden Flat Earth, Edward Snowden First Tweet, Edward Snowden Fox News, Edward Snowden Guardian, Edward Snowden Glenn Greenwald, Edward Snowden Glasses, Edward Snowden Global Warming, Edward Snowden Gif, Edward Snowden Google, Edward Snowden Girlfriend Movie, Edward Snowden Good, Edward Snowden Grandfather, Edward Snowden Genius, Edward Snowden Hero, Edward Snowden Height, Edward Snowden House, Edward Snowden Hawaii, Edward Snowden High School, Edward Snowden Hong Kong, Edward Snowden History, Edward Snowden Heartbeat, Edward Snowden Haarp, Edward Snowden Hbo, Edward Snowden Interview, Edward Snowden Iq, Edward Snowden Instagram, Edward Snowden Interview 2013, Edward Snowden Imdb, Edward Snowden Interview 2017, Edward Snowden Images, Edward Snowden Interview 2016, Edward Snowden Income, Edward Snowden Iphone, Edward Snowden Job, Edward Snowden Journalist, Edward Snowden Japan, Edward Snowden Julian Assange Bradley Manning, Edward Snowden Java, Edward Snowden Journalism, Edward Snowden Joseph Gordon-levitt, Edward Snowden Julian Assange, Edward Snowden John Oliver Passwords, Edward Snowden Jean Michel Jarre, Edward Snowden Kunia, Edward Snowden Kimdir, Edward Snowden Katie Couric Interview, Edward Snowden Katie Couric, Edward Snowden Kaskus, Edward Snowden Kim, Edward Snowden Kasus, Edward Snowden Kfc, Edward Snowden Kim Jest, Edward Snowden Koenig, Edward Snowden Location, Edward Snowden Lindsay Mills Moscow, Edward Snowden Laptop, Edward Snowden Lindsay Mills, Edward Snowden Living, Edward Snowden Lawyer, Edward Snowden Life, Edward Snowden Latest News, Edward Snowden Latest, Edward Snowden Live Stream, Edward Snowden Movie, Edward Snowden Movie Netflix, Edward Snowden Movie Cast, Edward Snowden Military, Edward Snowden Movie Online, Edward Snowden Memes, Edward Snowden Middlebury College, Edward Snowden Married, Edward Snowden Moscow, Edward Snowden Medical Condition, Edward Snowden Net Worth, Edward Snowden Now, Edward Snowden News, Edward Snowden New York Times, Edward Snowden Netflix, Edward Snowden Natal Chart, Edward Snowden Nobel Prize, Edward Snowden Nsa Salary, Edward Snowden Npr, Edward Snowden Nationality, Edward Snowden On Trump, Edward Snowden Osama Bin Laden, Edward Snowden Obama, Edward Snowden Oscar, Edward Snowden On Movie, Edward Snowden On Twitter, Edward Snowden Openstack, Edward Snowden On Antarctica, Edward Snowden Os, Edward Snowden Original Interview, Edward Snowden Parents, Edward Snowden Political Views, Edward Snowden Privacy Tips, Edward Snowden Political Party, Edward Snowden Patriot Act, Edward Snowden Pictures, Edward Snowden Podcast, Edward Snowden Phone Case, Edward Snowden Poll, Edward Snowden Putin, Edward Snowden Quotes, Edward Snowden Quizlet, Edward Snowden Questions, Edward Snowden Quien Es, Edward Snowden Quote About Privacy, Edward Snowden Quotes Citizenfour, Edward Snowden Quick Facts, Edward Snowden Qualifications, Edward Snowden Russia, Edward Snowden Reddit, Edward Snowden Research Paper, Edward Snowden Real Name, Edward Snowden Residence, Edward Snowden Resume, Edward Snowden Robot, Edward Snowden Recommended Apps, Edward Snowden Reporter, Edward Snowden Russian, Edward Snowden Story, Edward Snowden Salary, Edward Snowden Status, Edward Snowden Signal, Edward Snowden Speech, Edward Snowden Security Tips, Edward Snowden Shirt, Edward Snowden Siblings, Edward Snowden Special Forces, Edward Snowden Still Alive, Edward Snowden Twitter, Edward Snowden Today, Edward Snowden Trump, Edward Snowden Timeline, Edward Snowden Ted Talk, Edward Snowden The Guardian, Edward Snowden Trailer, Edward Snowden The Movie, Edward Snowden T Shirt, Edward Snowden Tor, Edward Snowden Update, Edward Snowden Ufo, Edward Snowden Us Army, Edward Snowden University Of Michigan, Edward Snowden Used Tails, Edward Snowden Umich, Edward Snowden University Of Maryland, Edward Snowden Ufo Wikileaks, Edward Snowden Ufo Video, Edward Snowden Urban Dictionary, Edward Snowden Video, Edward Snowden Vpn, Edward Snowden Vice, Edward Snowden And Julian Assange, Edward Snowden Voice, Edward Snowden And Bradley Manning, Edward Snowden Vault 7, Edward Snowden Visa, Edward Snowden And Wikileaks, Edward Snowden Vanity Fair, Edward Snowden Wife, Edward Snowden Wiki, Edward Snowden Wired, Edward Snowden William And Mary, Edward Snowden Washington Post, Edward Snowden Who Is He, Edward Snowden Website, Edward Snowden Worth, Edward Snowden Wikileak, Edward Snowden Washington Post 2013, Edward Snowden Youtube, Edward Snowden Young, Edward Snowden Yahoo Answers, Edward Snowden Youtube Channel, Edward Snowden Youtube Documentary, Edward Snowden Yokota, Edward Snowden And Lindsay Mills, Edward Snowden Yify, Edward Snowden Zodiac Sign, Edward Snowden Zcash, Edward Snowden Zuckerberg, Edward Snowden Zoho, Edward Snowden Zizek, Edward Snowden Zimbabwe, Edward Snowden Zitate, Edward Snowden Zusammenfassung, Edward Snowden Zivilisation, Edward Snowden Zvi\u017eda\u010d, Cryptome Eyeball, Cryptome Twitter, Cryptome Wikileaks, Cryptome Archive, Cryptome Trump, Cryptome Wikipedia, Cryptome Secret Service, Cryptome Down, Cryptome Payment Technologies, Cryptome Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Cryptome Archive, Cryptome Area 51, Cryptome Air Force One, Cryptome Archive Download, Cryptome Alien, Cryptome Albania, Cryptome Assange, Cryptome Alternatives, Cryptome Pharmaceuticals Australia, Cryptome Mi6 Agents, Cryptome Boston Marathon, Cryptome Benghazi, Cryptome Bitcoin, Cryptome Brazil, Cryptome Cn, Cryptome Cia, Cryptome China, Cryptome Charlie Hebdo, Cryptome Contact, Crypto Code, Cryptome Citizenfour Download, Citizenfour Cryptome Mirror, Cryptome Down, Cryptome Download, Cryptome Drones, Cryptome Definition, Cryptome Deep Web, Define Cryptome, Cryptome Archive Download, Cryptome Full Disclosure, Cryptome Site Down, Cryptome Citizenfour Download, Cryptome Eyeball, Cryptome Edward Snowden, Cryptome Eyeballing Presidential Protection, Cryptome Que Es, Cryptome Fru, Cryptome Fukushima, Cryptome For Sale, Cryptome Facebook, Cryptome Femen, Cryptome Full Disclosure, Cryptome Feed, Cryptome Free List, Cryptome Fukushima Daiichi, Cryptome Rss Feed, Cryptome