Nach Informationen aus dem Umkreis der NSA werden nunmehr alle deutschen Putin-Unterstuetzer erfasst und beleuchtet.
Anlass ist das Wirken von Ex-Kanzler Gerhard Schroeder fuer Putin.
Putin war selbst in der DDR lange Jahre taetig
Hierzu zaehlen die Linke, alle dieser Gruppierung zuzuordnenden Unternehmen, alle ehemaligen KGB- und STASI-Agenten und STASI-IM und deren Unternehmen und Beteiligungsgesellschaften.
Hinzu kommen deren Kunden, Finanziers und Sponsoren.
Dies betrift wohl insbesondere “Neues Deutschland”, und “GoMoPa”, als auch die mutmasslich unterwanderten “Das Investment” und “Immobilien Zeitung” sowie “Die Bewertung” berichten die Washington-Insider, die auch von verstaerkten militaerischen Konflikten weltweit ausgehen.
Deutschland als wichtiges NATO-Land neben den USA und mit der DDR-Historie gilt als besonders wichtig und kritisch fuer die NSA-Analysen.
Die betroffenen Unternehmen und Personen muessen mit Sanktionen und internationalen FBI-Haftbefehlen wie im Fall der FIFA fuer die mutmasslich korrupte WM-Vergabe an Putins Russland rechnen, die auch in der Schweiz vollstreckt wurden.
Russian Agents Of Shield,Russian Agents Killed,Russian Agents In The Us,Russian Agents Dying,Russian Agents Voted For Trump,Russian Agents Behind Yahoo,Russian Agents Of Influence,Russian Agents Indicted,Russian Agents Trump,Russian Agents Yahoo Hack,Russian Agents Arrested,Russian Agents Are Behind Yahoo Breach,Russian Agents In America,Russian Travel Agents Association,Russian Sleeper Agents In America,Russian Kgb Agents In America,Russian Travel Agents In Australia,Russian Visa Agents In Australia,Russian Agents Behind Yahoo,Russian Agents Behind,Russian Basketball Agents,Russian Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Agents Executed By Isis,Russian Agents Killed By Is,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Agents In Britain,Russian Visa Agents In Bangalore,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Chemical Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents Cold War,Russian Estate Agents Cyprus,Russian Sleeper Agents Caught,Russian Property Agents Cyprus,Russian Real Estate Agents Chicago,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Visa Agents In Chennai,Child Russian Agents,Russian Agents Dying,Russian Agents Dead,Russian Double Agents,Russian Double Agents In The Cold War,Russian Double Agents Executed,Russian Visa Agents Delhi,Russian Travel Agents Directory,Russian Real Estate Agents Dubai,Russian Visa Agents In Dubai,Russian Travel Agents In Dubai,Russian Agents Executed,Russian Agents Executed By Isis,Russian Estate Agents,Russian Estate Agents London,Russian Estate Agents In Cyprus,Russian Estate Agents In Spain,Russian Education Agents,Russian Estate Agents In Paphos,Russian Estate Agents In Limassol,Russian Estate Agents Tenerife,Russian Foreign Agents Law,Russian Football Agents,Russian Fsb Agents,Russian Free Agents,Russian Free Agents Hockey,Russian Fifa Agents,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Fsb Agents Executed,Russian Free Agents Nhl,Russian Federal Agents,Russian Gru Agents,Russian Real Estate Agents Greece,Russian Hockey Agents,Russian Hunting Agents,Russian Free Agents Hockey,Russian Holiday Agents,Russian Agents In The Us,Russian Agents Indicted,Russian Agents In America,Russian Agents In The White House,Russian Agents In Uk,Russian Agents Isis,Russian Agents In Ukraine,Russian Agents In Europe,Russian Agents In Syria,Russian Agents In Romania,Russian Agents Killed,Russian Agents Killed By Isis,Russian Agents Killed By Child,Russian Kgb Agents In America,Russian Kgb Agents,Russian Fsb Agents Killed By Isis,Famous Russian Kgb Agents,Russian Visa Agents In Kolkata,Russian Sleeper Agents Movie,Russian Estate Agents Marbella,Russian Travel Agents Melbourne,Russian Real Estate Agents Miami,Russian Visa Agents In Mumbai,Russian Nerve Agents,Russian Free Agents Nhl,Russian Real Estate Agents New York,Russian Agents Of Shield,Russian Agents Of Influence,Russian Travel Agents Outbound,Russian Property Agents,Russian Property Agents London,Russian Property Agents Cyprus,Russian Port Agents,Russian Patent Agents,Russian Agents In Poland,Russian Visa Agents In Pakistan,Russian Estate Agents In Paphos,Russian Estate Agents Selling Property In Spain,Russian Agents In Romania,Russian Sleeper Agents Real,Russian Inteligence Agents Face Risk Of Disclosure,Russian Agents Shot,Russian Agents Series,Russian Sleeper Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents 2010,Russian Sleeper Agents 2014,Russian Secret Agents,Russian Sleeper Agents Tv Series,Russian Secret Agents Arrested In Us,Russian Sleeper Agents 1980s,Russian Special Agents,Russian Agents Trump,Russian Travel Agents,Russian Travel Agents List,Russian Travel Agents Association,Russian Travel Agents Uk,Russian Travel Agents In Dubai,Russian Tour Agents,Russian Travel Agents In Australia,Russian Travel Agents Melbourne,Russian Travel Agents In San Francisco,Russian Undercover Agents,Russian Agents In Us,Russian Agents In Uk,Russian Agents In Ukraine,Russian Travel Agents Uk,Russian Estate Agents In Uk,Russian Agents Voted For Trump,Russian Visa Agents In Delhi,Russian Visa Agents In Mumbai,Russian Visa Agents In Pakistan,Russian Visa Agents In Chennai,Russian Visa Agents In Dubai,Russian Visa Agents,Russian Visa Agents In Islamabad,Russian Visa Agents In India,Russian Visa Agents In Lahore,Russian Agents Were Behind Yahoo Hack,Russian Sleeper Agents Wiki,Russian Sleeper Agents Cold War,Russian Agents Yahoo Hack,Russian Agents Yahoo,Russian Agents Yahoo Breach,
Earlier this month we learned the name of a second person who stole top secret documents from the US National Security Agency (NSA). After Edward Snowden admitted doing so publicly in June 2013, the FBI has now arrested the 51-year old Harold T. Martin III at his home in Maryland.
