Criminal Justice Access to Data in the Cloud: Cooperation with “Foreign” Service Providers
Page Count: 38 pages
Date: May 3, 2016
Originating Organization: Council of Europe, Cybercrime Convention Committee
File Type: pdf
File Size: 555,121 bytes
File Hash (SHA-256):A66EEB1A5F8C37F33B3F16374A46EA655168CBD3F226551050C878D1D8531F32
The Cybercrime Convention Committee (T-CY), at its 12th plenary (2-3 December 2014), established a working group to explore solutions to access for criminal justice purposes to evidence in the cloud, including through mutual legal assistance (“Cloud Evidence Group”). The Cloud Evidence Group is to submit a report to the T-CY with options and recommendations for further action by December 2016.
In 2015, the T-CY Cloud Evidence Group, following a discussion paper summarizing the challenges of criminal justice access to data in the cloud (published in May 2015 and discussed at the Octopus Conference in June 2015), held a hearing for providers on 30 November 2015 which focused on the direct cooperation by criminal justice authorities with service providers in foreign jurisdictions:
Often a prosecution or police authority (a “law enforcement authority”) of a Party to the Budapest Convention requests a service provider in another jurisdiction for data in relation to a specific criminal investigation. Typically, subscriber information is sought from multinational service providers with their headquarters in the USA (“US service providers”). Some of them have subsidiaries in Europe or elsewhere.
Transparency reports published by US service providers indicate that they respond positively to about 60% of such requests “on a voluntary basis”.
Article 18 Budapest Convention covers “production orders” and Article 18.1.b specifically the production of subscriber information by a service provider “offering its services on the territory of the Party”:
Article 18 – Production order
1 Each Party shall adopt such legislative and other measures as may be necessary to empower its competent authorities to order:
a a person in its territory to submit specified computer data in that person’s possession or control, which is stored in a computer system or a computer-data storage medium; and
b a service provider offering its services in the territory of the Party to submit subscriber information relating to such services in that service provider’s possession or control.
The Explanatory Report (paragraph 171) to the Budapest Convention indicates Article 18 was also intended to cover situations of voluntary cooperation:
171. A “production order” provides a flexible measure which law enforcement can apply in many cases, especially instead of measures that are more intrusive or more onerous. The implementation of such a procedural mechanism will also be beneficial to third party custodians of data, such as ISPs, who are often prepared to assist law enforcement authorities on a voluntary basis by providing data under their control, but who prefer an appropriate legal basis for such assistance, relieving them of any contractual or non-contractual liability.
The purpose of the present background paper is to provide a snapshot of policies and practices of some major US service providers regarding their “voluntary” disclosure of information to law enforcement authorities in foreign jurisdictions, and thus to facilitate discussion of future options regarding criminal justice access to electronic evidence in the cloud.