Gchq, Cryptome Gang Stalking, Giganews Cryptome, Cryptome Microsoft Spy Guide, Cryptome Hacked, Cryptome White House, Cryptome Sandy Hook, Cryptome Jade Helm, Cryptome Ira Members, Cryptome Ira, Cryptome Isis, Cryptome Iraq, Cryptome Ireland, Cryptome Inspire, Cryptome India, Cryptome Interview, Cryptome Israel, Cryptome Improvised Munitions, Cryptome Jade Helm, Cryptome North Korea, Cryptome Like Sites, Cryptome Legal, Cryptome Libya, Cryptome List, Cryptome Le Siecle, Like Cryptome, Cryptome Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Cryptome Mi6, Cryptome Mirror, Cryptome Microsoft, Cryptome Microsoft Spy Guide, Cryptome Mirror Sites, Cryptome Mk Ultra, Cryptome Boston Marathon, Cryptome Ira Members, Cryptome Improvised Munitions, Citizenfour Cryptome Mirror, Cryptome North Korea, Cryptome Nuclear, Cryptome Northern Ireland, Cryptome Nsa, Cryptome-nov 2015, Cryptome Nedir, Cryptome.org Wikipedia, Cryptome Obama Protection, Cryptome.org Down, Cryptome.org Eyeball, Cryptome Org Fukushima, Cryptome.org Parastoo, Cryptome.org Rss, Cryptome.org Femen, Cryptome.org 9\/11, Cryptome.org 911, Cryptome Photos, Cryptome Payment Technologies, Cryptome Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Cryptome Protection, Cryptome Pgp, Cryptome Parastoo, Cryptome Pharmaceuticals Australia, Cryptome Pdf, Cryptome Prism, Cryptome Pictures, Cryptome Que Es, Cryptome Rss, Cryptome Rheinland Pfalz, Cryptome Secret Service, Cryptome Search, Cryptome Snowden, Cryptome Sandy Hook, Cryptome Satellite, Cryptome Similar Sites, Cryptome Saudi, Cryptome Syria, Cryptome Site, Cryptome Stingray, Cryptome Twitter, Cryptome Trump, Cryptome Tempest, Cryptome Tor, Cryptome Tunisia, Crypto Tool, Cryptome Fukushima Tepco, Cryptome Payment Technologies, Similar To Cryptome, Cryptome Turkey, Cryptome Ufo, Cryptome Ukraine, Cryptome Vs Wikileaks, Cryptome Venezuela, Cryptome Videos, Cryptome Wikileaks, Cryptome Wikipedia, Cryptome White House, Cryptome Vs Wikileaks, Cryptome Deep Web, Nsa Jobs, Nsa Director, Nsa Softball, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Careers, Nsa Definition, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Internships, Nsa Acronym, Nsa Address, Nsa Advisor, Nsa Agent, Nsa Alabama, Nsa Annapolis, Nsa Agent Salary, Nsa Arc, Nsa Approved Shredders, Nsa Agreement, Nsa Building, Nsa Bahrain, Nsa Budget, Nsa Bethesda, Nsa Baseball, Nsa Badge, Nsa Benefits, Nsa Building Nyc, Nsa Budget 2016, Nsa Backdoor, Nsa Careers, Nsa Chief, Nsa Colorado, Nsa Crane, Nsa Cyber Security, Nsa Conference, Nsa Csfc, Nsa Cae, Nsa Crypto Challenge, Nsa Css, Nsa Director, Nsa Definition, Nsa Data Center, Nsa Day Of Cyber, Nsa Director Salary, Nsa Data Collection, Nsa Domestic Surveillance, Nsa Datasheet, Nsa Deputy Director, Nsa Datasheet Is Called, Nsa Employment, Nsa Edward Snowden, Nsa Exploits, Nsa Employees, Nsa Email, Nsa Evaluated Products List, Nsa Echelon, Nsa Emblem, Nsa Encryption, Nsa Eternal Blue, Nsa Fastpitch, Nsa Florida Youth, Nsa Fort Meade, Nsa Flynn, Nsa Florida, Nsa Friend, Nsa Facebook, Nsa Fort Gordon, Nsa Foia, Nsa Facts, Nsa Georgia, Nsa Glassdoor, Nsa Government, Nsa Grindr, Nsa Github, Nsa Gift Shop, Nsa Game, Nsa Grants, Nsa Gif, Nsa Guy, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Head, Nsa Hacking Tools, Nsa Hawaii, Nsa Hampton Roads, Nsa Hacked, Nsa History, Nsa Hiring Process, Nsa Hacking Tools Leaked, Nsa Headquarters Address, Nsa Internships, Nsa Industries, Nsa Intelligence Analyst, Nsa Indiana, Nsa Influence 2017, Nsa Iad, Nsa Ias 2017, Nsa India, Nsa Illinois, Nsa Insurance, Nsa Jobs, Nsa Juice Plus, Nsa Job Openings, Nsa Jobs Utah, Nsa Jobs Salary, Nsa Jokes, Nsa Job Requirements, Nsa Jurisdiction, Nsa Jobs In Md, Nsa Japan, Nsa Keywords, Nsa Kunia, Nsa Kc, Nsa Key, Nsa Kentucky, Nsa Kmi, Nsa Kankakee, Nsa Korea, Nsa Kaspersky, Nsa Keith Alexander, Nsa Leaker, Nsa Logo, Nsa Leak, Nsa Locations, Nsa Listening, Nsa Leader, Nsa Login, Nsa Leadership, Nsa Language Analyst, Nsa Leaked Tools, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Meme, Nsa Media, Nsa Meet, Nsa Mid South, Nsa Mike Rogers, Nsa Museum, Nsa Mcmaster, Nsa Maryland, Nsa Mission Statement, Nsa News, Nsa Naples, Nsa Name Generator, Nsa North, Nsa Number, Nsa Norfolk, Nsa Nyc, Nsa Nashville, Nsa Nursing, Nsa New Orleans, Nsa Orlando, Nsa Opm Test, Nsa Online Test, Nsa Offices, Nsa Obama, Nsa Organization, Nsa Operational Interview, Nsa Only, Nsa Org Chart, Nsa Of 1947, Nsa Prism, Nsa Police, Nsa Panama City, Nsa Police Officer, Nsa Phone Number, Nsa Philadelphia, Nsa Pay Scale, Nsa Play, Nsa Polygraph, Nsa Purpose, Nsa Quantum Computer, Nsa Quotes, Nsa Qualifications, Nsa Quantum, Nsa Quizlet, Nsa Questions, Nsa Qualifier, Nsa Quantum Computer Farm, Nsa Quartet, Nsa Quiz, Nsa Rogers, Nsa Requirements, Nsa Rules, Nsa Recruiting, Nsa Relationship, Nsa Rule Book, Nsa Ransomware, Nsa Russia, Nsa Responsibilities, Nsa Reno, Nsa Softball, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Slang, Nsa Salary, Nsa Stands For, Nsa Soccer, Nsa Softball Rules, Nsa Scholarship, Nsa Scandal, Nsa Texas, Nsa Tournaments, Nsa Tools, Nsa Trump, Nsa Tao, Nsa Tools Leaked, Nsa Twitter, Nsa Tinder, Nsa Test, Nsa Training, Nsa Utah, Nsa Urban, Nsa Usa, Nsa Utah Facility, Nsa Unmasking, Nsa Utah Jobs, Nsa Unconstitutional, Nsa Umpire, Nsa Under Obama, Nsa Uniform, Nsa Vs Cia, Nsa Visitor Center, Nsa Virginia, Nsa Vs Fbi, Nsa Vs Cia Vs Fbi, Nsa Virus, Nsa Visitor Control Center, Nsa Vpn, Nsa Vanilla, Nsa Violation Of Privacy, Nsa Wiki, Nsa Whistleblower, Nsa Washington, Nsa Wiretapping, Nsa Website, Nsa Water Filter, Nsa Watchlist, Nsa World Series, Nsa Wikileaks, Nsa Wannacry, Nsa Xkeyscore, Nsa Xbox One, Nsa Xeno World Qualifier, Nsa Xkeyscore Download, Nsa Xcode, Nsa Xbox Live, Nsa Xeno Tournament, Nsa Xkeyscore Presentation, Nsa X, Nsa X Files, Nsa Youtube, Nsa Yogurt, Nsa Young Investigator Grant, Nsa Youth Florida, Nsa Yearly Budget, Nsa Yottabyte, Nsa Youth Program, Nsa Youth, Nsa Yellow Dots, Nsa Yakima, Nsa Zero Day, Nsa Zip Code, Nsa Zeus, Nsa Zimmermann Telegram, Nsa Zimbabwe, Nsa Za, Nsa Zero Day Exploit, Nsa Zyxel, Nsa Zero Division, Nsa Zone Store