Martin hoarded lots of classified documents, not only from NSA but also from a number of other military and intelligence agencies. The FBI is still comparing them with those from the recent Shadow Brokers leak and a range of other NSA leaks from the past few years, but given what’s known now, it seems likely that at least one other leaker is still at large.
The New York Times reported that when the FBI raided Martin’s house on August 27, they found paper documents and many terabytes of highly classified information, even going back the 1990s. At least six documents were from 2014. It was reported that Martin first took the classified documents on paper, later on CDs and more recently on thumb drives.
The reason why Harold Martin brought home and stored such large numbers of top secret documents isn’t yet clarified. One suggestion is that he may have used them forresearch for his dissertation about “new methods for remote analysis of heterogeneous & cloud computing architectures”, which he was working on at the University of Maryland.
Documents from multiple agencies
It should be noted that not everything Martin stole comes from NSA. In the official charges there are no names of the agencies where the documents come from, they are only described as highly classified, including ones that are marked as Top Secret and Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI).
With the documents going back to the 1990s, he may well have started hoarding them from the places where he worked in those days. From 1987 to 2000, Martin served at the US Navy, achieving the rank of lieutenant, but he left active duty in 1992.
As the Washington Post found out, he then took a variety of tech jobs with government contractors, like at Computer Sciences Corp. (CSC) somewhere in the 1990s and later, until 2009, at Tenacity Solutions, for which he worked at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI).
In 2009, Harold Martin started to work for Booz Allen Hamilton, for which he was a contractor at NSA from 2012 to 2015, when Booz transferred him to the Pentagon’s Office of Acquisition, Technology and Logistics (AT&L), which is responsible for often highly sensitive and classified procurement programs. There he stayed until the moment of his arrest last August.
Officials have meanwhile said that Martin took classified documents not only from NSA, but also from his other workplaces, including ODNI and AT&L.
It’s interesting as well that in the charges against Martin, a whole paragraph is dedicated to the at least six documents from 2014, which are described as being produced “through sensitive government sources, methods, and capabilities”. As signals intelligence is traditionally seen as the most sensitive capability, maybe just these six documents are from NSA.
Shadow Brokers investigation
After the “Shadow Brokers” disclosed a large set of secret NSA hacking tools last August, the FBI began investigating this leak. At the same time there was a lot of speculation: was NSA hacked from the outside? Had an NSA hacker been sloppy? Were the tools leaked by an insider? Maybe the same insider responsible for earlier leaks that hadn’t been attributed to Snowden?
On September 22, it was reported that during the FBI investigation, NSA officials had said that a former agency operative had carelessly left the hacking tool files available on a remote computer, where Russian hackers found them. If that’s correct, then it seems likely that the FBI traced Harold Martin when they were looking for that careless NSA hacker. It has not yet been confirmed that Martin was that person though.
Harold Martin was working at NSA’s hacking division TAO around the time when the tools were considered to be left exposed, somewhere after October 18, 2013, but a former TAO hacker told the Washington Post that Martin “worked in the unit’s front office carrying out support roles such as setting up accounts, not conducting actual operations.”
Even if Martin was the man who left the hacking tools exposed, then we still don’t know who found them and published them under the name Shadow Brokers. It’s not very likely that this was done by Martin himself, as Shadow Brokers published additional messages on August 28, October 1 and October 15, when he was already in custody. The actual publication can therefore be the work of for example Russian, Iranian or North Korean hackers or even independent hacktivists.
Could Harold Martin also be the source of earlier leaks, that were not attributed to Edward Snowden? In theory he could have been that “second source” next to Snowden: none of these other leaked documents (like the TAO catalog, XKEYSCORE code, tasking lists and end reports) are newer than 2015, when Martin left NSA. Contrary to this Martin is described as very patriotic, which doesn’t fit the fact that these particular leaks were clearly meant to harm and embarrass the US and NSA.
Also, Martin hasn’t (yet) been charged with espionage or the attempt to provide classified information to a third party or a foreign government – which doesn’t seem something the US government would leave out or keep secret after the recent and unprecedented statement in which the Office of the Director of National Intelligence accused Russia of hacking the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and other political organizations.
Should the FBI investigation confirm that Harold Martin was only responsible for leaking the NSA hacking tools (after which unknown others published them) and that none of his documents were provided to foreign intelligence agencies or showed up in the earlier revelations, then there’s most likely yet another leaker from inside NSA.
The Shadow Brokers leak standing alone and not related to the earlier non-Snowden leaks is of some importance, because only among the stuff published by the Shadow Brokers there are files with a date (October 18, 2013) after the day that Snowden left NSA (May 20, 2013).
This means that when Harold Martin is the initial source of the Shadow Brokers files, we can no longer exclude the possibility that the earlier leaks do come from the Snowden trove. If that would be the case, then someone with access to them went rogue and had them published on his own account. But it should also be noted that both Glenn Greenwald and Bruce Schneier explicitly said that some of these leaked documents did not come from Snowden.
The more likely option is therefore that there’s still another leaker at large, someone with a more evil intent than Harold Martin and Edward Snowden – a conclusion which is not very comforting and which also raises questions about NSA’s internal security…
NSA’s internal security measures
The NSA’s hacking division TAO, where Harold Martin worked for some time, isapparently not located in the well-known NSA headquarters building at Fort Meade, but in one or more leased office buildings outside, one of them at an office complex calledFriendship Annex (FANX) near Baltimore. TAO also has units at NSA’s four Cryptologic Centers across the US.
Entrance to the highly secured TAO headquarters building is strictly controlled: one has to go through an imposing steel door, protected by armed guards, and entrance is only possible after entering a six-digit code and passing a retinal scanner to ensure that only specially cleared individuals are allowed in.
Such security measures are more aimed at keeping outsiders out, than at insiders in. And when it comes to finding inside moles of hostile foreign intelligence agencies, the NSA is also said to have a rather bad track record. The Manning and Snowden leaks made NSA painfully aware of this and so preventive insider-threat detection programs were put in place.
It’s not clear whether these new systems failed in the case of Harold Martin, or that they simply weren’t yet implemented at the TAO location where he worked – anti-leak software that was designed by Raytheon to “spot attempts by unauthorized people to access or download data” was also not yet installed at the NSA facility in Hawaii when Snowden was working there.
Tracking what employees are doing inside is one thing, checking what they take out is another. But according to The Washington Post, the NSA (like other agencies) does notimpose universal checks of personnel and their belongings as they enter and leave agency buildings. Security guards only conduct random checks and use their discretion in order to keep en build the trust of the employees.