Eu Countries, Eu Brexit, Eu To Usd, Eu Members, Eu Flag, Eu Lcs, Eu Definition, Eu Map, Eu Shoe Size To Us, Eu News, Eu Article 7, Eu Army, Eu Anthem, Eu Armory, Eu Article 50, Eu Adapter, Eu Abbreviation, Eu Amo Voce, Eu Atleta, Eu American Visa, Eu Brexit, Ue Boom, Eu Blue Card, Eu Breakup, Eu Battle Net, Eu Business School, Eu Brexit Guidelines, Eu Brussels, Eu Budget, Eu Building, Eu Countries, Eu Countries List, Eu Currency, Eu Citizenship, Eu Countries Map, Eu Commission, Eu Collapse, Eu Cookie Law, Eu Capital, Eu Court Ruling On Wearing Headscarves, Eu Definition, Eu Data Protection, Eu Data Protection Directive, Eu Directive 2014\/53\/eu, Eu Da Butt, Eu Directive, Eu Directive 95\/46\/ec, Eu Data Protection Regulation, Eu Debt, Eu Declaration Of Conformity, Eu Element, Eu Economy, Eu Elections, Eu Exchange Rate, Eu Ets, Eu Expansion, Eu Established, Eu Elv Directive, Eu Environmental Policy, Eu Electron Configuration, Eu Flag, Eu Founded, Eu Formation, Eu Flight Delay Compensation, Eu Falo Portugues, Eu Falling Apart, Eu Four Freedoms, Eu France, Eu French, Eu Facts, Eu Gdp, Eu Gdpr, Eu General Data Protection Regulation, Eu Gdp Per Capita, Eu Goals, Eu Government, Eu Glass, Eu Gdp Growth, Eu Gdp 2016, Eu Gmp, Eu Headquarters, Eu History, Eu Health Certificate, Eu Holidays, Eu Human Rights, Eu Harmonized Standards, Eu Head, Eu Holidays 2017, Eu Healthcare, Eu Headquarters Building, Eu Iv, Eu Immigration Policy, Eu Immigration, Eu Institutions, Eu Iv Cheats, Eu In English, Eu In French, Eu Is Doomed, Eu Integration, Eu In Spanish, Eu Jobs, Eu Jean Size To Us, Eu Juncker, Eu Jacksonville, Eu Jeans, Eu Jokes, Eu Jacket Size To Us, Eu Journal, Eu Japan, Eu Jrc, Eu Kicks, Eu Keyboard, Eu Klems, Eu Kodi, Eu Keyboard Layout, Eu Korea Fta, Eu Kosovo, Eu Kommission, Eu Kyoto Protocol, Eu Lcs, Eu Lcs, Eu Lcs 2017, Eu Lcs Promotion Tournament 2017, Eu Leaders, Eu Logo, Eu Lcs Playoffs, Eu Lcs Spring 2017, Eu Lcs Summer Split 2017, Eu Lcs Teams, Eu License Plate, Eu Members, Eu Map, Eu Meaning, Eu Medical Term, Eu Member Nations, Eu Military, Eu Mdr, Eu Membership, Eu Model Clauses, Eu Meme, Eu News, Eu Nations, Eu Natural, Eu National Anthem, Eu Official Languages, Eu Open Borders, Eu Organization, Eu Op Gg, Eu Outlet, Euobserver, Eu Official Journal, Eu Octopus Meme, Eu Origin, Eu Overwatch, Eu Plug, Eu Population, Eu Prefix, Eu President, Eu Passport, Eu Parliament, Eu Purpose, Eu Plug Type, Eu Privacy Shield, Eu Proxy, Eu Quero, Eu Quero In English, Eu Quizlet, Eu Quero Voce, Eu Quero Tchu, Eu Quantitative Easing, Eu Quotes, Eu Quiz, Eu Quero Ver O Oco, Eu Quis, Eu Rail, Eu Referendum, Eu Reach, Eu Return Directive, Eu Rome, Eu Regulations, Eu Refugee Crisis, Eu Rohs, Eu Root Word, Eurail Pass, Eu Shoe Size To Us, Eu Shoe Size, Eu Size 36 To Us, Eu Stands For, Eu Symbol, Eu States, Eu Size 40, Eu Star Wars, Eu Size 40 To Us, Eu Single Market, Eu To Usd, Eu Time, Eu To Dollar, Eu Te Amo, Eu To Us Shoe Size, Eu To Rf, Eu To Us Plug Adapter, Eu Trademark Search, Eu Time Zone, Eu Turkey Agreement, Eu Unemployment Rate, Eu Us Privacy Shield, Eu Us Visa, Eu Us Shoe Size, Eur Usd, Eu Union, Eu University, Eu Ukraine, Eu Us Relations, Eur Usd Exchange