Exposed – How German BND Spies Work with NSA

Become a Patron!
True Information is the most valuable resource and we ask you to give back.

This is part III about the German parliamentary committee which investigates NSA spying activities and the cooperation between NSA and the German foreign intelligence service BND.

The hearings of a number of BND employees which are summarized below, provided many interesting details about BND cable and satellite collection and how these data are selected and filtered and how privacy rights are implemented. This was especially of concern for the cooperation between NSA and BND in the Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA).

The witnesses also stated that contrary to the initial press report, under the joint operation Eikonal not a single German communication was passed on to NSA.

These summaries are based upon transcripts of a live blog, kept by volunteers of the German digital civil rights website Netzpolitik.org, who attended the hearings.
The employees of the BND are designated by initials, not of their real names, but of those of the cover names they are using when at work(!).

The room where the hearings of the parliamentary committee take place
(photo: DPA)

20th Meeting, November 6, 2014 (Transcript)

– Hearing of the witness Mr. T. B. (BND, head of the JSA unit from 2003-2007):

In Bad Aibling, the BND has dishes to intercept satellite communications. When satellite links are intercepted, the following things have to be done: first a specific frequency has to be selected, and as one frequency often contains multiple channels, these have to be broken down (de-multiplexed) into single data streams. Based upon metadata it can be decided that certain types of communications are not of interest for BND.

The next step is to separate the various content encodings, like for IP-traffic, telephony, fax, etc. This also needs error correction, which sometimes is a bit more difficult because some communication systems use proprietary methods. This results in data in a readable or audible format (like an e-mail or a phone call), which can be used to prepare an intelligence report. The witness estimates that BND produces around 20 reports a day.

For processing, filtering and selecting commercial computer systems were used, as wel as systems that were custom made by NSA. The Americans were ahead of BND in this, not necessarily better, but often just in doing more, or faster, like in analysing signals.

Compare: the data flow at NSA, according to a presentation
from the NSA’s European Cryptologic Center (ECC)
(Click to enlarge)

Mass surveillance?

The witness stated that there was and is no mass surveillance by BND. Mass surveillance is even more difficult for fiber optic cables than for satellite links. If there would be any mass surveillance for the latter, then this should involve some 300 communications satellites, for which there should be ground stations at at least three places around the world.

There you would need 250 satellite dishes of 10 million euros each to receive the up to 500 frequencies per satellite. For each frequency two modems and converters were needed, and with the necessary processing capacity, this would require a nuclear power plant for electricity.

Mass surveillance on cable traffic could probably only be done with the capacity of the American, Russian and Chinese intelligence agencies combined. For BND, mass surveillance would drown the agency in data. The witness had never witnessed any kind of economical espionage by NSA in Germany. But he had to admit that not everything was talked about.

Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA)

NSA’s Bad Aibling Station was scheduled for closure in 2002, but after 9/11 this was postponed to 2004, and maybe this led to the creation of the JSA. In the Joint SIGINT Activity, NSA and BND cooperated in collecting both satellite and cable communications.

The JSA was located at the Mangfall Barracks in Bad Aibling. In 2002, this military complex still had a compound of the Bundeswehr, where you had to go through to reach the BND section. The Bundeswehr left these barracks by the end of 2002, and NSA went to a new building nicknamed the Tin Can (Blechdose).

The compound had three sections: one for Germans only, one for US persons only and one common section. The collection of data took place in the common section, and the exits were strictly monitored, so NSA had no access to German sources on its own, although there weren’t every day checks on people carrying thumb drives.

BND personnel had no access to NSA databases and vice versa, but both had access to joint databases. NSA had also some contractors working there. JSA was connected to NSANet, just like NSA’s European Security Operations Center (ESOC) near Darmstadt.

Until 2007 only cable traffic from Frankfurt was passed on to JSA, not from other internet cables. Satellite traffic intercepted by the BND antennas in Bad Aibling was probably also transferred to JSA, where it was processed and analysed in the interest of both NSA and BND.

After the Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA) was closed in 2012, the logical path over the physical cables between BND headquarters and Bad Aibling was probably cut off. After 2012, BND continued to cooperate with NSA in the field of satellite interception and operations in Afghanistan.

Google Maps view of the Mangfall Barracks in Bad Aibling, Germany.
The building in the upper left corner could be the BND facility,
and the one with the white roof the NSA’s “Tin Can”.

Protection of German data

BND did everything to prevent that communications of German citizens or corporations were collected and/or passed on to NSA. Initially, 4 out of 5 selectors came from the Americans, the rest were German. The witness did not know the total number of selectors. These selectors were checked before they were fed into the collection system, and what came out was again checked whether it contained German communications.

The selectors from NSA were first checked by the Americans in the Tin Can at the Mangfall Barracks and then passed on to a unit of the technical division (which included lawyers) of BND at its then headquarters in Pullach. A final check was conducted by BND personnel in Bad Aibling. Only about one permille of the selectors were rejected because they were related to Germans or contrary to German interests.

Filtering out German data

This filtering works fine, but experience in Bad Aibling has learned that it is not possible to do this fully automated. Therefore, there was no automatic forwarding to NSA. A 100% accurate filtering was only possible with a final selection by hand. As far as the witness was aware of, not a single German communication was passed on to NSA.

In the press report about operation Eikonal it was said that the filter system could only filter out 95% of German communications, but according to the witness, this was only during the test period. When the system went live, this percentage rose to 99% with a second stage that could filter out even more than 99%. When necessary, a final check was conducted by hand.

Especially e-mail addresses have to be checked by hand, because nowadays it’s much more difficult to attribute such internet communications to specific countries. During the test period, about 3000 communications had to be checked by hand, 300 of which were e-mails. BND didn’t collect data from US citizens or passed these on to NSA, so NSA did not use BND to get data that it wasn’t allowed to collect by itself (Ringtausch).

The witness suggested that Süddeutsche Zeitung (the media that claimed that the BND filters wouldn’t work and German data was forwarded to the NSA) had documents of conversations between BND and NSA, in which maybe BND made “political statements” about the efficiency of the filters.

(This could explain the discrepancy between the press reports and the BND witnesses, who all assured that the filter worked, and with additionally manual checks not a single German data was forwarded to NSA)

The witness clearly stated that German G-10 Act only protects Germans and people living in Germany. The privacy of foreigners living abroad is not protected by German law.

Operations center room in the former BND headquarters in Pullach
(Screenshot from ARD television – Click to enlarge)

– Hearing of Ms. G. L. (BND, head of IT development and operations at JSA from 2007-2008):

This witness is responsible for databases that store data after having been collected and filtered. These databases are at various locations. Currently, between 8.000 and 10.000 pieces of content with some additional information (Meldungen) come in each month, often but not always accompanied by metadata.

Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA)

Each unit of BND’s analysis division (Auswertung) could request intelligence information from the JSA. They could suggest specific selectors to be tasked or articulate what their information needs were. Ultimate goal was to present relevant information for the federal government. BND sees itself as a service provider for customers in the government.