“If you have a bag full of stuff, you’re probably going to get stopped” said a former TAO operator to the Post, but, in general, “Disneyland has more physical security checks than we had”. Additionally, NSA facilities will have detection gates, but it seems that it was easier for Snowden to walk out with his thousands of documents than many would have thought.
As former NSA general counsel Rajesh De explained, it is unlikely “you’re going to be able to stop every incident of somebody taking documents if they’re determined to do so. But the real question is how quickly can you detect it, how quickly can you mitigate the harm of any such incident.”
Harold Martin stole a lot of classified documents from multiple military and intelligence agencies where he worked over the past 20 years, with maybe just a small number from NSA. The still ongoing FBI investigation has to make clear whether Martin was responsible for exposing the TAO hacking tools.
If not, then there has to be yet another careless NSA employee, but then it’s also still possible that the hacking tools came from a source responsible for a range of earlier leaks. So far it seems that Martin isn’t the source of those earlier leaks, which means that the so-called “second source” is still at large.
The case of Harold Martin also made clear that security measures at NSA, and other US agencies, were not as strict and tight as outsiders would have expected: even for someone without a strong ideological or financial drive like Martin it was apparently not that difficult to regularly walk out with top secret documents.
Many things have not yet been confirmed or clarified, but at least the Shadow Brokers leak and the subsquent arrest of Harold Martin created more awareness among the American public of the fact that there have been more leaks than just those from Snowden.
In August 2014, Bruce Schneier was probably one of the first who identified a second and a third leaker besides Snowden. Many more similar leaks followed and a full listof them was compiled on this weblog in December 2015 (still being updated). As an excerpt of this listing, a short overview of the most important non-Snowden leaks was published in The New York Times last week.
Shortly after this blog posting was published, The New York Times came with a new report saying that the volume of classified documents Harold Martin had in his possesion is larger than those stolen by Edward Snowden and even than those of the Panama Papers from 2015.
FBI investigators apparently also found that the TAO hacking tools were among Martin’s documents, but because he is not very cooperative, it is still not clear how they came in the hands of the mysterious Shadow Brokers, who subsequently published them. So far there’s no evidence that Martin was hacked or that he sold information.
He seems to have hoarded all these documents in order to get better at his job, as he is described as someone who imagined himself a top spy and an important player in the world of digital espionage.
On Thursday, October 20, government lawyers said they would prosecute Harold Martin under the Espionage Act because of stealing classified information. The FBI found the huge amount of 50 terabytes of data at his home, but it is not yet clear how much of that is classified. Also foundwere “hard-copy documents that were seized from various locations during the search that comprise six full bankers’ boxes worth of documents” with “Many of the documents marked ‘Secret’ and ‘Top Secret,’ also bear special handling caveats. The information stolen by the Defendant also appears to include the personal information of government employees”.
Links and Sources
– John Schindler: It’s Time to Rename NSA the National INsecurity Agency
– The Washington Post: NSA contractor thought to have taken classified material the old-fashioned way
– Daily Beast: Democrats Say WikiLeaks Is a Russian Front, U.S. Intelligence Isn’t So Sure
– Defense One: Data-Theft Arrest Shows that Insider Threat Remains Despite Post-Snowden Security Improvements
– John Schindler: Has the Russian Mole inside NSA finally been arrested?
– New York Times: N.S.A. Suspect Is a Hoarder. But a Leaker? Investigators Aren’t Sure.
– The Cipher Brief: First on The Cipher Brief: Snowden’s Boss Shares Lessons Learned
Leak Detection, Leak Down Test, Leak Down Tester, Leak Detector, Leak Definition, Leak In Spanish, Leak Detection Pump, Leak Seal, Leak Stopper, Leakforums, Leak And Sons Funeral Home, Leak Alarm, Leak Ap Gov, Leak Amniotic Fluid, Leak Alert, Leak Around Chimney, Leake And Watts, Leek And Potato Soup, Leaked Albums, Leak At Water Meter, Leak B Gone, Leak Bros, Leak Barrier, Leak Base, Leak Bali, Leak Barrier Ms300, Leak Busters, Leak Behind Shower, Leak Behind Wall, Leak Before Break, Leak Channels, Leakcanary, Leak Crossword Clue, Leak Check, Leak Channels Definition, Leak Controller, Leak Code, Leak Catcher, Leak City, Leak Ceiling, Leak Detection, Leak Down Test, Leak Down Tester, Leak Detector, Leak Definition, Leak Detection Pump, Leak Detection Equipment, Leak Doctor, Leak Definition Government, Leak Defense System, Leak Ender 2000, Leak En Espanol, Leak Eliminators, Leaked Early, Leak Electric, Leak Experts, Leak En Francais, Leak Early Album, Leak Exhaust, Leak Emoji, Leakforums, Leak Freeze, Leek Food, Leak Finders, Leak Fix, Leakfrog, Leak Fixer, Leak Fix Spray, Leaked Forms, Leak Famous.com, Leak Gopher, Leak Guard, Leak Gif, Leak Geeks, Leak Guard Protection, Leaky Gut, Leak Garbage Disposal, Leak Guardian, Leak Girl, Leak Gopher Vs Fortrezz, Leak Heart Valve, Leak House Of Cards, Leak Hunters, Leak Hack, Leak Hose, Leek Hustle, Leak House Of Cards Season 5, Leak Head Gasket, Leek Hunting, Leek Herb, Leak In Spanish, Leak In Ceiling, Leak In Roof, Leak In Radiator, Leak In Basement, Leak In Pool, Leak In Tire, Leak In Basement Wall, Leak In The Boat, Leak In Heart, Leek Jack, Leak