Rate, Eu Visa, Eu Visa Usa, Eu Vat, Eu Vs Us, Eu Vat Number, Eu Visa Requirements For Us Citizens, Eu Vs Dollar, Eu Vs Cn Hearthstone, Eu Voltage, Eu Vs Uk, Eu Wow Armory, Eu Wow, Eu Wiki, Eu Words, Eu Website, Eu Work Permit, Eu Work Visa, Eu West, Eu Wow Forums, Eu Waist Size To Us, Eu X Ayumu, Eu X Wing, Eu Xiaomi, Eu Xenophobia, Eu Xl To Us, Eu Xl Size, Eu Xl In Uk Size, Eu Xs Size, Eu Xl, Eu Xfel, Eu Yan Sang, Eu Yan Sang Usa, Eu Youtube, Eu Youth Unemployment Rate, Eu Yan Sang Malaysia, Eu Yan Sang Hong Kong, Eu Youtube Channel, Eu Yield Curve, Eu Yellow Card, Eu Yellow Card Thailand, Eu Zone, Eu Zip Code, Eu Zombie, Eu Zone 1, Eu Zika Map, Eu Zambia, Eu Zakup, Eu Zone 1 Countries, Eu Zimbabwe, Cybercrime Definition, Cybercrime Statistics, Cybercrime Prevention, Cybercrime Articles, Cybercrime Jobs, Cybercrime Law, Cybercrime Statistics 2017, Cyber Crime Cases, Cyber Crime News, Cybercrime Topics, Cybercrime Articles, Cybercrime And Security, Cybercrime As A Service, Cybercrime And Digital Forensics An Introduction, Cybercrime And Digital Forensics, Cybercrime And Society, Cybercrime And Terrorism, Cybercrime Attacks, Cybercrime Act, Cybercrime Against Businesses, Cyber Crime Batman, Cyber Crime Book, Cybercrime Blog, Cybercrime Bill, Cybercrime Banks, Cybercrime Background, Cyber Crime By Country, Cybercrime Bangalore, Cybercrime Billion Dollar Industry, Cybercrime Background Information, Cyber Crime Cases, Cybercrime Certification, Cybercrime Convention, Cybercrime Careers, Cybercrime Cost, Cybercrime Cafe, Cybercrime Cost 2016, Cybercrime China, Cybercrime Conference, Cybercrime Conclusion, Cybercrime Definition, Cybercrime Definition Computer, Cybercrime Definition Fbi, Cyber Crime Data, Cybercrime Degrees, Cybercrime Definition Pdf, Cybercrime Database, Cyber Crime Detective, Cyber Crime Documentary, Cyber Crime Department, Cybercrime Example, Cyber Crime Essay, Cybercrime Effects, Cybercrime Events, Cybercrime Enforcement, Cybercrime Economy, Cyber Crime Ethics, Cybercrime Effects On Business, Cybercrime Ecosystem, Cybercrime Enforcement Training Assistance Act, Cybercrime Facts, Cybercrime Fbi, Cybercrime Forensics, Cybercrime Forum, Cybercrime Forensics Training Center, Cybercrime Federal Laws, Cyber Crime Fiction, Cybercrime Financial Services, Cybercrime Future Trends, Cybercrime Fiji, Cybercrime Gets Personal Money Magazine, Cybercrime Gets Personal, Cybercrime Growth, Cyber Crime Graph, Cybercrime Groups, Cybercrime Government, Cybercrime Global Statistics, Cyber Crime Gov, Cyber Crime Games, Cybercrime Gif, Cybercrime Hacking, Cyber Crime History, Cybercrime Help, Cybercrime Healthcare, Cybercrime Hyderabad, Cybercrime How To Report, Cyber Crime Hotline, Cybercrime Hacking News, Cyber Crime Head Office India, Cybercrime Hacking And Cracking, Cybercrime Identity Theft, Cybercrime In The Us, Cyber Crime Investigation, Cybercrime Images, Cyber Crime Insurance, Cybercrime Is Also Known As, Cybercrime Investigating High-technology Computer Crime, Cybercrime Infographic, Cybercrime Information, Cyber Crime In Russia, Cybercrime Jobs, Cybercrime Jurisdiction, Cybercrime Journal Articles, Cybercrime Job Description, Cybercrime Jobs Salary, Cybercrime Job Openings, Cybercrime Jobs In Chennai, Cybercrime Job Qualification, Cybercrime Journal Articles Pdf, Cyber Crime