A federal judge on Thursday ordered the release of an independent monitor’s review of HSBC’s internal cleanup after a landmark $1.92 billion settlement for laundering drug money and for sanctions violations.
The U.S. Justice Department and the bank had claimed that disclosing the report could harm law enforcement efforts and provide criminals with a “road map” to holes in HSBC’s defenses against money laundering.
But U.S. District Judge John Gleeson ruled that the court and the public had a right to know whether HSBC was living up to its agreement to improve internal controls and merited a deferral of prosecution by the government.
“I care a great deal about the results of the monitor’s investigation,” Gleeson wrote. “[M]y review of those results is necessary to do my job properly.”
“If, for example, the monitor’s report disclosed that HSBC were systematically and extensively laundering money for drug traffickers, it would demean this institution for me to sit by quietly while the government took no action.”
Gleeson also said it was “equally appropriate and desirable for the public to be interested and informed now in the progress” of the HSBC settlement.
HSBC in 2012 reached a landmark settlement with the federal government, admitting that it had deliberately laundered funds for drug cartels and countries under trade sanctions. Prosecutors described the settlement as a “sword of Damocles” hanging over HSBC. Should the bank fail to improve, it would face prosecution for unbridled financial wrongdoing.
A condition of the settlement was that the bank submit to extensive outside review of its reform efforts. The former New York State ethics chief Michael G. Cherkasky was appointed as the HSBC monitor in 2013.
A leaked copy of his report recounted instances of U.S. bank managers bullying and shouting at compliance team members, and drew attention to the bank’s dealings with clients that had possible links to terrorism, according to Bloomberg.
Both Cherkasky and a spokesman for the Justice Department declined to comment. However in court papers Cherkasky had been quoted as saying that foreign government officials had only agreed to speak with him as part of his monitoring on condition that their communications remain confidential.
HSBC told 100Reporters that both British and American authorities had argued against releasing the report, citing the terms of the 2012 settlement.
“We therefore regret this decision and are considering our next steps,” said Rob Sherman, a spokesman for the bank.
White Collar Impunity
The HSBC settlement sits at the center of public outrage at perceived leniency in the federal government’s white-collar criminal law enforcement.
Under the terms of a so-called “deferred prosecution agreement,” the Justice Department will drop all charges — leaving HSBC with no conviction or criminal record — if after a five-year period prosecutors believe the bank has sufficiently cleaned up its act.
Since the early 1990s, such settlements have become a preferred tool for policing the corporate world and similar methods have recently been introduced in the United Kingdom. Prosecutors have defended them, saying they encourage cooperation and reform by targeted companies.
However, lawmakers and critics have denounced deferred prosecution agreements as symbols of white-collar impunity, reducing penalties for corporate crime to nothing more than the cost of doing business while less powerful defendants end up behind bars for lesser crimes.
Outside monitoring by independent experts, who often are awarded highly lucrative contracts to inspect companies’ performance and report back to prosecutors, have been a key feature of such settlements.
However, their reporting has been closely held and previous efforts to pry them loose from courts and the federal government have failed.
A federal appeals court in 2013 refused to allow the release of outside monitoring reports for the insurance giant American International Group Inc., which was bailed out with public funds during the global financial crisis.
Its outside monitor, James M. Cole, — who recently stepped down as the Justice Department’s No. 2 official — produced the reports as AIG was building the very derivatives portfolio that caused its liquidity crisis — a central element in the ensuing economic meltdown. The reports had been sought by the business reporter Sue Reisinger.
(100Reporters is currently also suing the Justice Department under the Freedom of Information Act for access to outside monitoring reports on anti-corruption compliance at Siemens, the German engineering colossus which pleaded guilty in 2008 to systematic bribery across the globe.)
Key to the decision in the AIG case was whether the reports were “judicial records” to which the public is entitled.
Federal appeals judges in Washington found that no judge had based any decision on the requested records and so they were not judicial records and could not be released.
But in his ruling handed down in Brooklyn on Thursday, Gleeson said that the HSBC case remained a matter before him and that the court would oversee any future prosecution of HSBC, based in no small part on the Cherkasky report — meaning the review was a judicial record.