Jones, Leak Jet, Leak Jokes, Leak Jacob, Leek Jack Campus Girl, Leek Jack Lyrics, Leak Journalism, Leak James Comey, Leek Jack Age, Leak Kingdom, Leak King, Leak Kitchen Faucet, Leek Knife, Leak Kitchen Sink, Leak Kanseng, Leak Kitchen Sink Drain, Leak Khan Bombak Sne, Leak K Channels, Leaky Kohler Faucet, Leak Lock, Leak Live, Leak Like A Siv, Leak Locators, Leak Less, Leak Like A Sieve, Leak Location Services, Leak Light, Leak Lock Sds, Leak League Of Legends, Leak Meaning, Leak Masters, Leak Memory Chapel, Leak Meme, Lake Mead, Leak Music, Leak Master Roofing, Leak Movie, Leak Memorial, Leak Meaning In Hindi, Leak No More, Leak News, Leak No More For Dogs, Leak Nutrition, Leak Near Me, Leak No More Reviews, Leak No More York Pa, Leak Near Water Meter, Leaked Nsa, Leak No Stallin, Leak Off Test, Leak Out, Leak Oil, Leak Of Information, Leek Onion, Leak On Ceiling, Leak Of Orange Is The New Black, Leak On Roof, Leak Out Meaning, Leak Or Leakage, Leak Project, Leak Proof Underwear, Leak Proof, Leak Proof Travel Bottles, Leak Proof Containers, Leek Plant, Leak Proof Tape, Leak Proof Water Bottle, Leak Proof Bag, Leak Project Youtube, Leak Quotes, Leek Quiche, Leak Quizlet, Leek Quiche Recipes, Leek Quinoa, Leek Quiche Bacon, Leek Quiche Healthy, Leek Quiche Crustless, Leek Quiche Epicurious, Leek Quiche Allrecipes, Leak Repair, Leak Repair Tape, Leak Rate Calculator, Leak Rate, Leak Reddit, Leek Recipes, Leak Rate Units, Leak Rate Conversion, Leak Repair Spray, Leak Repair Putty, Leek Soup, Leak Seal, Leak Stopper, Leak Synonym, Leak Stop, Leak Sealer, Leek Spin, Leak Seal Tape, Leak Squad, Leak Source, Leak Test, Leak Tape, Leak Tester, Leak Threads, Leak Tamer, Leak Tech, Leak Tec, Leak Tools, Leak Test Solution, Leak Tracing Powder, Leak Under Sink, Leak Under Car, Leak Urine, Leak Under Toilet, Leak Under Slab, Leak Under Bathroom Floor, Leak Under Dishwasher, Leak Under Washer, Leak Under Toilet Tank, Leak Under House, Leak Video, Leek Vegetable, Leak Valve, Leak Veggie, Leek Veggie, Leek Vs Onion, Leek Vs Scallion, Leek Vegetable Soup, Leak Vrf To Global, Leak Or Leakage, Leak Wizard, Leak Water, Leak Website, Leak Wall House Rockingham Nc, Leak Week, Leaked White House, Leaked Winner, Leak Washington Post, Leak Water Heater, Leak Wrap, Leak Xenforo, Leak Xur, Leak Xbox One, Leak Xur 3 April, Leak You, Leak Your Ex, Leak Youtube, Leak Your Number, Leak Year, Leak You Up And Down, Leak Young Og Project, Leak Leaky, Leak Make Your Future Bleak, Liveleak Youtube, Leak Zip, Leak Z10, Leak Z4, Leak Zelda, Leak Zimbabwe, Leak Zhang Ziyi, Leak Zelda Wii U, Leak Zombies, Zircon Leak Alert, Zero Leak Gold, Nsa Jobs, Nsa Director, Nsa Softball, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Careers, Nsa Definition, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Internships, Nsa Acronym, Nsa Address, Nsa Advisor, Nsa Agent, Nsa Alabama, Nsa Annapolis, Nsa Agent Salary, Nsa Arc, Nsa Approved Shredders, Nsa Agreement, Nsa Building, Nsa Bahrain, Nsa Budget, Nsa Bethesda, Nsa Baseball, Nsa Badge, Nsa Benefits, Nsa Building Nyc, Nsa Budget 2016, Nsa Backdoor, Nsa Careers, Nsa Chief, Nsa Colorado, Nsa Crane, Nsa Cyber Security, Nsa Conference, Nsa Csfc, Nsa Cae, Nsa Crypto Challenge, Nsa Css, Nsa Director, Nsa Definition, Nsa Data Center, Nsa Day Of Cyber, Nsa Director Salary, Nsa Data Collection, Nsa Domestic Surveillance, Nsa Datasheet, Nsa Deputy Director, Nsa Datasheet Is Called, Nsa Employment, Nsa Edward Snowden, Nsa Exploits, Nsa Employees, Nsa Email, Nsa Evaluated Products List, Nsa Echelon, Nsa Emblem, Nsa Encryption, Nsa Eternal Blue, Nsa Fastpitch, Nsa Florida Youth, Nsa Fort Meade, Nsa Flynn, Nsa Florida, Nsa Friend, Nsa Facebook, Nsa Fort Gordon, Nsa Foia, Nsa Facts, Nsa Georgia, Nsa Glassdoor, Nsa Government, Nsa Grindr, Nsa Github, Nsa Gift Shop, Nsa Game, Nsa Grants, Nsa Gif, Nsa Guy, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Head, Nsa Hacking Tools, Nsa Hawaii, Nsa Hampton Roads, Nsa Hacked, Nsa History, Nsa Hiring Process, Nsa Hacking Tools Leaked, Nsa Headquarters Address, Nsa Internships, Nsa Industries, Nsa Intelligence Analyst, Nsa Indiana, Nsa Influence 2017, Nsa Iad, Nsa Ias 2017, Nsa India, Nsa Illinois, Nsa Insurance, Nsa Jobs, Nsa Juice Plus, Nsa Job Openings, Nsa Jobs Utah, Nsa Jobs Salary, Nsa Jokes, Nsa Job Requirements, Nsa Jurisdiction, Nsa Jobs In Md, Nsa Japan, Nsa Keywords, Nsa Kunia, Nsa Kc, Nsa Key, Nsa Kentucky, Nsa Kmi, Nsa Kankakee, Nsa Korea, Nsa Kaspersky, Nsa Keith Alexander, Nsa Leaker, Nsa Logo, Nsa Leak, Nsa Locations, Nsa Listening, Nsa Leader, Nsa Login, Nsa Leadership, Nsa Language Analyst, Nsa Leaked Tools, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Meme, Nsa Media, Nsa Meet, Nsa Mid South, Nsa Mike Rogers, Nsa Museum, Nsa Mcmaster, Nsa Maryland, Nsa Mission Statement, Nsa News, Nsa Naples, Nsa Name Generator, Nsa North, Nsa Number, Nsa Norfolk, Nsa Nyc, Nsa Nashville, Nsa Nursing, Nsa New Orleans, Nsa Orlando, Nsa Opm Test, Nsa Online Test, Nsa Offices, Nsa Obama, Nsa Organization, Nsa Operational Interview, Nsa Only, Nsa Org Chart, Nsa Of 1947, Nsa Prism, Nsa Police, Nsa Panama City, Nsa Police Officer, Nsa Phone Number, Nsa Philadelphia, Nsa Pay Scale, Nsa Play, Nsa Polygraph, Nsa Purpose, Nsa Quantum Computer, Nsa Quotes, Nsa Qualifications, Nsa Quantum, Nsa Quizlet, Nsa Questions, Nsa Qualifier, Nsa Quantum Computer Farm, Nsa Quartet, Nsa Quiz, Nsa Rogers, Nsa Requirements, Nsa Rules, Nsa Recruiting, Nsa Relationship, Nsa Rule Book, Nsa Ransomware, Nsa Russia, Nsa Responsibilities, Nsa Reno, Nsa Softball, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Slang, Nsa Salary, Nsa Stands For, Nsa Soccer, Nsa Softball Rules, Nsa Scholarship, Nsa Scandal, Nsa Texas, Nsa Tournaments, Nsa Tools, Nsa Trump, Nsa Tao, Nsa Tools Leaked, Nsa Twitter, Nsa Tinder, Nsa Test, Nsa Training, Nsa Utah, Nsa Urban, Nsa Usa, Nsa Utah Facility, Nsa Unmasking, Nsa Utah Jobs, Nsa Unconstitutional, Nsa Umpire, Nsa Under Obama, Nsa Uniform, Nsa Vs Cia, Nsa Visitor Center, Nsa Virginia, Nsa Vs Fbi, Nsa Vs Cia Vs Fbi, Nsa Virus, Nsa Visitor Control Center, Nsa Vpn, Nsa Vanilla, Nsa Violation Of Privacy, Nsa Wiki, Nsa Whistleblower, Nsa Washington, Nsa Wiretapping, Nsa Website, Nsa Water Filter, Nsa Watchlist, Nsa World Series, Nsa Wikileaks, Nsa Wannacry, Nsa Xkeyscore, Nsa Xbox One, Nsa Xeno World Qualifier, Nsa Xkeyscore Download, Nsa Xcode, Nsa Xbox Live, Nsa Xeno Tournament, Nsa Xkeyscore Presentation, Nsa X, Nsa X Files, Nsa Youtube, Nsa Yogurt, Nsa Young Investigator Grant, Nsa Youth Florida, Nsa Yearly Budget, Nsa Yottabyte, Nsa Youth Program, Nsa Youth, Nsa Yellow Dots, Nsa Yakima, Nsa Zero Day, Nsa Zip Code, Nsa Zeus, Nsa Zimmermann Telegram, Nsa Zimbabwe, Nsa Za, Nsa Zero Day Exploit, Nsa Zyxel, Nsa Zero Division, Nsa Zone Store