In 2005/2006 the selection process was fully automated. The witness couldn’t remember how many selectors were used in her period at JSA. These numbers were also not registered. NSA was not able to get any German communications before these were thoroughly filtered and checked by BND. An e-mail that was selected, could be forwarded to NSA through a secured gateway. There was only access to local databases, not to those of NSA.

NSA employees working for JSA were not recognizable as such, they just had ID cards for the compound, issued by the security unit that was responsible for access control of the premises. The Tin Can building also housed SUSLAG (Special US Liaison Activity, Germany), which was a separate unit, different from JSA.

Header of a newsletter from the Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA)
(Click for a JSA newsletter (pdf) from 2007)

Operation Eikonal

The witness confirmed that in Frankfurt fiber optic cables were intercepted (operation Eikonal), although without mentioning whether this was at DE-CIX or somewhere else. She wouldn’t answer the question whether BND is still doing this.

The data collected in Frankfurt were first sent to BND headquarters and then to Bad Aibling, where they were filtered by selectors from both NSA and BND. After the cooperation with NSA was ended, the transmission to Bad Aibling was cut off.

Legal issues

The witness was responsible for the implementation of the Federal Intelligence Service Act (BND Gesetz), which governs the activities of this agency. As such, she had the opinion that satellite interception conducted in Bad Aibling also took place under this act, but the Director of BND overruled her, saying this was not the case.

The BND management said: this kind of collection takes place in outer space, and therefore German law doesn’t apply. But apart from that, employees should always apply with law and order. Once data collected from satellite links had been stored in BND databases, they fall under the German Data Protection Act (Bundesdatenschutzgesetz) though.

(In general, most of these witnesses didn’t knew much about topics that are not related to their own duties. They also showed very little interest in the Snowden-revelations. This might be from a common attitude in the intelligence world: the less you know, the less you can (accidently) give away)

– . – . – . – . –

22th Meeting, November 13, 2014 (Transcript)

– Hearing of the witness Mr. W. K. (BND, sub-division manager in the Signals Intelligence division):

The witness stated that BND is definitely not comparable with the former East German Stasi and that BND only collects what is necessary for fulfilling the information need of the federal government.

Today, mainly fiber optic cables are intercepted, but not everything that flows through, only specific data channels are selected, or in case of satellite links: specific frequencies. Asked about the Snowden-revelations, the witness said that he was surprised by how close the Five Eyes partners are cooperating.

Tapping internet cables

There are search profiles and criteria according to which specific data flows are selected in a very focussed way. The first selection is of a route between two places (like from Afghanistan to Pakistan), then a specific fiber optic cable is chosen.

These are human decisions, based upon where a cable is located, by which company it is operated and where it’s most useful to tap it. Picking a specific cable is also discussed with the provider, with some of them this is easier than with others.

Because internet traffic travels over many different routes, picking specific cables, means that a lot of communications cannot be collected. This is taken for granted as BND doesn’t want to collect everything. Sometimes multiple routes are selected for interception, but not always.

According to the witness, BND doesn’t provide foreign intelligence agencies access to cables. No raw data are transferred to foreign agencies, only end reports.

In some cases, internet data have to be converted into a readable format. This sometimes means cracking encryption, consisting either of complex algorithms or proprietary methods. This can be done on the traffic as it flows past, or with data after having been stored in databases.

Filtering

The next step is filtering the data through selectors. This is done by a computer system, for which the data stream may be buffered for a few milliseconds. The amount of data flowing through these filter systems isn’t counted by BND. Filtering by selectors is done as close to the actual tapping point as possible.

The selectors are chosen based upon the information needs and a set of criteria, which in combination prevent that communications of innocent people are touched. The results went to the (then) BND headquarters in Pullach over leased cables. The number of data forwarded to Pullach is not registered, it depends upon the costs of the capacity for transmission.

The constitutionally guaranteed Privacy of Correspondence can have effect on each of these selection stages: for example no cables are chosen that start and end in Germany, and no selectors belonging to Germans are used.

Data of Germans are currently filtered out by a system called DAFIS, which succeeded a BSI-certified filter system that was used since the 1990s. Data from German citizens and German companies (Grundrechtsträgern) are deleted.

After data have been selected, they are pulled out based upon their relevance and finally analysts can use them at a certain moment to write an intelligence report, of which approximately 20 a day are produced.

Operation Eikonal

Regarding the joint NSA-BND operation Eikonal, the witness said that there was no massive scale surveillance of German citizens with data forwarded to NSA. Under Eikonal, which was a one of a kind operation, there was targeted collection from traffic that transited Germany from one foreign country to another.

This was focussed on Afghanistan and anti-terrorism. Selected data were collected and forwarded to NSA. The witness would give more details only behind closed doors, because BND is still using these methods. The internal codename for Eikonal was Karat, but that name wasn’t shared with NSA. There was even a third codename. Eikonal was tested during a few months (early 2006?), during which period no data were shared with NSA.

For Germany, Eikonal was useful because it provided foreign intelligence for protecting German troops and countering terrorism. The NSA provided better technical equipment that BND didn’t had. In return, BND provided NSA with data collected from transit traffic using search profiles about Afghanistan and anti-terrorism. BND was asked to cooperate because NSA isn’t able to do everything themselves.

What was collected under Eikonal was far less than the 500 million metadata a month as shown in the German BOUNDLESSINFORMANT chart. Actual collection only led to a few hundred selected contents (in German: Daten, like phone calls or e-mails) a year, which was a huge disappointment for NSA. Nothing that was worth while came out anymore, contrary to the expectations when the operation was set up.

This, combined with the fact that it proved to be impossible to 100% guarantee that no German data were collected and forwarded, led BND to terminate the program. As a “compensation” for NSA, a joint project in a country outside Europe was planned. In crisis regions, the BND is still cooperating with NSA, which provides “huge benefits” for the Germans, according to the witness.

The witness wouldn’t say anything about whether BND was tapping into the Frankfurt internet exchange DE-CIX, but later on he said that operation Eikonal involved just one telecommunications provider.

(These kind of indications by some of the witnesses eventually led the Committee to conclude that operation Eikonal was actually about tapping one single cable of Deutsche Telekom, instead of the DE-CIX exchange as a whole, as the initial report by Süddeutsche Zeitung said. More about this later)

Things the BND learned from the Eikonal-cooperation were:

1. How the technique worked, which is now used for own operations outside, and collection efforts inside Germany
2. It is not possible to conduct 100% automated filtering. This wouldn’t be done anymore.

Filtering through selectors

For Eikonal, the cable traffic was filtered by using selectors provided by both NSA and BND. A BND unit which included lawyers checked for every selector from the NSA whether it was legal and according to the goals of the cooperation. Besides German interests, also the interests of friendly countries were taken into account. Only a few selectors were rejected, but it wasn’t told to NSA which ones. They were just not entered into the filtering system.

Selectors include not just phone numbers and e-mail addresses, but also MAC addresses, which have no country identifier. Although there may have been up to several hundred thoused selectors, BND was still able to check whether every single one was appropriate, this by using special criteria. Only selectors that can be checked are used.

Besides Eikonal, BND also taps into cables of multiple other communication providers, but this is within the proper legal framework, approved by the G-10 Committee. For this, there is dedicated hardware equipment in the building of the provider, in accordance with the regulations of the federal communications authority (Bundesnetzagentur). This hardware is installed at the point where the cable is tapped.

Screenshot from NSA’s BOUNDLESSINFORMANT tool, showing the number of foreign
metadata that BND collected in crisis regions and shared with NSA
(Click to enlarge)

Telephony metadata

According to the witness, one phone call creates between 30 and 50 metadata, which includes not only time and number but also a lot more technical data. With the given number of users in a crisis zone, this easily adds up to billions of metadata. But not all these have to be collected (erfasst); less than one percent can actually be pulled in. This is no mass surveillance without a reasonable ground (anlasslose Massenüberwachung). The witness assumes that NSA and GCHQ operate in a similar way as the BND.