Gleeson gave the Justice Department and HSBC until February 12 to submit proposed redactions after which he said he would release the “majority” of the report.
Gleeson’s decision was prompted by a seemingly obscure source — a November letter from a Pennsylvania man Hubert Dean Moore, who asked to review the report for a complaint against the bank that he had lodged with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
Moore had sought a loan modification from the bank but believed that without the Cherkasky report, “my complaint is essentially a ‘he-said-she-said’ argument.”
Moore told The New York Post that he was “extremely happy” with Gleeson’s decision.
Brandon L. Garrett, a professor of law at the University of Virginia who analyzes corporate settlements, said Gleeson had struck a blow for transparency in the annals of white-collar criminal law.
“So much of what these monitors do remains totally out of the public eye. We do not even know who the monitors are in some of these prosecution agreements,” Garrett wrote in an email.
“We have no idea when these prosecutions quietly end whether the company actually complied. It is only because of Judge Gleeson’s supervision that the public knows so much about the apparently slow progress HSBC has made towards compliance.”
Judge Judy, Judge Mathis, Judge Dredd, Judge Theresa Brennan, Judge Faith, Judge Jeanine Pirro, Judge Ito, Judge Joe Brown, Judge Gorsuch, Judge Yankees, Judge Alex, Judge Andrew Napolitano, Judge Alex Ferrer, Judge Avern Cohn, Judge Annette Berry, Judge Alexander Oakland County, Judge Advocate General, Judge Amber Wolf, Judge Archie Brown, Judge Aquilina, Judge Brennan, Judge Bernstein, Judge Biernat, Judge Bruce Morrow, Judge Bernard Friedman, Judge Brennan Wayne County, Judge Bowman, Judge Brian Mackenzie, Judge Bork, Judge Beagle, Judge Caprio, Judge Craig Strong, Judge Charlene Elder, Judge Cleland, Judge Chabot, Judge Crater, Judge Cholack, Judge Caretti, Judge Cedric Simpson, Judge Cheryl Matthews, Judge Dredd, Judge Definition, Judge Doom, Judge Dredd Cast, Judge Dredd Movie, Judge Death, Judge Damon Keith, Judge Daniel Hathaway, Judge David Braxton, Judge Dredd 2012, Judge Ewell, Judge Edward Servitto, Judge Ewell Wayne County, Judge Elder, Judge Eric Cholack, Judge Evans, Judge Eric Clay, Judge Edo, Judge Emoji, Judge Elizabeth Stafford, Judge Faith, Judge Frank Caprio, Judge Faunce, Judge Fresard Wayne County, Judge Friedman, Judge Found In Hudson River, Judge Found Dead, Judge Fresard, Judge Frollo, Judge Fullerton, Judge Gorsuch, Judge Greg Mathis, Judge Gun, Judge Gorcyca, Judge Group, Judge Gavel, Judge Garland, Judge Goldsmith, Judge Gershwin Drain, Judge Gillis Wayne County, Judge Handgun, Judge Hatchett Age, Judge Hammer, Judge Hatchett, Judge Hathaway, Judge Home Run Seattle, Judge Halloran, Judge Hatchett Daughter In Law, Judge Hala Jarbou, Judge Holden, Judge Ito, Judge In Spanish, Judge In Court, Judge Iddings, Judge In Arabic, Judge Ito Actor, Judge Isaac Parker, Judge In To Kill A Mockingbird, Judge In The Bible, Judge In Asl, Judge Judy, Judge Jeanine Pirro, Judge Joe Brown, Judge Judy Salary, Judge Judy Episodes, Judge Judy Divorce, Judge Judy Gif, Judge Judy Youtube, Judge Judy House, Judge Judy