Earlier this week, a group or an individual called the Shadow Brokers published a large set of files containing the computer code for hacking tools. They were said to be from the Equation Group, which is considered part of the NSA’s hacking division TAO.
The leak got quite some media attention, but so far it was not related to some earlier leaks of highly sensitive NSA documents. These show interesting similarities with the Shadow Brokers files, which were also not attributed to Edward Snowden, but seem to come from an unknown second source.
The Shadow Brokers files
One of the encrypted files could be decrypted into a 301 MB archive containing a large number of computer codes for server side utility scripts and exploits for a variety of targets like firewalls from Cisco, Juniper, Fortinet and TOPSEC. The files also include different versions of several implants and instructions on how to use them, so they’re not just the malware that could have been found on the internet, but also files that were only used internally.
A full and detailed list of the exploits in this archive can be found here.
Security experts as well as former NSA employees considered the files to be authentic, and earlier today the website The Intercept came with some unpublished Snowden documents that confirm the Shadow Brokers files are real.
Besides the accessible archive, Shadow Brokers also posted a file that is still encrypted, and for which the key would only be provided to the highest bidder in an auction. Would the auction raise 1 million bitcoins (more than 500 million US dollars), then Shadow Brokers said they would release more files to the public. This auction however is likely just meant to attract attention.
Update: Shadow Brokers, or people posing like them, posted an short announcement on Pastebin on August 28, and a third, long message including a “self-interview” on Medium.com on October 1. On October 15, a fourth message was published on Medium, saying that the auction was cancelled.
From the Snowden documents?
According to security experts Bruce Schneier and Nicholas Weaver the new files aren’t from the Snowden trove. Like most people, they apparently assume that Snowden took mostly powerpoint presentations and internal reports and newsletters, but that’s not the whole picture. The Snowden documents also include various kinds of operational data, but this rarely became public.
Most notable was a large set of raw communications content collected by NSA under FISA and FAA authority, which also included incidentally collected data from Americans, as was reported by The Washington Post on July 5, 2014. The Snowden documents also include technical reports, which are often very difficult to understand and rarely provide a newsworthy story on their own.
Someone reminded me as well that in January 2015, the German magazine Der Spiegel published the full computer code of a keylogger implant codenamed QWERTY, which was a component of the NSA’s WARRIORPRIDE malware framework. So with the Snowden trove containing this one piece of computer code, there’s no reason why it should not contain more.
Contradicting the option that the Shadow Brokers files could come from Snowden is the fact that some of the files have timestamps as late as October 18, 2013, which is five months after Snowden left NSA. Timestamps are easy to modify, but if they are authentic, then these files have to be from another source.
A second source?
This brings us to a number of leaks that occured in recent years and which were also not attributed to Snowden. These leaks involved highly sensitive NSA files and were often more embarrassing than stuff from the Snowden documents – for example the catalog of hacking tools and techniques, the fact that chancellor Merkel was targetedand intelligence reports proving that NSA was actually successful at that.
It is assumed that these and some other documents came from at least one other leaker, a “second source” besides Snowden, which is something that still not many people are aware of. The files that can be attributed to this second source have some interesting similarities with the Shadow Brokers leak. Like the ANT catalog published in December 2013, they are about hacking tools and like the XKEYSCORE rulespublished in 2014 and 2015 they are internal NSA computer code.
This alone doesn’t say much, but it’s the choice of the kind of files that makes these leaks look very similar: no fancy presentations, but plain technical data sets that make it possible to identify specific operations and individual targets – the kind of documents many people are most eager to see, but which were rarely provided through the Snowden reporting.
As mainstream media became more cautious in publishing such files, it is possible that someone who also had access to the Snowden cache went rogue and started leaking documents just for harming NSA and the US – without attributing these leaks to Snowden because he would probably not approve them, and also to suggest that more people followed Snowden’s example.