Jamaica, Cybercrime Kenya, Cybercrime Key Issues And Debates, Cybercrime Kuwait, Cybercrime Ki Dhara, Cybercrime Key Issues And Debates Pdf, Cybercrime Kasus, Cyber Crime Karnataka, Cybercrime Kartu Kredit, Cybercrime Kolkata, Cyber Crime Karachi, Cybercrime Law, Cybercrime Laws In Usa, Cybercrime Law Enforcement, Cybercrime Laws Of The United States, Cybercrime List, Cybercrime Legislation Us, Cybercrime Laws In Florida, Cybercrime Legal Issues, Cybercrime Law Outline, Cyber Crime Lesson Plans, Cybercrime Meaning, Cyber Crime Movies, Cybercrime Methods, Cybercrime Methodology, Cyber Crime Money, Cybercrime Markets, Cyber Crime Magazine, Cyber Crime Most Wanted, Cybercrime Meaning In Tamil, Cybercrime Masters Degree, Cyber Crime News, Cyber Crime News Articles, Cyber Crime News Articles 2017, Cyber Crime Netflix, Cybercrime Nigeria, Cyber Crime Novels, Cybercrime Number, Cybercrime Nhs, Cyber Crime News Philippines, Cybercrime Nbi, Cybercrime Or Cyber Crime, Cybercrime Organizations, Cybercrime On The Rise, Cybercrime On The High Seas, Cybercrime Offenses, Cyber Crime Outline, Cybercrime Office, Cybercrime Office In Ahmedabad, Cybercrime Office In Patna, Cybercrime Office In Nashik, Cybercrime Quotes, Cyber Crime Quizlet, Cybercrime Questions, Cyber Crime Quiz, Cybercrime Questionnaire, Cybercrime Question Paper, Cybercrime Qatar, Cybercrime Question And Answers, Cybercrime Report, Cybercrime Research Paper, Cyber Crime Rates, Cyber Crime Recent, Cybercrime Research Topics, Cybercrime Research, Cybercrime Reported To The Ic3, Cybercrime Resources, Cybercrime Riding Tax Season Tides, Cyber Crime Report 2016, Cybercrime Statistics, Cybercrime Statistics 2017, Cyber Crime Stories, Cybercrime Spyware, Cybercrime Statistics 2015, Cybercrime Security, Cybercrime Solutions, Cybercrime Salary, Cybercrime Small Business, Cyber Crime Synonym, Cybercrime Topics, Cybercrime Trends, Cybercrime Tracker, Cybercrime Treaty, Cyber Crime Types, Cybercrime Training, Cybercrime Threats, Cybercrime Tools, Cybercrime Terms, Cybercrime The Transformation Of Crime In The Information Age, Cyber Crime Unit, Cybercrime Us, Cybercrime Uk, Cybercrime Uae, Cybercrime University, Cybercrime Un, Cyber Crime Unit Mauritius, Cyber Crime Unit Malta, Cybercrime Uc, Cybercrime Unodc, Cybercrime Victims, Cybercrime Vs Traditional Crime, Cybercrime Videos, Cybercrime Vs Traditional Crime Statistics, Cybercrime Virus, Cyber Crime Vocabulary, Cybercrime Vs Traditional Crime Punishment, Cybercrime Vs Computer Crime, Cybercrime Vs Cyber Warfare, Cybercrime Vs Cyber Espionage, Cybercrime Wiki, Cybercrime Worm, Cybercrime World Wide War 3.0, Cyber Crime Websites, Cyber Crime Worksheet, Cybercrime Wallpaper, Cyber Crime Worldwide, Cybercrime Working Group, Cyber Crime What Is It, Cybercrime Wikipedia Indonesia, Cybercrime X-remote Download, Tedx Cybercrime, Cyber Crime Youtube, Cyber Crime Yahoo, Cyber Crime Yahoo Answers, Cyber Crime Yesterday, Cyber Crime Youth, Cybercrime Yang Menyerang Hak Cipta, Cybercrime Yar, Youth Cyber Crime, Cyber Crime Yogyakarta, Cybercrime Yang Menyerang Pemerintah, Cybercrime Zimbabwe, Cybercrime Zeus, Cybercrime Zimbra, Zurich Cyber Crime, Zimbabwe Cybercrime Bill, Cyber Crime In Zambia, New Zealand Cyber Crime, Los Zetas Cybercrime, Cybercrime Law In Zambia, Cyber Crime Cases In Zambia,