Meme, Judge Killed In Chicago, Judge Kennelly, Judge Kocoras, Judge Kendall, Judge Kirby Cook County, Judge Kathy Flanagan, Judge Kubasiak, Judge Karen, Judge Kirby, Judge Katz, Judge Lance Ito, Judge Lynn Toler, Judge Leo Bowman, Judge Lisa Gorcyca, Judge Lisa Langton, Judge Linda Davis, Judge Lita Popke, Jude Law, Judge Lyrics, Judge Langford Morris, Judge Mathis, Judge Mathis Wife, Judge Michael Warren, Judge Martha Snow, Judge Morty, Judge Marilyn Milian, Judge Me, Judge Mathis Show, Judge Melissa Cox, Judge Maceroni, Judge Neil Gorsuch, Judge Not Lest, Judge Nancy Edmunds, Judge Nanci Grant, Judge Neithercut, Judge Napolitano, Judge Norma Dotson, Judge Nicholson, Judge Newblatt, Judge Nick Holowka, Judge O’brien, Judge O’meara, Judge On Fox News, Judge O’brien Oakland County, Judge Opperman, Judge Odette, Judge Of Character, Judge Olu Stevens, Judge Orrick, Judge On Yankees, Judge Parker, Judge Pirro, Judge Pistol, Judge Popke, Judge Posner, Judge Patrick Conlin, Judge Patricia Fresard, Judge Paul Borman, Judge Plakas, Judge Potts, Judge Qiana Lillard, Judge Quotes, Judge Qiana Lillard Bio, Judge Quist, Judge Qualifications, Judge Questions, Judge Q, Judge Quinn, Judge Quackenbush, Judge Qualities, Judge Rinder, Judge Roy Bean, Judge Raymond Myles, Judge Reinhold, Judge Revolver, Judge Ross, Judge Rachel Rancilio, Judge Rae Lee Chabot, Judge Roberta Archer, Judge Robert Colombo, Judge Salary, Judge Smails, Judge Shannon Holmes, Judge Synonym, Judge Strong, Judge Scalia, Judge Servitto, Judge Sheila Abdus-salaam, Judge Shalina Kumar, Judge Shelia Johnson, Judge Theresa Brennan, Judge Tanya Acker, Judge Toia, Judge Theresa M. Brennan, Judge Thomas Borresen, Judge Terrance Keith, Judge Tarnow, Judge Toler, Judge Terrence Berg, Judge To Be, Judge Ulysses Boykin, Judge Unworthy, Judge Uke Chords, Judge Unworthy Wow, Judge Uniform, Judge Ursula Ungaro, Judge Urban Dictionary, Judge Ungaro, Judge Upholds Travel Ban, Judge Ultra Lite, Judge Vonda Evans, Judge Vonda Evans Birthday, Judge Viviano, Judge Valentine, Judge Victoria Roberts, Judge Virgil Smith, Judge Vinsmoke, Judge Vonda Evans Age, Judge Van Houten, Judge Verb, Judge Wapner, Judge Wanda Evans, Judge Wendy Potts, Judge Wade Mccree, Judge William Hackel, Judge William Mcconico, Judge Woodward, Judge Warren, Judge Wig, Judge Wolf, Judge Xavier Rodriguez, Judge X Factor, Judge Xinis, Judge Xue, Judge Xue Hanqin, Judge Xavios, Judge Xiomara Torres Mattson, Judge X Factor Uk 2015, Judge Xifaras, Judge Xavios Reading Pa, Judge Yankees, Judge Yokich, Judge Yankees Stats, Judge Yankees Height, Judge Yates Kent County, Judge Your Neighbor Worksheet, Judge Yachts, Judge Yuille, Judge You, Judge Yourself, Judge Zone, Judge Zemaitis, Judge Zloch, Judge Zeller, Judge Zecht, Judge Zimmerman, Judge Zouhary, Judge Zagel, Judge Zainey, Judge Zargabaath, Public Storage, Public House, Public House Ferndale, Public Library, Public Records, Public Enemy, Public Relations, Public Pools Near Me, Public Service Credit Union, Public Health, Public Auction, Public Administration, Public Arrest Records, Public Affairs, Public Agenda Definition, Public Administration Jobs, Public Access Lakes Near Me, Public Assistance, Public Access, Public Adjuster, Public