Of course the Shadow Brokers leak can still be unrelated to the earlier ones. In that case it could have been that an NSA hacker mistakenly uploaded his whole toolkit to a server outside the NSA’s secure networks (also called a “staging server” or “redirector” to mask his true location) and that someone was able to grab the files from there – an option favored by for example Edward Snowden and security researcher the grugq.
Meanwhile, several former NSA employees have said that the current Shadow Brokers leak might not be the result of a hack from the outside, but that it’s more likely that the files come from an insider, who stole them like Snowden did earlier.
Of course it’s easier for an insider to grab these files than for a foreign intelligence agency, let alone an ordinary hacker, to steal them from the outside. But if that’s the case, it would mean that this insider would still be able to exfiltrate files from NSA premises (something that shouldn’t be possible anymore after Snowden), and that this insider has the intent to embarrass and harm the NSA (Snowden at least said he just wanted to expose serious wrongdoings).
Here we should keep in mind that such an insider is not necessarily just a frustrated individual, but can also be a mole from a hostile foreign intelligence agency.
On August 21, NSA expert James Bamford also confirmed that TAO’s ANT catalog wasn’t included in the Snowden documents (Snowden didn’t want to talk about it publicly though). Bamford favors the option of a second insider, who may have leaked the documents through Jacob Appelbaum and Julian Assange.
On Twitter, Edward Snowden said that “Circumstantial evidence and conventional wisdom indicates Russian responsibility”, but it’s not clear what that evidence should be. It seems he sees this leak as a kind of warning from the Russians not to take revenge for the hack of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) e-mails, which was attributed to Russian intelligence.
This was also what led Bruce Schneier to think it might be the Russians, because who other than a state actor would steal so much data and wait three years before publishing? Not mentioned by Schneier is that this also applies to the documents that can be attributed to the second source: they also pre-date June 2013.
A related point of speculation is the text that accompanied the Shadow Brokers files, which is in bad English, as if it was written by a Russian or some other non-western individual. This is probably distraction, as it looks much more like a fluent American/English speaker who tried to imitate unexperienced English.
The text also holds accusations against “Elites”, in a style which very much resembles the language used by anarchist hacker groups, but that can also be faked to distract from the real source (it was also noticed that the e-mail address used by Shadow Brokers (firstname.lastname@example.org) seems to refer to the manga Code Geass in which an exiled prince takes revenge against the “Britannian Empire”).
With the authenticity of the Shadow Brokers files being confirmed, the biggest question is: who leaked them? There’s a small chance that it was a stupid accident in which an NSA hacker uploaded his whole toolkit to a non-secure server and someone (Russians?) found it there.
Somewhat more likely seems the option that they came from an insider, and in that case, this leak doesn’t stand alone, but fits into a series of leaks in which, since October 2013, highly sensitive NSA data sets were published.
So almost unnoticed by the mainstream media and the general public, someone was piggybacking on the Snowden-revelations with leaks that were often more embarrassing for NSA than many reportings based upon the documents from Snowden.
Again, obtaining such documents through hacking into highly secured NSA servers seems less likely than the chance that someone from inside the agency took them. If that person was Edward Snowden, then probably someone with access to his documents could have started his own crusade against NSA.
If that person wasn’t Snowden, then it’s either another NSA employee who was disgruntled and frustrated, or a mole for a hostile foreign intelligence agency. But for an individual without the protection of the public opinion like Snowden, it must be much harder and riskier to conduct these leaks than for a foreign state actor.
Former NSA counterintelligence officer John Schindler also thinks there could have been a (Russian) mole, as the agency has a rather bad track record in finding such spies. If this scenario is true, then it would be almost an even bigger scandal than that of the Snowden-leaks.
During an FBI-led investigation of the ShadowBrokers leak, NSA officialsreportedly said that a former agency operative carelessly left the hacking tool files available on a remote computer, where Russian hackers found them. After this was discovered, NSA tuned its sensors to detect use of any of the tools by other parties, like China and Russia. But as that wasn’t the case, NSA did not feel obligated to warn the US manufacturers.
On October 6, 2016, The New York Times reported that on August 27, 2016, the FBI arrested 51-year old Harold T. Martin III, who worked at NSA as a contractor for Booz Allen Hamilton. In his home in Glen Burnie, Maryland, “many terabytes” of highly classified information was found, from the 1990s until 2014. Hal Martin was described as a hoarder, but so far, investigators are not sure he was also responsible for the various leaks that could not be attributed to Snowden.
Links and Sources
– TheWeek.com: How the NSA got hacked
– EmptyWheel.com: Where Are NSA’s Overseers on the Shadow Brokers Release?
– Observer.com: NSA ‘Shadow Brokers’ Hack Shows SpyWar With Kremlin Is Turning Hot
– TechCrunch.com: Everything you need to know about the NSA hack (but were afraid to Google)
– WashingtonPost.com: Powerful NSA hacking tools have been revealed online
– NYTimes.com: ‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Alarming Question: Was the N.S.A. Hacked?