The over 500 million metadata records from the Germen BOUNDLESSINFORMANT chart were most certainly from Afghanistan, more precisely from satellite communication links between two foreign countries in crisis regions. According to the witness this huge number of metadata for a single month is quite normal.

It could be that these numbers are collected up to today, although he isn’t sure about that. BND isn’t counting every single part of metadata, as NSA is apparently doing and which leads to those huge numbers.

XKeyscore

BND got the XKeyscore program from NSA, which is only used to analyse data that are already collected. BND didn’t had such a tool before. Unlike NSA, which uses Xkeyscore as federated query system, BND uses it as a stand-alone system for analysis. The actual collection systems of BND are antennas and outposts (Aussenstellen).

The witness doesn’t know how many servers BND purchased for XKeyscore. Presently, BND uses XKeyscore only for traffic that is intercepted from satellite links, apparently because the system isn’t (yet) certified for filtering out communications of German citizens. BND got no software programs from NSA for profiling or for decrypting data.

Legality

Personal data are only those data that can be related to specific persons. For German data it is easy to retrieve the identity behind certain metadata, but for foreign metadata this is much more difficult and hence those metadata are not seen as personal data.

The witness said multiple times that he isn’t a lawyer and he therefore had no opinion of his own about the legality of certain decisions. He also didn’t knew whether data collected in foreign countries had been acquired with or without the consent of the provider. He just assumed that the data collection takes place in a legal way. Foreign partner agencies don’t provide BND with data they are not allowed to collect themselves.

– Because of time shortage, the BND employees L. and W. P. couldn’t be heard in this meeting.

> Next time: More hearings of BND employees

UPDATE:
Meanwhile, the following numbers about government eavesdropping operations in 2013 have been made public. These numbers are only about the interception of communcations with at least one-end-German, so traffic with both-ends-foreign are not included:

– The G10 Committee approved 212 eavesdropping operations, most of them were conducted by the domestic security service BfV (up from 157 in 2012). This involved some 350 people, most of them suspected of islam fundamentalism.

– In 26 cases, the domestic security service BfV used an IMSI-catcher to trace or intercept the mobile phone of 29 persons (more as twice as often as in 2012)

– BND is allowed to filter communications by using selectors. If Germans could be involved, it is not allowed to use selectors that identify specific targets (like phone numbers and e-mail adresses), so in that case, only generic search terms (keywords) may be used.

– The official report (pdf) provided the following numbers of approved search terms, of what was filtered out and of what was marked as relevant for foreign intelligence purposes:

Subject	Search terms	Filtered out	Relevant
Terrorism	Ca. 800	Content: 906 Metadata: 639	73
Proliferation	Ca. 11.700	Content: 14.411 Metadata: 1	32
Immigration	Ca. 28	Content: 84 Metadata: 76	13

Links and Sources
– Offical page of the committee: 1. Untersuchungsausschuss (“NSA”)
– Internal NSA presentation: Structure of the BND (pdf)
– Spiegel.de: Spying Together: Germany’s Deep Cooperation with the NSA
– Reports with numbers for 2013:
– Gemäss Terrorismusbekämpfungsgesetz (pdf)
– Gemäss Artikel 10-Gesetz (pdf)

See also: BND Codewords and Abbreviations

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Bnd Obituary, Bnd Stock, Bnd Logo, Bnd Germany, Bnd Dividend, Bnd Sports, Bnd Quote, Bnd Commercial, Bnd Jobs, Vnd To Usd, Bnd Airport, Bnd Acronym, Bnd Archives, Bnd Agency, Bnd Address, Bnd App, Bnd Automotive, Bnd Adapter Beeping, B&d Auto, Band Aid, Bnd Burger, Bnd Bank, Bnd Belleville, Bnd Berlin, Bnd Bond, B&d Burgers, Bnd Burger Miami, Bnd Baseball, Bnd Bakery, Bnd Blood Test, Bnd Commercial, Bnd Currency, Bnd Chart, Bnd Construction, Bnd Clg Wiki, Bnd Crime Blotter, Bnd College Save, Bnd Corp, Bnd Crime, Bnd Contact, Bnd Dividend, Bnd Dividend Yield, Bnd Duration, Bnd Deal Loan, Bnd Definition, Bnd Deal One, Bnd Deutschland, Bnd Deaths, Bnd Design, Bnd Death Notices, Bnd Etf, Bnd Etf Price, Bnd Engineers, Bnd Ex Dividend Date, Bnd Etf Quote, Bnd Events, Bnd Etf Review, Bnd Exe, B&d Electric, Bnd Etf Chart, Bnd Fact Sheet, Bnd Fund, Bnd Facebook, Bnd Flagpole Sales, Bnd Fidelity, Bnd File, Bnd Fees, Bnd Finance, Bnd For Rent, Bnd File Rebuilder, Bnd Germany, Bnd Google Finance, Bnd Garage Sales, Bnd Germany Website, Bnd Group, Bnd Glen Carbon Fire, Bnd Gradle Plugin, Bnd Gets In Dead Meat, Bnd Gov, B&d Genetics, Bnd Holdings, Bnd High School Baseball, Bnd Houses For Rent, Bnd Homes, B And H, Bnd Hours, Bnd Historical Prices, Bnd Headquarters, Bnd Homeland, Bnd Hmo, Bnd Intelligence, Bnd Interiors, Bnd Index, Bnd Illinois, Bnd Interiors Inc, Bnd Include-resource Examples, Bnd Include-resource, B&d Industries, Bnd Obits, Bend It Like Beckham, Bnd Jobs, Bnd Jake Arter, Bnd Joann Reed, Bnd Jumpers, Bnd Jumpers Riverside Ca, Bnd Jingle Competition, Bnd Java, Bnd Jurist, Bnd Jobs Berlin, Bnd Karriere, Bnd Kahl, Bnd Kitchener, Bnd Kanpur, Bnd Kaffeestudio, Band Karke Sheeshe Car De, Bnd Knives, Band Kamre Me Pyar Karenge, B&d Kilsyth, Bdn Kitchens Parkes, Bnd Logo, Bnd Loans, Bnd Logo Of Doom, Bnd Local News, Bnd Logo History, Bnd Loan Consolidation, Bnd Loan Forgiveness, Bnd Lab, Bnd Logo Remake, Bnd Local Events, Bnd Morningstar, Bnd Mask, Bnd Meaning, Bnd Morphs, Bnd Mask Of Doom, Bnd Metro East News, Bond Mutual Fund Equivalent, Bnd My Account, B&d Mechanical, Bond Mutual Fund, Bnd News, B&d Nation, Bnd Number, Bnd North Dakota, Bnd News Sports, Bnd Nyse, B&d Nails, Bnd News Today, Bnd Nd, Bnd No Doubt, Bnd Obituary, Band Of Brothers, Band Of Horses, Bnd Osgi, Band Of Brothers Cast, Bnd Oil, Bnd Oil Inc, Bnd Online, Band On The Run, Bend Oregon, Bnd Plastering, Bnd Price, Bnd Performance, Bnd Police Blotter, Bnd Prospectus, Bnd Pets, Bnd Public Salary Database, Bnd Paper, Bnd Public Pay Database, Bnd Properties, Bnd Quote, Bnd Qualified Dividends, B And Q, B And Q Wallpaper, B And Q Paint, B And Q Near Me, B And Q Bbq, B And Q Jobs, B And Q Lighting, B And Q Kitchen, Bnd Rentals, Bnd Real Estate, Bnd Returns, Bnd Review, Bnd Rebuilder, Bnd Reddit, Bnd Recipes, Bnd Russia, Bnd Rates, Bnd Reporters, Bnd Stock, Bnd Sports, Bnd Stock Price, Bnd Student Loan Login, Bnd Sports Baseball, Bnd Stock Quote, Bnd Stands For, Bnd Stock Price Today, Bnd Share Price, Bnd Stock Dividend, Vnd To Usd, Bnd Ticker, Bnd Treasure Chest, Bnd Tools, Bnd Total Return, Vnd To Usd Chart, B&d Towing, Bnd Twitter, Bnd Today, Bnd Test, Vnd Usd, Bnd Urban Dictionary, Vnd Usd Chart, Vnd Urban Dictionary, B&d Used Cars, Vnd Unity, Vnd Usd Exchange Rate History, Vnd Usd Vietcombank, Bnd Us, Bnd Us Equity, Bnd Vanguard, Bnd Vs Biv, Bnd Vs Bndx, Bnd Vs Vbmfx, Bnd Vs Vcit, Bnd Vs Schz, Bnd Vs Vbtlx, Bnd Vs Bond, Bnd Vs Bsv, Bnd View From The Cheap Seats, Bnd Wynwood, Bnd Weather, Bnd Wiki, Bnd Wholesale, Bnd Website, Bend Walmart, Bnd Wab, Bnd Wrap Jar, Bandwagon, Bnd What Neighbor’s House Sell For, Bnd Yield, Bnd Yahoo Finance, Bnd Yard Sales, Bnd Ytd, Bnd Year To Date, Band Yes, Bnd Ytd Performance, Bnd Yield History, Bond Yield, Bnd Yoga, Bnd Zacks, Bnd Zentrale, Bnd Zac Epplin, Bnd Zulage, Bnd Zentrale Berlin Adresse, Bnd Zentrale Pullach, Bnd Zentrale Neubau