Beaches Near Me, Public Bikes, Public Broadcasting, Public Boat Launches Near Me, Public Basketball Courts, Public Bank, Public Bathroom Near Me, Public Bathroom, Public Benefit Corporation, Public Birth Records, Public Chicago, Public Criminal Records, Public Citizen, Public Consulting Group, Public Credit Union, Public Court Records Michigan, Public Cite Web, Public Choice Theory, Public Car Auctions, Public Colleges In Michigan, Public Defender, Public Domain, Public Domain Images, Public Desire, Public Domain Music, Public Definition, Public Domain Definition, Public Defender’s Office, Public Dump Near Me, Public Defender Salary, Public Enemy, Public Enemy Movie, Public Education, Public Enemy Fight The Power, Public Enemy Songs, Public Execution, Public Enemy #1, Public Enemy Bike, Public Enemy Fight The Power Lyrics, Public Entity, Public Foods, Public Fishing Near Me, Public Figure, Public Freakout, Public Forum, Public Finance, Public Forum Debate, Public Fax Machine, Public Float, Public Funding, Public Goods, Public Golf Courses Near Me, Public Good Definition, Public Golf Courses, Public Golf Courses In Michigan, Public Gardens Michigan, Public Goods Are Those For Which There, Public Goods Face The, Public Garden, Public Gardens Near Me, Public House, Public House Ferndale, Public Health, Public House Menu, Public Health Jobs, Public House Monroe, Public Hotel Chicago, Public Health Jobs Michigan, Public Hotel Nyc, Public Health Umich, Public Ip, Public Intoxication, Public Ip Address, Public Indecency, Public Image Ltd, Public Incline House, Public Ivy, Public Information Officer, Public Interest Groups, Public Interest, Public Justice, Public Jobs, Public Jail Records, Public Journalism, Public Jail Records Ohio, Public Justice Center, Public Json Api, Public Java, Public Jacuzzi, Public Jacuzzi Near Me, Public Key Encryption, Public Kahoot, Public Key Cryptography, Public Kitchen Nyc, Public Key Infrastructure, Public Knowledge, Public Kitchen, Public Key Vs Private Key, Public Key Encryption Definition, Public Key Authentication, Public Library, Public Lumber, Public Library Near Me, Public Lakes Near Me, Public Library Hours, Public Loan Forgiveness, Public Landfill, Public Lighting Authority, Public Law 94-142, Public Law, Public Museum, Public Market, Public Mobile, Public Marriage Records Michigan, Public Media Network, Public Marriage Records, Public Museum Grand Rapids, Public Mailbox Near Me, Public Morals, Public Meaning, Public Notary, Public Nuisance, Public Notary Near Me, Public Ntp Server, Public Nyc, Public Notice, Public Near Me, Public News Service, Public Ntp Servers Us, Public Nuisance Michigan, Public Opinion Polls, Public Opinion, Public Opinion Definition, Public Option, Public Official, Public Order Crimes, Public Opinion Quarterly, Public Opinion Poll Definition, Public Office, Public Offering, Public Pools Near Me, Public Policy, Public Parking Near Me, Public Pair, Public Pools, Public Policy Definition, Public Pools Chicago, Public Policy Uchicago, Public Private Partnership, Public Parking Chicago, Public Queries Exist In Which Of The Following Lists, Public Quotes, Public Questions, Public Quizzes, Public Quests Eq2, Public Quantum Computer