– LawfareBlog.com: NSA and the No Good, Very Bad Monday
Shadow Broker Dlc, Shadow Broker Mass Effect, Shadow Broker Vulnerability, Shadow Broker Nsa, Shadow Broker Dossiers, Shadow Broker Mass Effect 2, Shadow Broker Download, Shadow Broker Ship, Shadow Broker Tools, Shadow Brokers Leak, Shadow Broker Attack, Shadow Broker Andromeda, Shadow Broker Achievements, Shadow Broker After Beating Game, Shadow Broker Agent, Shadow Broker Adalah, Shadow Broker Analysis, Shadow Broker Agent Mass Effect 2, Shadow Broker Arrested, Shadow Broker Archive, Shadow Broker Base, Shadow Broker Base Investment Opportunities, Shadow Broker Book, Shadow Broker Boss Fight, Shadow Broker Before Or After, Shadow Broker Bug, Shadow Broker Base Model, Shadow Brokers Bbc, Shadow Broker Blog, Shadow Broker Base Video Archive, Shadow Broker Crash, Shadow Broker Cve, Shadow Broker Cisco, Shadow Broker Cyber Attack, Shadow Broker Cerberus, Shadow Broker Cyber Threat, Shadow Broker Comments, Shadow Broker Cyber Security, Shadow Broker Comments Squadmates, Shadow Broker Companion Comments, Shadow Broker Dlc, Shadow Broker Dossiers, Shadow Broker Download, Shadow Broker Definition, Shadow Brokers Dump, Shadow Broker Dlc Crash, Shadow Broker Dlc Review, Shadow Broker Dlc Ps3, Shadow Broker Dlc Glitch, Shadow Broker Dlc Cost, Shadow Broker Exploits, Shadow Broker Eternal Blue, Shadow Broker Exploit List, Shadow Broker Equation Group, Shadow Broker Eternal Champion, Shadow Broker Exploits Download, Shadow Broker Effects On Mass Effect 3, Shadow Broker Ending, Shadow Broker Mass Effect 2, Shadow Broker Mass Effect, Shadow Broker Files, Shadow Broker Fight, Shadow Broker Fuzzbunch, Shadow Broker Files Garrus, Shadow Broker Framework, Shadow Broker Fb.py, Shadow Broker Facebook, Shadow Broker Forces Mass Effect 3, Shadow Broker Free Download, Shadow Broker Files Legion, Shadow Broker Github, Shadow Broker Group, Shadow Broker Garrus, Shadow Broker Grunt, Shadow Broker Glitch, Shadow Broker Guide, Shadow Broker Dlc Glitch, Shadow Broker Mission Glitch, Shadow Broker After Beating Game, Cz Shadow Gunbroker, Shadow Broker Hack, Shadow Broker Hackers, Shadow Broker Hack Nsa, Shadow Broker Hug Liara, Shadow Broker Hack Terminals, Shadow Broker Hatch, Shadow Broker Dlc How To Start, Lair Of The Shadow Broker How To Start, Lair Of The Shadow Broker How Long, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Hours, Shadow Broker Investments, Shadow Broker Identity, Shadow Broker Information Terminals, Shadow Broker Pc, Shadow Broker Insanity, Shadow Broker Intel, Shadow Broker Illusive Man, Shadow Broker Ilium, Shadow Broker In Underworld Empire, Giving Shadow Broker Info Cerberus, Shadow Brokers June, Shadow Brokers Juniper, Shadow Brokers July, Shadow Brokers June Dump, Shadow Brokers January, Shadow Brokers June Release, Shadow Brokers June 2017, Shadow Brokers Join, Shadow Broker Jack, Shadow Broker Jak Zainstalowa\u0107, Shadow Broker Kb, Shadow Broker Kahoku, Shadow Broker Keeps Crashing, Liara Shadow Broker Kiss, Shadow Broker Who To Kill, Kasumi Shadow Broker Dossier, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Key, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Keygen, Shadow Broker Leaks, Shadow Broker Liara, Shadow Broker Legion, Shadow Broker Logs, Shadow Brokers Lost In Translation, Shadow Brokers Linux, Shadow Broker List, Shadow Brokers Leak Download, Shadow Brokers Letter To Trump, Shadow Brokers List Of Exploits, Shadow Broker Mass Effect, Shadow Broker Mass Effect 2, Shadow Broker Mass Effect 1, Shadow Broker Malware, Shadow Broker Meaning, Shadow Broker Microsoft, Shadow Broker Microsoft Patch, Shadow Broker Ms17-010, Shadow Broker Morinth, Shadow Broker Model Ship, Shadow Broker Nsa, Shadow Broker News, Shadow Brokers Nsa Tools, Shadow Brokers Nsa Tools Download, Shadow Brokers Nsa Hack, Shadow Brokers Nsa Leaks, Shadow Brokers Nsa Hacking Tools, Shadow Brokers North Korea, Shadow Brokers New Release, Shadow Brokers Nytimes, Shadow Broker Observer, Shadow Broker Oracle, Shadow Broker Oddjob, Shadow Broker Ost, Shadow Broker Investment Opportunities, Shadow Broker Before Or After, Shadow Broker Comments On Squad, Shadow Broker Effects On Mass Effect 3, Shadow Broker Door Wont Open, Origin Shadow Broker, Shadow Broker Patch, Shadow Broker Password, Shadow Broker Paragon Interrupt, Shadow Broker Planet, Shadow Broker Ps3, Shadow Broker Paragon, Shadow Broker Parking Lot, Shadow Broker Dlc Price, Shadow Broker Data Points, Liara Shadow Broker Paragon Interrupt, Shadow Broker Quotes, Shadow Broker Quest, Liara Shadow Broker Quest, Mass Effect Shadow Broker Quotes, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Quotes, Mass Effect 2 Shadow Broker Quotes, Shadow Broker Release, Shadow Broker Race, Shadow Broker Rdp, Shadow Broker Rdp Exploit, Shadow Broker Romance, Shadow Broker Reddit, Shadow Broker Ransomware, Shadow Broker Romance Liara, Shadow Broker Review, Shadow Broker Rapid7, Shadow Broker Ship, Shadow Broker Smb, Shadow Broker Species, Shadow Broker Smb Exploit, Shadow Broker Solaris, Shadow Broker Subscription, Shadow Broker Smb Vulnerability, Shadow Broker Ship Model, Shadow Broker Support Team, Shadow Broker Squad, Shadow Broker Tools, Shadow Broker Twitter, Shadow Broker Terminals, Shadow Broker Tool