Top Pentagon Official Ordered Destruction of bin Laden Death Photos, NSA Employee Gave Snowden Password to Classified Info Network, US Falls in Press Freedom Rankings to #46

McRaven’s order to destroy the photos was first mentioned in a 2011 draft Pentagon IG report examining whether the Obama administration gave special access to Hollywood executives planning the film “Zero Dark Thirty.”

A FOIA lawsuit brought against the Department of Defense by Judicial Watch has spurred the declassification of documents revealing U.S. Special Operations Commander, Admiral William McRaven, ordered the immediate destruction of any photos of the death of Osama bin Laden. On May 13, 2011, McRaven told subordinates that any photos should have already been turned over to the CIA –presumably so they could be placed in operational files out of reach of the FOIA– and if anyone still had access to photos, to “destroy them immediately or get them to the [redacted].” McRaven issued the directive only hours after Judicial Watch issued a press release stating they would be filing suit for the records.

The National Security Agency (NSA) currently collects data on less than a third of domestic calls, according to anonymous officials, raising questions about the efficacy of the bulk surveillance tool. Officials reported that the agency collects information from most landlines, but that it is incapable of collecting information from cell phones or internet calls. However, the NSA is in the process of building “the technical capacity over the next few years to collect toll records from every domestic land line and cellphone call, assuming Congress extends authority for Section 215 of the USA Patriot Act after it expires in June 2015.”

A new audit from the Government Accountability Office reports that spy agencies, including the FBI, CIA, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, and components of the Departments of Justice, Energy, Treasury, Homeland Security, and State, “have provided unreliable and incomplete reports to Congress since 2011 on the use of private contractors.” The unclassified report does not disclose the number of core contractors –like Edward Snowden- these agencies employ, or how much money is spent on them.

A document posted to Cryptome.org reveals Snowden was given access to NSAnet to scrape 1.7 million classified files by a civilian NSA employee. Photo: EPA

A declassified document recently posted on Cryptome.org reveals that a civilian NSA employee gave Snowden their Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) certificate, allowing Snowden access to classified information on NSAnet that would otherwise have been unavailable to the contractor. Then, without the civilian employee’s knowledge, Snowden used a commonly available web crawler to “scrape” 1.7 million files.

The Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, said during a Senate Armed Services Committee hearing Tuesday that nearly a year after Edward Snowden accessed the classified files, the agency still does not have the technology fully in place to prevent a similar unauthorized disclosure. Under questioning, Clapper said that Snowden would have been caught had he tried to scrape material from NSA headquarters in Ft. Meade, MD, rather than an agency outpost in Hawaii, further commenting that “[o]ur whole system is based on personal trust.”

A February 4 report from Republicans on the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee reported that more than 15 federal agencies were hacked last year, and either lost control of their networks or had them stolen as a result. The report further notes the occurrence of 48,000 other cyber ‘incidents’ involving government systems, and that “civilian agencies don’t detect roughly four in 10 intrusions.”

The debate over targeting an American terror suspect in Pakistan in a lethal drone attack continued this week. This is the first time officials have discussed killing an American citizen in such an attack, and comes in the middle of another debate about whether the lethal drone program should be transferred from the CIA to the Pentagon. DNI Clapper publicly acknowledged the existence of the covert CIA drone program for the first time this Tuesday during the aforementioned Senate Armed Services Committee hearing. Sen. Bill Nelson (D-FL) asked Clapper to confirm if the White House was considering “shifting the use of drones, unmanned aerial vehicle strikes, from the CIA to the DOD,” to which Clapper responded, “Yes, sir, it is. And again, that would also be best left to a closed session.”

Former State Department analyst Stephen Kim pled guilty to leaking a Top Secret intelligence report on North Korea to a Fox News reporter and is expected to serve 13 months in prison. The report led to a June 11, 2009, Fox News story that stated “Pyongyang’s next nuclear detonation is but one of four planned actions the Central Intelligence Agency has learned, through sources inside North Korea…” implying the source inside North Korea was CIA human intelligence that was placed at risk due to the story’s publication.

USA, #46.

The US fell 13 places to #46 in Reporters Without Borders’ latest ranking of press freedom around the world, and is now sandwiched between Romania and Haiti. The report cites national security measures as the reason for the rankings plummet, including Chelsea Manning’s conviction, the DOJ’s seizure of AP phone records as part of a leak investigation, and the government’s attempts to have Edward Snowden returned for prosecution.

The NSA refuses to acknowledge the existence or non-existence of documents on a Top Secret U.S. intelligence facility in Mexico City, a communications hub that barred Mexican personnel and focused on “high value targeting,”despite previously declassified information describing its role. The NSA issued a “Glomar” denial in response to a FOIA request filed by the National Security Archive last year, even after the Archive published a declassified Pentagon memo confirming the NSA’s involvement in the operations of the “Mexico Fusion Center.”

Finally this week, Polish prosecutors may try to question Guantanamo detainees as part of an investigation into whether or not the CIA maintained a secret “black” prison in the Eastern European nation between 2002 and 2003. The Polish investigation began in 2008 after CIA officials told the AP that a prison in operated in Poland “from December 2002 until the fall of 2003.” Human rights groups believe more than a handful of terror suspects were held there, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.

Happy FOIA-ing!