Companies, Public Quarry, Public Quizlet Live, Public Quarrel Crossword Clue, Public Quartet, Public Records, Public Relations, Public Records Michigan, Public Records Ohio, Public Relations Jobs, Public Records Search, Public Relations Salary, Public Rubber, Public Restaurant, Public Radio, Public Storage, Public Service Credit Union, Public Service Loan Forgiveness, Public Service, Public Service Announcement, Public Surplus, Public Swimming Pools, Public Speaking, Public Sector, Public Safety, Public Transportation, Public Tennis Courts Near Me, Public Theater, Public Transportation Detroit, Public Tv Detroit, Public Trust Clearance, Public Television, Public Transportation In Chicago, Public Trust, Public Trust Doctrine, Public University Rankings, Public Universities In Michigan, Public Utilities, Public University, Public Urination, Public Universities In New York, Public Utility Definition, Public Utilities Commission, Public Universities In Ohio, Public Unscramble, Public Vs Private School, Public Vs Private Goods, Public Vs Private Sector, Public Vs Private College, Public Vs Private, Public Vs Charter School, Public Vs Private Accounting, Public Vs Private Cloud, Public Vs Private Ip Address, Public Void, Public Works Administration, Public Works, Public Works Definition, Public Works Department, Public Wifi, Public Works Jobs, Public Works Projects, Public Warehouse, Public Welfare, Public Works Week 2017, Public Xmpp Servers, Public Xfinity Wifi, Public Xml Data Sets, Public Xfinity Wifi Not Working, Public X509 Certificate, Public Xml Api, Public Xbox One Minecraft Servers, Public Xiaomi, Public Xalandri, Public Xania, Public Yoga Pants, Public Yard Sales, Public Yoga, Public Youtube, Public Yellow Pages, Public Your School Connected, Public Yum Oracle, Public Yearbooks, Public Yum Oracle Linux 6, Public Yelp, Public Zeeland, Public Zeeland Restaurant, Public Zone, Public Zoo, Public Zone Definition, Public Zoo Near Me, Public Zone Distance, Public Zirmed, Public Zeitgeist, Public Zombie Prank, Hsbc Mexico, Hsbc Login, Hsbc Bank, Hsbc Usa, Hsbc Credit Card, Hsbc Log On, Hsbc Near Me, Hsbc Mortgage, Hsbc Stock, Hsbc Careers, Hsbc Advance, Hsbc Argentina, Hsbc Auto Finance, Hsbc Account, Hsbc Australia, Hsbc Arena, Hsbc Atm, Hsbc Atm Near Me, Hsbc Address, Hsbc Acronym, Hsbc Bank, Hsbc Bank Usa, Hsbc Bank Nevada, Hsbc Banca Por Internet, Hsbc Bank Near Me, Hsbc Business, Hsbc Bermuda, Hsbc Beneficial, Hsbc Bank Canada, Hsbc Buffalo Ny, Hsbc Credit Card, Hsbc Careers, Hsbc Canada, Hsbc Credit Card Login, Hsbc Co Uk, Hsbc Card Services, Hsbc Checking Account, Hsbc Currency, Hsbc Cd Rates, Hsbc China, Hsbc Direct, Hsbc Divisas, Hsbc Dividend, Hsbc De Mexico, Hsbc Detroit, Hsbc Debit Card, Hsbc Dubai, Hsbc Dividend History, Hsbc Direct Savings, Hsbc Depew Ny, Hsbc Egypt, Hsbc Expat, Hsbc En Linea, Hsbc Exchange Rate, Hsbc Evolve, Hsbc Europe, Hsbc Email Format, Hsbc Employee Benefits, Hsbc Email, Hsbc England, Hsbc France, Hsbc Finance Corporation, Hsbc Full Name, Hsbc Finance, Hsbc Foreclosure, Hsbc Florida, Hsbc Foreign Currency Exchange, Hsbc Financial, Hsbc Finance Corp, Hsbc Foreign Exchange, Hsbc Gm Card, Hsbc Glassdoor, Hsbc Global Banking, Hsbc Global Asset Management, Hsbc Group, Hsbc