Dump, Shadow Broker Tali, Shadow Broker Tools Download, Shadow Broker Timeline, Shadow Broker Threat, Shadow Broker Toolkit, Shadow Broker Tutorial, Shadow Broker Unique Dialogue, Shadow Broker Upgrades, Shadow Broker Update, Shadow Broker Underworld Empire, Shadow Broker Upgrades Mass Effect 3, Shadow Broker Dlc Upgrades, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Unique Dialogue, Shadow Broker Dlc Not Showing Up, Underworld Shadow Broker, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Upgrade Locations, Shadow Broker Vulnerability, Shadow Broker Video Archive, Shadow Broker Virus, Shadow Broker Vs Illusive Man, Shadow Broker Voice, Shadow Broker Vasir, Shadow Broker Base Videos, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Vasir Bug, Shadow Broker Windows, Shadow Broker Wiki, Shadow Broker Wannacry, Shadow Broker Wikileaks, Shadow Broker Walkthrough, Shadow Broker Wet Squad, Shadow Broker Website, Shadow Broker Windows 2003, Shadow Broker Windows Exploit, Shadow Broker Windows 10, Shadow Broker Dlc Xbox, Lair Of The Shadow Broker Xbox 360, Shadow Broker Yahg, Shadow Broker Youtube, Shadow Broker Zero Day, Shadow Broker Zcash, Shadow Broker Zaeed, Shadow Broker Jak Zainstalowa\u0107
Nsa Jobs, Nsa Director, Nsa Softball, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Careers, Nsa Definition, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Internships, Nsa Acronym, Nsa Address, Nsa Advisor, Nsa Agent, Nsa Alabama, Nsa Annapolis, Nsa Agent Salary, Nsa Arc, Nsa Approved Shredders, Nsa Agreement, Nsa Building, Nsa Bahrain, Nsa Budget, Nsa Bethesda, Nsa Baseball, Nsa Badge, Nsa Benefits, Nsa Building Nyc, Nsa Budget 2016, Nsa Backdoor, Nsa Careers, Nsa Chief, Nsa Colorado, Nsa Crane, Nsa Cyber Security, Nsa Conference, Nsa Csfc, Nsa Cae, Nsa Crypto Challenge, Nsa Css, Nsa Director, Nsa Definition, Nsa Data Center, Nsa Day Of Cyber, Nsa Director Salary, Nsa Data Collection, Nsa Domestic Surveillance, Nsa Datasheet, Nsa Deputy Director, Nsa Datasheet Is Called, Nsa Employment, Nsa Edward Snowden, Nsa Exploits, Nsa Employees, Nsa Email, Nsa Evaluated Products List, Nsa Echelon, Nsa Emblem, Nsa Encryption, Nsa Eternal Blue, Nsa Fastpitch, Nsa Florida Youth, Nsa Fort Meade, Nsa Flynn, Nsa Florida, Nsa Friend, Nsa Facebook, Nsa Fort Gordon, Nsa Foia, Nsa Facts, Nsa Georgia, Nsa Glassdoor, Nsa Government, Nsa Grindr, Nsa Github, Nsa Gift Shop, Nsa Game, Nsa Grants, Nsa Gif, Nsa Guy, Nsa Headquarters, Nsa Head, Nsa Hacking Tools, Nsa Hawaii, Nsa Hampton Roads, Nsa Hacked, Nsa History, Nsa Hiring Process, Nsa Hacking Tools Leaked, Nsa Headquarters Address, Nsa Internships, Nsa Industries, Nsa Intelligence Analyst, Nsa Indiana, Nsa Influence 2017, Nsa Iad, Nsa Ias 2017, Nsa India, Nsa Illinois, Nsa Insurance, Nsa Jobs, Nsa Juice Plus, Nsa Job Openings, Nsa Jobs Utah, Nsa Jobs Salary, Nsa Jokes, Nsa Job Requirements, Nsa Jurisdiction, Nsa Jobs In Md, Nsa Japan, Nsa Keywords, Nsa Kunia, Nsa Kc, Nsa Key, Nsa Kentucky, Nsa Kmi, Nsa Kankakee, Nsa Korea, Nsa Kaspersky, Nsa Keith Alexander, Nsa Leaker, Nsa Logo, Nsa Leak, Nsa Locations, Nsa Listening, Nsa Leader, Nsa Login, Nsa Leadership, Nsa Language Analyst, Nsa Leaked Tools, Nsa Meaning, Nsa Meme, Nsa Media, Nsa Meet, Nsa Mid South, Nsa Mike Rogers, Nsa Museum, Nsa Mcmaster, Nsa Maryland, Nsa Mission Statement, Nsa News, Nsa Naples, Nsa Name Generator, Nsa North, Nsa Number, Nsa Norfolk, Nsa Nyc, Nsa Nashville, Nsa Nursing, Nsa New Orleans, Nsa Orlando, Nsa Opm Test, Nsa Online Test, Nsa Offices, Nsa Obama, Nsa Organization, Nsa Operational Interview, Nsa Only, Nsa Org Chart, Nsa Of 1947, Nsa Prism, Nsa Police, Nsa Panama City, Nsa Police Officer, Nsa Phone Number, Nsa Philadelphia, Nsa Pay Scale, Nsa Play, Nsa Polygraph, Nsa Purpose, Nsa Quantum Computer, Nsa Quotes, Nsa Qualifications, Nsa Quantum, Nsa Quizlet, Nsa Questions, Nsa Qualifier, Nsa Quantum Computer Farm, Nsa Quartet, Nsa Quiz, Nsa Rogers, Nsa Requirements, Nsa Rules, Nsa Recruiting, Nsa Relationship, Nsa Rule Book, Nsa Ransomware, Nsa Russia, Nsa Responsibilities, Nsa Reno, Nsa Softball, Nsa Surveillance, Nsa Spying, Nsa Slang, Nsa Salary, Nsa Stands For, Nsa Soccer, Nsa Softball Rules, Nsa Scholarship, Nsa Scandal, Nsa Texas, Nsa Tournaments, Nsa Tools, Nsa Trump, Nsa Tao, Nsa Tools Leaked, Nsa Twitter, Nsa Tinder, Nsa Test, Nsa Training, Nsa Utah, Nsa Urban, Nsa Usa, Nsa Utah Facility, Nsa Unmasking, Nsa Utah Jobs, Nsa Unconstitutional, Nsa Umpire, Nsa Under Obama, Nsa Uniform, Nsa Vs Cia, Nsa Visitor Center, Nsa Virginia, Nsa Vs Fbi, Nsa Vs Cia Vs Fbi, Nsa Virus, Nsa Visitor Control Center, Nsa Vpn, Nsa Vanilla, Nsa Violation Of Privacy, Nsa Wiki, Nsa Whistleblower, Nsa Washington, Nsa Wiretapping, Nsa Website, Nsa Water Filter, Nsa Watchlist, Nsa World Series, Nsa Wikileaks, Nsa Wannacry, Nsa Xkeyscore, Nsa Xbox One, Nsa Xeno World Qualifier, Nsa Xkeyscore Download, Nsa Xcode, Nsa Xbox Live, Nsa Xeno Tournament, Nsa Xkeyscore Presentation, Nsa X, Nsa X Files, Nsa Youtube, Nsa Yogurt, Nsa Young Investigator Grant, Nsa Youth Florida, Nsa Yearly Budget, Nsa Yottabyte, Nsa Youth Program, Nsa Youth, Nsa Yellow Dots, Nsa Yakima, Nsa Zero Day, Nsa Zip Code, Nsa Zeus, Nsa Zimmermann Telegram, Nsa Zimbabwe, Nsa Za, Nsa Zero Day Exploit, Nsa Zyxel, Nsa Zero Division, Nsa Zone Store