NSA, Prism– Mittendrin die alten STASI-Genossen der „GoMoPa“

Hysterie in Berlin und Brüssel: Die Politiker Europas sind erzürnt. Sie wurden flächendeckend von den US-Geheimdiensten ausspioniert. Nun dämmert ihnen, dass die Überwachung vor allem für sie persönlich gedacht sein könnte. Der normale Internet-Nutzer ist nämlich nicht das Haupt-Ziel der Überwachung. Den Geheimdiensten geht es um die „großen Fische“. Viele zittern daher vor dem nächsten Schlag: Der Enthüllung von Fehltritten, die Spitzenpolitiker das Amt kosten könnten.
Der NSA-Skandal erregt die Politiker Europas. Selten hat man an einem Wochenende so viele aufgeregte Flügelschläge gesehen. Martin Schulz, Präsident des EU-Parlaments spricht von einer „Riesensauerei“.
Justizministerin Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger fühlt sich an den Kalten Kriegerinnert und weist jeden Terror-Verdacht von sich (hier). Renate Künast verlangt volle Aufklärung und notfalls eine Klage vor dem Internationalen Gerichtshof. Der CSU-Mann im EU-Parlament, Markus Ferber, spricht von der Stasi und dem Verlust der moralischen Glaubwürdigkeit. Sigmar Gabriel, der SPD-Chef, will nicht, dass er als gläserner Mensch durchleuchtet werden kann.
Der Grund der Aufregung ist verständlich: Der US-Geheimdienst NSA hat zugegeben, in Deutschland und der EU so gut wie alles bespitzelt zu haben, was sich im Internet tummelt. Auch Angela Merkel soll ausspioniert worden sein. Die Amerikaner haben Emails gehackt, Telefonate abgehört, Internet-Bewegungen überwacht.
Das ist an und für sich keine Neuigkeit.
Mitarbeiter des BND und der NSA sagen schon seit langem: Wir nehmen jede Information, die wir kriegen können. Wir wären verrückt, wenn wie die Emails der Bundeskanzlerin ignorieren würden. Es ist immer interessant zu sehen, was Barroso macht. Wenn wir Martin Schulz am Telefon zuhören können, machen wir das. Wir haben keine Hemmungen und einen großen Magen.
Wer weiß, was man da so alles finden kann.
Denn tatsächlich ist die Enthüllung der Überwachung vor allem eine Botschaft an die politischen Eliten: Sie werden massiv kontrolliert.
Und meist haben sie etwas zu verbergen.
Dann werden sie erpressbar.
Und fallen.
Wie der New Yorker Staatsanwalt Eliot Spitzer: Er tappte in die Sexfalle, während er versuchte, den Wall Street-Kriminellen zu Leibe rückte. Ein schwerer Fehler: Sein Hotel in Washington wurde verwanzt, als er sich mit einer Escort-Lady traf – und weg war er.
Seither ermittelt niemand mehr gegen Wall Street.
Oder Dominique Strauss-Kahn: Der labile IWF-Chef, ein Glücksspieler und Sex-Besessener, war besonders leichte Beute für seine Feinde. Auch Strauss-Kahn hatte begonnen, sich kritisch über die Rolle des Weltfinanz-Systems zu äußern. Man schickte ihm ein Zimmermädchen zum Oralverkehr.
Keine Stunde später holte ihn die New Yorker Polizei aus dem Flugzeug.
Und weg war er.
Für beide Coups waren erhebliche Vorbereitungen nötig, inklusive Kosten – etwas für die Mädchen.
Dank des Internet und der grenzenlosen Geschwätzigkeit der Politiker können sich jene, die das System kontrollieren, nun zurücklehnen.
Die Arbeit machen die Systemadministratoren.
Gelegentlich wird ein Whistleblower an die Öffentlichkeit geschickt, um die überwachten Eliten in Angst und Schrecken zu versetzen. Edward Snowden ist der beste Mann der Wall Street. Seine Mitteilung ist ein Signal an die Eliten: Wir wissen alles, was ihr macht.
Und wir werden es gegen Euch verwenden.
Die normalen Bürger dürften nicht überrascht sein, dass ihre Daten faktisch öffentliches Gut sind.
Jedem einigermaßen denkfähigen Bürger muss klar sein, dass von den Bank-Konten über die Kreditkarten bis hin zum Online-Einkauf oder der Nutzung von Google, Apple, Facebook und Microsoft alle Daten in irgendeiner Weise bei den Behörden landen.
Naiv sind jene, die glauben, dass die Behörden solche Daten nach Datenschutz-Kriterien verwenden würden.
Die CIA, das FBI und Datenschutz! Vieles an der Daten-Sammelwut ist eine Art staatlich finanzierte Arbeitsplatzbeschaffung. Sinnlos, aber sie schafft Jobs. Niemals zu überblicken, weil zu umfangreich – aber tausende Leute sitzen von 9 bis 17 Uhr hinter den Computern und haben das Gefühl, einer Beschäftigung nachzugehen.
Auch für die Statistik sind solche Entwicklungen sehr erfreulich.
Die Hauptziele der Überwachung sind jedoch die Politiker und die Eliten selbst.
Das System, das um seine Existenz kämpft, traut sich selbst nicht mehr.
Und dank Email und Internet ist jeder Politiker ein gläserner Mensch. Da hat Sigmar Gabriel schon recht: Jeder Politiker ist nämlich durch die Daten erpressbar.
Niemand ist fehlerlos: Der eine hat eine kleine außereheliche Affäre. Der nächste ist sexuell anders orientiert als er öffentlich sagt. Die nächste hat Spielschulden. Wieder ein anderer hat seine Steuern nicht komplett bezahlt. Eine Putzfrau, die nicht sozialversicherungspflichtig angemeldet ist. Private Nutzung von Dienstwagen.
Das sind die kleinen Sünden.
Und wie ist das mit den großen Sünden?
Nehmen wir José Manuel Barroso, den nun die deutschen Politiker um Hilfe anflehen: Er unterhält seit jeher beste Beziehungen zu dubiosen griechischen Geschäftsleuten. Er hat mehrfach Urlaub auf der Yacht Alexandros des reichsten Griechen der Welt, Spiro Latsis, gemacht. Das ist bekannt und umstritten. Welche Beziehungen unterhält Barroso noch zu Oligachen in Griechenland, in Portugal sonstwo?
Bei jüngsten Treffen der Bilderberger wurde Barroso von den Eliten der Welt in die Mangel genommen, weil er in Europa nicht geliefert hat. Kritik ist das eine. Aber mit der Überwachung haben die Eliten noch ganz andere Werkzeuge.
Man kann die Daten-Massen der Politiker perfekt zu ihrer Erpressung einsetzen.
Knallhart, zielgenau, sauber zu bedienen wie die Drohnen.
Die Mafia würde vor Neid erblassen ob des Arsenals, über das die Finanz-Eliten verfügen.
Es geht natürlich nicht nur um Barroso.
Es geht um alle Politiker in Brüssel – Kommissare, Abgeordnete, Verbandsvertreter. Es geht um die Politiker in Deutschland.
Nehmen wir einen anderen Bilderberger.
Der Chef des CDU-Wirtschaftsrats, Kurt Joachim Lauk, ist neben seiner Beratungstätigkeit für Angela Merkel Präsident von Globe Capital Partners. Die Firma ist ein knallharter US-Finanzinvestor, der sich in Deutschland wie überall auf der Welt nach Unternehmen umsieht, die er sich einverleiben kann.
Natürlich haben die Eliten ein Interesse daran, was Herr Lauk in seinen Emails schreibt, mit wem er telefoniert. Ob er gute Deals macht, schlechte Deals macht oder gar keine Deals macht. Natürlich gibt es viele Banker, die sich interessieren, was Herr Lauk zu Frau Merkel über die nächsten Gesetze sagt, die etwa im regulatorischen Bereich geplant sind.
Herr Lauk tut gut daran, möglichst keine privaten Emails zu schreiben.
Aber kann er das überhaupt durchhalten? Sind nicht alle Politiker gehetzt und überfordert mit den neuen Kommunikations-Mitteln? Ist es nicht zwangsläufig so, dass dem einen oder anderen genau der eine Fehler passiert, der ihm am Ende zum Verhängnis wird?
Oder der FDP-Hoffnungsträger Christian Lindner, der auch beim Bilderberger-Treffen dieses Jahr anwesend war: Er war einmal bei Geschäftsführer bei dem Internet-Unternehmen Moomax, das später pleitemachte. Er hat Erfahrung mit dem Geld anderer – das Unternehmen erhielt Fördergelder und hatteInvestoren. Da möchte man schon gerne mitlesen, welche Emails der FDP-Chef von NRW seinen politischen und Geschäfts-Freunden schreibt. Seine Leidenschaft sind schnelle Autos. Er muss höllisch aufpassen, dass er nicht zu schnell fährt beim Kommunizieren.
Die Gefahr der Überwachung für die Politiker ist erheblich.
Denn die Überwachung ist die Vorstufe zur Enthüllung.
Mit der Überwachung sagen die NSA-Leute den nun vor Angst bibbernden europäischen Politikern: Wir wissen alles.
Und wenn nötig, sagen wir auch alles.
Nichts fürchten die Politiker mehr als einen „Leak“.
Die Bekanntgabe von brisanten Details an die Medien.
Eine Freundin, ein unsauberes Geschäft, eine vergessene Steuer-Erklärung.
So etwas wird „geleakt“.
Zu diesem Zweck haben die Überwachungs-Eliten die Medien erst kürzlich getestet: Von bis heute unbekannter Quelle sind die Steuerdaten von tausenden „Steuerflüchtlingen“ an die Medien gelangt.
Die Medien, stets dankbare Sammler von Brosamen, die vom reich gedeckten Tisch der Mächtigen gelegentlich abfallen, haben bei den „Offshore-Leaks“ glänzend mitgespielt (mehr zu dieser Ouvertüre zur Hexenjagd – hier).
Sie haben sich als verlässliche Partner für jene erwiesen, die etwas „leaken“ wollten.
Das wird auch bei künftigen Enthüllungen so sein.
So sehr die Medien „Datenschutz“ schreien, wenn es um ihre Facebook-Postings geht, so skrupellos sind sie, wenn es sich um illegal erworbene Dokumente handelt. Sie sind blind vor triefender Moral, wenn aus der Schweiz Bankdaten gestohlen werden (hier).
Kein Medium hat gefragt, ob es denn rechtmäßig sei, gestohlene Informationen zu verwenden.
Für die Medien gilt: Alles, was wir exklusiv bekommen, ist rechtmäßig.
Denn wir sind die vierte Gewalt.
Tatsächlich sind die die fünfte Kolonne, die ihren Beitrag leistet, wenn es um die Kontrolle der Eliten geht.
Doch läuft diese Kontrolle nicht so, wie sich die Medien das gerne einreden. Nicht die Medien kontrollieren die Politiker.
Das Machtsystem der Geld-Eliten kontrolliert die Politiker. Ausgewählte Ergebnisse der Kontrolle dürfen die Medien publizieren.
Die Medien sind durch die Wirtschaftskrise geschwächt und willfährig. Die Politiker sind durch die Schuldenkrise extrem geschwächt und angreifbar.
Die Neuigkeit der Meldung von der flächendeckenden Überwachung der Politiker Deutschlands und der EU ist nicht die Allwissenheit der Geheimdienste.
Die ist so bekannt wie die Tatsache, dass die Sonne im Osten aufgeht.
Die Neuigkeit ist die Panik, mit der die Politiker auf die Überwachung reagiert haben. Als es „nur“ um die Bürger ging, haben die Herren Gabriel, Schulz und Ferber nicht einmal mit der Wimper gezuckt.
Nun aber merken die politischen Eliten, dass sie im Endspiel der Schuldenkrise plötzlich ins Visier ihrer einstigen Gönner, der Finanz-Eliten geraten sind. Sie könnten in Ungnade fallen, weil das taumelnde System nach Sündenböcken sucht.
Jede unbedachte Email kann zur Pistole werden, die der einzelne Politiker sich selbst an die Schläfe setzen muss.
Jedes aufgezeichnete, unpassende Telefonat kann zur Zyankali-Kapsel werden, die dem Betreffenden dezent zugeschoben werden muss.
Die Mafia muss erblassen ob der Möglichkeiten, über die die Finanz-Eliten dank der modernen Informations-Technologien heutzutage verfügen.