Germany, Hsbc Graduate Program, Hsbc Greece, Hsbc Golf, Hsbc Global, Hsbc Hong Kong, Hsbc Holdings, Hsbc Headquarters, Hsbc Hong Kong Swift Code, Hsbc Hours, Hsbc Headquarters Usa, Hsbc History, Hsbc Hong Kong Login, Hsbc Headquarters Address, Hsbc Holdings Stock, Hsbc India, Hsbc Illinois, Hsbc India Online Banking, Hsbc In The News, Hsbc India Login, Hsbc In Chicago, Hsbc International, Hsbc Investor Relations, Hsbc Internship, Hsbc Insurance, Hsbc Jobs, Hsbc Jersey, Hsbc Japan, Hsbc Jobs Usa, Hsbc James Comey, Hsbc Jade, Hsbc Jetway, Hsbc Job Search, Hsbc Jersey City, Hsbc Jordan, Hsbc Korea, Hsbc Kuwait, Hsbc Kyc, Hsbc Kawasaki, Hsbc Kenya, Hsbc Kuala Lumpur, Hsbc Kyc Form, Hsbc Kingston, Hsbc Kolkata, Hsbc Krakow, Hsbc Login, Hsbc Locations, Hsbc London, Hsbc Locations Usa, Hsbc Log On, Hsbc Logo, Hsbc Login Usa, Hsbc Loans, Hsbc Lien Release, Hsbc Life Insurance, Hsbc Mexico, Hsbc Mortgage, Hsbc Mortgage Services Inc, Hsbc Malta, Hsbc Mexico Personas, Hsbc Michigan, Hsbc Movil, Hsbc Malaysia, Hsbc Money Laundering, Hsbc Meaning, Hsbc Near Me, Hsbcnet, Hsbc New York, Hsbc News, Hsbc New York Office, Hsbc North America, Hsbc Number, Hsbc Netbanking, Hsbc Nevada, Hsbc Now, Hsbc Online Banking, Hsbc Online Savings, Hsbc Online Banking Usa, Hsbc Online Apply, Hsbc Oman, Hsbc Online Savings Login, Hsbc Offshore, Hsbc Online Mmkt Savings, Hsbc Online Banking Hong Kong, Hsbc Online Banking Uae, Hsbc Personas, Hsbc Premier, Hsbc Private Bank, Hsbc Premier Usa, Hsbc Puntos, Hsbc Por Internet, Hsbc Philippines, Hsbc Personal Banking, Hsbc Pib, Hsbc Premier World Mastercard, Hsbc Quote, Hsbc Qatar, Hsbc Q1 2017, Hsbc Queretaro, Hsbc Quick Pay, Hsbc Quicken, Hsbc Quarterly Report, Hsbc Quantitative Analyst, Hsbc Qantas, Hsbc Q1 Earnings, Hsbc Routing Number, Hsbc Retail Services, Hsbc Rewards, Hsbc Reo, Hsbc Reviews, Hsbc Rates, Hsbc Rugby, Hsbc Revenue, Hsbc Rewards Usa, Hsbc Research, Hsbc Stock, Hsbc Stands For, Hsbc Savings, Hsbc Sevens, Hsbc Swift Code, Hsbc Singapore, Hsbc Sucursales, Hsbc Securities, Hsbc Settlement, Hsbc Secured Credit Card, Hsbc Toluca, Hsbc Ticker, Hsbc Taleo, Hsbc Taiwan, Hsbc Toronto, Hsbc Travel Insurance, Hsbc Turkiye, Hsbc Tipo De Cambio, Hsbc Thailand, Hsbc Tower, Hsbc Usa, Hsbc Uk, Hsbc Uae, Hsbc Us Login, Hsbc Usa Routing Number, Hsbc Usa Locations, Hsbc Uk Customer Service, Hsbc Uk Online Banking, Hsbc Usa Careers, Hsbc Usa Customer Service, Hsbc Vietnam, Hsbc Vancouver, Hsbc Vice President, Hsbc Visa, Hsbc Values, Hsbc Voice Id, Hsbc Virginia, Hsbc Visa Credit Card, Hsbc Valuation, Hsbc Vietnam Locations, Hsbc Wiki, Hsbc Windsor Ontario, Hsbc Wire Transfer Fee, Hsbc Wire Transfer, Hsbc Wealth Management, Hsbc Washington Dc, Hsbc Wire Routing Number, Hsbc Website, Hsbc Women’s Champions, Hsbc Wells Fargo, Hsbc Xiamen, Hsbc Xero, Hsbc X, Hsbc Xian, Hsbc Expat, Hsbc Xd Date, Hsbc Xiamen Branch, Hsbc Xalapa, Hsbc Xexec, Hsbc Extra Points, Hsbc Yahoo Finance, Hsbc Youtube, Hsbc Yamaha, Hsbc Your Benefits Resources, Hsbc Ys, Hsbc Yield, Hsbc Yelp, Hsbc Your Spending Account, Hsbc Yangon, Hsbc Yerevan, Hsbc Zimbabwe Currency Exchange, Hsbc Zurich, Hsbc Zip Code, Hsbc Zapopan, Hsbc Zim Redemption, Hsbc Zim, Hsbc Zelle, Hsbc Zertifikate, Hsbc Zimbabwe, Hsbc Zalora