Und mittendrin: Die alten STASI-Genossen der „GoMoPa“, die sich mit diesen Techniken als „FINANZ-NACHRICHTENDIENST“ bestens auskennen und diese gegen Gelds an das nächst-schlechte Finanz-„Unternehmen“ verhökern oder auf eigene Rechnung arbeiten !

Quellen: Edward Snowden, Wikileaks, Deutsche Wirtschaftsnachtichten, NSA, Insider

NSA Domestic Spying Targeted Journalists

Russell Tice, former NSA insider turned whistleblower on the Bush domestic electronic spying program, reveals that the NSA program targeted journalists and news agencies within the US.

The Hawaii Connection

Not an Exception, but a Pattern

The Rise of a “Shadow Intelligence Community”

A Record of Breaches

The Profitability of Privacy

After the IRS Fallout

Accessing Even More Data

🏛️ Compliance & Legal Repository Footer

Formal Notice of Evidence Preservation

Audit Standards & Reporting Methodology:

Legal Disclaimer:

Digital Signature & Tags

Rate this:

Share this:

🔴 ABOVE TOP SECRET – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPERATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

☣️ SUBJECT: Integrated Cognitive Warfare & Digital Domination

1. CIA–Silicon Valley Nexus

2. ELON MUSK: Architect of Dual-Use Systems

3. FACEBOOK/META: Mass Surveillance & Behavior Manipulation

4. GOOGLE/ALPHABET: The Algorithmic Panopticon

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON: Data Dominance for Defense

6. OPENAI: The Algorithmic Cold War

⚠️ CLASSIFIED FINDINGS

✊ FINAL WARNING

✌️DEUTSCHE VERSION✌️

🔴 OBERSGEHEIM – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPERATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

☣️ THEMA: Kognitive Kriegsführung & Digitale Vorherrschaft

1. CIA–Silicon Valley

2. ELON MUSK: Dual-Use-Technologiearchitekt

3. FACEBOOK/META: Verhaltensmanipulation & Überwachung

4. GOOGLE/ALPHABET: Überwachung & Predictive Tech

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON: Zivil-militärische Datenkontrolle

6. OPENAI: Der Algorithmische Kalte Krieg

⚠️ KLASSIFIZIERTE ERKENNTNISSE

✊ SCHLUSSWORT

✌️VERSION FRANÇAISE✌️

🔴 ULTRA SECRET – COSMIC BLACK DOSSIER

OPÉRATION TECHNARCHY 5.1

☣️ SUJET : Guerre Cognitive Intégrée & Domination Numérique

1. CIA & Silicon Valley

2. ELON MUSK : Le Stratège Dual Usage

3. FACEBOOK : Manipulation Psychologique

4. GOOGLE : Domination Algorithmique

5. PALANTIR & AMAZON : Infrastructure de Surveillance

6. OPENAI : La Guerre Algorithmiques

⚠️ CONCLUSIONS CLASSIFIÉES

✊ AVERTISSEMENT FINAL

✅ ACTION DIRECTIVE – FOR COSMIC BLACK PATRONS ONLY

Support the Mission

Spread the Signal

Report Anomalies

TAG THE HIDDEN INFOSPHERE

✅ HANDLUNGSBEFEHL – NUR FÜR COSMIC BLACK SUPPORTER (Deutsch)

Unterstütze die Mission

Signal verbreiten

Melde Anomalien

✅ DIRECTIVE POUR LES PARRAINS COSMIC BLACK (Français)

Soutenez la mission

Diffusez l’information

Signalez toute anomalie

Rate this:

Share this:

Rate this:

Share this:

Rate this:

Share this:

Rate this:

Share this:

Thank you for your response. ✨

Rate this:

Share this:

Rate this:

Share this:

Thank you for your response. ✨

Rate this:

Share this:

Thank you for your response. ✨

Rate this: